Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that circumcising baby/young boys is the equivalent to FGM?

259 replies

Cress42 · 08/11/2023 17:22

I’m part of a baby group - our babies are all younger than 12 months and there are parents looking to get their sons REcircumcised 😢

They’re all based in America. I understand it’s a cultural norm there and nobody is talking about any medical issues to warrant having them circumcised.

It’s a fact that it causes desensitisation and part of me feels that along with the general pain of the operation this is similar to FGM.

The baby can’t consent to the mutilation. Also mutilation isn’t too severe a word, it literally means: act or instance of destroying, removing, or severely damaging a limb or other body part of a person or animal.

YABU - It’s not similar to FGM. There’s nothing wrong with it, snip away!

YANBU - It’s similar / the male equivalent to FGM and unless carried out for medical reasons it should be up to the discretion of the person who is being circumcised

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Thread gallery
5
samG76 · 11/11/2023 20:29

Totaly - “most religions are based on kindness and caring”.

Where did you get that idea from? I’d’ve thought the opposite…..

iLovee · 11/11/2023 03:57

Its not the same 🤷‍♀️ FGM happeneds when the girl is older, normally woth unsterile equipment and causes life-long pain and consequences.

Maybe you should post on an American forum instead if you are American? Thankfully, i am (perhaps nieve-ly) hoping that most "average mn user" would not have to deal with FGM, or indeed circumcision. Male circumcision is very, very rare oursode of religious reasons.

NotBadConsidering · 11/11/2023 03:28

My view is that men are highly unlikely to perpetuate practices that diminish their own sexual pleasures as a sex, so the harms are exaggerated.

Outside of religious practice, circumcision became popular in the Victorian era because of an attempt to curb the immoral practice of masturbation. Circumcision can most definitely result in negative impacts on the masturbation and sex practices of men:

https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/17155977/

63% masturbation difficulty after.
20% worse sex life after.

When it’s done to babies, they don’t get to weigh up this evidence. When it’s done to everyone in your community and country, no one ever considers any alternative outcome. When it was done to men as babies there’s nothing to be gained from dwelling on what might have been. It can’t be put back on.

I would welcome legislation prosecuting parents and practitioners from practising circumcision. I don’t think religion freedom should be extended to cutting of healthy functioning body parts of non-consenting children because of a belief in sky fairies.

The effect of male circumcision on sexuality - PubMed

There was a decrease in masturbatory pleasure and sexual enjoyment after circumcision, indicating that adult circumcision adversely affects sexual function in many men, possibly because of complications of the surgery and a loss of nerve endings.

https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/17155977/

Screamingabdabz · 11/11/2023 00:01

Prrambulate · 10/11/2023 23:46

The UK is not going to start imprisoning rabbis any time soon so it’s a moot point.

My view is that men are highly unlikely to perpetuate practices that diminish their own sexual pleasures as a sex, so the harms are exaggerated.

How would they know? If it’s been their culture since childhood and all their community have it done, they won’t necessarily compare and contrast.

Prrambulate · 10/11/2023 23:46

Totaly · 10/11/2023 23:14

Do the majority of posters here believe that all practising Jewish and Muslim parents in the UK should be imprisoned for 7 years?

Do you think it’s right that babies are harmed for religious reasons?
surely these practices are outdated now? Most religions are based on kindness and caring - this goes against that.

The UK is not going to start imprisoning rabbis any time soon so it’s a moot point.

My view is that men are highly unlikely to perpetuate practices that diminish their own sexual pleasures as a sex, so the harms are exaggerated.

Prrambulate · 10/11/2023 23:44

This basically equates child ear piercing with FGM which I know is basically the mumsnet view.

Totaly · 10/11/2023 23:14

Do the majority of posters here believe that all practising Jewish and Muslim parents in the UK should be imprisoned for 7 years?

Do you think it’s right that babies are harmed for religious reasons?
surely these practices are outdated now? Most religions are based on kindness and caring - this goes against that.

IncompleteSenten · 10/11/2023 16:04

Prrambulate · 09/11/2023 23:31

In the UK, anyone failing to protect a girl from FGM faces up to 7 years in prison.

Do the majority of posters here believe that all practising Jewish and Muslim parents in the UK should be imprisoned for 7 years?

Because if you think they are comparable, then it stands to reason that the legal consequences should also be the same.

