Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Religious Celebrations in school

116 replies

ClippitiClop · 08/11/2023 07:28

DS is 4, in reception. He goes to a great school, we are in London so very diverse intake of kids. The school has no religious affiliation and when we asked at open days how religion is taught and celebrated they told us that all religious holidays are treated with equal prominence with the exception of Christmas as it’s also a cultural holiday in the UK - fair enough!
Yesterday was DS parents evening. We got to have a look at work they have done so far this year while waiting to speak to the teacher.
Not many religious holidays have happened since school started but in September they did “celebrate” Rosh Hashanah (Jewish).
They read books about how Jews celebrated the holiday, tried some exotic fruits (I’ll be honest I’m not sure of the relevance here), along with Apple and Honey (traditional I believe), and did some related crafts.
The teacher mentioned on Friday they are celebrating Diwali, themed lunch for all students and other in class activities in the afternoon. All great - right?

Well DH has decided he thinks it is insensitive, he feels like it is allowing the children to pick and chose which parts of a religion to engage with (the “fun” parts). He thinks celebrating Eid for example would be offensive as it comes at the end of fasting, he doesn’t see why anyone who hasn’t participated in fasting should be able to “just” join the fun celebration at the end. I pointed out it’s really no different to Easter for most and he claimed it’s different as there are secular aspects to Easter (quite frankly he’s very much partial to a lamb dinner and chocolate egg at Easter!!).
DH thinks it would be better if these religious holidays were taught but not necessarily celebrated in the school. He thinks this should include Easter, Eid, Rosh Hashanah, Diwali etc. (though he feels Chinese new year is fine as it’s more cultural than religious). He agrees with the school that Christmas is different.

AIBU to think DH is being silly and it’s totally fine (actually a positive) that the kids are getting to learn about and appreciate other religions, in a way that is engaging and in my opinion respectful (feel free to disagree). Or is he right, picking and choosing which parts of a religion to engage with is insensitive?

If you are religious (Muslim, Jewish, Hindu, Christian or any other) would the way the school seems to celebrate these holidays offend you? Would you rather they only taught and not celebrate? (I appreciate you can’t speak for your religion as a whole but curious none the less)

OP posts:
SingingSands · 08/11/2023 12:29

Your DH sounds like hard work. All this hand-wringing! Your child is going to be at school for many years to come. Save yourselves some emotional energy and instead appreciate that the school knows what they're doing and that your son is enjoying learning in a happy environment.

Mrsjayy · 08/11/2023 12:08

ClippitiClop · 08/11/2023 11:49

I think you’re missing what I was saying. The debate was in the context of our family and why we celebrate Christmas but not say Diwali. We boiled it down to in the UK (where we live) Christmas cultural, Diwali is religious. Like I said if we lived or were from elsewhere this could be different.
It wasn’t about which holidays have become cultural elsewhere, as it was specifically about a debate DH and I, about our own beliefs, why we have them etc.

So you think Christmas is a culturally a Christian festival Because England is a Christian country ? That looks like what he's saying. Non observant Jews might celebrate Hanukkah or Indians Diwuali because its culturally important to them but your husband doesn't think it Is important enough for the wider school to acknowledge and take part/ interest in because well that's for "them" not "us".

karmakameleon · 08/11/2023 11:55

ClippitiClop · 08/11/2023 11:49

I think you’re missing what I was saying. The debate was in the context of our family and why we celebrate Christmas but not say Diwali. We boiled it down to in the UK (where we live) Christmas cultural, Diwali is religious. Like I said if we lived or were from elsewhere this could be different.
It wasn’t about which holidays have become cultural elsewhere, as it was specifically about a debate DH and I, about our own beliefs, why we have them etc.

Does your DH have issues with the school celebrating Xmas? Because there are are lot of families of Indian descent in the UK who celebrate Diwali as a purely cultural festival and don’t place any religious significance on it. Why should these children not get to celebrate at school and culturally Christian children do? It does sound like he wants other religions to “get back in their box” as another poster put it.

ClippitiClop · 08/11/2023 11:49

karmakameleon · 08/11/2023 10:24

What do you think atheists in India do? I’m of Indian origin, my ancestors were Hindu but I don’t believe. We’ll still have a small Diwali celebration with my family. I just don’t do the religious bits.

I think you’re missing what I was saying. The debate was in the context of our family and why we celebrate Christmas but not say Diwali. We boiled it down to in the UK (where we live) Christmas cultural, Diwali is religious. Like I said if we lived or were from elsewhere this could be different.
It wasn’t about which holidays have become cultural elsewhere, as it was specifically about a debate DH and I, about our own beliefs, why we have them etc.

OP posts:
NeverNotDreaming · 08/11/2023 11:24

They’re four. They don’t fully understand the signifiante of anything, from birthdays to Christmas to Bonfire night. They just like the celebrations.
as they get older, they’ll understand and learn more about all of these religious festivals from a deeper POV and hopefully be more understanding of other faiths and cultures.

MsSquiz · 08/11/2023 11:17

I went to a non dom school in the north east and we also celebrated a lot of religious festivals (Christmas, Diwali, Hanukkah, Eid, etc) and we would have a party for each one while learning about what the festivals were for and what was being celebrated. I loved it! It's a great way to get primary children engaged with celebrations they wouldn't usually be part of, and learn at the same time

kaka79 · 08/11/2023 11:15

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

CaptainMyCaptain · 08/11/2023 11:11

Needmorelego · 08/11/2023 07:31

The school is using the word "celebrating" but it's just learning. It's their RE lesson - part of the national curriculum but taught in an accessible way for 4 year olds.
That's all.

This. You could hardly enforce the fasting for Ramadan but you can tell the children the celebration comes at the end of the fasting period. It will also be covered differently according yo the age of the children.

EverybodyJumpsuit · 08/11/2023 11:09

I’m gonna say it one more time- this isn’t just about your DH and your kid! There are other children in the school and it’s right that the school (and their peers) honour their festivals too. If the school has a diverse intake they aren’t ‘taking it upon themselves to organise’- they’re reflecting their community. This is what the inclusion part of the D&I is all about.
you’ve said this isn’t coming from intolerance but unless parents from those religions have complained and he’s allying with them, it sort of looks that way….

WimpiestMum · 08/11/2023 11:01

I love that schools do this. I'm an atheist of Indian origin and I strictly only do the fun parts of any celebration. I dont know about the other ones but I wouldn't say Diwali is particularly religious. Yes, it's based on mythology but to be honest I had no idea till my DD learnt about the mythology bit in school!! In the UK!!

Besides most religions are not just about faith. They are about community and culture and I'd say in their country of origin most of these festivals would be considered cultural as well as possibly religious.

I also think it's good for kids to learn that in fact you can pick and choose when it comes to religion. You don't have to slavishly follow every single doctrine but you should think about which ones make sense and help you and others and which ones are harmful. Any other way leads to fundamentalism.

SwingTheMonkey · 08/11/2023 10:56

Maddy70 · 08/11/2023 10:46

This

one Of the many reasons I left teaching in the uk. Teachers can't do anything right

Same here.

Complaining because 4 year olds aren’t taking religion seriously enough?! They’re 4!

Perhaps learning about Opus Dei should be included in the NC and the kids can self flagellate…

ElaineMBenes · 08/11/2023 10:53

Ahtishoo · 08/11/2023 09:25

I agree with your DH. I don’t think it’s offensive but I do think it’s intellectually and morally incoherent. My DC went to a church school which has given them a solid grounding in Christian religious philosophy, including critiquing it (we are not religious). They also learned about other important religions. I don’t think the problem is about ‘celebrating’ vs ‘learning’, it’s more the pick n mix. How will they grasp the central philosophies of any of these religions?

They're 4........

Maddy70 · 08/11/2023 10:46

SwingTheMonkey · 08/11/2023 07:33

I think this is a perfect example of teachers thinking they’re doing something lovely and engaging for the children, only to discover some miserable bastard disagrees. I’d be embarrassed if he was my husband.

This

one Of the many reasons I left teaching in the uk. Teachers can't do anything right

sashh · 08/11/2023 10:24

But they are not actually 'celebrating' are they? They are just teaching the children what happens at different festivals in the UK and hopefully why.

I've done similar with teenagers when I was teaching, "Equality and Diversity", brought in Indian sweets or red envelopes for Lunar New Year (I had a Vietnamese student who corrected me on that one).

If elsewhere this isn’t the case, I’m sorry, but could you give some examples, genuinely keen to learn!!

I'm in Wolverhampton. Vaisakhi consists of a Sikhs marching from one of the Gurdwaras to West Park, where you can buy Indian food, clothes, books and also ride dodgems at the fun fair that is set up.

There are Punjabi dances and singers and I'm far from being the only white person there.

It usually happens on the Sunday before Vaisakhi here and then most of the stall holders decamp to Southall for a repeat the next Sunday.

Put it in your diary for April next year.

There are lots of pagan festivals still celebrated by many people who are not pagan.

Lots of schools / colleges and some work places still serve fish on a Friday and I doubt most people even associate that with religion.

Actually fish and chips are interesting, it started as a Jewish food, has become a staple of British food and adopted by many RC families to eat on 'days of abstinence'.

My brother lives in a very undiverse area, I have sent his children money in red envelopes.

karmakameleon · 08/11/2023 10:24

ClippitiClop · 08/11/2023 09:35

I’ll stand corrected then, I can’t think of any personally (we live in a diverse area, I don’t know any other “cultural” celebrations which have evolved from a religious one (okay Easter, pancake day etc but these are still Christian).
Eid is celebrated by many of our neighbours but I don’t know any non-Muslims who would celebrate unless invited to do so.
Same for Diwali.
If elsewhere this isn’t the case, I’m sorry, but could you give some examples, genuinely keen to learn!!

What do you think atheists in India do? I’m of Indian origin, my ancestors were Hindu but I don’t believe. We’ll still have a small Diwali celebration with my family. I just don’t do the religious bits.

GonnaGetGoingReturns · 08/11/2023 10:10

Ahtishoo · 08/11/2023 09:25

I agree with your DH. I don’t think it’s offensive but I do think it’s intellectually and morally incoherent. My DC went to a church school which has given them a solid grounding in Christian religious philosophy, including critiquing it (we are not religious). They also learned about other important religions. I don’t think the problem is about ‘celebrating’ vs ‘learning’, it’s more the pick n mix. How will they grasp the central philosophies of any of these religions?

But at 4/5 with the fun bits, at least they’re getting into an introduction for it.

GonnaGetGoingReturns · 08/11/2023 10:03

It’s great for kids to know about other religions. I have no idea what I learned at 4, but our school was quite Christian (70s) and I think later we did learn more about other religions.

The only difference for me was secondary school at a private convent where it was Christianity and nothing else (despite the fact that pupils from other cultures and religions went there).

romdowa · 08/11/2023 09:52

As far as I'm aware there a certain people who aren't required to fast during eid, pregnant women , children and the sick. These people still take part in the celebrations when the fasting is finished . Your husband is being ridiculous

Needmorelego · 08/11/2023 09:50

@Ahtishoo they will do that when they are a bit older.
4 year olds have an attention span of about 10 minutes for learning. If food is involved it might get stretched to 15.

Needmorelego · 08/11/2023 09:48

@Moonmelodies that probably comes up in Key Stage 4 (the GCSE years).
My daughter is Year 11 and she was telling me the other day that she's "no longer Jewish but a Spaghetti believer" 😂
(We aren't Jewish)

Moonmelodies · 08/11/2023 09:35

It might be interesting to see how they commemorate Satanism, and the Church Of The Flying Spaghetti Monster (pbuh).

ClippitiClop · 08/11/2023 09:35

Busephalus · 08/11/2023 09:27

Op, there are plenty of areas in the UK where other religious celebrations have crossed over into cultural, its a bit narrow to say its just Christmas

I’ll stand corrected then, I can’t think of any personally (we live in a diverse area, I don’t know any other “cultural” celebrations which have evolved from a religious one (okay Easter, pancake day etc but these are still Christian).
Eid is celebrated by many of our neighbours but I don’t know any non-Muslims who would celebrate unless invited to do so.
Same for Diwali.
If elsewhere this isn’t the case, I’m sorry, but could you give some examples, genuinely keen to learn!!

OP posts:
Snugglemonkey · 08/11/2023 09:31

ClippitiClop · 08/11/2023 07:35

Interesting, where’s the line between “teaching” and “celebrating”.
Such as the school have decorated for Diwali as they would for Christmas, does this move into the celebrate category then or still teaching?

Still teaching. Our classroom is decorated with owl stuff because they read an owl book, learned about birds of prey, dissected owl droppings etc. They do a topic, they decorate.

RoseAndRose · 08/11/2023 09:31

Wait for a full calendar year to pass, and see which festivals are marked in school before assuming they are being unfair.

What other festivals between the start of the school year in September and the date of your visit have been unfairly omitted?

(Diwali is late this year, so might not have yet been mentioned, as it's not untilthis weekend)

Ahtishoo · 08/11/2023 09:30

I’d want to be sure that school were teaching religion in a depth, not just eating funny food, decorating the room and having a sing-song. It’s nice for cultural understanding but it’s a bit shallow. 4 year olds are actually natural philosophers ime. They love grappling with big questions.