Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Fil’s ‘manners’

182 replies

ItsMissChanandlerBong · 08/11/2023 16:38

This is a bit of an awkward issue, and I’m hoping for some advice on how to deal with it!

My fil is THE loveliest man. We have a great relationship and he’s an amazing fil and grandad. But one awkward thing keeps cropping up, his insistence on ‘old fashioned manners’. These include opening all doors for me, pulling out chairs, kisses on the cheek on greeting and leaving, all of which make me very uncomfortable! He even attempts to put my coat on for me by picking it up and holding it out.

I once got to a door first and held it open for my husband who was carrying our son. My fil refused to walk through unless he was holding it open as it would be rude! This led to a weird awkward standoff.

I suppose I want to know if I’m being unreasonable and should just let him do these things for me (which he NEVER does for his son or any other male) or do I keep doing what I’m doing (rushing ahead to get to the car first, grabbing my coat as soon as we’re leaving and deliberately choosing a chair no where near him at dinner). Or do I brave it and say to him I’d rather do it myself…

OP posts:
ManateeFair · 08/11/2023 18:17

Honestly, I couldn't get remotely worked up about this. No, it's not necessary for him to do this things and yes, it's moderately sexist, but jeez, it's sexist in the least harmful and most well-meaning way ever. Insisting on holding a door or helping with your coat, for men of his generation, is basically the old man equivalent of Mrs Doyle in Father Ted becoming anxious if she can't provide a cup of tea. It's not really needed and sometimes mildly baffling but it honestly comes from a good place and it's not a battle I would choose.

Both my grandads were old-school cockney gents born in the 1910s and had absolutely astonishing 'manners' towards women. They would tell other men off for swearing in women's company, even if the women swore themselves. One of them would offer me his seat when he was in his 90s (obviously I didn't accept it and make a 95-year-old man stand, I'm not a monster).

Ohhbaby · 08/11/2023 18:14

I would really like to understand why this grates you so much?
I think that generations were raised differently and whilst I generally think we should have respect for that, I can understand if you were to speak up about things that are harmful to you. Say for example your father in law believed only women should care for the babies and expected you to do all the nappies or if he expected you to make his tea for him because you were female ect.
But nothing he is doing is harming you in any way? I presume if you walked into the office door and a female colleague kept the door open for you to walk in behind, you'd accept.
Now because it's a man you fume about it.
I can think of more than one person that's being sexist here.
He was raised that this is a respectful thing to do for women. You are basically for sing him to do something that was ingrained in him to be disrespectful.

Honestly I find that selfish.
It takes so little of your time to respect someone enough to just walk through the door when it's open. It takes longer to argue about it

As a side note I don't know why we give our own kin so little slack.

We accept it if someone is from a different culture. We go 'oh it's their culture, we've got to be respectful of that'. Do you go to a Muslim woman and say that she should drop wearing the birka if her husband can go without covering his head?
Or speak to the Indian woman and ask why she is doing all the cooking? No you don't.

But for your own fil, who arguably grew up in a different 'culture' (one where men where taught that certain things are respectful to women) you are unwilling to budge an inch

ashleysilver · 08/11/2023 18:11

I think it's sexist and infantilising. Refusing to walk through the door that you politely hold open for him is insulting, not polite at all.

I get why you don't want to make a fuss about it, but I wouldn't feel comfortable with that behaviour either.

Cornishclio · 08/11/2023 18:03

Personally I couldn't get upset over this but I am older than you. It is just old fashioned manners and the way boys were brought up to treat women as the fairer sex and hold doors open or give up your seat etc etc. I don't suppose he knows you consider it degrading unless you tell him. So do you feel strongly enough about it to embarrass him and tell him you would rather he not treat you differently to his son or other men. Does he treat your MIL the same way?

Dacadactyl · 08/11/2023 18:02

pickledandpuzzled · 08/11/2023 18:00

My sons and I help my mum in this way, and wouldn’t dream of doing differently. I very much hope they do for me as I get older.

I am already at the stage where I wish strong young people would hold the door, or open it for me, as it takes all my strength these days.

Men are generally stronger- opening and holding a weighted door like a restaurant or a fire door is genuinely easier for them. Carrying your shopping bags etc.

I think it’s a shame we’ve lost all that to be honest. Women might find life a bit easier if men were helpful instead of ignorant.

A while back a man wordlessly took a bag from me as I wrestled my way down the station stairs, then deposited it at the bottom, without breaking stride or uttering a word. I can’t tell you how appreciative I was.

Some on here would've called the police at that bloke 😂

I'd have been thinking "there's a proper man"

angowa · 08/11/2023 18:01

How old is he? 150?! I'm not sure it's about age really. It all seems a bit performative if you're having a stand off at the door like that. It's a bit of a showy gallant knight nonsense to me. Does he do it with other women?

I had a male colleague once who laid on all that stuff and I told him I'd rather he didn't do that kind of thing with me. He frowned but did stop doing it. We still got along. However, is FIL going to change his behaviour if you tell him nicely to cut it out or will he act all hurt and confused? If you tell him not to and he continues that's treating you like a child.

pickledandpuzzled · 08/11/2023 18:00

My sons and I help my mum in this way, and wouldn’t dream of doing differently. I very much hope they do for me as I get older.

I am already at the stage where I wish strong young people would hold the door, or open it for me, as it takes all my strength these days.

Men are generally stronger- opening and holding a weighted door like a restaurant or a fire door is genuinely easier for them. Carrying your shopping bags etc.

I think it’s a shame we’ve lost all that to be honest. Women might find life a bit easier if men were helpful instead of ignorant.

