Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

If you are autistic do people often not answer the question you are asking but give a more generalised answer?

389 replies

Hotandsunny · 07/11/2023 22:20

Just a thought that came to mind. I often find when I ask people questions about something very specific they don't seem to get it and just give you a general answer. I don't know what it is. But I have oftenish been in a situation where people just don't seem to understand what you are asking. So I was wondering if it was an autistic thing.

The example from today was I was doing a school appeal and the school had sent a list of rooms and room sizes as evidence that the school was full. I tried to question the school about what the different rooms were used for, about class sizes and what rooms the 6th form used. All the deputy head could do was repeat that Y7 was full.

I say you haven't answered my question and ask again and get the same reply. A member of the panel says to me I just don't like the reply I'm getting. I don't, because it doesn't answer my question.

This isn't an isolated incident by a long shot.

OP posts:
Ger1atricMillennial · 08/11/2023 23:26

GoodnightGentlemen · 08/11/2023 23:14

The thing with that that I don’t get, is why not just say it. So “do 6th form use communal areas?” Answer “I am not going to answer that question because of xyz”.

Then everyone knows where they stand and can act accordingly. No one gains anything from obfuscating and vagaries.

Then they could be perceived by other individuals of withholding information or not engaging. You are only viewing this from your point of view not the point of view of the officials in the room who have to manage everyones expectations.

Also, you have to ask what 6th Form rooms have to do with Yr 7 applications. If someone was asking that, I would be seeking to move on as there might be some more relevent questions.

Hotandsunny · 08/11/2023 23:24

Ger1atricMillennial · 08/11/2023 23:04

Exactly... what seems like a simple question to you that is relevant, may be more complex to others and not relevant. It happens to everyone not just people who are neuro-atypical, just watch any interview with a politician!

I suspect the purpose of the appeal would have been to review any applications to make sure they hadn't overlooked anything and to be transparent about the selection process as appose to be discussing the running of the school. As someone who has worked with prioritising people, it is very challenging to be able to pitch the message that someone (or their loved one) doesn't qualify for the service. You know its personal to them, and everyone takes that news very differently.

However, it's awful when you are in a situation where you are just doing the best for your child, and it feels like it's unfair. It's reasonable to be angry about it, and if you have extra barriers, it is normal to think they are at fault when actually it's just the system didn't fall your way.

Edited

The appeal is in 2 parts. Basically the first part is the school arguing they are full and the parent arguing they aren't and then the panel assessing whether they think it is full or not. It is weird because you would think it either is or it isn't but that's not how it works. Then the second bit is about your individual child.

It is very difficult but the bit I'm actually angry about is the whole process rather than the school.

OP posts:
BertieBotts · 08/11/2023 23:21

I think also in NT communication it's considered rude to say "I won't answer that question" - I don't really know why actually. So I think people try to come up with an answer they can give in order not to be rude but also not answer the question they don't want to answer.

And saying I can't answer or I don't know is seen as avoidant or even evidence that the person is incompetent or stupid, so again people generally try to avoid saying that and will instead either try to come up with an indirect way to answer the question so that they can give an answer, but also sometimes people just make stuff up! Which is really annoying if you find it out later, but most of the time people don't find out, so it stays as an uncorrected habit and people keep doing it all their lives.

Hotandsunny · 08/11/2023 23:18

napody · 08/11/2023 23:01

This.
There is absolutely no chance that your 'how many rooms...' questions are going to be anywhere near your final questions on the subject. It'll be an absolute can of worms with you questioning other aspects of timetabling and school building use- and planning all of this is insanely complicated. They don't have time to go through it with you, and it has no bearing on the issue at hand.

'Why send the list?': I'm sure that they are thoroughly regretting doing so! And if they answered your next question it'd be 'why tell me that if they won't tell me....?'
Because people have limits, and you've reached them.

So they refuse to answer a question because I might ask another one? What were they expecting at an appeal where the panel and parents ask questions of the school?

I find it interesting saying they don't have time...it would have probably saved about a third of the time if they'd answered the questions the first time. Obviously if certain information is needed for my case I'm going to keep asking til I get it. And so glad I did as now my DD has a place at the school. If I'd just said 'oh, no, it's fine, I'm sure your busy, don't worry about engaging with the appeal' then things would have been different.

Would you really go to an appeal for your child's school and really not fight with every ounce of your being? Because a teacher might be busy???

OP posts:
Ger1atricMillennial · 08/11/2023 23:18

Hotandsunny · 08/11/2023 23:09

I was about to say I'm a nurse and I would answer that question much more like you've suggested.

It is about setting expectations. When you work with people they grasp onto numbers as facts. Then if things don't conform to the expectation that they have been set with they respond with "well you told me that it would take x number of weeks." or they become anxious if they have been told that "normal" is a certain number of weeks.

GoodnightGentlemen · 08/11/2023 23:14

Ger1atricMillennial · 08/11/2023 23:04

Exactly... what seems like a simple question to you that is relevant, may be more complex to others and not relevant. It happens to everyone not just people who are neuro-atypical, just watch any interview with a politician!

I suspect the purpose of the appeal would have been to review any applications to make sure they hadn't overlooked anything and to be transparent about the selection process as appose to be discussing the running of the school. As someone who has worked with prioritising people, it is very challenging to be able to pitch the message that someone (or their loved one) doesn't qualify for the service. You know its personal to them, and everyone takes that news very differently.

However, it's awful when you are in a situation where you are just doing the best for your child, and it feels like it's unfair. It's reasonable to be angry about it, and if you have extra barriers, it is normal to think they are at fault when actually it's just the system didn't fall your way.

Edited

The thing with that that I don’t get, is why not just say it. So “do 6th form use communal areas?” Answer “I am not going to answer that question because of xyz”.

Then everyone knows where they stand and can act accordingly. No one gains anything from obfuscating and vagaries.

Hotandsunny · 08/11/2023 23:09

GoodnightGentlemen · 08/11/2023 22:49

Why wouldn’t the doctor say “usually it takes 4 weeks, but it could be longer”. Or “on average this type of wound takes between 4-6 weeks to heal”? Or “I can’t give an exact number, but in my experience about 4 weeks”

What does monitor it mean? What does go from there mean? Does it mean that it should heal by 4 weeks and if it doesn’t there is a problem? Or does it mean that the doctor expects it to take over 4 weeks but they won’t need to monitor it after that?!

I was about to say I'm a nurse and I would answer that question much more like you've suggested.

OP posts:
Ger1atricMillennial · 08/11/2023 23:08

Hotandsunny · 08/11/2023 23:06

I didn't ask for 3 different types of information in one question. I asked something like 'do the 6th form use the main school communal areas?'.
To me a clear answer could be for example 'yes, they do although in addition they have a kettle/hot drink making area they use at break time.'
'our communal areas are very busy' to me does not answer the question clearly.

I tried to question the school about what the (1) different rooms were used for, (2) about class sizes and (3) what rooms the 6th form used.

Hotandsunny · 08/11/2023 23:06

Ger1atricMillennial · 08/11/2023 22:38

She has asked for 3 different types of information, that is a lot of detail. As someone who is not experienced or knowledgeable about the subject matter it might sound like a straightforward question with a finite answer, but to someone who is experienced it will be more complex.

For example A patient might ask how long it will take for a wound to heal. They just want a number i.e. 6 weeks, but for an experienced clinician who has seen a lot of different responses they will give an answer such as "we will monitor it over the next 4 weeks and go from there".

I didn't ask for 3 different types of information in one question. I asked something like 'do the 6th form use the main school communal areas?'.
To me a clear answer could be for example 'yes, they do although in addition they have a kettle/hot drink making area they use at break time.'
'our communal areas are very busy' to me does not answer the question clearly.

OP posts:
Ger1atricMillennial · 08/11/2023 23:04

Hotandsunny · 08/11/2023 22:46

But I was just giving a rough idea of the topics that were covered. They were specific questions to back up specific points. And if myself, the panel and other parent were asking such irrelevant questions the chair could have stepped in. An appeal is much more nuanced than why your child didn't get a place.

But yes, they may have interpreted the question differently and not understood the relevance.

