Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that circumcising baby/young boys is the equivalent to FGM?

259 replies

Cress42 · 08/11/2023 17:22

I’m part of a baby group - our babies are all younger than 12 months and there are parents looking to get their sons REcircumcised 😢

They’re all based in America. I understand it’s a cultural norm there and nobody is talking about any medical issues to warrant having them circumcised.

It’s a fact that it causes desensitisation and part of me feels that along with the general pain of the operation this is similar to FGM.

The baby can’t consent to the mutilation. Also mutilation isn’t too severe a word, it literally means: act or instance of destroying, removing, or severely damaging a limb or other body part of a person or animal.

YABU - It’s not similar to FGM. There’s nothing wrong with it, snip away!

YANBU - It’s similar / the male equivalent to FGM and unless carried out for medical reasons it should be up to the discretion of the person who is being circumcised

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
NotBadConsidering · 09/11/2023 22:26

Not remotely comparable.

But they are comparable, and not remotely. As I wrote in an earlier post:

Tick ✅ or cross❌ if applies to both or not, FGM vs newborn (not adult) circumcision:

Done on non-consenting children ✅
Done by non-medical professionals ✅
Done without anaesthesia ✅
Done in non-sterile places in many parts of the world ✅
Done for cultural not medical reasons ✅
Results in permanent alteration of the genitalia ✅
Can have significant complications ✅
Can result in death ✅ many boys have died from newborn circumcision.

Results in significant alteration of sexual function ✅❌: there are more men that aren’t bothered compared to those who do suffer problems and are outspoken about them (reduced sensitivity, erectile issues) but that number is not zero. Equally, remarkably there are women who advocate for FGM (which is inexplicable to me) but they are a tiny minority. Importantly though, men suffer harm. Many men have no idea what sex could feel like if they hadn’t been circumcised. This is from late circumcision data.

The degree of tissue removed and the motivation behind it is where the comparisons diverge, but that doesn’t mean they aren’t remotely comparable.

AhNowTed · 09/11/2023 21:10

Circumcision - the cutting and removal of the foreskin.

FGM - the cutting and removal of the clitoris (type 1), plus the labia (type 2) with a rudimentary blade with no anaesthetic, and (type 3) sowing up the vulva so a tiny hole is left for urine and menstruation. None of the wounds are treated. Extreme likelihood of infection. Normal sex not possible only anal. Designed to control female desire. Childbirth excruciating. Woman mutilated for life.

Not remotely comparable.

2mummies1baby · 09/11/2023 20:29

I am totally anti-circumcision, but male circumcision and FGM are not even comparable. The male equivalent of FGM would be cutting off the head of the penis, not the foreskin.

IncompleteSenten · 09/11/2023 19:36

If it's medically necessary then it's medically necessary and not removing for no reason. I think it is black and white and that's as it should be.

Is it medically necessary?

Yes. Its a medical procedure being carried out for genuine reason / proven risk that it is in the patient's best interests to avoid.

no. It's a cultural / religious practice and there are no medical problems that are being solved by doing it.

There is no middle ground and there's no need to create one.

GoodnightGentlemen · 09/11/2023 19:15

ludocris · 09/11/2023 17:54

I take the point, but I still think that the two positions available to you as a parent (concerned and caring vs barbaric and abusive) are too extreme and leave no space for a middle ground.

The two examples given (mastectomy and removal of part of the liver) refer primarily to cancer diagnoses. Whereas phimosis, whilst sometimes being serious, could be mild enough that it just means the penis gets a bit sore from time to time and sometimes infected. If a parent decides to go for circumcision in those circumstances, are the medical issues enough to warrant an exemption from being labelled barbaric or abusive? Or does it have to be something as serious as a cancer diagnosis or immediate risk of death to get away with it?

This is no one's responsibility, but rhetoric like this can make it difficult to make a balanced decision.

I still don't feel that I'm effective expressing what I mean.

Phimosis is a medical condition (albeit one that varies in severity), “my son has been born with a foreskin but my religion says he shouldn’t have one” is never a medical condition.

I don’t think we need to worry about calling abusive practices abusive because some people might be worried about taking appropriate medical decisions if they have heard something being called abusive.

If I stood in the street and shoved my son until he was bent double and whacked him repeatedly, as hard as possible, on the back, because my religion told me too, people would say (rightly) it was child abuse. I know this. But that doesn’t mean if he was choking I’d stand about dithering because hitting children is abusive. People know the difference.

ludocris · 09/11/2023 17:54

I take the point, but I still think that the two positions available to you as a parent (concerned and caring vs barbaric and abusive) are too extreme and leave no space for a middle ground.

