Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Religious Celebrations in school

116 replies

ClippitiClop · 08/11/2023 07:28

DS is 4, in reception. He goes to a great school, we are in London so very diverse intake of kids. The school has no religious affiliation and when we asked at open days how religion is taught and celebrated they told us that all religious holidays are treated with equal prominence with the exception of Christmas as it’s also a cultural holiday in the UK - fair enough!
Yesterday was DS parents evening. We got to have a look at work they have done so far this year while waiting to speak to the teacher.
Not many religious holidays have happened since school started but in September they did “celebrate” Rosh Hashanah (Jewish).
They read books about how Jews celebrated the holiday, tried some exotic fruits (I’ll be honest I’m not sure of the relevance here), along with Apple and Honey (traditional I believe), and did some related crafts.
The teacher mentioned on Friday they are celebrating Diwali, themed lunch for all students and other in class activities in the afternoon. All great - right?

Well DH has decided he thinks it is insensitive, he feels like it is allowing the children to pick and chose which parts of a religion to engage with (the “fun” parts). He thinks celebrating Eid for example would be offensive as it comes at the end of fasting, he doesn’t see why anyone who hasn’t participated in fasting should be able to “just” join the fun celebration at the end. I pointed out it’s really no different to Easter for most and he claimed it’s different as there are secular aspects to Easter (quite frankly he’s very much partial to a lamb dinner and chocolate egg at Easter!!).
DH thinks it would be better if these religious holidays were taught but not necessarily celebrated in the school. He thinks this should include Easter, Eid, Rosh Hashanah, Diwali etc. (though he feels Chinese new year is fine as it’s more cultural than religious). He agrees with the school that Christmas is different.

AIBU to think DH is being silly and it’s totally fine (actually a positive) that the kids are getting to learn about and appreciate other religions, in a way that is engaging and in my opinion respectful (feel free to disagree). Or is he right, picking and choosing which parts of a religion to engage with is insensitive?

If you are religious (Muslim, Jewish, Hindu, Christian or any other) would the way the school seems to celebrate these holidays offend you? Would you rather they only taught and not celebrate? (I appreciate you can’t speak for your religion as a whole but curious none the less)

OP posts:
Busephalus · 08/11/2023 09:27

Op, there are plenty of areas in the UK where other religious celebrations have crossed over into cultural, its a bit narrow to say its just Christmas

Ahtishoo · 08/11/2023 09:25

I agree with your DH. I don’t think it’s offensive but I do think it’s intellectually and morally incoherent. My DC went to a church school which has given them a solid grounding in Christian religious philosophy, including critiquing it (we are not religious). They also learned about other important religions. I don’t think the problem is about ‘celebrating’ vs ‘learning’, it’s more the pick n mix. How will they grasp the central philosophies of any of these religions?

AbbeyGailsParty · 08/11/2023 09:16

Your little lad is 4!!! He has 14 years of education ahead of him, experiencing the “fun” part of different religions isn’t going to harm him or offend anyone, I’m sure.
I grew up in multicultural city in the 60s but no other religion but CofE was mentioned or allowed, ( in school or home) probably did my generation far more harm.

HonoriaLucastaDelagardie · 08/11/2023 09:10

Although on a side note I’m not a great fan of poppy wearing as it glorifies war

Where on earth do you get that idea? We wear a poppy to remember those who died. Hence Remembrance.

In Flanders fields the poppies grow
Beneath the crosses, row on row.

They shall not grow old, as we that are left grow old
Age shall not weary them, not the years condemn.
At the going down of the sun, and in the morning
We will remember them.

Mrsjayy · 08/11/2023 09:08

no 4 year olds don't fast it's around 11 or 12 .

89redballoons · 08/11/2023 09:06

Do 4 year olds from Muslim families fast during Ramadan anyway?

My family is Catholic and I know that actual fasting obligations in the Catholic church don't apply until the children are teenagers. Maybe children would give up chocolate for lent or something, but probably not at 4 or 5.

RudsyFarmer · 08/11/2023 09:03

MintJulia · 08/11/2023 09:01

The children are FOUR & FIVE. If you want to get their attention and have them start to understand the varieties of religions, they need to enjoy the fun bits.

Your DH may not be religious but he has a distinct tint of puritan about him. Is he joyless in other ways?

Your last paragraph made me laugh 🤣

RudsyFarmer · 08/11/2023 09:02

I am going to guess your DH sees it as a form of cultural appropriation. Personally I think it’s a fun way for children to learn about other peoples beliefs whilst getting to enjoy the celebratory aspect.

MintJulia · 08/11/2023 09:01

The children are FOUR & FIVE. If you want to get their attention and have them start to understand the varieties of religions, they need to enjoy the fun bits.

Your DH may not be religious but he has a distinct tint of puritan about him. Is he joyless in other ways?

Bells3032 · 08/11/2023 08:59

Your DH is an idiot. You can't teach a four year old entire religions that have developed over thousands of years. I'm in my 30s and don't know about every aspect of my own religion let alone others.

I think it's a lovely idea to "celebrate" other religions. Think it's just a way of being engaging when teaching. I am Jewish and would be more than happy about other kids starting to learn about it by learning about Rosh Hashanah. I wouldn't even think that it's that exciting a festival to be honest. (the exotic fruit thing is because on RH you're meant to eat a fruit that you've not had that year so most people will pick some wacky fruit)

My two year olds childminder is mostly Jewish kids (not officially but because of location most, if not all, are Jewish) and yesterday they were "learning" about Diwali ie colouring in Diwali related pics.

You do it at the level kids can engage and they learn more as they get older

Isometimeswonder · 08/11/2023 08:52

I love learning about all the cultures and religions, I think it fosters better understanding.

ExpressCheckout · 08/11/2023 08:48

Your husband is (politely) being a bit of a d*ck.
Is there anything useful you could give him to do around the house?😁

PurpleBugz · 08/11/2023 08:47

As a Christian who observes lent I have no problem with people celebrating Easter. If it was done in school and the meaning of Easter was taught I'd find that preferable to the Easter bunny. I hate Santa and the Easter bunny

FloofCloud · 08/11/2023 08:43

Understanding religion is essential, being indoctrinated is unacceptable in schools particularly... this sounded more like a fun learning lesson

Mrsjayy · 08/11/2023 08:42

they are 4 years old how much information do you think they take in?

Wrongsideofpennines · 08/11/2023 08:36

If the school is simply teaching/celebrating the nice bits of religion and not the rest then yes I'd be concerned. But you can't really teach the resurrection without the crucifixion, and Eid isn't such a feast if you ignore the Ramadan that came before, or Pesach without the bit about being slaves in Egypt and the angel of death. And at age 4 I think its much easier to understand the celebration part.
Would he prefer they make the pupils fast during ramadan or kill a lamb and paint blood on their doorposts in their RE lessons instead?

Mrsjayy · 08/11/2023 08:33

ElaineMBenes · 08/11/2023 08:31

It all feels a bit 'white saviour' to me....
Has he any evidence at all that anyone is actually offended?

yes this.

ElaineMBenes · 08/11/2023 08:31

It all feels a bit 'white saviour' to me....
Has he any evidence at all that anyone is actually offended?

Hermittrismegistus · 08/11/2023 08:29

So your husband isn't even religious, he's an atheist? Who does he think he is taking offence on other's behalf?

Does he think we religious folk are too timid to speak up if we found something our school was doing offensive?

Mrsjayy · 08/11/2023 08:29

but acknowledging and celebrations of different festivals in schools gives the children a taste of other cultures, and what about the children of different cultures in the school surely they should be allowed to celebrate and share their festivals its their school as we as the "Christian " children.

ClippitiClop · 08/11/2023 08:27

MidnightOnceMore · 08/11/2023 08:23

Hmm.

He sounds uncomfortable with religious diversity.

Like I’ve said I genuinely don’t believe this is the case. He’s always keen to be extremely respectful of others beliefs and religion and is more worried he is offending someone by not being respectful enough than anything else.

OP posts:
Trulywonderful · 08/11/2023 08:27

Op your school sounds like it is doing a good job teaching the students about each others culture and religions. This is a wonderful way to stop the children fearing difference of others as an adult. The fear of others differences has led to many prejudices and conflicts both small and massive.

Also a lot of secondary schools have RS as a non optional choice for GCSE, so your kids will have a good headstart with that.

ElaineMBenes · 08/11/2023 08:27

Mrsjayy · 08/11/2023 08:19

I think husband is looking to be offended on behalf of other cultures and making himself look a bit daft in the process.

This. While also being a massive hypocrite.

He seems happy enough to celebrate the 'fun' bits of certain religious festivals.

ClippitiClop · 08/11/2023 08:25

MidnightOnceMore · 08/11/2023 08:21

But how do other religions achieve the same status as Christianity - not in terms of numbers but social value - if they are only ever enjoyed by followers of the faith?

It could sound a little bit like he just doesn't really like multiculturalism and wants mainstream things to be Christian while the 'niche' religions stay in their boxes?

I genuinely don’t think this is the case at all. He is a very loving man and I do think his concerns are from a good place (a fear that we are diluting religious holidays insensitively) rather than one of intolerance.
DH couldn’t care less for Christmas or Easter, he celebrates for me and our DS. If one year I said let’s not do anything he would probably go “yeah fine grand”.
We have celebrated Eid in the past, with some muslim friends. He feels this was different as we were invited to join their celebrations, rather than taking it upon ourselves to plan them (which is what he feels the school is doing).

OP posts:
Mrsjayy · 08/11/2023 08:25

MidnightOnceMore · 08/11/2023 08:23

Hmm.

He sounds uncomfortable with religious diversity.

yeah he does like a pp said they should stay in their box.

Swipe left for the next trending thread