Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DS hurt another child, so humiliated

288 replies

ToddlerIs2 · 08/11/2023 16:34

So there's a boy that annoys DS. Seems to revel in winding DS up just to before the point where he's actively naughty. Not an excuse, just context.

Today the child, C, did something annoying but not something that harmed DS - screwed up some paper on the table. DS thought he was going to throw it at him so DS pushed down on C's hand to make him drop the paper, hurting C.

Happened right at the end of school so DS was told off and sent to another classroom for the last half hour but no time to discuss punishment with SLT.

I just feel so humiliated that school will think he's a violent child who witnessed violence in the home and it just acting out his upbringing. This isn't the case.

I've told him he's looking at an internal exclusion (for deliberately putting hands on C to hurt him) and once I can talk to DH tomorrow a punishment at home. I've told him if this happens again he'll end up excluded permanently and he won't be able to see his friends. He hates the idea of being homeschooled. I've explained that being internally excluded could mean him missing photo day with his brothers in school and a cultural day. No pint grounding him, he doesn't go out without us, even Cubs he goes to with me. He's not allowed to play his game tonight or on YouTube later.

What punishment would you give and how the fuck is this my life and my child? I don't understand where we've gone wrong or how I'm meant to stop this given I don't know where I've messed up as a parent.

I'm so angry with him and me.

OP posts:
ToddlerIs2 · 08/11/2023 18:26

Flamingos89 · 08/11/2023 18:22

It sounds like your DS is being bullied and stood up for himself for the first time.

I don’t think violence should be tolerated- but what he did doesn’t seem violent or more importantly, unprovoked.

If it was my child I’d be explaining to the school that he is being bullied and this is why he had the reaction. The reaction wasn’t right, but understandable given the circumstances.

If this child was about to throw something at your child that is also not right and the school and his parents should know.

It’s really difficult as I genuinely think this is such a grey area. We don’t want our kids to resort to hitting or being physical, but at the same time if they never take a stand, then how will they ever be able to stick up for themselves.

I do think you have gone way to hard on your child. Sounds like he has been tormented and had enough.

The problem is the kid hadn't even lifted up his hand holding the paper or said anything, Ds just thought he would and this is why it's so hard to say to school it's bullying because it's so vague and indirect.

I will be asking to split them, I will be reiterating my concerns about how they are together but unless he does something directly to DS and DS tell me or school, it's just DS over reacting to an annoying kid.

OP posts:
Shopper727 · 08/11/2023 18:25

No one has said you’re a shit mum well no one except you? Do you think perhaps you’re getting yourself very worked up and stressed so you can’t see the wood for the trees.

kid has been tormenting and annoying your child, let school say them on a table together, why do that? Ask for them to be sat separately. Be firm about physical play in your home, my boys can be too overzealous whilst playing and someone ends in tears - I have 4 boys so it’s a no re wrestling play as it ends badly. And firm consistent consequences for physically hurting siblings. I have a child with asd and did triple 3 parenting course, it wasn’t great for him, however it worked well for his brothers, lot of it made sense. I think many areas now use Solihull but you could ask which your area recommends.

I do think you’ve lost perspective somewhat, your child didn’t mean to hurt this child, he was reacting to what he thought child was going to do. Listen to your son, have a plan in place with him, let him know you’re there for him and be rational with school and plan how you will stop something like this happening again, school have a part to play and you at home too to support your child and prevent future issues. you’ve not failed, being a mum is tough - mum of 4 so I know it’s hard but please do ask for support if you need it, it’s tough. Hope things improve for you all

AnneValentine · 08/11/2023 18:23

ToddlerIs2 · 08/11/2023 16:51

He's 8, year 4.

Maybe I am.

I was in school two weeks ago because a DIFFERENT child pushed him over and we ended up in hospital but now he's hurting others.
He's also really physical with his 3 yo brothers, slapping their hands of they're holding something he wants, being really rough with them of they upset him so I'm conflating my annoyance.

He struggled to control his temper and will say he lost control and it happened by accident
Obv I correct the use of the word "accidentally"

You are hugely over reacting. He will absolutely not be excluded for this and you need to make it clear to him that you made a mistake. The poor kid.

As someone who works in behaviour at a school we wouldn’t assume any of the things you’ve suggested, but if a child said my mum says I will be excluded and will never see my friends again that would be red flags at dawn.

ToddlerIs2 · 08/11/2023 18:23

Iwasafool · 08/11/2023 18:11

I think the bit you are missing is that he was recently assaulted, his lip split and he needed hospital attention. That's a big thing for him to deal with and the school need to acknowledge that, he had that experience in their care not yours. Have they given him any support with his feelings about that?

You are embarrassed and disappointed and that is understandable but take a big breath and think about why he might be feeling vulnerable and talk to the school about the whole situation, the attack that happened to him, the "winding up" by this other boy and his reaction to it. It all needs to be considered.

I wouldn't worry about brothers fighting too much, I've got three and they did it as kids, all adults now and never been in any trouble about fighting as adults and only one had an issue as a child and that was defending his younger brother.

He's ok with the lad who did it. It's grey area whether it was intentional or not, the kid has apologised, he's normally really good with DS and has been making an effort to be nice to him. DS wasn't upset about back to school, no anxiety about being around J, lots of attention off staff checking in if he was ok but he was honestly ok.

OP posts:
Flamingos89 · 08/11/2023 18:22

It sounds like your DS is being bullied and stood up for himself for the first time.

I don’t think violence should be tolerated- but what he did doesn’t seem violent or more importantly, unprovoked.

If it was my child I’d be explaining to the school that he is being bullied and this is why he had the reaction. The reaction wasn’t right, but understandable given the circumstances.

If this child was about to throw something at your child that is also not right and the school and his parents should know.

It’s really difficult as I genuinely think this is such a grey area. We don’t want our kids to resort to hitting or being physical, but at the same time if they never take a stand, then how will they ever be able to stick up for themselves.

I do think you have gone way to hard on your child. Sounds like he has been tormented and had enough.

FarmGirl78 · 08/11/2023 18:22

ToddlerIs2 · 08/11/2023 18:02

Thank you.
I do think the consequences is something he struggles to retain. Which is why I wanted to impress them on him so heavily, so if even 50% of it sticks, he will do something different.
I'm aware how frustration and anger needs dealing with, were trying to access some parenting classes for kids with autism to see if that will give us some new ideas

I think more than parenting classes so you can help him deal with his emotions the much bigger issue is you dealing with yours. You've gone from "he tried to squash someone else's hand" to "they'll exclude him and think he's from a violent home" and also "I perhaps went overboard in this instance" to "I'm a shit Mum and he's doomed forever".

I'd say the priority is getting you to start being more realistic with your reactions instead of catastrophising and turning everything up to 100%. CBT is excellent for this kind of thing. You can do it online, with a book (CBT for dummies is great) in person or with an app.

Your Son is 8. He's a child and he's going to mess up. He can't be expected to react perfectly to every difficult situation he's in. You're an adult and you've got to whatever age you are still reacting to stressors by your emotions going up and up and up. You need to learn to calm down, be rational and BREATHE. Please look at doing some CBT - it's really coming across like you'd benefit from it.

margotrose · 08/11/2023 18:20

ToddlerIs2 · 08/11/2023 18:06

This kid is low level annoying, stuff like pretending to wee at the table, not at DA, the other kids ignore of laugh off but really winds up DS.

And DS just won't tell the teacher, he's so focused on what C is doing, he "forgets" to tell.

But another child pushed him over two weeks ago and split his lip open.

C might not be physically bullying your son but his behaviour is unkind and antagonistic, and if your DS is already being picked on by another child, it's not really surprising that he snapped.

He's eight. He doesn't have the willpower of an older child or an adult.

ToddlerIs2 · 08/11/2023 18:19

Alifestylechoice · 08/11/2023 18:13

Why are you obsessed with him ‘telling the teacher’ about what sounds like really minor stuff? That’s not going to do him any favours. If the boy is being mean or bullying then sure, tell the teacher, but not for ‘pretending to wee’.

Do you have anxiety as it sounds like he might have too

Because this is the kind of stuff that is happening that's winding DS up. It isn't bullying as in doing mean things to DS. But then DS gets wound up and it ends up on him expecting C to do something worse so hence assuming he'd throw the paper at him.

I've told him to ignore it. I've told him when C is making baby sounds to just ignore him and not respond. I've told him when C is drawing stupid pictures instead of working to ignore C's attempts to show him. But if he can't ignore him, he needs to tell the teacher because otherwise he comes out of school and comes out that tightly wound he screams at me until he cries.

OP posts:
TheShellBeach · 08/11/2023 18:18

You do sound very stressed and upset about this, OP.

EvilElsa · 08/11/2023 18:16

ToddlerIs2 · 08/11/2023 18:11

DS is fine thanks. He's had a night off his favourite game. O get you think I'm a shit Mom but he's hardly on need of rescuing from my clutches.

She's reported because she's worried about YOU op, not that you are a danger to your son. Sometimes threads can be more harmful than helpful and you sound very stressed by some of the comments. MN can either move your thread to a more appropriate place or provide advice, or delete if you want or if they feel its a pile on.

ToddlerIs2 · 08/11/2023 18:15

neilyoungismyhero · 08/11/2023 17:36

It's hardly a knife attack is it. My 5 year old daughter once hit a boy round the head with a brick at school because he'd annoyed her. The head teacher told us we told her not to do it again it was unacceptable. She listened and never did it again. Her and the lad remain great friends 35 years later.
I think you're making a mountain out of a molehill honestly.

The difference is age.
DTwin pulled a toy off someone else. He got told off. I got told. End of.
DS os 8, in juniors.

OP posts:
Cheeesus · 08/11/2023 18:14

ToddlerIs2 · 08/11/2023 17:15

I didn't say he'd get permanently excluded for this just if he continued to hurt people. I think he will get an internal exclusion because he deliberately laid hands on another child. We did talk, and have previously talked about how to manage with this child, he doesn't listen or isn't capable of applying it in the moment.

I think people are just picking up on this “I've told him if this happens again he'll end up excluded permanently and he won't be able to see his friends.”

Scirocco · 08/11/2023 18:14

@ToddlerIs2 you're spiralling - calm down, this isn't the end of the world and it doesn't mean you're a bad mum.

Your son has done something that hundreds of other children will have done this term. It's not extreme violence, it's not bullying. The school will have a behaviour policy, they'll assess what's happened and implement a (hopefully proportionate) consequence. A firm talking to and a short electronics restriction sounds plenty to show that behaviour at school has consequences at home, if that's your usual approach. This isn't worth going nuclear over.

It sounds like your self-esteem and anxiety might be bigger issues though, you sound like you're feeling in quite a vulnerable frame of mind just now. Do you have anyone you could talk to in real life about how you're feeling? They might help you get more perspective on things.

Alifestylechoice · 08/11/2023 18:13

Why are you obsessed with him ‘telling the teacher’ about what sounds like really minor stuff? That’s not going to do him any favours. If the boy is being mean or bullying then sure, tell the teacher, but not for ‘pretending to wee’.

Do you have anxiety as it sounds like he might have too

Bertiesmum3 · 08/11/2023 18:13

ToddlerIs2 · 08/11/2023 16:52

Because school have a zero tolerance on kids hurting each other in purpose?? Internal exclusion so in heads office. The child who pushed DS over resulting in a split lip got a week.

Is that why you took your child to hospital because of a split lip??

ToddlerIs2 · 08/11/2023 18:13

Cantab54321 · 08/11/2023 18:06

I would also work through steps DS can take to defuse the situation and then make him write each one out. This should help it stick a bit more and he can use the time writing to reflect.

Oh god now having to WRITE really is a punishment

OP posts:
Minniem2020 · 08/11/2023 18:12

I really feel for your son. He's probably terrified of the punishment to come, he's 8, yes they should know not to hurt someone but come on, give him a break. He probably didn't even hurt the other boys hand

Iwasafool · 08/11/2023 18:11

ToddlerIs2 · 08/11/2023 17:30

But all the other kid kid was scrunch up paper. There was zero evidence he was going to throw it. He didn't lift his hand. He didn't say he was going to. He's not thrown paper at DS previously.

I think the bit you are missing is that he was recently assaulted, his lip split and he needed hospital attention. That's a big thing for him to deal with and the school need to acknowledge that, he had that experience in their care not yours. Have they given him any support with his feelings about that?

You are embarrassed and disappointed and that is understandable but take a big breath and think about why he might be feeling vulnerable and talk to the school about the whole situation, the attack that happened to him, the "winding up" by this other boy and his reaction to it. It all needs to be considered.

I wouldn't worry about brothers fighting too much, I've got three and they did it as kids, all adults now and never been in any trouble about fighting as adults and only one had an issue as a child and that was defending his younger brother.

ToddlerIs2 · 08/11/2023 18:11

Didimum · 08/11/2023 17:52

Well I guess that's why his life is fucked eh, shit Mom he'd do better off without.

I have reported this post, OP. You are posting some deeply concerning things about yourself and on the face of it, I’m worried for your wellbeing.

DS is fine thanks. He's had a night off his favourite game. O get you think I'm a shit Mom but he's hardly on need of rescuing from my clutches.

OP posts:
PlumpAndGrump · 08/11/2023 18:10

Everyone has a breaking point.

It sounds like your son reached his.

I would think whatever punishment the school decide as well as a day without his game etc is enough in terms of reprimanding him but I would seriously focus on the underlying issues where you say he is aggressive to siblings etc as well.

Behaviours like these are usually communication so try and see what he is trying to tell you. Is he struggling with something you can help with? Can you work on helping him to communicate his frustration/anger/jealousy (whatever it is) in a better way? And praise him when he does so.

That's the only way to make a long lasting change as children don't necessarily learn from harsh punishments, it only makes them hate themselves and feel shame. They aren't learning anything from it.

Topseyt123 · 08/11/2023 18:10

ToddlerIs2 · 08/11/2023 17:59

He has been told to ignore annoying behaviour or tell the teacher, if he thinks he's going to do something to shout out and tell someone, to move, to put his hand up.

I will be mentioning all the stuff they C has done to annoy DS but DS just won't tell!! If he won't tell on C, school don't see it and I find out vaguely weeks later (I've asked if they've fell out much this week, apparently C keeps pretending to wee. Have you told the teacher? No, I forgot!).

It sounds like he will tell you if you speak to him sympathetically and directly though. So make a note of it when he does and YOU speak to the teacher. Put it down in an email so that they have a paper trail.

Raincloudsonasunnyday · 08/11/2023 18:09

Oh my word OP. I'm getting stressed and anxious just reading your messages.

You know how they say to put the oxygen mask on yourself before you put it on your child? Take a deep breath and give yourself a talking to, before you disproportionately lash out on your DS with your worry and anxiety.

Nothing remotely serious has happened. No irreperable harm has been done. Your son is not a wrong'un. He's 8. You have time to talk to him, teach him, raise him.

You've lost perspective (not surprising if you've got 3yo twins at home!) and are struggling to keep control. That's your problem. Don't take it out on your eldest DS.

(Also, were you raised with brothers? Everything you've described is totally, 100%, completely age-appropriate and normal. There is absolutely nothing to suggest your 8yo will grow into a violent thug).

purplesky18 · 08/11/2023 18:08

My kid kicked another kid today because he made her friend cry. My kid has form for being a bit handsy when she’s frustrated however today she knows she has crossed the line and came out of school bawling her eyes out. She’s 5 years old she is not a thug or going to be excluded, 98% of the time she is a model student. Kids go through big emotional leaps, keep explaining hands to yourself and consequences of these actions and they will get it eventually. I worked in primary schools and this is not a rare event unless it becomes a theme then it will need working on.

Zebedee55 · 08/11/2023 18:07

A lot of stress about nothing. Chill - it'll come to nothing. 🙂

Cantab54321 · 08/11/2023 18:06

ToddlerIs2 · 08/11/2023 17:13

He's had a one day ban on his favourite game, he's not been locked in the coal hole. I don't know if that's enough because he doesn't seem to learn when I tell him off from being handsy with his brothers, he doesn't seem to learn when I tell him off about constantly touching other people, he doesn't seem to learn when he's on trouble in class for not concentrating. He just doesn't seem to change his behaviour for anything.

I would also work through steps DS can take to defuse the situation and then make him write each one out. This should help it stick a bit more and he can use the time writing to reflect.