The two examples given (mastectomy and removal of part of the liver) refer primarily to cancer diagnoses. Whereas phimosis, whilst sometimes being serious, could be mild enough that it just means the penis gets a bit sore from time to time and sometimes infected. If a parent decides to go for circumcision in those circumstances, are the medical issues enough to warrant an exemption from being labelled barbaric or abusive? Or does it have to be something as serious as a cancer diagnosis or immediate risk of death to get away with it?

This is no one's responsibility, but rhetoric like this can make it difficult to make a balanced decision.

I still don't feel that I'm effective expressing what I mean.

Caerulea · 09/11/2023 16:36

Male circumcision is barbaric, nothing but for rare medical cases (foreskin too tight etc) excuses it. Absolutely nothing. I couldn't stay in the group & I couldn't leave without saying what I thought. Why the Fuck we excuse ppl for doing this to boys is beyond me.

However. If we go from the word barbaric for MC then there simply isn't an adequate word for FGM, there just isn't. I vote YANBU but that's the caveat.

Re ear piercing little kids (usually girls & not boys...) - I don't get it myself but it's not on the same level. 14yo ds has wanted his done for years & I said he has to wait till he's 15 before he permanently changes his body. And I say that as someone with huge tattoos.

GoodnightGentlemen · 09/11/2023 16:35

IncompleteSenten · 09/11/2023 16:33

Why something is done does change things though. It's crazy to think that it doesn't.

If a child has a tumor in their liver and has part of their liver removed to remove the tumor then good. That's what should happen.

If a child has no tumor and the parents ask someone to remove part of the child's liver purely because in their culture, children have been having part of their liver removed for hundreds of years - that's abuse. And barbaric.

This is a better way of saying what I was trying to say!

IncompleteSenten · 09/11/2023 16:33

Why something is done does change things though. It's crazy to think that it doesn't.

If a child has a tumor in their liver and has part of their liver removed to remove the tumor then good. That's what should happen.

If a child has no tumor and the parents ask someone to remove part of the child's liver purely because in their culture, children have been having part of their liver removed for hundreds of years - that's abuse. And barbaric.

GoodnightGentlemen · 09/11/2023 16:23

ludocris · 09/11/2023 15:49

@GoodnightGentlemen that's exactly what I mean. If, as a parent, you're told it's an option that could prevent future medical problems, I wouldn't deem that 'medically necessary'. Does that mean you're abusive if you choose to go down that route?

I don't think I explained my point very well though. It's really that I struggle to see how the same action can be 'barbaric' and 'abusive' if done for one reason, totally acceptable if done for another. Such rhetoric could make it very difficult to make an objective decision where there are potential medical issues down the road.

I think one of the big differences is that if it’s done on older children for medical reasons then it’s done with anaesthetic.

Also, I don’t think anyone would argue it’s never necessary- sometimes it is- but that goes for a lot of medical things.

A mastectomy for instance- everyone knows it’s a serious operation that can have serious psychological consequences, but we accept it is sometimes necessary and the lesser of two evils. People wouldn’t think of that as barbaric or abusive. Parents deciding to give their daughter a mastectomy for religious reasons though, rather than medical reasons, would definitely be barbaric and abusive.

Basically all medical procedures would be abusive if they were being done/not done because a third party decided it was necessary because of their belief system. Like withholding blood transfusions.

ludocris · 09/11/2023 15:49

@GoodnightGentlemen that's exactly what I mean. If, as a parent, you're told it's an option that could prevent future medical problems, I wouldn't deem that 'medically necessary'. Does that mean you're abusive if you choose to go down that route?

I don't think I explained my point very well though. It's really that I struggle to see how the same action can be 'barbaric' and 'abusive' if done for one reason, totally acceptable if done for another. Such rhetoric could make it very difficult to make an objective decision where there are potential medical issues down the road.

GoodnightGentlemen · 09/11/2023 15:34

ludocris · 09/11/2023 14:38

Personally I have a real issue with this black and white suggestion that male circumcision is alright if it's for medical reasons but disgusting if done for cultural or religious reasons. Because how is that going to make you feel, as a parent, if you have to make a decision where there's possibly a medical issue down the line, but not definitely? I totally understand people saying they personally wouldn't do it unless for medical reasons - that's one thing. But the hyperbolic language used, like 'mutilation' and 'abuse' can create such feelings of guilt and sorrow, unnecessarily. And can also lead to some terribly unfair judgement on the parts of some.

I’m struggling to understand what you mean. Do you mean that some boys are circumcised because it looks like there will be a future problem with their penis, and those parents won’t ever know 100% if it was necessary?

Or have I totally misunderstood?

I actually wish my ds had been circumcised as a baby… the nhs kept saying he might need it but wait until he is older… our gp now says he does need it (he is 9 now) but the waiting list is so long, the consultants keep disagreeing about it and he is dead against the idea now and I’m not comfortable forcing him into it.

s4usagefingers · 09/11/2023 15:10

BoobyDazzler · 09/11/2023 14:59

Im male have friends who were snipped. It hasn't effected their lives in any way.

You, or they, have no idea what sex would have been like with their foreskin intact.

But in the same vein why get upset over something you never experienced? My circumcised ex husband had a (too) active and colourful sex life and would have laughed if told he was missing out. The fact is the sensations were in different areas to an uncircumcised penis but not less. Having said that he would not have chosen circumcision if he’d been allowed to choose.

Also it is nothing like FGM, that’s a horrible idea.

Maddy70 · 09/11/2023 15:09

I agree. It is being done for religious reasons which in my opinion is barbaric and unnecessary

BoobyDazzler · 09/11/2023 14:59

Im male have friends who were snipped. It hasn't effected their lives in any way.

You, or they, have no idea what sex would have been like with their foreskin intact.

ludocris · 09/11/2023 14:38

Personally I have a real issue with this black and white suggestion that male circumcision is alright if it's for medical reasons but disgusting if done for cultural or religious reasons. Because how is that going to make you feel, as a parent, if you have to make a decision where there's possibly a medical issue down the line, but not definitely? I totally understand people saying they personally wouldn't do it unless for medical reasons - that's one thing. But the hyperbolic language used, like 'mutilation' and 'abuse' can create such feelings of guilt and sorrow, unnecessarily. And can also lead to some terribly unfair judgement on the parts of some.

Elvis1956 · 09/11/2023 14:30

Im male have friends who were snipped. It hasn't effected their lives in any way.

FGM is dreadful and designed to ensure women cannot enjoy sex. Now you cannot compare the two

Brefugee · 09/11/2023 13:59

Cress42 · 08/11/2023 17:22

I’m part of a baby group - our babies are all younger than 12 months and there are parents looking to get their sons REcircumcised 😢

They’re all based in America. I understand it’s a cultural norm there and nobody is talking about any medical issues to warrant having them circumcised.

It’s a fact that it causes desensitisation and part of me feels that along with the general pain of the operation this is similar to FGM.

The baby can’t consent to the mutilation. Also mutilation isn’t too severe a word, it literally means: act or instance of destroying, removing, or severely damaging a limb or other body part of a person or animal.

YABU - It’s not similar to FGM. There’s nothing wrong with it, snip away!

YANBU - It’s similar / the male equivalent to FGM and unless carried out for medical reasons it should be up to the discretion of the person who is being circumcised

Look up what FGM actually is. It is nowhere near the same.

Neither is acceptable

Cress42 · 09/11/2023 13:40

VoiceOfCommonSense · 09/11/2023 12:12

YABU, stupid comments like this minimise the horrific barbaric practice of FGM. Circumcision is nothing at all like FGM. I don’t like the idea of circumcision but apparently there are health benefits to it.

There are no health benefits to newborns / young boys

Stupid comments like yours normalise the practice of circumcision

OP posts:
Pumpkinpie1 · 09/11/2023 13:28

Ridiculous

RomeoOscarXrayXray · 09/11/2023 13:27

Comparing circumcision to FGM is awful and minimises the absolute damage to girls.

Circumcision is sometimes medically necessary - is what happens to girls EVER medically necessary?

You can disagree with the practice without comparing it to FGM.

LoopyLooooo · 09/11/2023 12:38

FoodCentre · 09/11/2023 11:58

@LoopyLooooo

Yeah whatever. It's a pretty straightforward process, albeit unnecessary which is why I didn't do it for my children.

Why is ear piercing in a conversation about genital mutilation?

No idea but you asked what was wrong with it so I answered.

MrsSlocombesCat · 09/11/2023 12:38

I remember years ago my baby son had to have an operation because his kidney wasn’t functioning properly. On the same ward there was a baby with Hirschsprungs who had undergone a big operation to remove part of his colon. On the day the parents took him home the mother said to the nurse that he was going to be circumcised due to their religion after he had recovered. It upset me so much at the time and I still think about it. I don’t think it’s as bad as FGM but it’s still awful to put babies through an unnecessary operation in the name of religion.

comfyshoes2022 · 09/11/2023 12:20

I don’t like it but it’s not the same

NotBadConsidering · 09/11/2023 12:15

but apparently there are health benefits to it.

There are no health benefits to newborn circumcision.