Exactly... what seems like a simple question to you that is relevant, may be more complex to others and not relevant. It happens to everyone not just people who are neuro-atypical, just watch any interview with a politician!

I suspect the purpose of the appeal would have been to review any applications to make sure they hadn't overlooked anything and to be transparent about the selection process as appose to be discussing the running of the school. As someone who has worked with prioritising people, it is very challenging to be able to pitch the message that someone (or their loved one) doesn't qualify for the service. You know its personal to them, and everyone takes that news very differently.

However, it's awful when you are in a situation where you are just doing the best for your child, and it feels like it's unfair. It's reasonable to be angry about it, and if you have extra barriers, it is normal to think they are at fault when actually it's just the system didn't fall your way.

napody · 08/11/2023 23:01

BannedfromChristmas · 07/11/2023 23:15

They probably have a million and one other things to be doing and don't understandably want to gave you scrutinising their use of rooms. I'm not quite sure how you think the capacity of the sixth form room is relevant though?
Schools timetable different groups in different rooms according to capacity and year group they are nit going to re timetable tge entire school so its a complete non argument. Just because you want your child in the school doesn't mean you will be able berate them into it.
Maybe a backup plan is required:)

This.
There is absolutely no chance that your 'how many rooms...' questions are going to be anywhere near your final questions on the subject. It'll be an absolute can of worms with you questioning other aspects of timetabling and school building use- and planning all of this is insanely complicated. They don't have time to go through it with you, and it has no bearing on the issue at hand.

'Why send the list?': I'm sure that they are thoroughly regretting doing so! And if they answered your next question it'd be 'why tell me that if they won't tell me....?'
Because people have limits, and you've reached them.

Hotandsunny · 08/11/2023 22:58

BertieBotts · 08/11/2023 22:31

This is a fascinating thread, marking place to read it fully later. I started earlier and it quickly got too long!

I am fascinated by the differences between autistic and neurotypical communication styles. I often feel that I understand both and can sort of "translate" (maybe it's the ADHD?) but I could be wrong. For example, GoodnightGentleman's example has just blown my mind. I actually think I need to hire you as a translator for my 5yo DS2. He is constantly asking me questions that are extremely important to him and I want to answer for him but I don't understand what specifically he is asking and we just get frustrated with each other. (If I get any tomorrow, I'll try to remember them, and write them on the thread as examples).

I think NT communication is a lot of making assumptions about what the other person really wants to know, and this is very frustrating to autistic people who are being more direct.

I'm glad you're enjoying it it is interesting. And you may well be a 'translator' and just what I needed at the appeal! Actually that would be amazing having an autism translator!! So many people have got so cross with me and told me I'm rude. I'm really not trying to be! It would be great for people to be aware of our different ways of communicating and that it might be different but it isn't wrong. I actually feel terrible if I realise people think I'm being rude.

And yes, please if you have any examples I'd love to hear them.

OP posts:
InattentiveADHD · 08/11/2023 22:55

Hotandsunny · 08/11/2023 22:52

It really does feel like that. I often think but if I wanted to know for example if Y7 was full I would ask if Y7 was full. But if I ask if the 6th form use the communal areas within the main school then I want to know if the 6th form use the communal areas within the main school. It seems simple to me.

Exactly! Very straightforward. NTs seem to want to complicate it? It must constantly lead to misunderstandings even amongst themselves surely?

I would have answered your questions OP :-)

Hotandsunny · 08/11/2023 22:52

InattentiveADHD · 08/11/2023 22:24

I can't believe the amount of people trying to justify why someone can't listen to the words someone says and answer a question clearly. Somehow that it's the thought of the person who's being precise, asking a clear question, and simply wanting a clear answer to their clear question. 🤯 This world is never going to work for ND people, if that's the bar!

It really does feel like that. I often think but if I wanted to know for example if Y7 was full I would ask if Y7 was full. But if I ask if the 6th form use the communal areas within the main school then I want to know if the 6th form use the communal areas within the main school. It seems simple to me.

OP posts:
GoodnightGentlemen · 08/11/2023 22:49

Ger1atricMillennial · 08/11/2023 22:38

She has asked for 3 different types of information, that is a lot of detail. As someone who is not experienced or knowledgeable about the subject matter it might sound like a straightforward question with a finite answer, but to someone who is experienced it will be more complex.

For example A patient might ask how long it will take for a wound to heal. They just want a number i.e. 6 weeks, but for an experienced clinician who has seen a lot of different responses they will give an answer such as "we will monitor it over the next 4 weeks and go from there".

Why wouldn’t the doctor say “usually it takes 4 weeks, but it could be longer”. Or “on average this type of wound takes between 4-6 weeks to heal”? Or “I can’t give an exact number, but in my experience about 4 weeks”

What does monitor it mean? What does go from there mean? Does it mean that it should heal by 4 weeks and if it doesn’t there is a problem? Or does it mean that the doctor expects it to take over 4 weeks but they won’t need to monitor it after that?!

Hotandsunny · 08/11/2023 22:46

Ger1atricMillennial · 08/11/2023 21:12

" I tried to question the school about what the different rooms were used for, about class sizes and what rooms the 6th form used. All the deputy head could do was repeat that Y7 was full." To me this sounds like you are asking a detailed plan of their day-to-day operations. You want to know at least 3 different things that are irrelevant as to why your child didn't get a place.

As you can see the question that you are asking and maybe the way a person understands that question can be different. They have may have interpreted as such or another way and that's why they didn't go into any further detail.

But I was just giving a rough idea of the topics that were covered. They were specific questions to back up specific points. And if myself, the panel and other parent were asking such irrelevant questions the chair could have stepped in. An appeal is much more nuanced than why your child didn't get a place.

But yes, they may have interpreted the question differently and not understood the relevance.

OP posts:
GoodnightGentlemen · 08/11/2023 22:43

BertieBotts · 08/11/2023 22:31

This is a fascinating thread, marking place to read it fully later. I started earlier and it quickly got too long!

I am fascinated by the differences between autistic and neurotypical communication styles. I often feel that I understand both and can sort of "translate" (maybe it's the ADHD?) but I could be wrong. For example, GoodnightGentleman's example has just blown my mind. I actually think I need to hire you as a translator for my 5yo DS2. He is constantly asking me questions that are extremely important to him and I want to answer for him but I don't understand what specifically he is asking and we just get frustrated with each other. (If I get any tomorrow, I'll try to remember them, and write them on the thread as examples).

I think NT communication is a lot of making assumptions about what the other person really wants to know, and this is very frustrating to autistic people who are being more direct.

It’s just practice- I have had my son with me pretty much 100% of the time for 9 years (he is home Ed) so we have got used to each other!

And to be honest I can be pretty pedantic myself.

He is constantly asking me questions that are extremely important to him and I want to answer for him but I don't understand what specifically he is asking and we just get frustrated with each other

thats why I say ‘you asked x’ or ‘you want to know x’… so hopefully I understand the question correctly before I try and answer it! Doesn’t always work though.

Ger1atricMillennial · 08/11/2023 22:38

InattentiveADHD · 08/11/2023 22:20

Well maybe they need to listen to the actual question rather than putting their own (incorrect) interpretation over the top of it (as I constantly tell my NT DH! Lol). Listen to the words coming out of a person's mouth. Stop adding extra context that isn't there!

She has asked for 3 different types of information, that is a lot of detail. As someone who is not experienced or knowledgeable about the subject matter it might sound like a straightforward question with a finite answer, but to someone who is experienced it will be more complex.

For example A patient might ask how long it will take for a wound to heal. They just want a number i.e. 6 weeks, but for an experienced clinician who has seen a lot of different responses they will give an answer such as "we will monitor it over the next 4 weeks and go from there".

BertieBotts · 08/11/2023 22:31

This is a fascinating thread, marking place to read it fully later. I started earlier and it quickly got too long!

I am fascinated by the differences between autistic and neurotypical communication styles. I often feel that I understand both and can sort of "translate" (maybe it's the ADHD?) but I could be wrong. For example, GoodnightGentleman's example has just blown my mind. I actually think I need to hire you as a translator for my 5yo DS2. He is constantly asking me questions that are extremely important to him and I want to answer for him but I don't understand what specifically he is asking and we just get frustrated with each other. (If I get any tomorrow, I'll try to remember them, and write them on the thread as examples).

I think NT communication is a lot of making assumptions about what the other person really wants to know, and this is very frustrating to autistic people who are being more direct.

InattentiveADHD · 08/11/2023 22:24

I can't believe the amount of people trying to justify why someone can't listen to the words someone says and answer a question clearly. Somehow that it's the thought of the person who's being precise, asking a clear question, and simply wanting a clear answer to their clear question. 🤯 This world is never going to work for ND people, if that's the bar!

InattentiveADHD · 08/11/2023 22:20

Ger1atricMillennial · 08/11/2023 21:12

" I tried to question the school about what the different rooms were used for, about class sizes and what rooms the 6th form used. All the deputy head could do was repeat that Y7 was full." To me this sounds like you are asking a detailed plan of their day-to-day operations. You want to know at least 3 different things that are irrelevant as to why your child didn't get a place.

As you can see the question that you are asking and maybe the way a person understands that question can be different. They have may have interpreted as such or another way and that's why they didn't go into any further detail.

Well maybe they need to listen to the actual question rather than putting their own (incorrect) interpretation over the top of it (as I constantly tell my NT DH! Lol). Listen to the words coming out of a person's mouth. Stop adding extra context that isn't there!

GoodnightGentlemen · 08/11/2023 22:14

LittleMooli · 08/11/2023 18:13

My DH is autistic and finds this. I'm used to it now but I couldn't understand why he was saying I hadn't answered his question when I had I just hadn't answered it as precisely as he wanted.

my son prefaces ever question by saying ‘question’. I often end up saying ‘you asked X- my answer is Y’.

and it needs to be specific- my dad once tried to take him out and was back home 2 minutes later because the conversation went son- how long is the drive to McDonald’s?” Dad- “5 minutes” son- “how long is that?” Dad “not long” son- “but how long is it?” Dad- “5 minutes isn’t long, it’s about the length of a YouTube video (?!)” son- “BUT HOW LONG IS IT” and frustrated tears. My dad brought him home and I opened the door to “he won’t tell me how long 5 minutes is sob sob sob”. I said, 5 minutes is 5 lots of sixty seconds, if you count using Mississippi. sobbing stopped replaced with “why didn’t he tell me that?!”.

So much easier just to be precise in the first place.

Ger1atricMillennial · 08/11/2023 21:12

Hotandsunny · 08/11/2023 02:25

Where have I said I want a detailed plan of their day to day operations? 😂

I mean I think some of the questions she didn't answer because she really wasn't listening and thought her set phrase was a satisfactory answer. But there were questions that she obviously didn't have the knowledge for and the clerk and 1 panel member had to step in. I think she should have prepared better as I don't think the clerk and panel member are meant to be helping.

" I tried to question the school about what the different rooms were used for, about class sizes and what rooms the 6th form used. All the deputy head could do was repeat that Y7 was full." To me this sounds like you are asking a detailed plan of their day-to-day operations. You want to know at least 3 different things that are irrelevant as to why your child didn't get a place.

As you can see the question that you are asking and maybe the way a person understands that question can be different. They have may have interpreted as such or another way and that's why they didn't go into any further detail.

Hotandsunny · 08/11/2023 20:10

TheBirdintheCave · 08/11/2023 19:18

@Hotandsunny The stupidest part my autism and co-morbidities are all over my notes. The midwife at my booking in appointment made a special point of noting down that I'm not contactable by phone.

I feel like I'm shouting into the void sometimes 😂

Oh my goodness! It's so frustrating! And for me feeling I'm not being listened to is such a big trigger...probably because I get made to feel like that so often!

OP posts:
TheBirdintheCave · 08/11/2023 19:18

@Hotandsunny The stupidest part my autism and co-morbidities are all over my notes. The midwife at my booking in appointment made a special point of noting down that I'm not contactable by phone.

I feel like I'm shouting into the void sometimes 😂