Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

If you are autistic do people often not answer the question you are asking but give a more generalised answer?

389 replies

Hotandsunny · 07/11/2023 22:20

Just a thought that came to mind. I often find when I ask people questions about something very specific they don't seem to get it and just give you a general answer. I don't know what it is. But I have oftenish been in a situation where people just don't seem to understand what you are asking. So I was wondering if it was an autistic thing.

The example from today was I was doing a school appeal and the school had sent a list of rooms and room sizes as evidence that the school was full. I tried to question the school about what the different rooms were used for, about class sizes and what rooms the 6th form used. All the deputy head could do was repeat that Y7 was full.

I say you haven't answered my question and ask again and get the same reply. A member of the panel says to me I just don't like the reply I'm getting. I don't, because it doesn't answer my question.

This isn't an isolated incident by a long shot.

OP posts:
Autiebibliophile · 08/11/2023 03:27

I'm AA too. I think people who don't answer questions by giving another answer either don't know the answer and are trying to cover up or they don't want to answer as it confirms your point. I would have said something like " so based on your answer there is enough room" (or words to that affect) basically making up an answer in the same way they made up an answer.

Hotandsunny · 08/11/2023 03:24

DontLeanOnTheKeyboard · 08/11/2023 01:17

OP, kindly, it’s none of your business what they do with classrooms in the school. Oversubscribed isn’t just about Real estate, there’s many more complexities. Your question was not appropriate as it could come across as arrogant with you giving the impression you don’t think they’re doing things very well. From your perspective they’re not, but you aren’t, and don’t need to be privy to all the plans and arrangements for everything the school does.

Avoiding the question is a social habit for situations where the person can’t say ‘stop fucking asking, mind yer own’ or doesn’t want to come across as rude, so they just go vague news. I’m a bit obsessed with where people live, and really have to hold myself back from trying to nail them down to their Road etc. I’m fascinated with houses and people’s decor.

It’s just more of the unwritten rule thing. If the answer is vague it prob means that’s all you’re getting.

I'm sorry, but it's entirely relevant. What else aside from staffing is part 1 about? I've taken advise so knew what I needed to ask. Everyone else was asking on this theme too. Would you literally go into an appeal for your DC and not engage with the whole first part in case the school thinks I think they aren't doing very well. I mean I obviously think they are doing well otherwise why would I want my DD to go there! I'd love to know what your argument for the first part of the appeal would be? And why you'd go through an appeal process for a school you don't think is doing well??

The school actually must give information to a parent regarding the school beforehand. Not sure if that is the case during the appeal but if so 'mind yet own' isn't appropriate. There was some information I asked for that she didn't want me to know but the clerk said she had to tell me.

OP posts:
Princessconsuelabananahammock9 · 08/11/2023 03:17

All children have needs, but not all children have special needs.

Does your child have special needs?

My son has sn's and I require extra resources from the school to accommodate him.

If this school is already maxed out, it is reasonable to assume a child with additional needs will become lost in the shuffle as it is. Or take up too many unavailable resources.

YogaBearOnAChair · 08/11/2023 03:13

OP I would have interpreted your repeated question as pushy and rude, and overstepping. Did you expect the school to completely change the school timetable for all years to allow them to increase the size of Year 7 just for your child? Why would they want to do all that extra work when they are not obliged to? That would impact on everyone in the school. Then they have created a precedent they probably can’t repeat the next year, but people are going to say “but you did it for Hotandsunny’s child last year”

Hotandsunny · 08/11/2023 03:07

Disturbia81 · 08/11/2023 01:00

You say "meet her needs" so I assume she has additional needs. So it's not just adding 1 child to a class of 29.

All children have needs. This school is well set up to meet my DD's needs. This is a key point of an appeal you have to say how the school will meet your DC's needs, it doesn't mean they have additional needs.

OP posts:
Hotandsunny · 08/11/2023 03:04

EveSix · 08/11/2023 00:59

debrianna, see my post re the PAN. They could just be full. Galling, OP, when named school says no, for whatever reason. Ensuring a suitable education for one's SEN child shouldn't have to be a fight. I'm doing the same -it's exhausting.

It is isn't it? But if the appeals are upheld the school will go above their PAN.

OP posts:
Hotandsunny · 08/11/2023 03:03

debbrianna · 08/11/2023 00:56

What if the one space you calculated went to another child during the same appeal process?

I'm not sure what you mean by 'the one space I calculated' but I clearly have to argue for one extra space for my DD.

If both appeals (there were only 2) are upheld then both DC will get a space at the school.

OP posts:
decionsdecisions62 · 08/11/2023 03:01

Just because you ask a question in a very particular way does not automatically mean it has to be reciprocated. You are thinking in a very one dimensional way.

Everyone comes to the table with their own agendas. The schools agenda is to put up with you for a few hours so they look like they are following process so you then go away, whilst also not saying anything that could get into the local press and reflect poorly on the school.

Hotandsunny · 08/11/2023 02:57

Nepmarthiturn · 08/11/2023 00:45

The thing is, people don't have to communicate on your terms

I recommend autistic people repeat this back over and over again to NT people who moan about how we communicate.

Can't have it both ways... 😁

So true!

OP posts:
InWalksBarberalla · 08/11/2023 02:57

Given someone else tried to ask her a question 3 times and then gave up this feels like it was an issue with her rather than any NT/ND communication style.
Maybe she was under prepared because she was given short notice, or the time she has allocated to prepare was chewed up by an emergency, or she had a migraine and was pumped up on painkillers and her brain wasn't working as normal, or she just generally is a bit crap at her job. Who knows. Hopefully there is a way to appeal the appeal if she couldn't answer yours or others questions.

Hotandsunny · 08/11/2023 02:55

Ger1atricMillennial · 08/11/2023 00:45

Its a difficult situation OP, but in this instance, it seems like their current decision is final. As admirable as it is that you are pushing for a good education for your child, asking for more and more detailed answers thinking you are going to get a "gotcha" moment is not a good way to build a relationship with this school.

Is there a way that you could develop a better relationship so you will be first on their list when a space does become available?

You have to go through the appeal process. A decision hasn't been made as yet but I'm hopeful we will succeed. I wasn't looking for a 'gotcha' on the school but the nature of an appeal is that you are fighting against each other. And you have to carefully question your opponent to get relevant information. I had taken advice so knew what things I needed to find out through questioning and knew what points to argue.

In terms of being on a waiting list there is a strict admissions policy to follow, they don't let in students on the basis of if they like their mum. Which is a shame as one of my close friends works there! 😂

OP posts:
Ladyj84 · 08/11/2023 02:51

I think what your trying to say is autistic people tend to want a proper full on answer to a question that may sound meaningless to a normal person. We want the ins and outs of things sometimes when other people are happy with a basic answer

Hotandsunny · 08/11/2023 02:48

SageLavenderThyme · 08/11/2023 00:45

Another reason this could have happened was that the teacher didn't know all of the information, but just wanted to finish the meeting on one day, and didn't want to have continued back and forth about it?

I don't think that people are necessarily answering your direct questions in a general way because you are autistic. People do this a lot, I am not autistic and have noticed this frequently.

Some people also like to almost 'set the scene' or 'tell the story' to lead in to a point. Example would be pp with autistic husband above.

My preferred communication style would be to answer the question directly, then explain. But this is definitely one of many styles of answering I have noticed.

It's she maybe hadn't prepared properly and didn't want to find information. And I know it is what it is but I just think if you don't prepare then you might have to waste a bit of time (everyone's not just yours) finding information. Just maybe you should prepare properly before an appeal. But I know that's very rigid.

OP posts:
Hotandsunny · 08/11/2023 02:44

debbrianna · 08/11/2023 00:44

I think the op is looking for an answer that the thread is not answering/giving. Going around in circles does not change the outcome of what you are looking for. Plenty of examples have been given.

Recheck your post and see where you would have gotten a different answer. Sometimes being completely direct without explaining why before the question you asked (as explained in your op) might be why the school was able to cut you off.

The thing I wasn't the first to ask questions. Obviously everyone was asking questions along the same theme.

But I'll accept the answer from the NT - nobody should feel compelled to answer a question in any circumstances and no matter the situation. And that was why the teacher didn't answer the questions. And that's fine but perhaps that teacher could have got someone who was ok answering questions to do the appeal as it's a big part of it.

OP posts:
MoonriseKingdom · 08/11/2023 02:42

The problem with using 6th form numbers as a point of your appeal is that this is not a static figure. They are currently undersubscribed but they could be full come September or the year after. Admitting an extra child to Year 7 could give a big issue further down the line. Do they then have to refuse some children entry into sixth form because they can only be in the smaller classrooms?

Hotandsunny · 08/11/2023 02:36

IBlinkThereforeIAm · 08/11/2023 00:37

Lol. Then in future for Q&A sessions the audience should receive in advance a pre-approved list of questions that the presenters deem worthy of an answer.

Somewhat defeats to purpose of the meeting...

I know it is so illogical. It just doesn't make sense.

We now want you to ask the school questions. They won't however answer them! 😂

OP posts:
Hotandsunny · 08/11/2023 02:31

EveSix · 08/11/2023 00:34

With regard to the question you asked, OP (although I predictably find the general premise of your post more interesting), schools have a PAN, a published admissions number, for admissions to Reception, Y7 and Y12. Once they meet PAN, they're full, irrespective of how pupil numbers are arranged in individual classes within the year group. There are guidelines for maximum numbers of pupils in a class, but the bottom line is the PAN for the year group. I am willing to bet that this is what the person referred to when he said, without qualifying why, that Y7 was 'full'. A school proposes each academic year's PAN to the LA well in advance, and it is on this basis that places are offered each March.

Edited to insert a space.

Edited

Yes, thank you, I'm aware of all that. The point you go to appeal is when the PAN has been reached. That's why your DC hasn't got a place so that's a given. There was no need for the teacher to constantly repeat a given. Obviously, you have to argue that the school can admit one more pupil. You do this by looking at class sizes etc.

OP posts:
DontLeanOnTheKeyboard · 08/11/2023 02:28

OP, yes, it’s a tactic, a tactic to say ‘butt out, there’s more complexity to this than you know, and we are not obliged to go into every teeny detail of how our school works’.

There may be others with just as compelling reasons to appeal as yours. A standard answer shuts the door, and prevents unfairness. There ARE student/teacher ratios, legal ones. If there are any SEND issues that ratio is even more stretched. It’s not just about how big each room is, or if you feel they’re not using them effectively. Your autism is making you only accept the situation as you see it, and you would carry on nitpicking even if they gave you the detail. They have their structure and policies and they can’t breach them. It sucks, but you have to accept the outcome.

You aren’t getting where you are overstepping boundaries, and ironically you are undermining your chance of getting a place were one to come up.

Hotandsunny · 08/11/2023 02:25

Ger1atricMillennial · 08/11/2023 00:21

Pop yourself in the shoes of the school OP. You are essentially asking the school to provide you with a detailed plan of their day-to-day operations. That would be a huge undertaking for someone who may not have a good understanding of how a school operates so essentially not a good use of their (clearly limited) resources

The reason people don't answer questions is because;

  1. They have already given a satisfactory response i.e. the ration of children to classrooms
  2. They weren't listening to the question properly
  3. Answering the question will incur more questions.
  4. Private information of the people or business deals involved.
  5. The question you are asking is too specific to your circumstances rather than about the system
  6. It's a lot of work to answer the question and you are not a priority for them.
  7. The answer relies on having specialist knowledge.
Edited

Where have I said I want a detailed plan of their day to day operations? 😂

I mean I think some of the questions she didn't answer because she really wasn't listening and thought her set phrase was a satisfactory answer. But there were questions that she obviously didn't have the knowledge for and the clerk and 1 panel member had to step in. I think she should have prepared better as I don't think the clerk and panel member are meant to be helping.

OP posts:
mrsmingleton · 08/11/2023 02:22

You title is suggesting that because you are autistic people give you answers that are generalised? How would everyone know you are autistic?

Or are you asking other autistic people if they find answers that they get not suitable because they are autistic?

Myotherdogsanoodle · 08/11/2023 02:21

I think most PPs are failing to understand the point the Op is making. This isn’t about a conversation or casual questions, she’s talking about an appeal hearing. That’s why she wants her specific questions answered. I’m not autistic and I would too, why wouldn’t you? It seems to me, OP, that the school is trying to fudge the issue as they don’t have a particularly valid explanation. I would be annoyed to and (like Jeremy Paxman that time!) keep asking the questions!

Hotandsunny · 08/11/2023 02:17

feedyourheed · 08/11/2023 00:10

Interesting view - I am like your colleague. Don't really talk much about myself except to close friends. I have acquaintances that as soon as I stop to talk to them bombard me with all sorts of random bits of stuff from their everyday lives. I find it insane to be honest, and realise that's why I have never been able to do small talk. I just really, really don't want to assault someone else with the minutiae of my life and it wouldn't even occur to me to verbalise it.

I hope people don't find me untrustworthy because I really just can't, and don't want, to do it.

I also agree about NT people and subtext. They think everyone thinks like them, so they answer questions on that basis. Some of us have different brains and have queries that help US to understand something.

Edited

That is such a good point.

I think NT people think about what they would need to know to understand the situation. But yes, maybe ND people need something different. Maybe we need something more. God forbid we might want a nuanced or complex question answered. But we have different needs and that's ok.

OP posts:
Disturbia81 · 08/11/2023 02:15

EveSix · 07/11/2023 23:39

My, this thread is eye-opening.

DP (ND) can be like this at times of heightened anxiety; asking very specific questions and expecting answers which fall precisely within his expected parameters. He gets bothered if, within the first couple of syllables of responding, it looks like an answer might be other than expected.

Example:

DP: "Are we going out straight after Dan comes home from football?"

Expected answer: yes or no.

Usual context: Dan always comes home from football at 18:30.

New, unknown to DP, development: Dan's lift has bailed so he'll be walking home, ETA 19:00.

Reasonable reply by me: "Dan just messaged me. His lift has bailed so he'll be walking home, ETA 19:00. We'll leave straight after that."

DP: (usually by the time I've hit the 3rd unexpected word) "Oh my days, just 'yes' or 'no', that's aaaaaall I ask! exasperated sigh", failing to take in the change of circumstance.

Lots of situations like these:
"Are we taking the A59 or shall we go up Houghton Way?"
(I've checked traffic updates and seen delays which promt considering a 3rd route, so I venture:)
"I've just checked the AA traffic updates, and as there are severe delays on both those routes, I'd suggest -"
"Jeesus, what is wrong with just answering the question the way I've asked it!? A59 or Houghton Way!?", again missing relevant information.

It is a deep reluctance to acknowledge that communication is a two-way process where both parties, unless one is under interrogation in a witness box, are able to respond with a reasonable degree of autonomy. I get furious with him -I don't owe him comms compliance-, but remind myself that he processes language so differently to anyone I know (paradoxically, he's an inspired lyricist and poet).

This is exhausting. How on earth do you live with this negativity and backchat! Life is too short

WednesdaysChild50 · 08/11/2023 02:12

I’m ND and I’m very anal, I like clear facts, firm answers. Everything has to be clear cut.

Hotandsunny · 08/11/2023 02:12

AGoodDayForSomebodyElseToDie · 08/11/2023 00:07

If the school felt the OP’s question was irrelevant, they would have been better to say so rather than answer a question of their own invention. An explanation of why the information was irrelevant (if it was) would have resolved the issue quickly and clearly instead of frustrating the OP and making it appear as if they don’t want to engage openly with the appeals process.

This sort of thing drives me mad too, OP. It’s poor communication and a waste of everyone’s time. Just answer the question, or explain why you don’t think it’s relevant.

Thank you! I agree with that so much. It makes things much quicker to either answer the question or explain why you can't won't. But honestly keeping on repeating the same very basic information is not just frustrating but feels condescending too.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread