Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DS hurt another child, so humiliated

288 replies

ToddlerIs2 · 08/11/2023 16:34

So there's a boy that annoys DS. Seems to revel in winding DS up just to before the point where he's actively naughty. Not an excuse, just context.

Today the child, C, did something annoying but not something that harmed DS - screwed up some paper on the table. DS thought he was going to throw it at him so DS pushed down on C's hand to make him drop the paper, hurting C.

Happened right at the end of school so DS was told off and sent to another classroom for the last half hour but no time to discuss punishment with SLT.

I just feel so humiliated that school will think he's a violent child who witnessed violence in the home and it just acting out his upbringing. This isn't the case.

I've told him he's looking at an internal exclusion (for deliberately putting hands on C to hurt him) and once I can talk to DH tomorrow a punishment at home. I've told him if this happens again he'll end up excluded permanently and he won't be able to see his friends. He hates the idea of being homeschooled. I've explained that being internally excluded could mean him missing photo day with his brothers in school and a cultural day. No pint grounding him, he doesn't go out without us, even Cubs he goes to with me. He's not allowed to play his game tonight or on YouTube later.

What punishment would you give and how the fuck is this my life and my child? I don't understand where we've gone wrong or how I'm meant to stop this given I don't know where I've messed up as a parent.

I'm so angry with him and me.

OP posts:
ToddlerIs2 · 08/11/2023 18:06

margotrose · 08/11/2023 17:59

He's being bullied - do you not see the link?

This kid is low level annoying, stuff like pretending to wee at the table, not at DA, the other kids ignore of laugh off but really winds up DS.

And DS just won't tell the teacher, he's so focused on what C is doing, he "forgets" to tell.

OP posts:
Myfabby · 08/11/2023 18:06

Didimum · 08/11/2023 18:01

Reporting isn’t only to flag material that is ‘against the rules’. When there is a well-being concern, MN can step in with more guided support. It’s not about getting the post removed.

Thanks for clarifying - I didn't know that.

Jibo · 08/11/2023 18:03

You are massively overreacting. Be kind to yourself and show DS you love him and are on his side. The other kid sounds like he deserves what he gets and can handle it!

Children are naturally very physical (esp boys I think) and in preschool and primary years it's not appropriate to judge by adult standards. You have 2 3yo boys so you must see this all the time? Personally when children are evenly matched in size/age I think it's generally best to leave them to work things out - if you're a twin mum this will become apparent over the next few years if it isn't already! I wouldn't let DS lay hands on his little brothers as he needs to learn not to use his strength against smaller weaker beings, but a scuffle between him and a schoolmate who winds him up is not a big deal. He shouldn't be punished at home as well as at school.

Mariposista · 08/11/2023 18:03

OP you're not being unreasonable per se, as in you are mortified that your son has drawn attention to himself via bad behaviour which has led to another child being hurt.
But take a step back - he is not a gangster yet. He is 8 and is learning how to deal with provocation. He needs to learnt to tell a teacher if he is being picked on, rather than take matters into his own hands. School have punished him, as have you. Clean slate tomorrow.

Topseyt123 · 08/11/2023 18:02

You're not a shit mom. You are a very anxious one though.

It means you care, but you need to remember that your DS is just being a fairly typical 8 year old who has reached his limit with the other brat's provocation of him.

You need to impress upon this year's class teacher that they were actually separated last year because they just didn't get on and that nothing has changed now. They still need to be separated.

Honestly, get this into perspective. If schools were to regularly exclude 8 year old boys (or sometimes girls) for this sort of stuff there would hardly be any of them in the classroom.

You have dealt with it proportionately already. School have too. Now you just need to push for the boys to be seated separately.

ToddlerIs2 · 08/11/2023 18:02

ChekhovsMum · 08/11/2023 17:26

Do the thing school probably won’t have time to do: talk to him in depth about what happened, what he thought as it happened, how it made him feel and what he hoped to gain from pushing the boy’s hand down. Do this without any judgement, and avoid a snippy tone of voice even if you think his reaction was unreasonable or you don’t understand his logic.
When you’ve properly listened to him, get him to think of all the unwanted consequences of being physical - not just the punishments and the consequences on himself, but the consequences on the other boy, how he will remember the incident, how he will feel in school and around your son, etc. There may even be other children who saw this and now think of your son as someone to avoid. Chances are your son will see that the overall end result is not quite what he wanted.
Next, get him to think of all the different things he could have done instead with his anger, and the consequences of each. Make your own suggestions alongside his if you think he’s missed a possibility, but let his suggestions stand too. Work out some of the good and unwanted consequences of those suggestions.
At the end of this, your son may not react with perfect zen tranquility and total diplomacy to every annoying thing that happens, but he will have thought properly about consequences and options, and he’ll be on the way to owning his reactions.
Punishment for things like this just makes kids push their negative emotions down and think they’re bad for having them in the first place. Then next time they’re physical with someone they hide it and lie about it better, or argue harder that the other person deserved it.

Thank you.
I do think the consequences is something he struggles to retain. Which is why I wanted to impress them on him so heavily, so if even 50% of it sticks, he will do something different.
I'm aware how frustration and anger needs dealing with, were trying to access some parenting classes for kids with autism to see if that will give us some new ideas

OP posts:
Didimum · 08/11/2023 18:01

Myfabby · 08/11/2023 17:54

I'm curious, how does reporting help her? Will MN HQ send her mental help tips/doctor? or they'll just delete/hide the thread?

I see someone anxiously looking for reassurance/advice.

Reporting isn’t only to flag material that is ‘against the rules’. When there is a well-being concern, MN can step in with more guided support. It’s not about getting the post removed.

EvilElsa · 08/11/2023 18:01

Myfabby · 08/11/2023 17:54

I'm curious, how does reporting help her? Will MN HQ send her mental help tips/doctor? or they'll just delete/hide the thread?

I see someone anxiously looking for reassurance/advice.

I think maybe because OP is clearly very anxious and AIBU can be brutally honest/unkind at times. Might cause more harm than good. I don't think anyone has been particularly harsh here but if the OP is already frazzled and sensitive it may seem that way to her.

PaperDoIIs · 08/11/2023 17:59

Because where has he learnt this behaviour?

That is not how it works.

ToddlerIs2 · 08/11/2023 17:59

sparepantsandtoothbrush · 08/11/2023 17:21

How exactly was this other child hurt? It can't have been badly

If your son was mine then I'd be fighting against any type of exclusion just for defending himself! All you're going to do by scaring him with threats of permanent exclusion is raise him to let others push him around through fear of being punished for it. So next time this other child does something you're happy for yours to just sit there and take it?

He has been told to ignore annoying behaviour or tell the teacher, if he thinks he's going to do something to shout out and tell someone, to move, to put his hand up.

I will be mentioning all the stuff they C has done to annoy DS but DS just won't tell!! If he won't tell on C, school don't see it and I find out vaguely weeks later (I've asked if they've fell out much this week, apparently C keeps pretending to wee. Have you told the teacher? No, I forgot!).

OP posts:
margotrose · 08/11/2023 17:59

ToddlerIs2 · 08/11/2023 17:56

Because where has he learnt this behaviour?

He's being bullied - do you not see the link?

Clemmie4 · 08/11/2023 17:59

How would you have reacted if your son came home and told you the other child chucked the paper ball at his face and your son reacted by doing absolutely nothing?

Your child was assertive not violent and he’s being punished for it.
He moved the child’s hand down, he didn’t pin it to the table and repeatedly stab a broken pencil through it.
In future he may not stick up for himself due to concerns of your reaction.
You’re being too hard on both him and yourself.

PaperDoIIs · 08/11/2023 17:59

@ToddlerIs2 in the nicest possible way , are you ok? The catastrophising,worrying the school lives in an abusive household, calling yourself a shit mum etc. all of them point to someone who is struggling. Stress, anxiety? Something is going on, and I think you're so overwhelmed you can't see the tree from the woods.

Leave this be. The school will deal with it, you gave a punishment, you had the talk it's done. However have a good look/think at whatever else is going on with you and whether you'd benefit from seeing your gp.

bombastix · 08/11/2023 17:58

He doesn't sound evil to me. He's been punished by the school and is 8.

Don't feel ashamed. None of this is very terrible. If your son was in his teens it would be different.

ToddlerIs2 · 08/11/2023 17:56

Passepartoute · 08/11/2023 17:25

I just feel so humiliated that school will think he's a violent child who witnessed violence in the home and it just acting out his upbringing. This isn't the case.

Assuming this is a one off, why on earth would the school jump to these conclusions from this one rather minor incident?

Because where has he learnt this behaviour?

OP posts:
ToddlerIs2 · 08/11/2023 17:55

PrudeyTwoShoes · 08/11/2023 17:06

Massive overreaction, OP. No, you shouldn't excuse the behaviour but you said he only pushed his had away as he was worried C would throw the paper. Defending yourself is very different to deliberately trying to hurt someone for no reason. Obviously C was hurt, so your son should be remorseful but I think the root issue lies elsewhere. I'd be speaking to his teacher and asking if they can be separated.

No C had his hand holding the scrunched paper and DS pushed DOWN by his own admission pushed hard and hurt C.

OP posts:
Alifestylechoice · 08/11/2023 17:55

He’ll probably be a drug addict by year 6 I’d kick him out now

listsandbudgets · 08/11/2023 17:55

@ToddlerIs2 You sound exhausted and overwhelmed and who wouldn't be with a pair of active 3 year old twins and a possibly jealous and mildly wilful 8 year old. It doesn't make you a shit mum - I reckon it makes you pretty normal.

