Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that circumcising baby/young boys is the equivalent to FGM?

259 replies

Cress42 · 08/11/2023 17:22

I’m part of a baby group - our babies are all younger than 12 months and there are parents looking to get their sons REcircumcised 😢

They’re all based in America. I understand it’s a cultural norm there and nobody is talking about any medical issues to warrant having them circumcised.

It’s a fact that it causes desensitisation and part of me feels that along with the general pain of the operation this is similar to FGM.

The baby can’t consent to the mutilation. Also mutilation isn’t too severe a word, it literally means: act or instance of destroying, removing, or severely damaging a limb or other body part of a person or animal.

YABU - It’s not similar to FGM. There’s nothing wrong with it, snip away!

YANBU - It’s similar / the male equivalent to FGM and unless carried out for medical reasons it should be up to the discretion of the person who is being circumcised

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
Screamingabdabz · 08/11/2023 21:53

You are being totally unreasonable to conflate the barbarism of FGM to circumcision. FGM is painful, damaging mutilation which leaves lifelong trauma.

Male circumcision wont leave lasting trauma but is still (unless medically necessary) gratuitous and abhorrent. Instead of lopping off bits of their child’s genitalia, these male dominated cultures could just teach their male offspring to wash their cocks properly. Problem solved.

willingtolearn · 08/11/2023 21:51

It's all mutilation when carried out for non medical reasons, but I suppose it's the difference between cutting off a little finger and cutting off a whole hand.

One has minimal impact on life, the other is long term disabling.

EnjoyingTheSilence · 08/11/2023 21:47

Agree with pp. If I had a son, I wouldn’t have had him circumcised. I don’t agree with it unless it’s for medical reasons, but to compare to FGM is just wrong.

There is absolutely no benefit whatsoever to a girl/woman going through FGM, no medical reason for the procedure, no good reason at all

vernatheraven · 08/11/2023 21:46

One of those threads where everyone says no you're misguided and the op says no I am not until it gets deleted.

Shraree · 08/11/2023 21:41

I agree you are mutilating your child's body. See also ear piercing.
It's not as damaging as FGM, but it still should be illegal.

penjil · 08/11/2023 21:40

ohbaby24 · 08/11/2023 17:34

Not comparable and not your concern!

Ha! Well, 99% of things on Mumsnet are none of our concern.....yet here we are.

HalloweenonXMas · 08/11/2023 21:38

I recommend that you read Cut: One Woman's Fight Against FGM in Britain Today
Book by Hibo Wardere.

No you are very wrong to make that comparison.
There are sometimes medical reasons for having a foreskin removed. There are never any reasons for removing the clitoris, labia and sewing up a woman or girl.

You are also preaching to the converted. Mumsnet is a UK site and the vast vast majority of people do not believe in circumcisions for boys unless medically necessary. It is the us this is a cultural problem so you need to tackle it there. Comparing it to fgm will not help your cause as people can obviously see there's a difference.

No I believe it's cruel and barbaric to do for religious or cultural reasons. But no it's not equivalent to even level 1 fgm. (You can read about this in the book)

vernatheraven · 08/11/2023 21:34

The difference is that fgm is never needed for health reasons it's done as previous posters have said to appease men.

At no benefit at all to women. It actually makes things worse for us. If you don't die from it first because it's not like it's carried out in a sterile safe hospital with a clear aftercare plan or antibiotics.

Then deal with the ptsd of actually remembering it all and dealing with everything that goes with that. every day. Mentally and physically.

Circumcision can be a solution to a medical issue.

Vinvertebrate · 08/11/2023 21:34

I am married to a Muslim and DS was to be circumcised by a Jewish doctor, until I got hysterical about it at the very last minute. Thank fuck I did, because I now wonder what I was thinking to entertain the idea of circumcision.

That said, it’s in a different league to FGM by some margin. It’s surely more equivalent to removing the entire glans?

FoodCentre · 08/11/2023 21:30

It is so wrong to co-opt FGM.

I do not believe in male circumcision and would never do it. But no, male circumcision is not comparable to FGM. if it was, we wouldn't have so many circumcised males who choose to promote it fgs.

FGM is something that is done in specific cultures in Africa. You are pushing them aside to further your narrative by centring FGM with circumcision. You have no right to use other people's plight as a pawn.

2023forme · 08/11/2023 21:26

OldChinaJug · 08/11/2023 18:05

Same.

The first time I sat through one, I fainted and had flashback images for months afterwards.

The thought of girls going through the process are the most upsetting images I've ever had.

Utterly, utterly horrific and in no way comparable. I cannot imagine how those girls/women even begin to live with it.

It's hugely ignorant to suggest a comparison.

This. FGM is utterly barbaric. Girls are sometimes “sown up” after, unable to urinate. They may end up with a fistula. A man can rip the sutures open with his penis to have sex and then the girl sown up again. It is utterly heartbreaking what these girls and young women go through and the permanent pain and disfigurement they are left in. Removal of all/part of the foreskin is not nearly as traumatic and is unlikely to cause death or lifelong pain and disfigurement. So YAVVVU to compare the two.

DadSupportingOrchid · 08/11/2023 21:24

NC for this for obvious reasons.

I was circumcised as a baby. It sucks, and I wish that I had not been circumcised. It has definitely reduced sensitivity significantly, to the point that I cannot orgasm while wearing a condom.

Despite this, male circumcision is absolutely not in the same league as FGM. FGM is a much more serious social problem.

I can still have an erection and an orgasm. I have no issues with urination and, the circumcision does not result in pain for me during sex. On the other hand, FGM even in its mildest form is intended to prevent female orgasm by removing the clitoris. The closest analogy to that for a man would be complete removal of the head of the penis. The more invasive forms of FGM, which involve even more cutting away of healthy tissue and also sometimes sewing up of areas that are not meant to be sewn up, can cause pain and tearing for a woman during sex, and in some cases increase the risks of tearing, blood loss, in some cases permanent fecal incontinence after childbirth, etc. The side effects are simply horrific.

The difference between male circumcision and FGM is so substantial that they should not be treated as similar in nature but different in extent - instead, they are different in nature.

Also, the purposes are different. FGM is designed to reduce female sexual pleasure, with the intent of preventing women from choosing to have sex with men to whom they are not married. Male circumcision is not designed to have that effect at all.

With different purposes and also levels of harm being so fundamentally different, any conflation of male circumcision with FGM is harmful because it dilutes efforts to stop FGM from happening.

WhereIsBebèsChambre · 08/11/2023 20:58

Cress42 · 08/11/2023 20:23

To anyone claiming that circumcision is ‘just removing a piece of skin’ I would suggest that it is YOU that is minimising circumcision.

How can anyone read a first hand account like this and say that it’s not on par?

Typical mumsnet to go the most extreme version of FGM in an argument to say it’s not genital mutilation.

https://www.bbc.com/news/uk-england-47292307.amp

You're going on about extremism yet post articles like this saying people will kill themselves because they've been circumcised?!!
I need to leave this thread as have been panicking enough about all the Surgery my baby needs and has had to have today and now you're saying we're pushing him to suicide as an adult??

CurlsnSunshinetime4tea · 08/11/2023 20:44

how about articles like this from the WHO
9789241596169_eng.pdf (who.int)

https://iris.who.int/bitstream/handle/10665/43749/9789241596169_eng.pdf

mapleriver · 08/11/2023 20:35

The problem with circumcision to me is that you can still opt to have your child's genitals mutilated in a first world country. FGM is more horrific but happens in countries known for some quite horrific things, circumcision apart from for penis issues is very backwards and sick imo

SapphOhNo · 08/11/2023 20:32

Can't vote as I dont agree with either stance.

Male circumcision is barbaric and removes male choice, if a guy wants to reduce the risk of STIs etc or medical intervention for other reasons that's one thing but it shouldn't be done to babies.

But to make it the equivalent of FGM is utterly ridiculous. It's on another level.

