Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

If you are autistic do people often not answer the question you are asking but give a more generalised answer?

389 replies

Hotandsunny · 07/11/2023 22:20

Just a thought that came to mind. I often find when I ask people questions about something very specific they don't seem to get it and just give you a general answer. I don't know what it is. But I have oftenish been in a situation where people just don't seem to understand what you are asking. So I was wondering if it was an autistic thing.

The example from today was I was doing a school appeal and the school had sent a list of rooms and room sizes as evidence that the school was full. I tried to question the school about what the different rooms were used for, about class sizes and what rooms the 6th form used. All the deputy head could do was repeat that Y7 was full.

I say you haven't answered my question and ask again and get the same reply. A member of the panel says to me I just don't like the reply I'm getting. I don't, because it doesn't answer my question.

This isn't an isolated incident by a long shot.

OP posts:
MakeItRain · 08/11/2023 06:42

What happened in your appeal? In my opinion, because of the way the school uses the rooms, I think it's entirely relevant to ask about the smaller number of children in the sixth form, freeing up rooms. A school lost several appeals near me some years ago, because it turned out there was theoretically "room" in a part of it that hadn't been accounted for. So personally I think your questions should go in your favour. The school can fudge it's reply, but the decision isn't made by them. (Ps I've never had a diagnosis but always suspected I'm autistic!)
I do understand why people give "vague" answers though. The teacher was trying to shut you down because she didn't like your question.

Namesbeenchanged · 08/11/2023 06:18

MadeOfAllWork · 07/11/2023 22:37

I understand what you are asking, but when you want to get a child into year 7 it doesn’t matter how big the 6th form room is. People don’t answer questions that are irrelevant.

It’s like if you asked me if you could have a lift somewhere and said that you couldn’t because the car was full, and then you asked what colour my car is. It doesn’t matter to the problem in hand so why would I answer.

This.

There are limited school places and a maximum number for each school in each year group.

You asking what particular rooms are for is completely irrelevant. They might have 2 spare rooms used for drama and art, so what, if the maximum number of pupils for a particular year group is reached then they cannot accept your child. They are busy and you are asking irrelevant questions!

SkinnyMalinkyLankyLegs · 08/11/2023 05:55

Hotandsunny · 08/11/2023 04:35

Do you understand what happens at a school appeal hearing.

Hint: you are expected to ask questions...

I understand perfectly well what happens at a school appeal hearing. There is no need for your sarcastic "hint", you're really just coming across as rude, which seems to be your general communication style which is probably why people don't get into things with you.

Hint - there is a difference between asking questions and bulldozing people into giving you exactly what you want, which is what your line of questioning to the school no doubt came across as.

There isn't really much point in trying to explain that further to you though as you seem unable to understand that and just want to argue against anything anyone says if you don't like it/don't agree with it.

Best of luck with your appeal.

TabithatheTabbycat · 08/11/2023 05:51

We won an appeal after our eldest DS was refused a place at our catchment school - the school was oversubscribed and we'd submitted the application a day late. We lived about 70m away from the school, and the alternative school suggested by the local authority was about 7km away.

At appeal, the school was adamant there was absolutely no space and the man from the local authority who represented the school at the appeal was quite vile to us - really nasty. I found it really upsetting.

However DH and I both had an opportunity to speak and to ask questions. My question was: how many children are there in these oversubscribed classes from outside of catchment? They refused to answer. It seemed really unfair to me that numerous children were being driven across town to go to this school, and then children living practically on its doorstep were being refused places on the basis of 'oversubscription'.

Anyway, the panel saw sense and ruled in our favour. I see nothing wrong with asking questions if it makes logical sense to ask them. After all, sometimes the explanations those in authority give us really make no sense.

Neurodiversitydoctor · 08/11/2023 05:35

Hotandsunny · 08/11/2023 00:37

The sixth form has smaller class sizes. What rooms they use are relevant as if they use for example the 4 smaller rooms, that frees up the larger rooms for Y7 etc. It is also relevant in terms of the school being under capacity by 100 in 6th form. Would these extra 100 be using the same corridors and communal spaces as Y7? If so an argument can be made that these areas can't be crowded if they have 100 less people using them than when the school is at capacity.

Sixth forms use the school quite differently often have separate common areas, won't have a fixed lunchtime and are allowed to leave the school in frees study periods.

Having space in the sixth form doesn't make room for another Yr7.

