Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DS hurt another child, so humiliated

288 replies

ToddlerIs2 · 08/11/2023 16:34

So there's a boy that annoys DS. Seems to revel in winding DS up just to before the point where he's actively naughty. Not an excuse, just context.

Today the child, C, did something annoying but not something that harmed DS - screwed up some paper on the table. DS thought he was going to throw it at him so DS pushed down on C's hand to make him drop the paper, hurting C.

Happened right at the end of school so DS was told off and sent to another classroom for the last half hour but no time to discuss punishment with SLT.

I just feel so humiliated that school will think he's a violent child who witnessed violence in the home and it just acting out his upbringing. This isn't the case.

I've told him he's looking at an internal exclusion (for deliberately putting hands on C to hurt him) and once I can talk to DH tomorrow a punishment at home. I've told him if this happens again he'll end up excluded permanently and he won't be able to see his friends. He hates the idea of being homeschooled. I've explained that being internally excluded could mean him missing photo day with his brothers in school and a cultural day. No pint grounding him, he doesn't go out without us, even Cubs he goes to with me. He's not allowed to play his game tonight or on YouTube later.

What punishment would you give and how the fuck is this my life and my child? I don't understand where we've gone wrong or how I'm meant to stop this given I don't know where I've messed up as a parent.

I'm so angry with him and me.

OP posts:
Chocolatepeanutbuttercupsandicecream · 08/11/2023 17:19

Also.. re the younger brothers.. he absolutely should be keeping his hands to himself, BUT does he have space away from them, a safe place to keep his things where they can’t touch or break them, and one on one time with you and his dad?

Gerrataere · 08/11/2023 17:19

ToddlerIs2 · 08/11/2023 17:16

Year 4, he's 8. He's likely to be internally excluded for putting his hands on another child which means short days so he's going to be stuck in the bike rack with me for an hour each day waiting for his brothers to finish!!

At which point you tell the school you won’t accept your child being so severely punished for being fed up of his ‘bully’, and you would hate to have to take it further but will if they insist on exclusion from
the classroom.

ToddlerIs2 · 08/11/2023 17:18

CharlotteRose90 · 08/11/2023 16:56

hes lashing out because he’s scared and being bullied. You need to find out what the school are doing about the other child. They need separating. He might be young but you need to try and get him to talk to someone like a doctor or referred for therapy. This isn’t a stand alone issue.

So you think this lashing out is an indication of deeper psychological damage?

School don't see it is bullying because it's just low level annoyance. But DS has zero tolerance for him.

OP posts:
Gerrataere · 08/11/2023 17:17

I tell him off about constantly touching other people, he doesn't seem to learn when he's on trouble in class for not concentrating.

@ToddlerIs2

Someone may as well say it - is he being assessed for ADHD? Because you’ve just given two big flags here. But pushing someone who’s been winding him up isn’t a red flag, that’s just a kid who’s had enough.

ToddlerIs2 · 08/11/2023 17:16

NerrSnerr · 08/11/2023 16:50

If he's in cubs he must be year 4, 5 or 6? Is that right? He won't be suspended or excluded for this- nowhere near. You need to chill out. Let the school deal with it, have a chat with him and take a massive deep breath.

Year 4, he's 8. He's likely to be internally excluded for putting his hands on another child which means short days so he's going to be stuck in the bike rack with me for an hour each day waiting for his brothers to finish!!

OP posts:
EvilElsa · 08/11/2023 17:16

He's been alive for EIGHT years op. He's a little boy still learning and making mistakes. No, he shouldn't be hurting people but pushing someone's hands down because he thinks he is going to be hurt/humiliated is entirely different from lashing out and punching someone in the face. He's had (in my opinion) a harsh punishment already for what he has done. You don't need to carry it on for days on end. You've spoken to him, he's had punishment at school, he's not watching YouTube tonight. He doesn't need multiple harsh lectures on exclusions and home schooling from his mum and then his dad when he gets home. Let it go now. Have a quiet chat with him later and make sure he understands what to do when he gets cross or feels upset.

Gro · 08/11/2023 17:15

He thought he was going to get something thrown at him so he defended himself. Doesn't sound like he deliberately hurt the boy.

Also the fact you are making this about you is so wrong. I'M humiliated, MY child, MY life.

This should be a post about helping your son deal with bullying. Not about you!

Chocolatepeanutbuttercupsandicecream · 08/11/2023 17:15

I was just reading an article earlier about how this type of behaviour - pushing and needling someone until they explode and react - is actually a form of bullying or abuse. The aim of the provocation is to get the victim in trouble.. in C’s case it would seem successfully. I wouldn’t punish my child at home, but I would help them to develop coping strategies for if the issue happens again, as unfortunately schools aren’t great at dealing with this issue, and it is often the wrong child taking the brunt of the blame.

ToddlerIs2 · 08/11/2023 17:15

GwenGhost · 08/11/2023 16:46

The threshold for permanent exclusion is way beyond this OP. He might be asked to apologize to the other kid, you may well be asked to come into school to discuss the incident and he was already sent out the classroom for the rest of the day.
The most useful thing here would be for you to talk to him about how to express his annoyance/anger verbally (not shouting, just normal volume) and also to learn to remove himself from the situation when he feels like physically retaliating.

I didn't say he'd get permanently excluded for this just if he continued to hurt people. I think he will get an internal exclusion because he deliberately laid hands on another child. We did talk, and have previously talked about how to manage with this child, he doesn't listen or isn't capable of applying it in the moment.

OP posts:
billy1966 · 08/11/2023 17:14

OP, take a very hard line at home.

He should not be touching his brothers.

He needs help to learn to regulate his temper.

Ask the teacher for them to be kept a part as they don't get on.

If he is getting away with it at home then he will do it in school.

He is 8 and his brothers are 3?

I would sit down and tell him firmly that he will be in huge trouble if he lays hands again on his brothers, and I would really mean it.

Nip it in the bud.
He's too big to be bullying 3 year olds.

Don't conflate the two issues.

Sort him out at home and deal with school separately.

At 8 he should not be hurting his brothers.

Iwasafool · 08/11/2023 17:13

Please don't scare him. He's been assaulted and then over reacted when he thought someone else was about to throw something at him. A boy who went to school with my son was scared about his parents reaction to something that was silly, the other parents whose kids were involved (including mine) rolled our eyes and told them to behave. He ran away and was missing for over 24 hrs which was a million times more serious than anything that went on at school.

I know you are disappointed and worried but try to keep it in proportion.

ToddlerIs2 · 08/11/2023 17:13

Crunchymum · 08/11/2023 16:46

You may not be a violent home but you sound very over zealous with punishment!!

He's had a one day ban on his favourite game, he's not been locked in the coal hole. I don't know if that's enough because he doesn't seem to learn when I tell him off from being handsy with his brothers, he doesn't seem to learn when I tell him off about constantly touching other people, he doesn't seem to learn when he's on trouble in class for not concentrating. He just doesn't seem to change his behaviour for anything.

OP posts:
Snoken · 08/11/2023 17:11

you are well on the way of creating a very anxious child op. He hasn’t done anything terribly bad or unusual for his age. He is already getting punished for it at school where the incident happened, don’t keep punishing him at home. He needs someone who will listen to him. He is being targeted at school and all you are concerned about is looking humiliated. Get your priorities right and you will have a happier and healthier son.

ToddlerIs2 · 08/11/2023 17:11

Tobacco · 08/11/2023 16:45

Is this the first time he's hurt someone? Just explain what happened to the school. They're not going to think he's got a violent home life over one incident, nor will they throw him out the school. Is there some information you've left out like he's constantly lamping people?

No o told DS it would happen if he kept hurting people, not this time . Although he is facing an internal exclusion. No back story. He's rough with his little brothers and I'm constantly telling him off for that but it doesn't seem to go in, he just struggles to keep his temper. Previously in school he'd have possibly acted out but not hurt someone.