Thelnebriati · 08/11/2023 20:28

Its not the same as FGM and its sad that activists try to link the two. Its also ridiculous for you organise the voting the way you did. Can't you just campaign against male circumcision without insulting women?

Cress42 · 08/11/2023 20:28

Thesunsstillupthere · 08/11/2023 19:06

I think no baby should be circumcised but it really pisses me off to see you comparing it to FGM. Absolutely classic to see female suffering minimised like this “oh men suffer too” 🤬 For some men foreskin removal can be medically necessary, and even when it isn’t necessary it is usually a simple procedure with no negative side effects. The purpose of it is to help the boy/man. FGM however is never medically necessary, and has nasty side effects such as incontinence, infection and childbirth problems. The sole purpose of it is to ensure that the girls/woman never enjoy sex it even find it painful. It is sadistic.

(DS’s lazy hygiene has given him an infected foreskin several times and when treating it I’ve had a lot of sympathy for people who just circumcise the damn thing early on! In historical cultures, with no antibiotics, I can see why it would become standard, particularly in desert peoples where getting clean washing water is problem).

There’s a nasty whiff of anti-semitism about this thread too which seems very tasteless given what’s going on in the world.

Shame on you for suggesting this is anti-Semitic

There’s a big whiff of ignorance from your post.

You are aware that circumcision is adopted by followers of both Islam and Judaism - so especially in the current climate please explain how this is anti-Semitic?

OP posts:
Cuttysark4321 · 08/11/2023 20:27

Exactly this.
a source online stated that "FGM is a leading cause of death in the countries where it is practiced. Our estimate that 44, 320 girls and young women die each year due to FGM is suggestive that FGM belongs in the first rank of causes of death in Africa."

this is precisely is why it is criminalised.

Haydug · 08/11/2023 20:27

SweetBirdsong · 08/11/2023 20:07

100% this! It boggles my mind that some people are implying they are the same (including the OP.) It's clear they have not educated themselves on FGM at ALL.

There's also the fact that the way the clitoris is removed is BARBARIC. Some girls die from septicemia, and even those that don't die, live with long term unpleasant and sometimes painful after affects.

FGM is utterly horrific. It's not just the fact you can't climax without your clitoris as a previous poster said!!!! FGM is barbaric, and is utter butchery. It is illegal in the UK, and you can be imprisoned for up to 14 years for committing this crime against girls. Should be longer!

@Cress42 You clearly know nothing whatsoever about FGM. Please stop!

I never said that 'it's just the fact you can't climax without your clitoris'. If that was aimed at me! That was my example as to why it is not the same for the male poster who doesn't enjoy sex as much. It's not nearly the same!!

Wellhellooooodear · 08/11/2023 20:27

Not comparable in the slightest. I don't agree with circumcision for religious reasons but it does not cause the same harm as FGM.

RoseAndRose · 08/11/2023 20:26

I voted YABU, not because I think "snip away" - I absolutely don't and think it should be dome for medical reasons only.

But it's not remotely comparable to genital mutilation.

Cress42 · 08/11/2023 20:25

PurpleChrayne · 08/11/2023 18:51

What a time to be Jewish on Mumsnet!

My G-d.

Educate yourself - there are many more cultures and religions than just Judaism that do this as the norm

OP posts:
Cuttysark4321 · 08/11/2023 20:23

do you actually understand what is involved in FGM? your post suggests not and is unbelievably ignorant.

Cress42 · 08/11/2023 20:23

To anyone claiming that circumcision is ‘just removing a piece of skin’ I would suggest that it is YOU that is minimising circumcision.

How can anyone read a first hand account like this and say that it’s not on par?

Typical mumsnet to go the most extreme version of FGM in an argument to say it’s not genital mutilation.

https://www.bbc.com/news/uk-england-47292307.amp

Alex and Lesley

'My son killed himself after circumcision' - BBC News

Why did a young man kill himself two years after being circumcised?

https://www.bbc.com/news/uk-england-47292307.amp

OP posts: