Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that circumcising baby/young boys is the equivalent to FGM?

259 replies

Cress42 · 08/11/2023 17:22

I’m part of a baby group - our babies are all younger than 12 months and there are parents looking to get their sons REcircumcised 😢

They’re all based in America. I understand it’s a cultural norm there and nobody is talking about any medical issues to warrant having them circumcised.

It’s a fact that it causes desensitisation and part of me feels that along with the general pain of the operation this is similar to FGM.

The baby can’t consent to the mutilation. Also mutilation isn’t too severe a word, it literally means: act or instance of destroying, removing, or severely damaging a limb or other body part of a person or animal.

YABU - It’s not similar to FGM. There’s nothing wrong with it, snip away!

YANBU - It’s similar / the male equivalent to FGM and unless carried out for medical reasons it should be up to the discretion of the person who is being circumcised

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
Hotcuppatea · 09/11/2023 09:07

If you think that male circumcision is the same as FGM then you clearly know very little about what happens to girls when FGM is done to them.

CurlewKate · 09/11/2023 09:03

@spookehtooth Putting the two even in the same sentence/Mumsnet post minimises women's experience. Everyone knows a man who has been circumcised. If you don't know a woman who has undergone FGM then it would be natural that they are not dissimilar. Women's experience is routinely minimised.

TrishIsMySpiritAnimal · 09/11/2023 08:51

YANBU - diabolical practice

enchantedsquirrelwood · 09/11/2023 08:50

PosteriorPosterity · 08/11/2023 17:40

It does minimise FGM, as people are more aware of circumcision, a procedure which is often done on males of all ages for legitimate medical reasons.

Circumcision does not destroy sex lives, cause a lifetime of pain and discomfort and is rarely done in unsterile circumstances. If people think FGM is like circumcision they are minimising it, which is the risk of equating them.

Circumcising babies is wrong, but not equivalent to FGM.

This. FGM is rightly a crime (albeit one that continues to go on because the authorities are still too scared of being accused of racism to deal with it properly).

It is not racist to stop cruelty to children!

spookehtooth · 09/11/2023 08:42

@CurlewKate it's only a false equivalent if you're comparing, if you're not then there are no comparisons false or otherwise. Even if it was beyond doubt two things were similarly bad .. why? What point or benefit? Besides turning suffering into some sort of top trumps like card game of facts and intellectual arguments

Maybe if both were criminal and you wanted to compare punishments for both it might be justified.

Vargas · 09/11/2023 08:03

I'm from North America, born in the 70s. Every boyfriend I had there was circumcised, as were all my friends' NA boyfriends. I have literally never heard of a single one of them having an issue with it, and certainly never heard of one of them having it redone!

ThePenguinIsDrunk · 09/11/2023 07:55

YABU for your YABU options. I don't agree with circumcision for non-medical or religious/cultural reasons but you cannot compare it to FGM. Posters aren't 'jumping to' the most severe version of FFM it exists and by comparing circumcision to it you are including all types. i'm not sure whether you are being deliberately provocative or just 'what about the menz'.

FoodCentre · 09/11/2023 07:40

@LoopyLooooo

I actually do think ear piercing should be done on adults rather children, b ex abuse it is cosmetic. But not because there's anything wrong with it, there's no identifiable harm that impacts a persons quality of life. Nobody lies awake at night wishing their parent didn't pierce their ears because now they can't orgasm, or suffer excruciating pain. It has no place on a thread about FGM or even circumcision.

And I still have heard what's 'wrong' with it.

CurlewKate · 09/11/2023 06:11

@spookehtooth "Can't we just call them both awful without comparing? I see no benefit to suffers of either experiences from any comparison."
Because while they are both abhorrent acts performed on children unable to consent, FGM has long term serious impacts on girls/women physically, sexually and emotionally. Circumcision, while also wrong, doesn't. It's a false equivalence, which minimises women's lived experience.

Pleaseme · 09/11/2023 06:05

Grapefruitsquash · 08/11/2023 22:29

I don't believe this. My best friend needed a medical circumcision and it was done under a local anaesthetic. It took less than 10 minutes.

I don't think they'd give babies a general anaesthetic for this. And how can it not work the first time?

Not the same thing atall but my baby had a general anaesthetic at 8 mo to correct a tongue tie that had been snipped at 2 weeks old and had healed badly with thick, fleshy scar tissue .

I can imagine if it heals badly it’s better to redo under general. Older children are really wiggly and uncooperative.

LoopyLooooo · 08/11/2023 22:53

FoodCentre · 08/11/2023 22:34

What's wrong with sticking holes in a child to decorate it?

If you can't even provide a serious answer, then I don't know what to say to you. You think this is mitigation yes - so please explain.

I had my ears pierced as a baby and it has precisely zero impact on my life. Was it necessary? No, of course not, it's cosmetic. I'm also fairly happy to have had it done.

What harm does it cause? How is it even in the same realm as male circumcision let alone FGM?

You asked what is wrong with piercing a child's ears.

What's wrong is that putting holes in children to decorate them is abhorrent and something that should be left to them to do as adults if they so wish.

It is in nowhere near the same realm as male circumcision or FGM.

crowisland · 08/11/2023 22:51

FWIW…I heard that the royal family traditionally always had their boys circumcised. Not sure if current generation is still doing this. Carried out by the Royal Moyle

spookehtooth · 08/11/2023 22:51

Can't we just call them both awful without comparing? I see no benefit to suffers of either experiences from any comparison.

I'd like to think that anyone who experiences either has some additional empathy & compassion for those who experience the other as a result. I was mutilated as a baby boy, I wouldn't even want to have that conversation with someone who suffered FGM. The biggest problem raising it as an issue is, nothing to do with women, it's the predominantly male religious hierarchy

Mumof2teens79 · 08/11/2023 22:50

There are a lot of circumcised mental feel itcery much is equivalent to FGM and I would not want to dismiss their feelings.
It's certainly entirely unnecessary and if we don't dock dogs tails or crop ears anymore we shouldn't be circumcising babies either.

But personally I don't think the risks or long term effects are anywhere near as bad as FGM.
Certainly it can go wrong for boys, but most men who have had it done successfully have no real problems. If they did men would have stopped this practice years ago.

FGM on the otherhand is often only considered successful if therd is significant loss of sensation and restricted opening.
And yet despite so many awful outcomes it continues because... patriarchy/misogyny .

So it's similar but not to same degree

CyberCritical · 08/11/2023 22:50

Read these stories OP and tell me whether you really believe the 2 things are equal.

Trigger warning, graphic accounts from women who are victims of FGM

x.com/thegirdlengr/status/1721899859329028558?s=61&t=_4AjlXbi-cbNgW2ZGAXrpQ

x.com/thegirdlengr/status/1721439109414080564?s=61&t=_4AjlXbi-cbNgW2ZGAXrpQ

Wotsitfappe · 08/11/2023 22:40

It's totally unacceptable. But it shows you have a huge ignorance of fgm of you think circumcision is the same.

QueenBitch666 · 08/11/2023 22:37

There's evidence of males slicing open their wives so they can have sex after FGM. No comparison whatsoever. FGM is fucking barbaric on an entirely different scale

FoodCentre · 08/11/2023 22:34

What's wrong with sticking holes in a child to decorate it?

If you can't even provide a serious answer, then I don't know what to say to you. You think this is mitigation yes - so please explain.

I had my ears pierced as a baby and it has precisely zero impact on my life. Was it necessary? No, of course not, it's cosmetic. I'm also fairly happy to have had it done.

What harm does it cause? How is it even in the same realm as male circumcision let alone FGM?

Grapefruitsquash · 08/11/2023 22:29

Cress42 · 08/11/2023 17:30

Yep, for whatever reason the first circumcision didn’t work and there are multiple people who are getting it done again, only this time the babies (all less than 1 years old) have to be put under general anaesthetic to have the procedure. They’re all seeking reassurance from one another. I can’t/won’t bring myself to comment

I don't believe this. My best friend needed a medical circumcision and it was done under a local anaesthetic. It took less than 10 minutes.

I don't think they'd give babies a general anaesthetic for this. And how can it not work the first time?

LoopyLooooo · 08/11/2023 22:25

FoodCentre · 08/11/2023 22:17

What's wrong with ear piercing now? Is that now mutilation the same league as circumcision, would you say?

What's wrong with sticking holes in a child to decorate it?

Is that a serious question?

FoodCentre · 08/11/2023 22:17

Shraree · 08/11/2023 21:41

I agree you are mutilating your child's body. See also ear piercing.
It's not as damaging as FGM, but it still should be illegal.

What's wrong with ear piercing now? Is that now mutilation the same league as circumcision, would you say?

Pleaseme · 08/11/2023 22:02

I personally think it’s wrong unless it’s medically necessary. That said circumcised men can still go on to have a relatively normal fulfilling sex life. I appreciate it can cause calcification and a loss of sensation.

FGM is brutal though, it’s not the same.

gravitytester · 08/11/2023 22:01

I disagree with both, but FGM of any form is horrific, traumatic and MEANT to emotionally and physically cripple women.
They are absolutely not the same. Nowhere near.

Vargas · 08/11/2023 21:58

Seriously? No equivalence whatsoever.

fearfuloffluff · 08/11/2023 21:56

You can disagree with circumcision without equating it to fgm.

You need to educate yourself about fgm.