A while back a man wordlessly took a bag from me as I wrestled my way down the station stairs, then deposited it at the bottom, without breaking stride or uttering a word. I can’t tell you how appreciative I was.

reclaimmyboobs · 08/11/2023 17:58

housethatbuiltme · 08/11/2023 17:51

Also the 'suck it up, your comfort doesn't matter since hes being a nice guy'... is so sickening to hear coming from other women.

Yes. I don’t want my coat put on for me or to have to do a silly dance to change around who’s going through a door and who’s holding it instead of just behaving normally. But because it’s “manners” OP has to indulge him? Whereas if he were a mouth kisser or a hugger, does she have to indulge him there too, because he means well and he wants to do it?

Trevorton · 08/11/2023 17:57

ItsMissChanandlerBong · 08/11/2023 17:32

@justalittlesnoel I think I feel like it infantilises me more than from a feminist perspective (although yes it does bother me that it’s only because I’m female). Especially the coat thing. I feel like a child having my coat put on 😬

Oh FFS... Have you not heard of chivalry? Surely this is better than some arsehole going through a door first and letting it slam in your face. It's gentlemanly manners is all. After reading about the abusive and nasty arseholes in so many posts on here you should thank your lucky stars you have a gentleman as a FIL.

W0tnow · 08/11/2023 17:56

He’s a man of his time. I’d leave it.

Oops! I’ve just seen his age! He’s 2 years older than me! Well. That is verrry unusual behaviour!

UncleHerbie · 08/11/2023 17:56

JaneyGee · 08/11/2023 17:54

Not a very pleasant or respectful way to describe an elderly man.

Cracking up at “elderly”! The “old codger” is a decrepit 57 😂

ThatAlbinoCat · 08/11/2023 17:55

Seren00090 · 08/11/2023 17:26

Jesus ducking Christ.
Imagine being offended by your family trying to be nice to you.

This.

MY (late) used to eat like an animal, fart and belch - no matter who was there, sit down without leaving a seat for anyone else (he'd put his legs up on the settee), scoff the last of the potatoes/veg/dessert/wine. etc., without waiting to see if anyone else might like some.

Be glad your FIL is a gentleman.

JaneyGee · 08/11/2023 17:54

Haydenn · 08/11/2023 16:42

It’s charming and makes him happy. Indulge the old codger.

Not a very pleasant or respectful way to describe an elderly man.

ItsMissChanandlerBong · 08/11/2023 17:53

@Haydenn 😂 he’s 57 so not really old

OP posts:
SecondUsername4me · 08/11/2023 17:53

I don't kiss or hug anyone I don't want to, so I'd say something about the cheek kisses. The rest I'd not raise as it's harmless quirks.

However, your children - do you have boys and girls? I'd raise any disparity in the way he treats them.

ItsMissChanandlerBong · 08/11/2023 17:51

Just want to reiterate that I know this is not even an actual problem and I do know how lucky I am. Fil is great and there’s no bad intent.

Thinking about it, it’s really the coat thing that bothers me. But the talk about how he won’t always be around has made me realise it’s a small thing to put up with. I would never make a fuss about it and haven’t mentioned anything to DH. I suppose I just wanted to see what other’s perspective was

OP posts:
housethatbuiltme · 08/11/2023 17:51

Also the 'suck it up, your comfort doesn't matter since hes being a nice guy'... is so sickening to hear coming from other women.

Passepartoute · 08/11/2023 17:49

Haydenn · 08/11/2023 16:42

It’s charming and makes him happy. Indulge the old codger.

Why assume he's an old codger? You can be a grandfather at 40. This sounds very much like the sort of thing people like Jacob Rees-Mogg would do (shudders).

housethatbuiltme · 08/11/2023 17:48

I hate it too... its sexist and infantalising, nothing 'charming' about it.

charm means 'to delight someone' if OP is not delighted by these actions (in fact irritated and a little offended) then its in no way 'charming'.

Its fine for a man to hold the door if he is there first but to refuse to walk through a door your holding or to race me to the door like a child because a woman couldn't possibly... ewww no.

I had a ex that did it and everyone thought the sun shone out of his arse but honestly it was the dullest relationship in the world and I couldn't stand it (needless to say hes an ex).

PortiaWithNoBreaks · 08/11/2023 17:46

It’s quite lovely I think. It sounds like he’s very fond you. Maybe not a hill to die on.

Zanatdy · 08/11/2023 17:43

I think it’s charming. I thought this thread was going to be about how rude he was. He sounds delightful

ItsMissChanandlerBong · 08/11/2023 17:43

@WB205020 this is a really helpful response. Thank you. It is refreshing and I should appreciate how nice he is to me

OP posts:
AcrossthePond55 · 08/11/2023 17:42

@ItsMissChanandlerBong

If FiL treats you with respect, if he doesn't denigrate you or women in general as 'lesser than' then I'd just let it go. It's old fashioned manners and he's not making some sort of statement of your or a woman's status in society.

My DH still opens doors for me, helps me on with my coat, and I occasionally find him walking on the street side of the pavement. I certainly don't take it as gestures of disrespect. Rather, I see them as harmless gestures of affection.

ItsMissChanandlerBong · 08/11/2023 17:40

@Seren00090 oh no I’m not offended! I know how lucky I am. He’s amazing. I just feel awkward having coats put on me, not being able to hold a door open for him etc but from the responses on here I need to suck it up and appreciate how lovely he is. It’s obviously my issue

OP posts:
Ponoka7 · 08/11/2023 17:39

Seren00090 · 08/11/2023 17:26

Jesus ducking Christ.
Imagine being offended by your family trying to be nice to you.

Yes we should all put up with being dressed like we are little girls.
Watch old films and see how women were infantilised, which fed into the beliefs around our husbands having the right to control us and the police not taking us seriously.

Swipe left for the next trending thread