OP posts:
Goldbar · 08/11/2023 17:09

He's 8. Kids wind each other up at that age, kids hurt each other (both intentionally and unintentionally). It's great that you and the school take a zero tolerance approach, but really there is no need to despair. Just let the school take whatever action they see fit and tell DS that he needs to mind his temper in future.

thaegumathteth · 08/11/2023 17:07

Get a grip OP your kid needs someone in his corner and it very much doesn't sound like that's you. Also why do you have to wait for dh to come home to decide on punishments? Bizarre.

Thesearmsofmine · 08/11/2023 17:07

ToddlerIs2 · 08/11/2023 16:57

You think at 8 they shouldn't know not to hurt other people??

I think at 8 kids make mistakes and don’t need their parent threatening them with things that aren’t going to happen over one minor incident.

PrudeyTwoShoes · 08/11/2023 17:06

Massive overreaction, OP. No, you shouldn't excuse the behaviour but you said he only pushed his had away as he was worried C would throw the paper. Defending yourself is very different to deliberately trying to hurt someone for no reason. Obviously C was hurt, so your son should be remorseful but I think the root issue lies elsewhere. I'd be speaking to his teacher and asking if they can be separated.

Dweetfidilove · 08/11/2023 17:05

I guess it’s better to overreact than underreact, but you’ve punished sufficiently now.

Hopefully the other child now knows your son is not for the bs and will leave him be 🤷🏽‍♀️

JenniferJupiterVenusandMars · 08/11/2023 17:05

housethatbuiltme · 08/11/2023 17:00

What on earth are you on about?

Unless he stabbed the kid or seriously hurt him of course non of that will happen. You jumping to them thinking you are violent at home and homeschooling is utterly bat shit and seriously worrying.

The damage you are doing DELIBERATELY trying to terrify your child with threats of awful things and a slew of exaggerated blame is actually a huge red flag that your mental health might not be suitable to being in charge of a child right now. You behavior could cause serious damage to your child.

I mean this in the nicest way but I think you need to speak to a medical professional about your anxieties and your misplacement of it before it does more irreparable damage.

I really feel sorry for your DS, wtf would you ramp up the punishment at home (inappropriate and scary for the child) by dragging it out until tomorrow?

CinnabarRed · 08/11/2023 17:04

Anyway, from your description I don’t think he did hurt the other child on purpose. His purpose was to stop the other child throwing paper. The hurt was incidental. Very different IMO from pushing a child over.

BlinkerGoBlink · 08/11/2023 17:04

Your child is learning how to be a human. Please allow him mistakes without getting to the “how the fuck is this my life” phase; that’s more for “my 16 year old smokes weed all day” scenarios. Good your vigilant, but you are being OTT.

mumof2many1943 · 08/11/2023 17:03

Toddleris2 I know where you are coming from, I was exactly the same when my son pushed another child away. Don’t worry too much it will be sorted out. You sound a kind mum who does not tolerate bullying at any level!

SoddingWeddings · 08/11/2023 17:01

He's 8. Give the kid a break.

Huge leap of assumption there that people will think he's witnessed domestic abuse at home though..... Has he?

ZeroFucksGivenToday · 08/11/2023 17:00

Meh. Honestly you're over reacting. And maybe the kid who winds your son up might think twice.

Id not even punish that at home, I'd let school deal with it, and only raise that maybe theh shouldn't be sat together.

My DD had a boy who did exactly the same, knew she struggled to keep her cool, she practised walking away but then he wound her up by saying things like all your friends are mine now you've walked off. He was making her miserable and angry.
One day he wound her too far and she absolutely flattened him with a two handed push and he landed on his back in the middle of everyone. School told her not to do it again, I didn't say much at home. And he's left her alone since as he knows she capable of it. But the teachers don't put them in the same groups. Everyone is happier now.