Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Religious Celebrations in school

116 replies

ClippitiClop · 08/11/2023 07:28

DS is 4, in reception. He goes to a great school, we are in London so very diverse intake of kids. The school has no religious affiliation and when we asked at open days how religion is taught and celebrated they told us that all religious holidays are treated with equal prominence with the exception of Christmas as it’s also a cultural holiday in the UK - fair enough!
Yesterday was DS parents evening. We got to have a look at work they have done so far this year while waiting to speak to the teacher.
Not many religious holidays have happened since school started but in September they did “celebrate” Rosh Hashanah (Jewish).
They read books about how Jews celebrated the holiday, tried some exotic fruits (I’ll be honest I’m not sure of the relevance here), along with Apple and Honey (traditional I believe), and did some related crafts.
The teacher mentioned on Friday they are celebrating Diwali, themed lunch for all students and other in class activities in the afternoon. All great - right?

Well DH has decided he thinks it is insensitive, he feels like it is allowing the children to pick and chose which parts of a religion to engage with (the “fun” parts). He thinks celebrating Eid for example would be offensive as it comes at the end of fasting, he doesn’t see why anyone who hasn’t participated in fasting should be able to “just” join the fun celebration at the end. I pointed out it’s really no different to Easter for most and he claimed it’s different as there are secular aspects to Easter (quite frankly he’s very much partial to a lamb dinner and chocolate egg at Easter!!).
DH thinks it would be better if these religious holidays were taught but not necessarily celebrated in the school. He thinks this should include Easter, Eid, Rosh Hashanah, Diwali etc. (though he feels Chinese new year is fine as it’s more cultural than religious). He agrees with the school that Christmas is different.

AIBU to think DH is being silly and it’s totally fine (actually a positive) that the kids are getting to learn about and appreciate other religions, in a way that is engaging and in my opinion respectful (feel free to disagree). Or is he right, picking and choosing which parts of a religion to engage with is insensitive?

If you are religious (Muslim, Jewish, Hindu, Christian or any other) would the way the school seems to celebrate these holidays offend you? Would you rather they only taught and not celebrate? (I appreciate you can’t speak for your religion as a whole but curious none the less)

OP posts:
MidnightOnceMore · 08/11/2023 08:23

ClippitiClop · 08/11/2023 08:19

I did make this point …. He didn’t give a real answer before deciding that in the UK atleast there are secular aspects to Easter (he seems to always be able to twist a situation to suit his narrative though)

Hmm.

He sounds uncomfortable with religious diversity.

Thesearmsofmine · 08/11/2023 08:23

This is how small children learn, through fun and role play. Does he want them sat down and given a lecture instead? He sounds clueless.

Mrsjayy · 08/11/2023 08:21

there Is also secular other cultures though, I don't think it's reserved to atheist "Christians ". I mean I might be wrong

MidnightOnceMore · 08/11/2023 08:21

ClippitiClop · 08/11/2023 08:17

I think it’s fair to say that in the UK (where we are both from and live and where our family is from and live) Christmas is not just a Christian celebration but a cultural one. If we lived elsewhere this might not be the case and another holiday may take the place of bridging the cultural/religious celebrations. If we lived somewhere this was the case we’d likely celebrate that holiday.
As we are British and live in the UK, but atheist, we celebrate holidays as they are part of our culture, (so we celebrate Christmas, less so Easter and that’s about it).

But how do other religions achieve the same status as Christianity - not in terms of numbers but social value - if they are only ever enjoyed by followers of the faith?

It could sound a little bit like he just doesn't really like multiculturalism and wants mainstream things to be Christian while the 'niche' religions stay in their boxes?

Mrsjayy · 08/11/2023 08:19

I think husband is looking to be offended on behalf of other cultures and making himself look a bit daft in the process.

ClippitiClop · 08/11/2023 08:19

Geneticsbunny · 08/11/2023 08:17

What did your husband give up/ take up for lent in order to enjoy his Easter eggs?

I did make this point …. He didn’t give a real answer before deciding that in the UK atleast there are secular aspects to Easter (he seems to always be able to twist a situation to suit his narrative though)

OP posts:
RedVanYellowVan · 08/11/2023 08:17

OK, this thread has moved on very fast, I see that your DH is an atheist. Yes, Christmas has shifted a bit from religious to cultural (otherwise why would the shops be full of imported plastic tat?) but my understanding is that there is a certain element of that with other religions - the fun, not the tat. I think Christians have the monopoly on that!

Learning through play is what children do at that stage. Your DH is over thinking it. Has he spoken to parents from different faiths at the school to gauge their feelings?

At my DCs primary school they used to invite parents and grandparents in to share different faiths and beliefs. My pagan friend was in her DDs school last year talking about that. I know a teacher at the school, she said it was brilliant.

ClippitiClop · 08/11/2023 08:17

Busephalus · 08/11/2023 08:07

'Other religious celebrations haven't'? Surely that's his egocentric view of the world and where he lives

I think it’s fair to say that in the UK (where we are both from and live and where our family is from and live) Christmas is not just a Christian celebration but a cultural one. If we lived elsewhere this might not be the case and another holiday may take the place of bridging the cultural/religious celebrations. If we lived somewhere this was the case we’d likely celebrate that holiday.
As we are British and live in the UK, but atheist, we celebrate holidays as they are part of our culture, (so we celebrate Christmas, less so Easter and that’s about it).

OP posts:
Geneticsbunny · 08/11/2023 08:17

What did your husband give up/ take up for lent in order to enjoy his Easter eggs?

JanglyBeads · 08/11/2023 08:13

As a Christian, I think he has a point tbh.

But also the points made here about cultural learning and experiential learning for younger children are valid too.

MidnightOnceMore · 08/11/2023 08:11

ClippitiClop · 08/11/2023 07:53

He thinks it’s insensitive/offensive, in his mind it’s watering down the religions to a couple of fun events a year and devalues them (the kids are 4-11 so I think this is a crazy mindset).

He is very much atheist, went to a non-denominational school up north as did I. Neither of us have any recollection of celebrating any holidays at school that weren’t Christian, but do remember learning about them in RE.
He loves the school ethos as a whole, child first, “celebrating the individual”, inclusive etc.
I don’t think he means anything bad by it, I think he just worries too much about being insensitive to others beliefs.

This is even less understandable to me now, if he is an atheist what does he care for the religious aspects?

I have never been told by someone of another religion that they find it insensitive for other people to understand and enjoy the festivals of importance to their communities.

Your DH is worrying on behalf of other people who are able to speak for themselves, this is not his job. If he wants to ask other people what they think, and they tell him it is insensitive, then he would have a point - but this appears to be a conclusion an atheist has come to on behalf of people of faith he has never met?

Is it possible he just doesn't like religious ceremonies in school very much full stop, as an atheist? That would be philosophically more consistent.

Your local area will probably have some form of multi-faith advisory group for RE in schools. Have a look at their work and rest assured that if there were an issue, local faith leaders would be speaking up.

Busephalus · 08/11/2023 08:07

'Other religious celebrations haven't'? Surely that's his egocentric view of the world and where he lives

HoppingLady · 08/11/2023 08:06

I’m Hindu and we’re doing Diwali decorations and food at my work place. It’s just something fun and we love it being celebrated at schools etc. Your DH is overthinking this.

RedVanYellowVan · 08/11/2023 08:04

Does your DH come from a background with an austere religion such as Free Presbyterian? Otherwise I can't think of a reason he would want to deprive 4 and 5 year olds of fun. Fun is a good way to learn, if it is enjoyable it will stick in the mind more. They can learn more age appropriate details as they get older.

My Humanist viewpoint would be it's ok to teach, celebrate, play at all the different religions if they are taught as "some people believe". Once it gets into the realms of "fact" it is very dodgy indeed.

This world desperately needs more understanding, not less.

Needmorelego · 08/11/2023 08:02

Your child is 4. He will learn about the not so fun and serious parts of religion when he is older. I expect if you asked one of the Year 6 children what they do.in their RE lessons it will be very different to the little babies in Reception.
Wait until about Year 3 or so when they start learning about WW2. It's all about Evacuees ("what an adventure") and food rations, building a model of an Anderson shelter out of cardboard etc. They don't get into the actual evils and politics about it until older.
It's age appropriate education.

ClippitiClop · 08/11/2023 07:59

Sirzy · 08/11/2023 07:55

I really hope your DH doesn’t do anything for Christmas unless he goes to church week in week out!

