Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

If you are autistic do people often not answer the question you are asking but give a more generalised answer?

389 replies

Hotandsunny · 07/11/2023 22:20

Just a thought that came to mind. I often find when I ask people questions about something very specific they don't seem to get it and just give you a general answer. I don't know what it is. But I have oftenish been in a situation where people just don't seem to understand what you are asking. So I was wondering if it was an autistic thing.

The example from today was I was doing a school appeal and the school had sent a list of rooms and room sizes as evidence that the school was full. I tried to question the school about what the different rooms were used for, about class sizes and what rooms the 6th form used. All the deputy head could do was repeat that Y7 was full.

I say you haven't answered my question and ask again and get the same reply. A member of the panel says to me I just don't like the reply I'm getting. I don't, because it doesn't answer my question.

This isn't an isolated incident by a long shot.

OP posts:
InattentiveADHD · 08/11/2023 17:21

TheYearOfSmallThings · 07/11/2023 23:02

Yes, I ask a very precise question because I want a precise answer.

The thing is, people don't have to communicate on your terms. You could ask a thousand questions about room size, and they could waste a lot of time answering questions that will have no bearing on the outcome, or they can fob you off rather than get into that cycle.

But fobbing off doesn't work as we just keep asking! With both parties getting more frustrated and annoyed. Why don't they just say "I don't want to answer your question" or "I can't answer your question" or "I don't think your question is relevant". So much clearer and easier to understand. Why all the fannying about with vaguely answering a different question to the one asked. And people wonder why ND people struggle with communication! Supposedly autistic people are the ones bad at communication!?!. I would argue is the NTs with all this vague bollocks that need to up their game!!

Hotandsunny · 08/11/2023 17:19

DarkWingDuck · 08/11/2023 13:15

Neurotypical people do tend to talk their decision making out loud and also jump into talking about a topic without recognising the question being asked. I’m ND and I find it quite confusing and frustrating. My NT husband finds me pedantic and rude at times when I insist on a simple and concise answer to what I think is a simple and clear question.

Yes, I think it is frustrating on both sides!

OP posts:
Hotandsunny · 08/11/2023 17:18

Tobacco · 08/11/2023 12:57

Im sure you wouldn't want to send your child to a school where the teachers were prone to lying, so in that case why not believe the teacher who is telling you the school is full? It sounds a ball ache to have to give details to prove the school is full rather than you just accepting they are not lying. Maybe the teacher wants to spend their time on the kids in the school rather than time wasting stuff to prove to people outside the school that they aren't liars.

Where have I said the teachers were lying?

And again I don't make the rules for an appeal, do I? They have to prove they are full, it may be a ball ache but that's what an appeal is. And why would I put an appeal forward and then not engage in it? Surely, that's more a waste of time. So we go to appeal and the school argues they are full and then the panel asks them lots of questions and asks them to prove they are full, then they ask me to question the school and I just say no, it's ok, I don't actually want to do an appeal. Huge waste of time for everyone.

I'm not sure everyone realises it is a given that the school believe they are full otherwise my DC would have been admitted. It's not a suprise at the appeal that they tell you they are full and you say oh I didn't realise in that case that's fine, don't admit my DC!

Maybe they don't want to do appeals in which case they should take it up with the LA rather than a parent going through due process!

OP posts:
InattentiveADHD · 08/11/2023 17:16

mimblewimble · 07/11/2023 22:54

Hi OP, I have an autistic child and this sounds quite familiar to me but from the other side. He often gets frustrated with me because I have not answered his questions.

From my perspective, he asks a lot of questions about very specific details, which I don't always have the energy or headspace to answer and which to me seem irrelevant to the situation.

When he pushes it, it feels as if he is trying to corner me or get me to slip up on some detail so he can prove a point. However, he maintains that he just likes to/needs to know information so that he understands.

I wouldn't assume that the details he needs are irrelevant. I need a lot of detail to understand things. My DH doesn't. I see this play out at work also, most people seem happy with a vague sense of something (in my mind!) but I need ALL the detail to understand something, to establish whether I agree with something, to work out how it fits into everything else, to remember it. Some of that detail hey be irrelevant to you but it's not to me. Without the detail it's incredibly confusing and sometimes stressful as i don't understand it and won't be able to commit to memory (if that's needed). A good analogy is maths: if one bit of the detail is missing you won't understand any of it and are likely to be lost going forward with future maths topics as the foundation isn't there. That's how my brain works, and it sounds the same for your DS.

Hotandsunny · 08/11/2023 17:10

Highlandsprocker · 08/11/2023 12:50

He just assumed that if he knew something, everyone else must know it too - eg he would regularly make allusions to his favourite TV show and then be miffed when none of us got the reference, despite the fact that we had told him many times that we didn't watch it and therefore didn't know what he was talking about
This is called Poor Theory of Mind.

