Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Free childcare - a farce?

86 replies

aliatalia · 08/11/2023 12:21

Does anyone think the government decided to offer free hours of childcare as an election strategy, which they don't care about or will share details on unless they win?
All local nurseries have said they won't offer it, so I'm guess they decided to fund it knowing that no one will be able to take it up!

OP posts:
Londonscallingme · 08/11/2023 14:24

MoltenLasagne · 08/11/2023 14:20

The nurseries I know who did this were forced to stop as it goes against the rules of the funded hours. I presume your council are either unaware or are choosing to turn a blind eye, as its by far the most sensible use of funding imo.

Yeah... very difficult to get around the massive regional differences in cost without allowing for top ups. I am glad of the discount, even if it's not a big one!

Boymummyofone · 08/11/2023 14:23

PuttingDownRoots · 08/11/2023 14:13

@Boymummyofone have I read that right... it costs over £2k to send a 2yo to your nursery a month? £24k a year?

With gritted teeth..

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 08/11/2023 14:23

Lollyloup80 · 08/11/2023 13:16

@KateyCuckoo but the ones already offering funding to 3 year olds will have to because it is the same scheme it's just being rolled out to a bigger age group.
They wouldn't be able to say "no actually we're just going to offer it to 3 year olds only" because that wouldn't be the scheme anymore. They either have it or they don't. And given that most nurseries have it, I think it's highly unlikely they'll take it all away for their customers.

Mark my words and you will see.

They won’t have to simply have it or not. They are already allowed to limit the number of funded places they offer so they absolutely can decide they’ll only accept it for certain ages or cap the number of funded children overall.

VivaVivaa · 08/11/2023 14:23

Despite having 2 pre school aged children my knowledge is lacking. Do the government pay a set amount per hour for each child over 3, no matter where they live in the country and no matter what setting they go to? For example, if it costs a nursery £10 per hour for each child over 3 (staff costs, heating, ground rent, toys, staff training etc) but they are only receiving £5 per hour from the government, they average out the shortfall over children aged 0-3 in extremely high fees, seeing as they aren’t allowed to charge top up to the >3 yo?

If I’m understanding correctly and that is the case then clearly this policy will never work. If every single space is subsidised but not to a great enough extent, where will the short falls come from, if top ups remain banned?

Wineisgreat · 08/11/2023 14:21

@Londonscallingme

Because qualified workers are realising that actually they aren't being paid enough to make the hard work worth it and are leaving the industry. There are plenty of less stressful jobs that they can be doing for only a tiny bit less money.

I'd rather they were paid more which is easier with less funding as more profit would be available to the companies running them to increase wages.

Coffeerum · 08/11/2023 14:20

Caledoniadreaming · 08/11/2023 14:03

@Coffeerum if I used a pre-school nursery I wouldn't be able to work. They're only usually open during school hours and obviously term time.

The reason we use a private nursery is like so many parents who use breakfast and after school clubs - they provide the cover and care we need in order to be able to work.

The Government have announced this "policy" - and I use the word loosely, in order to shore up the vast majority of the electorate they have ignored for the past however many years. They haven't done the homework, consulted the actual people who would be required to put this into place, and then are expected to suck up the shortfall. It's well publicised that the early years childcare shortage in this country is just getting worse, and that it is affecting children growing up - why wouldn't you want to invest in your kids and give then the best foundations possible?

I get that it is expensive (hell, LIFE is expensive), and yes there should be more thought put in to these offers/incentives from the Government, but consistent underfunding year after year does not help.

Edited

I don’t see how that’s really in reply to me. The poster was complaining about limiting the hours the funding applies in a day and there still being a charge in a day and that there needs to be provision to only use the few hours.
But that already exists in the form of a preschool. Otherwise parents use private nurseries and having caveats in place in terms of when the free hours count etc is still a benefit for parents paying for full days, throughout the full year.

MoltenLasagne · 08/11/2023 14:20

Londonscallingme · 08/11/2023 14:15

Our nursery doesn't give free hours, it reduces the overall fee and we pay (what I presume is) the difference. In reality because the fees at our nursery at high (£130 / day) the funding doesn't go very far but it does reduce the fees a bit.

The nurseries I know who did this were forced to stop as it goes against the rules of the funded hours. I presume your council are either unaware or are choosing to turn a blind eye, as its by far the most sensible use of funding imo.

princefamilypaper · 08/11/2023 14:17

Apparently only 17% of nursery's will offer it. Mine won't be offering it

KateyCuckoo · 08/11/2023 14:16

Actually labour said they would look at offering it to the lowest income families and introduce a tapering off of support for higher income families.

3WildOnes · 08/11/2023 14:15

PuttingDownRoots · 08/11/2023 14:13

@Boymummyofone have I read that right... it costs over £2k to send a 2yo to your nursery a month? £24k a year?

I was paying 2k for a full time place for mine and that was a few years ago now.

Londonscallingme · 08/11/2023 14:15

MoltenLasagne · 08/11/2023 14:10

There's no such thing as top up fees and hasnt been for a while. When the funded hours initially came in, nurseries treated them as partial funding. E.g. if the cost per hour was £6 and the government gave them £4 for 5 hrs a day, you'd pay £2 per hour for your 4 funded hours then paid full price for the remaining 2 hours. Essentially paying £22 total with a £20 subsidy from the government.

Nurseries were explicitly told they were not allowed to do this. Instead they now have to give you the free hours completely free but their costs haven't changed and they're losing money on every underfunded hour. So to survive they hike up the hourly rate for non funded to £10 an hour, or charge extra for food and nappies.

Our nursery doesn't give free hours, it reduces the overall fee and we pay (what I presume is) the difference. In reality because the fees at our nursery at high (£130 / day) the funding doesn't go very far but it does reduce the fees a bit.

3WildOnes · 08/11/2023 14:14

Boymummyofone · 08/11/2023 13:47

Hm I didn't realise it was still being worked out with the LA's but from the email we received yesterday it looked like their fees were set for the start of the April scheme. I might have a word with them and see whether this is due to be changed but as other people have said, the government might just change their stance on the whole thing 🤷‍♀️

I can't work this out. Is it saying you would be paying over 2k for a full time place for an under 2, with the funding in place?
Surely those are the fees without the funding?

PuttingDownRoots · 08/11/2023 14:13

@Boymummyofone have I read that right... it costs over £2k to send a 2yo to your nursery a month? £24k a year?

BoohooWoohoo · 08/11/2023 14:13

People are right to be sceptical about this policy. This government does not have a history of investing in education at any age and are clearly unbothered by the childcare issue as it's women who are mainly affected in terms of being customers and employees.
As 0-2 year olds currently subsidise the 3-4 year olds, I would predict more nurseries closing or fees for every age to rise so that the lack of government funding doesn't cause the business to fold. The government will then blame the nurseries rather than find nurseries properly.

I think that there will be more announcements like this that will act as a trap for the next Labour government.

Londonscallingme · 08/11/2023 14:12

Wineisgreat · 08/11/2023 14:06

Personally I'd rather not have the funding and have reliable, quality childcare. So many nurseries are losing qualified staff and struggling to run well/competently with unqualified staff that you can see that they will end up failing full stop. One of our nurseries around here have lost multiple staff and a recent ofsted inspection have now labelled them as inadequate in all areas. This is not sustainable.

Out of interest - in what way do you think the funding reduces the quality of care nurseries are able to offer? We live in an expensive part of the country so the funding only contributes a small amount to the overall cost of the hours. The nursery doesn't get less money because the funded hourly rate is less than the stated fees it just gets some from the government and some from the fee payer.

Londonscallingme · 08/11/2023 14:10

androidnotapple · 08/11/2023 13:32

I'm amazed by how many people I see basing their future plans on this random promise from a dying government who won't be in a position to make it happen.

I'm pretty sure that the reason the Tories announced the policy was in response to Labour saying they would do something similar (if not more generous) so whilst I take your point that nothing is guaranteed, it seems likely that when the Tories get voted out, Labour will continue with the policy (if already in place) or enact something similar. We have a very tight labour market (one of the reasons inflation has been worse in the UK than is other western nations) and childcare is seen as being a good way to get people back into work.

MoltenLasagne · 08/11/2023 14:10

There's no such thing as top up fees and hasnt been for a while. When the funded hours initially came in, nurseries treated them as partial funding. E.g. if the cost per hour was £6 and the government gave them £4 for 5 hrs a day, you'd pay £2 per hour for your 4 funded hours then paid full price for the remaining 2 hours. Essentially paying £22 total with a £20 subsidy from the government.

Nurseries were explicitly told they were not allowed to do this. Instead they now have to give you the free hours completely free but their costs haven't changed and they're losing money on every underfunded hour. So to survive they hike up the hourly rate for non funded to £10 an hour, or charge extra for food and nappies.

Wineisgreat · 08/11/2023 14:06

Personally I'd rather not have the funding and have reliable, quality childcare. So many nurseries are losing qualified staff and struggling to run well/competently with unqualified staff that you can see that they will end up failing full stop. One of our nurseries around here have lost multiple staff and a recent ofsted inspection have now labelled them as inadequate in all areas. This is not sustainable.

FoxtrotSkarloey · 08/11/2023 14:05

androidnotapple · 08/11/2023 13:32

I'm amazed by how many people I see basing their future plans on this random promise from a dying government who won't be in a position to make it happen.

Yep. Proves it's a vote winner. More lies.

Caledoniadreaming · 08/11/2023 14:03

@Coffeerum if I used a pre-school nursery I wouldn't be able to work. They're only usually open during school hours and obviously term time.

The reason we use a private nursery is like so many parents who use breakfast and after school clubs - they provide the cover and care we need in order to be able to work.

The Government have announced this "policy" - and I use the word loosely, in order to shore up the vast majority of the electorate they have ignored for the past however many years. They haven't done the homework, consulted the actual people who would be required to put this into place, and then are expected to suck up the shortfall. It's well publicised that the early years childcare shortage in this country is just getting worse, and that it is affecting children growing up - why wouldn't you want to invest in your kids and give then the best foundations possible?

I get that it is expensive (hell, LIFE is expensive), and yes there should be more thought put in to these offers/incentives from the Government, but consistent underfunding year after year does not help.

truptantripping · 08/11/2023 14:01

Nothing in life is free. It's paid for somewhere by someone.

I hate the notion of being entitled to free stuff.

KateyCuckoo · 08/11/2023 13:57

Lollyloup80 · 08/11/2023 13:44

Jeremy Hunt did address the shortfall issue and is looking to fix it given they have acknowledged there's a problem. Hence why they are rolling it out slowly so the nurseries have time to adapt etc.
It probably has already occurred to them that if they don't offer enough the nurseries will close? But maybe let's all just be really negative and assume we're going to be worse off.

Do you work in a childcare setting or are you coming at this from a parent perspective? Trying to work out who you think is negative?

KateyCuckoo · 08/11/2023 13:51

@Boymummyofone so there is currently 2 year funding in place for very low income families/ those on certain benefits /disability etc and I wonder if your nursery have assumed it's this rate that they will be given? Unlikely as that's something different.

Boymummyofone · 08/11/2023 13:47

Hm I didn't realise it was still being worked out with the LA's but from the email we received yesterday it looked like their fees were set for the start of the April scheme. I might have a word with them and see whether this is due to be changed but as other people have said, the government might just change their stance on the whole thing 🤷‍♀️

Free childcare - a farce?
Lollyloup80 · 08/11/2023 13:44

Jeremy Hunt did address the shortfall issue and is looking to fix it given they have acknowledged there's a problem. Hence why they are rolling it out slowly so the nurseries have time to adapt etc.
It probably has already occurred to them that if they don't offer enough the nurseries will close? But maybe let's all just be really negative and assume we're going to be worse off.

Swipe left for the next trending thread