EliflurtleAndTheInfiniteMadness · 08/11/2023 04:59

Hotandsunny · 08/11/2023 04:50

Oh 😞 That does make me sad that they couldn't care less about a little girl's life. I'm just glad I'm not like that...even if I do ask all the annoying.questions! 😂

I think more hadn't given it a moments thought or rationnalised she'll be fine elsewhere or are thinking of current students, there's many possible reasons. Sometimes it can help to explain the reason behind the question if it feels unconnected, like I'm asking this to find out how you coped with a bigger cohort. Sometimes they've already sorted an answer in their mind and haven't really heard all of the question so it can be good to rephrase and try asking again. If it's something your little girl really needs it's worth fighting for and asking all the "annoying" questions you need to.

ElevenSeven · 08/11/2023 04:51

Hotandsunny · 08/11/2023 04:33

No

OP, on your other threads, you’ve mentioned many times that your DD is on the pathway for an autism diagnosis.

Hotandsunny · 08/11/2023 04:50

EliflurtleAndTheInfiniteMadness · 08/11/2023 04:38

Sometimes people are just going through the motions because that is the official process they have to follow. So the why in terms of school meetings and a school appeal can be just that it's expected as part of their job or part of a process they have to follow in their job. If a person has to be there because that is required of them, but they dont want to give answers or feel your questions are pointless they may well fob you off and do whatever necessary to shut the process down. There are official reasons for things and you are taking those reasons at face value and thinking the other person is there for the right reasons.

You're thinking this meeting is here for us to work out if this is possible and to get questions answered, the other person/people might be there for the same reason or it might be a requirement of their job or of mandated or legislative process they have to follow, Reality is the other party might have zero intent in engaging. Some of those answers you were getting could be shutting the conversation down because they feel it's pointless. It also could be because they don't want to give you anything you need to succeed in your case or they just couldn't care less.

Oh 😞 That does make me sad that they couldn't care less about a little girl's life. I'm just glad I'm not like that...even if I do ask all the annoying.questions! 😂

OP posts:
EliflurtleAndTheInfiniteMadness · 08/11/2023 04:47

Interestingly the people that keep telling you the school is full are expecting you to take the school at face value and accept they will always tell the truth and always be 100% correct. Parents win some appeals, so there must sometimes be factors that schools haven't considered specific to those individual situations or sometimes incorrect decisions. If the schools were always right there'd be no point in having this process. Maybe they're right in this case, but as a parent or 3 children with SEN you can't assume school will do the right thing by your children and you often have to advocate and fight for the things they are supposed to be enrolled to.

EliflurtleAndTheInfiniteMadness · 08/11/2023 04:38

Hotandsunny · 07/11/2023 23:02

But I'm talking about situations like today. Where there is an expectation that an answer is given. Or like at formal meeting at my son's college. The point being to get my queries answered. Why do people put themselves in these situations if they don't want to answer questions?

Sometimes people are just going through the motions because that is the official process they have to follow. So the why in terms of school meetings and a school appeal can be just that it's expected as part of their job or part of a process they have to follow in their job. If a person has to be there because that is required of them, but they dont want to give answers or feel your questions are pointless they may well fob you off and do whatever necessary to shut the process down. There are official reasons for things and you are taking those reasons at face value and thinking the other person is there for the right reasons.

You're thinking this meeting is here for us to work out if this is possible and to get questions answered, the other person/people might be there for the same reason or it might be a requirement of their job or of mandated or legislative process they have to follow, Reality is the other party might have zero intent in engaging. Some of those answers you were getting could be shutting the conversation down because they feel it's pointless. It also could be because they don't want to give you anything you need to succeed in your case or they just couldn't care less.

Hotandsunny · 08/11/2023 04:35

SkinnyMalinkyLankyLegs · 08/11/2023 03:36

The school told you they were full, so why did you continue to push for information?

I have a friend who does this - she's told no, but she asks for more and more information to try and find a 'solution' to get her own way.

Do you understand what happens at a school appeal hearing.

Hint: you are expected to ask questions...

OP posts:
Hotandsunny · 08/11/2023 04:33

Princessconsuelabananahammock9 · 08/11/2023 03:17

All children have needs, but not all children have special needs.

Does your child have special needs?

My son has sn's and I require extra resources from the school to accommodate him.

If this school is already maxed out, it is reasonable to assume a child with additional needs will become lost in the shuffle as it is. Or take up too many unavailable resources.

No

OP posts:
Hotandsunny · 08/11/2023 04:31

YogaBearOnAChair · 08/11/2023 03:13

OP I would have interpreted your repeated question as pushy and rude, and overstepping. Did you expect the school to completely change the school timetable for all years to allow them to increase the size of Year 7 just for your child? Why would they want to do all that extra work when they are not obliged to? That would impact on everyone in the school. Then they have created a precedent they probably can’t repeat the next year, but people are going to say “but you did it for Hotandsunny’s child last year”

Yet I think those of us having to question multiple times found the lack of an answer rude. And oh yes of course I expect them to do that!

You seem very angry that I'm going through a legitimate process and DD will hopefully get a place at the school that meets her needs. And others can also go for an appeal and if upheld will get a place. That precedent has always been there.

OP posts:
Hotandsunny · 08/11/2023 04:26

decionsdecisions62 · 08/11/2023 03:01

Just because you ask a question in a very particular way does not automatically mean it has to be reciprocated. You are thinking in a very one dimensional way.

Everyone comes to the table with their own agendas. The schools agenda is to put up with you for a few hours so they look like they are following process so you then go away, whilst also not saying anything that could get into the local press and reflect poorly on the school.

Not sure the school succeeded but I do find it a shame they would be so disingenuous when this is a little girl's life.

OP posts:
Hotandsunny · 08/11/2023 04:19

MoonriseKingdom · 08/11/2023 02:42

The problem with using 6th form numbers as a point of your appeal is that this is not a static figure. They are currently undersubscribed but they could be full come September or the year after. Admitting an extra child to Year 7 could give a big issue further down the line. Do they then have to refuse some children entry into sixth form because they can only be in the smaller classrooms?

Yes but so much is static. How many teachers you have, how many pupils. You u can obviously only argue based on how things are now and the very short term future. But from what the teacher told us they've got lots of space available in the small classrooms. The clerk then stepped in because he obviously didn't think she was doing a good enough job at fighting her case. Then she tried to do a u turn and just kept contradicting herself.

OP posts:
Hotandsunny · 08/11/2023 04:12

DontLeanOnTheKeyboard · 08/11/2023 02:28

OP, yes, it’s a tactic, a tactic to say ‘butt out, there’s more complexity to this than you know, and we are not obliged to go into every teeny detail of how our school works’.

There may be others with just as compelling reasons to appeal as yours. A standard answer shuts the door, and prevents unfairness. There ARE student/teacher ratios, legal ones. If there are any SEND issues that ratio is even more stretched. It’s not just about how big each room is, or if you feel they’re not using them effectively. Your autism is making you only accept the situation as you see it, and you would carry on nitpicking even if they gave you the detail. They have their structure and policies and they can’t breach them. It sucks, but you have to accept the outcome.

You aren’t getting where you are overstepping boundaries, and ironically you are undermining your chance of getting a place were one to come up.

How do you know it's more complexity than I know?

Is the butt out also thrown at the panel asking the same/similar questions and the other non-autistic parent's?

How do you know I made a sole argument on room size? What makes you think I argued no other points?

You've invented a story.

Why do you think appeals exist if they 'can't breach them'? What outcome have I not accepted? How am I seeing the situation wrongly due to my autism?

I've not overstepped any boundaries and I thought you would know, as you know about all your procedures school places are not based on how much we like mum!!

OP posts:
Hotandsunny · 08/11/2023 03:59

mrsmingleton · 08/11/2023 02:22

You title is suggesting that because you are autistic people give you answers that are generalised? How would everyone know you are autistic?

Or are you asking other autistic people if they find answers that they get not suitable because they are autistic?

I'm asking autistic people if they find when they ask a specific question they just get a general answer. And many on this thread said they have had this experience too.

OP posts:
Hotandsunny · 08/11/2023 03:55

Myotherdogsanoodle · 08/11/2023 02:21

I think most PPs are failing to understand the point the Op is making. This isn’t about a conversation or casual questions, she’s talking about an appeal hearing. That’s why she wants her specific questions answered. I’m not autistic and I would too, why wouldn’t you? It seems to me, OP, that the school is trying to fudge the issue as they don’t have a particularly valid explanation. I would be annoyed to and (like Jeremy Paxman that time!) keep asking the questions!

Thank you. Yes, the teacher was trying to fudge some of the issues which was why I had to ask some specific questions. Thanks for explaining that perhaps others will understand now.

OP posts:
Hotandsunny · 08/11/2023 03:47

Schlurp · 08/11/2023 01:45

At risk of annoying you, are you actually wanting to chat about the general point re communication styles, or address the specific problem of getting an answer re the rooms?

