Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To want my therapist to share my religion

53 replies

Boughtthewrongone · 08/11/2023 13:57

I have been seeing a private therapist for depression for several months now. Just recently a topic has unexpectedly come up in our sessions. It is a “big life issue” (think dying and bereavement - it’s not that one but something along those lines) that we all have to deal with at some point.

I consider myself to be practising a particular religion, and while normally I don’t have any issue with relationships with people from other religions, I’ve realised it does shape my worldview and my perspective on things, especially these big issues. I don’t know one way or another what religion (if any) my therapist is. But I’m struggling to be completely honest and open with them about this big issue and how I feel about it as I’m not sure if they’ll totally get where I’m coming from.

AIBU?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Paradeofrain · 09/11/2023 08:59

Theres pros and cons to it.
I am in a similar field and some of this will depend on the nuances around modalities of therapy, if its actually counselling. Lots of replies focus on advice giving but in reality that's not what some modalities of therapy do.

Sharing the same faith can be helpful as described above for a shorthand. However it can be misleading

Everyone has their own relationship with faith, and even people of the same detonation with faith might have great differences.

Say we are talking about something like porn use (as someone described above) and for example I'm Catholic, you're Catholic. I might assume that the way you feel about this issues is sculpted by one bit of scripture but actually that might not be the case and you might value an opposing bit more. We would both have different Bible interpretations and put emphasis on different scripture etc.

Unless you find someone who shares 100% on your beliefs and is on the same page as you about everything. In reality any form of assumption is dangerous. In my view reality the question should always be posed to you rather than as assumption.

Eg, what are your beliefs about this, what has shaped that? Why is it important to you?

However you should have a therapist who you feel respects your beliefs, and that you feel comfortable with.

I think it's worth thinking about what you are hoping for. Someone above sounds like they got spiritual advice where someone pointed them towards scripture etc, others might rather someone say "what do you think? How do you weigh this up?"

DrinkingMyWaterMindingMyBiz · 09/11/2023 08:25

YANBU at all. I have requested a therapist from a similar cultural background to me as it will just be easier to not need to go into every tiny detail about how things are in my community when each session is a limited time. It wasn’t an issue on their end at all, it just meant that I may have a longer wait time to find a suitable therapist.

I think it’s perfectly reasonable and services will be used to such requests.

LadyBevvy · 09/11/2023 08:21

Catandsquirrel · 08/11/2023 16:53

Out of interest I don't necessarily see why?

Surely religion is just another framework to operate within.

In clinical practice it is perfectly understandable if a patient wants support from their faith group or leader.

A good friend of mine had excellent experiences with a therapist from her culture/ to a lesser extent religion. He tacitly understood some of the expectations and issues that applied to her culture that she felt would have taken quite a bit of unpicking with someone who didn't understand 'how things are'. The root of some of her problems are from family behaviour which may be why she specifically wanted someone who did get it.

Perhaps for her own assurance rather than nobody else being able to help her but if that helps the patient why shouldn't they try and find the therapist that fits them?

I'm not a therapist. ExDH was clinical psychologist and I remember having this discussion with him. Apparently the role of a psychotherapist / psychologist, as first mooted by Freud but since further developed obviously, is that they are a sort of neutral sounding board, a gentle questioner, this is apparently the best way to explore the patient's "neuroses" (or whatever the modern correct clinical word is!).

Apparently insisting on a therapist with certain sympathetic beliefs can compromise the patient's ability to fearlessly explore their issues and can be used as a way of avoidance on the part of the patient, or a way to subconsciously reinforce existing "neuroses".

He gave me an example of a conservative religious Christian father who fears his son is gay, so ensures he has a therapist who also shares fundamentalist Christian views. Or another example, a patient with anorexia whose therapist knows a lot about eating disorders and is very skilled but still not fully psychologically recovered from her own anorexia.

Something about bias and projection, i can't remember everything he said, just his emphasis on neutrality (although he used a different fancier word lol) in the approach to the therapy. 'Neutrality' is how the patient gets the best results.

I suppose a more current example would be whether 'trans affirming' therapists are the best bet for teens who may feel gender dysphoric but not sure if they are trans or not.

Now I'm not a psychologist and I know there's a massive difference between clinical psychology and 'therapy' which is usually something quite different. And of course there must be loads of clients who would prefer a therapist of a particular gender, sexuality, religion etc. Plus there's also a need for trauma-informed therapy where say a rape survivor wanted a woman therapist. I don't know all the ins and outs, just that in clinical psychology, this neautrality thing, in the approach to the patiernt, is key, the therapist should not be forming the treatment through the framework of their own beliefs to the extent that is possible of course.

Hopefully an actual clinician will shortly be along to explain it better!