School are not going to assume that you run a violent household - it's not as if he administered a through beating. Of course he shouldn't have done it BUT remind yourself he did it on the school's watch not yours so it's for them to deal with when he gets in tomorrow.

You've done enough - taking screens away for a while will sink in - you don't need to do more.

Now go find your son, give him a huge hug and tell him you love him regardless and that whatever school decide you'll help him through it. I'm sure h'es upset too and worrying about consequences and he just needs him mum. Tell him you won't talk about it again tonight and settle him down with a hot chocolate or whatever in front of the TV.

There is no need to be humiliated or anxious. He got it wrong, school will deal with it however they think fit and his mum will aways be there for him whatever and tonight, that's all you and he need to know Flowers

ToddlerIs2 · 08/11/2023 17:54

DistrictAndCircle · 08/11/2023 16:51

I think it only fair that you chop his hands off for such a serious offence.

I already did that for taking an extra sweet at Halloween 🙄

OP posts:
CynicalOne · 08/11/2023 17:54

@ToddlerIs2

Your little boy is just that, little. The school have punished him by sending him out of class and it sounds like they are going to continue punishing him with internal exclusion (!! an oxymoron! This could be a good English grammar lesson for your DS), and you have also punished him.

Why would you feel that you've got to keep punishing him? What will more punishment do? How does being violent (?? really? Violent? Did he break C's hand? Is DS a secret body builder with amazing upper body strength?) equal not only being unable to have fun activities today, but also for the next xx long? And how much punishment will be enough? Never allowed to watch TV or play games again, ever? The next week? Two weeks? 2 months? 2 years? 20 years?

C sounds like a thug.

This wasn't DS's fault. This was the fault of the school. The lad's only been in school for a few years and you've had to go in every year because the school keep putting him with C? There should be something on the school records ensuring that they aren't in the same class anymore.

And DS had a normal trauma informed response to what C was doing.

So, punishment? Take him to the ice cream parlour and get him an ice cream and ask open questions about what's been going on with C, bit try not to lead. Why did he squash C's hand instead of punching him on the nose? What was it about what C was doing that made DS feel unsafe and does he need a cosh for school? Has C made a similar hand shape in the past when he's hit DS? And so on.

Your DS sounds like he's got a lot of energy and likes to rough-house with his younger siblings but doesn't quite understand concepts of strength properly, because he's young.

However, if you think it's too rough, or you're concerned, ask yourself if this behaviour started after C the little toerag started being handsy with DS? If so, this could be trauma related and he's being rough because he finds it hard to verbalise what's happening to him at school, so he's acting out at home.

Myfabby · 08/11/2023 17:54

Didimum · 08/11/2023 17:52

Well I guess that's why his life is fucked eh, shit Mom he'd do better off without.

I have reported this post, OP. You are posting some deeply concerning things about yourself and on the face of it, I’m worried for your wellbeing.

I'm curious, how does reporting help her? Will MN HQ send her mental help tips/doctor? or they'll just delete/hide the thread?

I see someone anxiously looking for reassurance/advice.

MammaRoly · 08/11/2023 17:53

I feel for you OP, I really do as my DS went through a similar patch when he was year 3 and 4,. We don't rough house at home, and he isn't rough with his sister but he had several incidents at school where he was rough with friends when playing. And these were boys that he got along with, definitely no issues but I think DS couldn't control his exuberance during play. After every incident we spoke to him about it, talked about potential consequences as he got older and he seems to have grown out of it now in Y6 and age 11. So take heart OP, breathe .... but also use this as an opportunity to educate your son. Sending a big hug x

Frenchtoastandoj · 08/11/2023 17:53

OP - please calm down about this incident . You are not a shit mum even if you are feeling a bit overwhelmed in this scenario . Parenting is tough and none of us get a handbook. School will punish him , you don’t need to add to it . Talk it through and say you are not happy about it so that he knows you think he’s crossed a line not just school . At 8 his brain is not fully developed ,it won’t be until he’s an adult , he hadn’t done anything particularly unusual for a child of that age . Neither is the sibling bundling anything other than pretty normal childhood behaviour. Yes it’s worrying as we all worry about them getting hurt ( and needs addressing) but it doesn’t make them violent thugs !

Once the dust has settled talk to the teacher about moving the two boys apart.

Didimum · 08/11/2023 17:52

Well I guess that's why his life is fucked eh, shit Mom he'd do better off without.

I have reported this post, OP. You are posting some deeply concerning things about yourself and on the face of it, I’m worried for your wellbeing.

Sweetpea1532 · 08/11/2023 17:50

@ToddlerIs2 oh Sweetheart, you sound so overwhelmed....It is difficult to take care of a single child of three. I can't even imagine trying to take care of twins.

You are doing a great job being a mom to your boys. Do you have just 3 DSs or do you also have older children?