This is how the Op is coming across, fixating on the set up of the school and repeating this despite being told year 7 is full.
The appeal is not to argue whether the school is full or not ,it's to put forward the case of why this school is the only one that meets the DCs needs.

I'm confused though.
If the Ops DC has no specific SEN that mean they were on the general admissions list, why does Op think they were put in this group incorrectly?

The first part of the appeal is to argue against the school being full.
The second part is about how your DC. I don't make the rules that's the way it is.

There was a question about if she'd been put in the correct group for admission. As in for example DC with a sibling at the school are in a different group to those without.

OP posts:
InattentiveADHD · 08/11/2023 17:06

I am not autistic but have ADHD and agree with you. I think in the circumstance you describe they are being deliberately vague but a lot of times NTs do not seem to answer a question as asked. I am so careful to read a question and answer exactly what I believe is being asked. If I don't want answer I'll say that rather than give some vague answer. Just say what you bloody mean!! I would have been like you, saying back to them that they haven't answered my question whereas if they say they don't want answer then I'm clear there that info is being refused.

I also have a problem with NT questions which similarly are often vague or the options you have to answer don't fit the question or there is no answer that even closely fits how I would answer. Drives me insane.

I think NTs are better at reading between the lines and are happy to go with "well they sort of mean this, so I'll answer x" (gaging questioned by DH about it). I find it bizarre that most people are wandering round with just a vague sense of what's going on and are perfectly happy like that!. I need specifics and details!

SkinnyMalinkyLankyLegs · 08/11/2023 16:18

Hotandsunny · 08/11/2023 14:11

But you were shocked that I asked questions after the school said it was full. But that's what an appeal is. How was I 'bulldozing' by asking pertinent questions? Do you think the panel were also 'bulldozing' by asking similar questions?

"But" what? No, I wasn't "shocked".

As I say, you're not taking anything that people are saying on board, so what's the point in wasting time discussing this with you any further....

toddlepod · 08/11/2023 16:04

Absolutely get this! My H does this when he thinks he knows where I’m going with a question and thinks he’s short circuiting by his reading -between- the -lines interpretation. Trouble is, he gets it wrong too often and fries my head with the illogicality of his response.

I hear judge Judy snapping at plaintiffs and defendants to answer her question and either stop editorialising or anticipating a line of questioning… or stop trying to re-direct to a narrative they prefer to present. I can only marvel that her head doesn’t explode.

enchantedsquirrelwood · 08/11/2023 15:43

I am in a running club and an autistic lady joined recently and I try to make sure that I give her very clear answers when she asks about things. I am sure that she still thinks I am very vague at times, or still go around the houses, but I do try!

enchantedsquirrelwood · 08/11/2023 15:41

Bruisername · 07/11/2023 22:39

No - it’s a way of saying your question is irrelevant and doesn’t need to be answered

In their opinion. They know what you are trying to get at - are there other areas of the school that could be utilised for Y7s and they don't want to answer in case it weakens their position, even if it doesn't. Or it will take too much effort to provide the information.

In terms of the wider point, I wonder if autistic people in the UK have a harder time of it due to the British habit of talking round the houses about everything. The example of "what time are we going out" and "DH comes home at 6" is a case in point - you are then meant to imply that we'll be going out just after 6 but is that actually the case - does he want a shower, does he need to get changed, does he fancy a glass of wine with you before you all go out etc.

Hotandsunny · 08/11/2023 15:38

ManateeFair · 08/11/2023 12:33

I'm wondering whether perhaps your questions might seem clearer and more relevant to you than they do to other people? Maybe you're making assumptions that people understand your thought processes, when they're actually not obvious to others?

I used to work with a colleague who was autistic and would regularly complain that people weren't answering his questions.

However, his questions were often actually irrelevant to the discussion. For example, if we explained that we couldn't do something for him because our team was too busy, he would then ask questions about how busy a completely different team was. To which our answer was either 'No idea, and it doesn't matter anyway because the point here is that WE are too busy and we're the team that would deal with your request' or 'I think most teams are pretty busy at the moment, aren't they?'

This is very similar to you asking a question about sixth form capacity and what different rooms are used for. Your child is applying for a place in Y7. It doesn't actually matter what rooms the sixth forms use, because your child isn't entering sixth form. And they can't kick out any existing pupils in other years to make room for your child. They might have 10 places available in (for example) Y9, but that doesn't matter because your child is not entering Y9 and they can't move places from one year to another; that's not how it works. So I think they didn't answer your question about sixth form room use because it was tangential to the discussion at hand and gathering that information for you would make absolutely no difference to your case, and would be a waste of their time and yours.