DumboHimalayan · 08/11/2023 22:04

Disco50 · 08/11/2023 18:32

I'm with you OP! Secular therapists can be very biased against religious beliefs, some times you need someone of a faith background to give you that greater understanding.
Everyone being dismissive on this thread is exactly the point - non-faith people just don't get it.

Why are you making this specifically about faith vs non-faith? If anyone's being dismissive here, it's you.

As I was talking about earlier, providing good therapy is easier when the therapist has an understanding of the implicit and underlying stuff in the person's life, their social/family circles and worldview — and sometimes sharing a religious background can help with that. But there's no need, or justification, to single out "non-faith people" as being uniquely cloth-eared on this front. I'm a "non-faith person" who posted about why it can make sense to want a therapist who shares your religion, and I don't appreciate being lumped into a group of people who you assume are "dismissive" of this preference because "non-faith people just don't get it".

There's nothing wrong with preferring a therapist with particular personal characteristics — often women may prefer a female therapist, people from an ethnic minority background may prefer a therapist who shares that background, gay/lesbian/bisexual people might prefer a therapist who expresses belonging to that group, and so on.

But broad, blunt "faith" vs "non-faith" categorisation is a strange way to classify therapists (and MN posters). I'm sure there's plenty of hyper-religious "therapists" out there, of various religions that you don't happen to belong to, whose beliefs and ways of bringing those beliefs into the therapy you personally would find far more alien and obtrusive than the practising style of a typical non-religious professional therapist, one who understands and incorporates the principles of respectful secular practice (i.e. providing therapy which doesn't depend on a particular religion or prescribe particular beliefs for clients).

Lavender14 · 08/11/2023 21:39

Disco50 · 08/11/2023 18:32

I'm with you OP! Secular therapists can be very biased against religious beliefs, some times you need someone of a faith background to give you that greater understanding.
Everyone being dismissive on this thread is exactly the point - non-faith people just don't get it.

Then they are not doing their job properly. That's entirely the fault of those individuals and I say that as a Christian who has worked as a secular counsellor. Many counselors will have a faith but choose not to disclose it because its not about them. There's no way to know unless it's something you discuss up front with your counsellor.

Stravaig · 08/11/2023 21:37

Not read the entire thread, or able to engage further, however -

It's not at all unreasonable to seek out a therapist who shares your culture or faith. Almost all psychotherapeutic modalities have been developed through a western judeo-christian lens, which can be unhelpful or even harmful for people of other cultures and faiths. This is beginning to receive more research attention.

Also, within predominantly secular Western societies, any person of any faith might experience a barrier which hinders awareness and empathy when working with a therapist of no faith, or a different faith.

Not what you need when trying to heal!

If you're not comfortable, or feel you need something or someone different to be able to work more deeply, please do move on.

Lavender14 · 08/11/2023 21:37

NeedToChangeName · 08/11/2023 14:39

Genuine question, I don't know the answer, if you feel you can't work with a therapist who has a different religion from you (or no religion), is that discrimination?

Edited

You need to feel really comfortable with a counsellor... could be that you aren't content with their age, gender, their appearance, their tone of voice or mannerisms. Many people will struggle to 'click' with a counsellor because maybe they remind them of someone who was harmful to them in the past in some way. Because of the nature of the service provided its for the client to decide who they want to open up to. I went through a number of counsellors before I settled with one I just felt very emotionally safe with. There was nothing wrong with the others I just didn't feel like their personality was a good match for mine. A vibe is enough.

bathroomcupnoard · 08/11/2023 19:33

I can see that it would be an issue for some people, if you were for example JW

Luciansmum6 · 08/11/2023 19:12

If he’s practicing UPR which he should be then it shouldn’t matter. Therapists literally hear everything and nothing you could say would shock him. Just today my therapist could tell I was holding something back and told me to rip the proverbial plaster off and spit it out so I did and it was fine. Just say it. Even if you had a therapist with the same religion it wouldn’t matter because a proper therapist wouldn’t be putting their opinion in anyway.

Disco50 · 08/11/2023 18:32

I'm with you OP! Secular therapists can be very biased against religious beliefs, some times you need someone of a faith background to give you that greater understanding.
Everyone being dismissive on this thread is exactly the point - non-faith people just don't get it.

Ffsnotaconference · 08/11/2023 18:28

I think if you want a therapist that’s a certain religion it’s your job to seek one out that is advertising that.

I think it’s entirely wrong to expect or request your existing therapist to disclose something so personal when they aren’t sharing that already.

limefrog · 08/11/2023 18:24

Going against the grain a bit here (and I do have some counselling training), I think it's perfectly OK if you feel more comfortable with a therapist who shares your religion, but it's definitely worth reflecting/ thinking about why it feels so important to you.

If this is something you would like to know about the therapist, you might want to look for a therapist using a person-centred/ humanistic approach, rather than psychodynamic - as a psychodymanic therapist is very unlikely to share anything at all about themselves as a person - it's just not part of that approach.

Either way, it is definitely worth taking this thought to your next session and talking through why it feels important to you. Your therapist should then help you find a way forward whether that is continuing with them or finding a different therapist.

WineAndFireside · 08/11/2023 18:19

Crushed23 · 08/11/2023 17:14

I insisted on a female therapist when I sought help - was I being discriminatory?

No, of course not.

WineAndFireside · 08/11/2023 18:18

OKt · 08/11/2023 17:36

I would absolutely want a therapist with my faith, Catholic. I could imagine a therapist saying eg porn use is totally normal when in the Catholic faith it is a sin.

Therapists are not supposed to express personal opinions. Whether porn use is 'normal' or not is an opinion.

DumboHimalayan · 08/11/2023 18:09

I’d wonder what difference a therapist vs a priest would be when it comes to advice.

For one thing, a therapist shouldn't be giving advice, whether they share your religion or not.

DumboHimalayan · 08/11/2023 18:08

Seems reasonable to me — even if you don't want therapy that's explicitly based around a particular religious worldview (e.g. "Christian counselling"), it can be helpful to have therapy with someone who gets what it's like to be someone like you. If you're a white female 30-something middle-class British-born non-religious client, it's going to be pretty easy to find a therapist who intrinsically understands most of the assumptions and values baked into your social/family/lifestyle context and cultural background.

There's a well-known concept in therapy, and healthcare more broadly, of "cultural competence", which is about how to provide effective care for people from different cultural backgrounds, because it's recognised that a lack of understanding of somebody's culture can be a barrier to effective treatment. Religion is part of culture, so sharing a religious background would make it easier to feel like the therapist understands what you're saying without having to explain everything all the time.

Darkdiamond · 08/11/2023 18:03

Mariposista · 08/11/2023 17:59

@Darkdiamond I am weak, but thou art mighty, hold me with thy powerful hand.

I needed this! ❤️

Mariposista · 08/11/2023 17:59

Darkdiamond · 08/11/2023 17:51

I'm so sorry about your Gran. I'm so happy that you've found some positivity in going back to Church. When we are weak, He is strong x

@Darkdiamond I am weak, but thou art mighty, hold me with thy powerful hand.

Darkdiamond · 08/11/2023 17:51

Mariposista · 08/11/2023 16:33

@Darkdiamond this sounds lovely.
Since my gran died loads of horrible, uncomfortable feelings have been thrown to the surface, mainly about myself, self-worth, what the plan is for my future, where I fit in life etc. I have found talking to the lovely lady vicar who took my gran's funeral invaluable in working through them. She has encouraged me back to church (I have always been Christian but haven't had a church to go to in years). She is now a key part of my life and so helpful.

I'm so sorry about your Gran. I'm so happy that you've found some positivity in going back to Church. When we are weak, He is strong x

OKt · 08/11/2023 17:36

I would absolutely want a therapist with my faith, Catholic. I could imagine a therapist saying eg porn use is totally normal when in the Catholic faith it is a sin.

WeeOrcadian · 08/11/2023 17:23

I really don't understand why they need to share a religion - surely that isn't part of their job

Itsnotchristmasyet · 08/11/2023 17:22

I’m not religious but if I was then for certain things I’d definitely want a therapist that shared the same religion, so they could understand my POV better.

I would have asked around before I started therapy though.

I think some subjects it wouldn’t matter what religion they were but I definitely think there are some areas where you’d want the advice to come from a certain place.

I would be quite surprised if therapists brought religion into it though and I’d wonder what difference a therapist vs a priest would be when it comes to advice.

mynameiscalypso · 08/11/2023 17:19

It's a really interesting question. I know that my psychiatrist is of a different faith and I'm mindful of that but, faith aside, I know we also have broader philosophical differences on things like assisted dying, the sanctity of human life, the interaction between capacity and some mental health conditions. I don't feel that it interferes with the therapeutic process though and we have, to some extent, agreed to disagree. I think maybe because I'm an atheist and these are framed as academic disagreements, it's easier to separate them out from the actual work of therapy. I can see, however, that it might be different through the lens of having your own faith though.

JanefromLondon1 · 08/11/2023 17:18

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn due to privacy concerns.

Crushed23 · 08/11/2023 17:14

NeedToChangeName · 08/11/2023 14:39

Genuine question, I don't know the answer, if you feel you can't work with a therapist who has a different religion from you (or no religion), is that discrimination?

Edited

I insisted on a female therapist when I sought help - was I being discriminatory?

Swipe left for the next trending thread