Personally I think it should be illegal to remove or modify any part of the body of anyone unable to give informed consent unless such removal or modification is medically necessary.

The only body someone should be allowed to just chop bits off of in the game of culture or religion is their own.

Blondeshavemorefun · 10/11/2023 15:02

Imo it's wrong as baby get no choice

Diff for medical

I don't believe it should be done for religious either tbh

If older and man wants it done or as my friends son at 11 as having issues with foreskin /pain/infection

But their choice

My views are Same as ear piercing a baby

No need

If at it done at 5/8/13 when older then fine

Winteriscoming12 · 10/11/2023 14:44

Cress42 · 10/11/2023 13:44

If only anal is possible then childbirth isn’t.. 🙄

Only anal until marriage. Stops pregnancy outside marriage, I guess. Then the joy of being cut open by your new husband on your wedding night, with sex to follow through a raw wound. Nice.

Cress42 · 10/11/2023 13:44

AhNowTed · 09/11/2023 21:10

Circumcision - the cutting and removal of the foreskin.

FGM - the cutting and removal of the clitoris (type 1), plus the labia (type 2) with a rudimentary blade with no anaesthetic, and (type 3) sowing up the vulva so a tiny hole is left for urine and menstruation. None of the wounds are treated. Extreme likelihood of infection. Normal sex not possible only anal. Designed to control female desire. Childbirth excruciating. Woman mutilated for life.

Not remotely comparable.

If only anal is possible then childbirth isn’t.. 🙄

OP posts:
NotBadConsidering · 10/11/2023 00:21

Another comparator:

Those who practice both with come up with spurious weak justifications for their practice and deny any problems with it✅

NotBadConsidering · 10/11/2023 00:15

AhNowTed · 10/11/2023 00:05

@NotBadConsidering

The latter is not "worse"

The latter is butchered beyond all recognition.

I'm not sure what point you're trying to make anymore to be frank.

Yes it’s worse. Horrific. Butchered beyond recognition.

So is penile amputation when it goes wrong.

The point I’m trying to make is that just because one is objectively more horrific than another doesn’t mean they aren’t “remotely” comparable. I have listed many comparisons that are shared properties of both practices.

NotBadConsidering · 10/11/2023 00:13

therealcookiemonster · 10/11/2023 00:07

@NotBadConsidering I also never said male circumcision is essential... feel like you are responding to someone else's post rather than mine?

Ok, sorry, I misquoted you. You brought up the fallacy of circumcision reducing rates of HIV and STIs. I want to know why this matters for circumcising newborns.

The data of reducing HIV/STIs is very weak. It’s based on studies where HIV rates were very high, so a reduction would seem significant anyway, and didn’t factor in that many men in the study period had to abstain from sex because they’d just been circumcised. And the rates of reduction weren’t anywhere near as good as wearing a condom.

It also doesn’t explain why baby boys need to be circumcised. Baby boys aren’t having sex. Baby boys don’t contract HIV through sex. Baby boys should be given the option of growing up and deciding whether they’d rather a) have a piece of their penis removed or b) wear a condom.

It’s nice that you haven’t seen any complications (although surprising, I would expect you have seen some) I have, some horrific ones, but as a worldwide population it occurs on such a widespread basis that serious complications are inevitable.

therealcookiemonster · 10/11/2023 00:07

@NotBadConsidering I also never said male circumcision is essential... feel like you are responding to someone else's post rather than mine?

AhNowTed · 10/11/2023 00:05

@NotBadConsidering

The latter is not "worse"

The latter is butchered beyond all recognition.

I'm not sure what point you're trying to make anymore to be frank.

therealcookiemonster · 10/11/2023 00:00

@NotBadConsidering I never said neonates, that was the study you quoted.. I said infants, quire different.

obviously not, but one hopes when they grow up they are safer, although should be practising safe sex obviously, I am just sharing evidence, its facts - how you choose to use that information to make decisions is up to you, not here to be adverserial

therealcookiemonster · 09/11/2023 23:57

@NotBadConsidering the study you quoted compare neonates and children.... I was talking about the comparison between infants (so 6wk+, definitely would not reccommend in neonates) and adults.