DH and I have had this debate before. Eventually we concluded that in the UK atleast (and elsewhere in many cases), Christmas has crossed a line from religious to cultural, where other religious celebrations haven’t. So while there are many religious aspects (most of which we don’t engage in) there are also cultural aspects which are now only loosely related to the religious ones which we do engage in.

OP posts:
Thenewnewme · 08/11/2023 07:57

Muslim 4 year olds won’t be fasting but they will be celebrating Eid.

As for picking a choosing parts of events, it’s about doing things in an age appropriate way. My 4 year old is wearing a poppy this week but I’ve yet to tell her about the full realities of war. Does that mean she shouldn’t wear a poppy. Although on a side note I’m not a great fan of poppy wearing as it glorifies war so this probably isn’t a great example.

Learning happens in layers. Same as in Maths or English and more knowledge and skills are added each year.

Sirzy · 08/11/2023 07:55

I really hope your DH doesn’t do anything for Christmas unless he goes to church week in week out!

horseymum · 08/11/2023 07:55

I'm a Christian and know that there are many aspects of Christianity described in the curriculum and delivered by teachers as being quite far from my faith, so I'd assume the same for other religions. They are being shown a taster of what different groups think, probably often quite far from what those groups actually believe but if it fosters some tolerance and curiosity, it's all good. Probably better to learn from actual members of the faith community what is/ isn't offensive.

ClippitiClop · 08/11/2023 07:53

MidnightOnceMore · 08/11/2023 07:48

What is the harm your DH thinks will become your DS by learning about things in a happy and enjoyable way? You have said he thinks it is 'wrong' - but why is it wrong? Wrong to whom?

I am interested in your DH's religion, upbringing and schooling because his attitude smacks of very old-fashioned fear about 'corrupting' young people with too much fun!

He's wrong IMO. Enjoying cultural highlights from lots of religions is fun and aids understanding of other people.

He thinks it’s insensitive/offensive, in his mind it’s watering down the religions to a couple of fun events a year and devalues them (the kids are 4-11 so I think this is a crazy mindset).

He is very much atheist, went to a non-denominational school up north as did I. Neither of us have any recollection of celebrating any holidays at school that weren’t Christian, but do remember learning about them in RE.
He loves the school ethos as a whole, child first, “celebrating the individual”, inclusive etc.
I don’t think he means anything bad by it, I think he just worries too much about being insensitive to others beliefs.

OP posts:
Medicinalfriedchicken · 08/11/2023 07:52

Regarding your point about the exotic fruit, could it have been pomegranate, which is traditionally eaten on Jewish New Year?

Agree with others, this is what makes these religious and cultural celebrations accessible, and the curriculum will go into greater depth as they get older. No need to worry!

EverybodyJumpsuit · 08/11/2023 07:48

That said I think it’s positive your DH is considering if there is sensitivity for those who do practice when others join in- maybe he could gently explore this idea with parents from those groups?

MidnightOnceMore · 08/11/2023 07:48

What is the harm your DH thinks will become your DS by learning about things in a happy and enjoyable way? You have said he thinks it is 'wrong' - but why is it wrong? Wrong to whom?

I am interested in your DH's religion, upbringing and schooling because his attitude smacks of very old-fashioned fear about 'corrupting' young people with too much fun!

He's wrong IMO. Enjoying cultural highlights from lots of religions is fun and aids understanding of other people.

EverybodyJumpsuit · 08/11/2023 07:47

We are in a similar school in London that celebrates Chinese New Year, Eid, Diwali etc It’s also not just about your kids- children with heritage from, or who belong to those religions and cultures get to celebrate in school in just the same way that Christmas is celebrated even though they aren’t Christian. It fosters community and understanding between kids and supports the idea that their cultures and faiths are not other. It’s very enriching to all the kids. Many of our neighbours are Muslim and we make Eid cards and give dates at the start of the festival etc- its brilliant! Our school is about 35% Muslim intake, with a strong voice in the governors and If that community doesn’t like something the school is doing they very strongly make it known, and the school celebrating Eid is not something I’ve ever heard any objection to…

gravitytester · 08/11/2023 07:47

I actually love the way the school are doing that! It inclusive to all and teaches positivity and acceptance.

FWIW- as a white Brit, my best friend growing up was Pakistani and we were always invited to celebrate Eid with them, no one ever complain that we didn't fast.

Swipe left for the next trending thread