Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Free childcare - a farce?

86 replies

aliatalia · 08/11/2023 12:21

Does anyone think the government decided to offer free hours of childcare as an election strategy, which they don't care about or will share details on unless they win?
All local nurseries have said they won't offer it, so I'm guess they decided to fund it knowing that no one will be able to take it up!

OP posts:
Coffeerum · 08/11/2023 13:42

androidnotapple · 08/11/2023 13:32

I'm amazed by how many people I see basing their future plans on this random promise from a dying government who won't be in a position to make it happen.

I think people are just hopeful that the childcare sector has hit breaking point and needs reform now rather than further increasing costs.
When I have 2 in full time nursery it will total £550 a week and that is including the older one receiving the current 30 hours for 3 year olds.

Coffeerum · 08/11/2023 13:39

Boymummyofone · 08/11/2023 13:34

Our nursery just announced the price increase from Jan and also what the funded hours fees will be. They're adding extra fees on top of the funded hours which means we'll be back to square one with the fees being close to what we already pay. Pointless. But I do feel for the nurseries trying to recoup the costs with extra staffing needed etc. The system is broken, I might as well not be working as the fees are already astronomical.

Have they not just told you details on the current funded hours?

Nurseries haven't been given any information on the new funded hour price they will receive from their LA for the start of the expansion of the hours in April so I don't know why a nursery would guess and provide parents with a price from April using the new funded hours for 2 year olds.

Minniejam · 08/11/2023 13:36

I know a nursery that is offering it, no top up fees and it’s got an outstanding ofsted in a lovely area but they are the only one.

I imagine it will come in (up to the point of what can come in before the general election) but most nurseries will have to charge a huge top up.

Coffeerum · 08/11/2023 13:36

Crazydoglady1980 · 08/11/2023 13:32

Lots of nursery’s don’t ask for top ups as a part of the funded hours scheme there should be opportunity for children to access the hours without a cost.
Some nursery’s are talking about offering the hours only within a set time of day, such as 12-6pm, knowing most parents would then pay for 7-12

There is the opportunity though, they are pre-school nurseries.

If you only want to access the fully free, term time short days covered by the 30 hours then join a preschool nursery.
A private day nursery can make up whatever requirements for the hours that it likes.
For the vast majority of parents using private nurseries paying for 7-12 and then not 12-6 is hugely preferable.
Considering free preschool nurseries already exist why should parents who use private nurseries not be able to access help with fees too?

Boymummyofone · 08/11/2023 13:34

Our nursery just announced the price increase from Jan and also what the funded hours fees will be. They're adding extra fees on top of the funded hours which means we'll be back to square one with the fees being close to what we already pay. Pointless. But I do feel for the nurseries trying to recoup the costs with extra staffing needed etc. The system is broken, I might as well not be working as the fees are already astronomical.

Crazydoglady1980 · 08/11/2023 13:32

Lots of nursery’s don’t ask for top ups as a part of the funded hours scheme there should be opportunity for children to access the hours without a cost.
Some nursery’s are talking about offering the hours only within a set time of day, such as 12-6pm, knowing most parents would then pay for 7-12

androidnotapple · 08/11/2023 13:32

I'm amazed by how many people I see basing their future plans on this random promise from a dying government who won't be in a position to make it happen.

EbbandTheWanderingHearts · 08/11/2023 13:31

The Government are going to have to make sure that they actually cover the full cost of the funded place. The main issue is that there is a massive lack of qualified staff as the pay is so low. I earn 18p an hour more as a nursery practitioner than I do working my evening retail job. Add in the stress, paperwork, challenging children/parents, it's not an appealing job.

anniegun · 08/11/2023 13:31

It was just a sound bite from the Tories to pretend they care.

TrashedSofa · 08/11/2023 13:28

I assume the point is that some providers know or believe their private client group won't pay the extra necessary to make the increased funded hours viable. The top up fees can't 'just' increase. They can increase to the amount that the market will bear, and no more.

florafoxtrot · 08/11/2023 13:28

It was announced as a policy with clearly very little research into the feasibility of it. Yes affordable childcare is a big issue and it deserves a lot more airtime and consideration by those in power. But a promise with very little detail or backup is exactly what this is, and I strongly doubt they have any intention of making sure they can deliver on it.

KateyCuckoo · 08/11/2023 13:27

Lollyloup80 · 08/11/2023 13:16

@KateyCuckoo but the ones already offering funding to 3 year olds will have to because it is the same scheme it's just being rolled out to a bigger age group.
They wouldn't be able to say "no actually we're just going to offer it to 3 year olds only" because that wouldn't be the scheme anymore. They either have it or they don't. And given that most nurseries have it, I think it's highly unlikely they'll take it all away for their customers.

Mark my words and you will see.

No you're wrong, they can do exactly that!

Lollyloup80 · 08/11/2023 13:26

CaptainJackSparrow85 · 08/11/2023 13:20

The government can say what it likes but nurseries can refuse to offer the funded hours if it isn’t economically viable for them.

The scheme is massively underfunded so the only way most nurseries would be able afford to make it work is by turning it into a Ponzi scheme - cranking up the prices even further for 0-2s/any unfunded hours. Which clearly isn’t fair, and also wouldn’t work because there comes a point where most people simply can’t pay a bill that high so would withdraw their children which would mean there would be no one to pay the higher fees anyway.

How is it not economically viable for them? They take the funded money and charge whatever else they need to on top.

What's the alternative, charge the customers full wack and expect them not to go to the cheaper nurseries.

Everyone's acting like the govt funding is all the nurseries get... don't your nurseries charge top fees on top every month?
Have you thought maybe the top up fees will just increase?

Anonymousbosch39 · 08/11/2023 13:25

There have been 3 nurseries in my local area that have closed their doors for good as it was not financially viable.
I work in a nursery and we have to fund raise for things such as paint and paper. Good nurseries are closing and great people are leaving the profession, nobody cares though.

CaptainJackSparrow85 · 08/11/2023 13:20

The government can say what it likes but nurseries can refuse to offer the funded hours if it isn’t economically viable for them.

The scheme is massively underfunded so the only way most nurseries would be able afford to make it work is by turning it into a Ponzi scheme - cranking up the prices even further for 0-2s/any unfunded hours. Which clearly isn’t fair, and also wouldn’t work because there comes a point where most people simply can’t pay a bill that high so would withdraw their children which would mean there would be no one to pay the higher fees anyway.

Lollyloup80 · 08/11/2023 13:19

They will just raise the prices around the scheme. Not one business is going to turn down govt funding because the customers won't go near it.

Lollyloup80 · 08/11/2023 13:16

@KateyCuckoo but the ones already offering funding to 3 year olds will have to because it is the same scheme it's just being rolled out to a bigger age group.
They wouldn't be able to say "no actually we're just going to offer it to 3 year olds only" because that wouldn't be the scheme anymore. They either have it or they don't. And given that most nurseries have it, I think it's highly unlikely they'll take it all away for their customers.

Mark my words and you will see.

FoxtrotSkarloey · 08/11/2023 13:10

Round here the nurseries are already full without funded places. Given the funding doesn't cover costs anyway, why on earth would they start to take in more funded places.

In this scenario, there is zero incentive for them to do so.

PuttingDownRoots · 08/11/2023 13:08

It would be better if they just gave parents an allowance rather than claiming it covered certain hours!

Bo199 · 08/11/2023 13:07

I’ll believe it when I see it.

MintJulia · 08/11/2023 13:04

Tohaveandtohold · 08/11/2023 12:37

It’s not free hours, it’s funded hours. It’s just like the 15 and 30 hrs currently, nurseries here offer it but charge parents the difference between what they are paid by the government and what their fees are normally ( for example, I was still paying £270 a month when my dd had 30 funded hours though it would have been around £600 without the funding)
I’ve not heard of any nurseries here saying they won’t offer it and many nurseries here want children there more than one day a week for example so people using the scheme for their young children will still have to pay the difference and pay for the other days they use.

This.

Nursery restrictions are likely due to lack of staff because the staff ratios for little ones are lower.

trevthecat · 08/11/2023 13:01

I work closely with nurseries and childminders locally and most can't afford to offer the new funded places. The uptake will be very low and I'm in a council area that offers a higher rate than average.

Caledoniadreaming · 08/11/2023 13:00

It's not free hours, it's funded. And either way, nurseries/childminders do not have to offer this; most won't offer the expansion as it's already not viable for the 3-4 year old funding. There's a reason why the 0-2 years nursery fees are astronomical already - it's to plug the gap in funding.

If childcare settings ARE going to offer the new funding, they're removing other options such as half days, less than 3 days etc., to ensure they get something.

We're already past boiling point in terms of the lack of availability; all that happens is that more and more childminders/nurseries will close if they have to rely on Govt. funding.

TrashedSofa · 08/11/2023 12:57

The settings may also know they don't have and won't pursue the capacity, in terms of premises and/or staffing.

Parker231 · 08/11/2023 12:54

Coffeerum · 08/11/2023 12:35

I just find it hard to believe all the nurseries local to OP have explicitly said they will not be offering the expansion of the free hours. The details and new funding rates haven't been announced yet, why would a nursery say they won't be offering it?

Unless the government funds it properly, nurseries won’t be able to offer it as it’s not financially viable.