I probably know hundreds of men circumcised in infancy or childhood and I have been involved in hospital management in Bangladesh for over two decades with very high numbers of childhood circumcision (we are talking few hundred cases a week!) - can't remember complications except rarely. in my personal practice in the uk have managed atleast 2 - 300 adult circs... no early complications, not sure about late ones... have to look at the evidence for exact numbers.

obviously each to one's own, if someone doesn't want to circumcised their child, they shouldn't

NotBadConsidering · 09/11/2023 23:55

there is also strong evidence that circumcision reduces spread of some STIs, most notably HIV and genital herpes (will provide links on request).

I would like to see a link showing baby boys are having sex and contracting HIV and herpes at such a rate that neonatal circumcision is essential.

NotBadConsidering · 09/11/2023 23:48

there is a small risk of complications but this risk is extremely small in infancy (when most circumcision take place

This is not true. The complication rate is higher in neonates:

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9679242/

Overall complication rate of 8%, risk of bleeding 2.5%. Given it’s a procedure carried out on millions of baby boys worldwide per year, that is thousands of baby boys suffering serious complications every year. Because male genital mutilation is more widely practised, it will result in greater numbers of boys with serious problems. But it also means there are many, many who don’t who obscure this number.

A comprehensive comparison of the early and late complications of surgical circumcision in neonates and children: A cohort study

Major circumcision complications are rare; however, circumcision arouses distress in some special cases. The present study aimed to compare infancy and childhood regarding the frequency and relative risk of early and late complications of circumcision....

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9679242/

therealcookiemonster · 09/11/2023 23:39

having come across both FGM and circumcised patients in my medical practice, I can categorically say there is no comparison. we regularly do circumcision in adult men for medical reasons. there is a small risk of complications but this risk is extremely small in infancy (when most circumcision take place). the nerves in this region are not well developed at this time, so it is also not as painful. please see below a review of the scientific literature which states that circumcision does not cause desensitisation, sexual dysfunction etc. etc.

there is also strong evidence that circumcision reduces spread of some STIs, most notably HIV and genital herpes (will provide links on request).

having seen (and unfortunately smelt) foreskin infections, if i was a man, i would want it off. but each to one's own. i can understand why many find it difficult to accept.

https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/23937309/#:~:text=Conclusion%3A%20The%20highest%2Dquality%20studies,%2C%20sexual%20sensation%2C%20or%20satisfaction.

Does male circumcision affect sexual function, sensitivity, or satisfaction?--a systematic review - PubMed

The highest-quality studies suggest that medical male circumcision has no adverse effect on sexual function, sensitivity, sexual sensation, or satisfaction.

https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/23937309#:~:text=Conclusion%3A%20The%20highest%2Dquality%20studies,%2C%20sexual%20sensation%2C%20or%20satisfaction.

NotBadConsidering · 09/11/2023 23:35

AhNowTed · 09/11/2023 23:13

@NotBadConsidering

One has their foreskin removed.

The other is mutilated beyond recognition of what a vulva/vagina looks like.

I understand what you're trying to say, both have their genitals mutilated without consent, but the end-result is very different.

I'm not going to post pics here as they are so appalling, but look up FGM type 3. It's horrific.

As I posted earlier, the foreskin removed is the equivalent of 15 square inches of skin on an adult male. Draw a rectangle of 3 inches X 5 inches on your own skin for comparison.

I’m not saying male genital mutilation is as horrific as female genital mutilation. Clearly the latter is worse. It’s just not true to say they’re not remotely comparable, that’s all.

Prrambulate · 09/11/2023 23:31

In the UK, anyone failing to protect a girl from FGM faces up to 7 years in prison.

Do the majority of posters here believe that all practising Jewish and Muslim parents in the UK should be imprisoned for 7 years?

Because if you think they are comparable, then it stands to reason that the legal consequences should also be the same.

WearyAuldWumman · 09/11/2023 23:29

Busephalus · 08/11/2023 17:27

I can't vote either, because whilst I don't agree with it, it's nowhere near as bad as fgm

Agreed. My uni boyfriend had it done in his 20s, because he had a problem with an overly tight foreskin.

AhNowTed · 09/11/2023 23:13

@NotBadConsidering

One has their foreskin removed.

The other is mutilated beyond recognition of what a vulva/vagina looks like.

I understand what you're trying to say, both have their genitals mutilated without consent, but the end-result is very different.

I'm not going to post pics here as they are so appalling, but look up FGM type 3. It's horrific.