My former colleague would also sometimes ask questions or make points in a way that no doubt seemed very clear to him, but weren't always very clear to other people. He basically struggled to grasp that just because he had certain information available to him, that didn't mean everyone else had that same information as well. He just assumed that if he knew something, everyone else must know it too - eg he would regularly make allusions to his favourite TV show and then be miffed when none of us got the reference, despite the fact that we had told him many times that we didn't watch it and therefore didn't know what he was talking about. That tendency meant that questions that were clear in his eyes were not actually clear to others, and therefore the answers he got weren't the information he was looking for.

Yes, that's possible. I did try to explain. And the panel members were asking on similar themes. And I suppose to me what she was saying seemed irrelevant!

It wasn't just me asking about 6th form and it was a question I was advised to ask regarding communal areas. It was also not just me struggling to get answers but I'm sure these things played into it being harder for me to communicate. I did ask for reasonable adjustments but wasn't given them.

OP posts:
Londonscallingme · 08/11/2023 15:32

Hotandsunny · 07/11/2023 23:48

So what's the point of the appeal if the school refuse to engage in it?

My guess is that they have to offer an appeals process but they not willing to engage with you on this line of questioning. There is an obvious path your question takes them down and they would rather shut it down immediately. I’m not saying they are right to do that but the premise that they will answer all questions fully just because they are compelled to offer an appeals process is probably not valid.

RelationshipOrNot · 08/11/2023 15:30

Hotandsunny · 08/11/2023 15:21

They're not really doing their job then because they are meant to argue how the school can't take another pupil.

Yes, I'm not saying they're doing a good job, that might just be how they perceive it - that they can just show evidence for being full and assume that it will be accepted without engaging in discussion.

Well done on winning!

cardibach · 08/11/2023 15:25

Amazingly quick decision…

Hotandsunny · 08/11/2023 15:23

DontLeanOnTheKeyboard · 08/11/2023 12:11

Ironically the OP is a bit vague about this part, @cardibach. Perhaps there aren’t any that would warrant preferential treatment and so the fixation on class sizes.

Clearly not as we won. But the thing is that isn't what this thread is about.

OP posts:
Hotandsunny · 08/11/2023 15:21

RelationshipOrNot · 08/11/2023 10:40

Perhaps they have to? Maybe they see it as a formality and don't go into it with a view to actually engaging.

They're not really doing their job then because they are meant to argue how the school can't take another pupil.

OP posts:
Hotandsunny · 08/11/2023 15:20

cardibach · 08/11/2023 11:39

I’m a teacher with 35years experience, much of it in a position where I decided on group size/composition. I’m pretty sure I know exactly what there is to it and you are missing key points about how student ability/emotional state/ALN affect size of class. Maybe the rooms have 32 seats and every class of 30 has 2 adults working with ALN students. Maybe the class of 29 has more ALN students so needs more adult seats. Maybe when they are put into sets the children with ALN are distributed differently.
Your assumption you know more than everyone else (shown in ‘there’s much more to it than you think’ here) is rather arrogant. It also shows up what you don’t actually know.

And the school have a right to put that argument across. When I said there is more to it than you think, I meant the appeal. People keep wondering why I'm asking questions of the school or not talking about my DC. Because that is what you have to do! That is the process which I'm sure you know. And noone knows my background or my experience in schools either so rather arrogant to assume. Anyway we won so my arguments obviously were pertinent!

OP posts:
Triplixate · 08/11/2023 14:54

Yep all the time. I get a lot of quite patronising answers that assume I don’t understand something simple. So for example, a friend of a colleague came into our shop years ago and they were excitedly talking about how said friend was a medium and colleague said “I keep finding white feathers”. I said “oh what do white feathers mean?” And they gave each other a look like “oh she’s so simple” and went on to explain what a medium was. I was like “yes I understand that but what do white feathers mean?” So then I got an explanation of something else… anyway eventually after a third attempt I learnt that some people visiting spirits leave white feathers (or something similar.. was a long time ago). It’s like people assume I’m
too thick to possibly be asking what I am asking so they go back a step (or several) and give me some random background information.

Hotandsunny · 08/11/2023 14:53

DontLeanOnTheKeyboard · 08/11/2023 09:38

If the OP communicates in the same way as she does for people not agreeing with her here, or suggesting the reasons why her questions were met the vague way they were….

If you asked it several times, you were badgering. The focus should have been specifically why that school would be best for your daughter. Not an implied ‘I don’t think you’re using classrooms effectively so I want to check’

If your child is deserving of this above subscription place, perhaps they’re already going above with a child they feel has more need. Perhaps they’re in debt (like so many schools are) and daren’t take on another child who will need extra support.

Why is it this school provides more for your child than another? You said above there were not SEND issues, so what is it that makes this school so good for her? Bearing in mind you clearly think poorly of the people you met already.

Well then the panel were badgering too. But the reason was because we needed answers for certain questions. You may think that should be the focus but that isn't how it works. The first part is purely about the school and you can't bring your DC into it.

They were not already going above.

I don't think poorly of anyone at the school. I'm not going to go into why the school meets my Dd's needs because it would be a lot to write and I'm just so happy she has a place! 🎉

OP posts:
Hotandsunny · 08/11/2023 14:47

Phineyj · 08/11/2023 09:33

Hi OP, I teach in a large comprehensive where year 7 is more than full (as in every year 7-11 full plus a few more students who came on EHCP appeals or managed moves etc) but our sixth form is not full.

A year 7 class uses my GCSE/A-level classroom for their tutor time. The tutor has had to put 3 folding exam desks and extra chairs in there for tutor time (we used to have to do the same at the superselective grammar where I taught - up to 34 in a year 7 class there which didn't actually fit the room - fortunately there were normally1 or 2 at individual music or drama lessons).

The corridors are ridiculously crammed. I often can't easily get down them as a teacher. An additional 100 6th formers would make no difference to that. 2 or 3 extras in every KS3 class absolutely does. That's say 3 x 6 x 5 = 90 extra kids in those corridors.

The school, legally, has to hear the appeal. That doesn't mean they have to be happy about the overcrowding and lack of resources. It's not personal to you, although I'm sorry you had a stressful experience.

The most useful thing to do would be to look at last year's admissions booklet for your LA and you will be able to see how many appeals were allowed for that particular school.

As well as the power imbalance between you and the person chairing the appeal, there is a huge power imbalance between the school and the paymasters in Westminster who fund the school buildings!

Rubbish situation with lots of defensive behaviour all round.

I'm not suggesting the school has to be happy. But I believe they should be able to answer the questions. There have been no appeals allowed in the last few years. So grateful ours was!

OP posts:
Hotandsunny · 08/11/2023 14:43

SageLavenderThyme · 08/11/2023 08:52

Although I do think some of the of the discussion on this thread is interesting in terms of thinking about different communication styles, I do think that as part of a formal process such as OP is describing there is the expectation that questions should be answered.

The school have shared rooms and room sizes as part of their justification as to why the school can't accommodate OP's DD, and therefore it would be relevant for the school to answer specific questions related to school numbers and rooms, in order to give the OP a chance to properly challenge the decision.

The question of whether the teacher felt like answering, or predicted where discussion was going, shouldn't really come into it.

It sounds like OP's DD may have missed out on a school place due to an error on the school's part. Therefore I would suggest it is encumbant upon the school to examine their capacity and see if there is a way to accommodate OP's DD in these exceptional circumstances. If they have already done so and the exercise was not fruitful, fine. But it would be appropriate, as part of the appeal process, to fully explain how that decision was reached. OP's question was relevant there.

Thank you. It seems few people here really understand the appeal process. Fair enough I didn't until recently. But I wouldn't make comments about something I have no knowledge about.

Not sure which bit we won on but so relieved!

OP posts:
Hotandsunny · 08/11/2023 14:40

MoonriseKingdom · 08/11/2023 08:05

The school will say they are full as they are up to PAN and that is what determines how many children they should admit. It sounds from their response that this is what the panel chair felt as well. You might not like it or disagree with it but hyper focussing on this point won’t help. You are much more likely to win the appeal by showing why that school is best placed to meet your child’s needs rather than trying to make arguments about classroom arrangements. Hopefully you made some good points along this line and your child will get the place they need.

You can't argue about your child in the part about the school. You u have to ask questions about the school.

OP posts:
Hotandsunny · 08/11/2023 14:38

Highlandsprocker · 08/11/2023 07:37

They can say they are full end of!!

Your MH doesn't come into it.
Your question was irrelevant, if anything Your appeal should be about why your DD needs to go there not irrelevant questions about another year group.

Well, they can't because if your appeal is upheld...as ours has been!!! 😀🎉 Then they have to let the DC in!

And yes all those things come into it. The second part of the process is arguing about your DC. You can't do that in the first part that is about the school.

OP posts:
sollenwir · 08/11/2023 14:38

They understood what you were asking regarding room use, however didn't provide you with that information because how they use rooms isn't a/the only factor that will influence whether they have space to accept your child in Y7.

Boomboom22 · 08/11/2023 14:35

Yes but you've taken the argument too far. 6th form is irrelevant.