We had quite a bruising experience with the LA going through the EHCP process. Nothing to do with autism at all, they just completely stonewall all emails from parents. The answer wasn't adapting our communication style, it was forcing their hand by sending IPSEA letters reminding them of legal obligations, submitting multiple formal complaints and a Subject Access Request. Although not identical, you do have a kind of similar adversarial situation going on. I wonder if the problem is more about that than the fact that it's an autistic person making a request of an NT person. It's definitely the case that shorter emails and quick tasks are more likely to get a response, especially from SLT who will probably have a lot of emails incoming every day. But sometimes it's more structural.

But perhaps that is me being annoyingly NT and answering a different question from the one you asked!

I would say it's worth spelling out to him why you feel he is obliged to answer your question, preferably quoting from an appeals code or somesuch, and phrase it so it is as easy to digest and as simple to execute as you can.

This doesn't annoy me. I wanted to chat about the general point but it's been taken over with me being quizzed about the appeal. So I'm happy to talk about both.

But thanks for your experience. It sounds very intense.

OP posts:
SkinnyMalinkyLankyLegs · 08/11/2023 03:43

daylightplease · 08/11/2023 03:39

To be fair to OP the whole point of an appeal is that you continue to push after the school has said "No, we are full".
It is why the appeal system was created. Any individual applicant may be turned down but they are supposed to be asking for special consideration.

Yes but there is a difference between pushing for something and bulldozing people; the latter sounds like what the OP was trying to do, even though I appreciate that she may not understand that that's how her behaviour was coming across.

Hotandsunny · 08/11/2023 03:40

daylightplease · 08/11/2023 01:41

There wasn't really that dynamic as the teacher seemed out of her depth and the panel and clerk were having to help her. They're meant to be impartial.

I would argue that the teacher may well have been personally out of depth but she had more power in the meeting due to her status.

The fact the other impartial people helped her would support that for me.

Yes, that makes sense.

OP posts:
daylightplease · 08/11/2023 03:39

To be fair to OP the whole point of an appeal is that you continue to push after the school has said "No, we are full".
It is why the appeal system was created. Any individual applicant may be turned down but they are supposed to be asking for special consideration.

Hotandsunny · 08/11/2023 03:38

MrsTerryPratchett · 08/11/2023 01:32

I suspect this is part of it.

OP I often have clients asking me pages of questions about process at work. Many of them are ND and/or trauma impacted. I have about 4000 clients. I simply don't have time to respond to every single query (many of which are irrelevant and/or appear to be designed to try to get me to vary the procedures). People feel that I am not answering. For example, someone asks about a process. I say, "sorry you aren't eligible for that process". I'm right. I then get queries about the policy. I send the policy. They query a completely irrelevant piece and say, "you didn't do this". Well, no I didn't but it wouldn't make any difference to eligibility. They want a meeting to discuss it. Taking more time. I give a list of reasons it won't make a difference. They nitpick one of the reasons, they aren't interested in the other 19 which preclude them. They want this in writing, double spaced, in 18 font, notarised. I supply it, taking hours of my time. They then escalate to my boss, the Board, the MP, taking more time. Pointing out the irrelevancies.

At the very beginning of the process, I'd actually like to say, "I'm right, you aren't eligible, I'm the expert and all of this effort is for nothing" but I can't because of customer service standards.

I suspect the school feels they can't meet your child's needs, they don't have capacity and they have many reasons. Room size was floated because it's the least contentious. You think it's the one to deal with. It's not.

I don't know how much experience you have with school appeals but you're barking up the wrong tree. The school follows an admission process, children with additional needs are not precluded from this. The school was full before they got to where DD was in the admission criteria.

It turns out my DD was actually put in the wrong place so should have been offered a place.

The school has to put the case forward that they are full. So obviously classrooms, class size, staff is talked about. This is completely standard and happens as a group with other parents who are appealing.

OP posts:
SkinnyMalinkyLankyLegs · 08/11/2023 03:36

The school told you they were full, so why did you continue to push for information?

I have a friend who does this - she's told no, but she asks for more and more information to try and find a 'solution' to get her own way.

Hotandsunny · 08/11/2023 03:28

halesie · 08/11/2023 01:31

Damian Milton's double empathy problem is well worth looking up, both for autistic and non-autistic people. It may be especially useful for those of you who have autistic relatives and are finding it a struggle to communicate effectively with each other.

OP, good luck with the appeal. We're trying to get a place at a specialist school for one of our DC atm and are expecting the response to be that the suitable schools are "full", even though that isn't a valid reason to turn a child with an EHCP away. So I suspect I may be asking similar questions soon Grin

Thank you and good luck to you!

The default point is they are full and if everyone just accepted that there would be no appeals.

I'm sure some posters think I should have meekly gone to the appeal. Listened to the school's case that they are full and then just said 'ok, thank you' and left 😂

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread