Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

If you are autistic do people often not answer the question you are asking but give a more generalised answer?

389 replies

Hotandsunny · 07/11/2023 22:20

Just a thought that came to mind. I often find when I ask people questions about something very specific they don't seem to get it and just give you a general answer. I don't know what it is. But I have oftenish been in a situation where people just don't seem to understand what you are asking. So I was wondering if it was an autistic thing.

The example from today was I was doing a school appeal and the school had sent a list of rooms and room sizes as evidence that the school was full. I tried to question the school about what the different rooms were used for, about class sizes and what rooms the 6th form used. All the deputy head could do was repeat that Y7 was full.

I say you haven't answered my question and ask again and get the same reply. A member of the panel says to me I just don't like the reply I'm getting. I don't, because it doesn't answer my question.

This isn't an isolated incident by a long shot.

OP posts:
PriOn1 · 09/11/2023 07:24

Well, OP, now I’ve read all your replies and it would appear I inadvertently proved that the answer to your original question was “yes”.

So it appears that your looking for loopholes in their argument was exactly the task you were meant to be doing in the circumstances and you were successful, which is hopefully good for your daughter.

PriOn1 · 09/11/2023 06:05

This reply has been withdrawn

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

LittleMooli · 09/11/2023 05:23

GoodnightGentlemen · 08/11/2023 22:14

my son prefaces ever question by saying ‘question’. I often end up saying ‘you asked X- my answer is Y’.

and it needs to be specific- my dad once tried to take him out and was back home 2 minutes later because the conversation went son- how long is the drive to McDonald’s?” Dad- “5 minutes” son- “how long is that?” Dad “not long” son- “but how long is it?” Dad- “5 minutes isn’t long, it’s about the length of a YouTube video (?!)” son- “BUT HOW LONG IS IT” and frustrated tears. My dad brought him home and I opened the door to “he won’t tell me how long 5 minutes is sob sob sob”. I said, 5 minutes is 5 lots of sixty seconds, if you count using Mississippi. sobbing stopped replaced with “why didn’t he tell me that?!”.

So much easier just to be precise in the first place.

It takes a lot of practice though.

InattentiveADHD · 09/11/2023 03:15

TwoShades1 · 09/11/2023 01:40

I have to say you sound quite difficult and fixated from this thread. Im quite glad I don’t work at your child’s new school, I feel like you will be one of those parents that’s always asking for “more information” or clarification. There’s always one that wants to know precisely what their child will be eating on Tuesday lunchtime of the biology trip that’s still months away.

No she doesn't. She's just communicating clearly and explaining her point in the face of loads of NTs who are telling an autistic person they are communicating incorrectly simply because they ask clear questions and want clear answers to the question asked. Honestly the responses on this thread have made it really clear why ND people find society so bloody difficult. NTs are supposed to be good at this and find it easy so why can't you adjust a little to allow some other, slightly different, but not unreasonable ways of communicating into the mix. There's literally no movement on your side. Do it our way or fuck off!!

(Not including the PP who does try to make adjustments- thank you! - but sadly you seem to be in the minority!)

InWalksBarberalla · 09/11/2023 02:15

I think another consideration is that many people don't like saying they don't know the answer to something - especially in a work based context when they could reasonably be expected to know the answer. As in they feel very uncomfortable saying they don't know. So instead they answer a different question .

TwoShades1 · 09/11/2023 01:40

I have to say you sound quite difficult and fixated from this thread. Im quite glad I don’t work at your child’s new school, I feel like you will be one of those parents that’s always asking for “more information” or clarification. There’s always one that wants to know precisely what their child will be eating on Tuesday lunchtime of the biology trip that’s still months away.

Hotandsunny · 09/11/2023 00:33

GoodnightGentlemen · 09/11/2023 00:02

@Hotandsunny sorry, I’ve gone off on a tangent there!

Oh no, it's very interesting and I can relate. I am very black and white in my thinking.

OP posts:
Hotandsunny · 09/11/2023 00:28

cardibach · 08/11/2023 23:51

You remember I’m a teacher? Appeals interviews can be over several days and there has to be discussion. I’d say it’s rare to get a decision the same/next day.

Many people told me they got the answer the same day. And no sorry, I didn't remember you were a teacher. After the first part the panel spent a short time then made the decision. There were only 2 appeals so the 2nd half didn't take too long. So I imagine the decision would have been decided there and then.

OP posts:
Hotandsunny · 09/11/2023 00:22

BertieBotts · 08/11/2023 23:35

One thing I find really interesting that I didn't get my head around for ages and ages is that there is a fairly common, (I think), ND (maybe just ADHD?) sense of curiosity about why people do things differently, but in NT communication the same exactly worded question is a veiled insult.

So for example on MN every so often you get a thread that is something like "Why do people choose to go through natural childbirth?" or "Why do some people not try breastfeeding?"

To me I always took these at face value and assumed ok, here's someone being curious, they made a choice that was different and it seemed so obvious to them that they are curious about what might make somebody lean the other way. But a lot of MNers will react with anger towards these types of thread and want to shut them down as being goady. Because to them, the implicit, unwritten line is "Only stupid idiot people would want to go through childbirth pain. Give me your reasons, so I can mock and laugh at them and feel superior that I made a better choice!"

I thought they were being weirdly defensive about this for years, and then I started to realise that they're right in some cases, because threads like that do attract some handwringing about why those poor other people made that obviously terrible choice.

But I think it's a shame because I always find it really interesting to read about why and how people make decisions and come to conclusions especially when they're different to what I'd have come to.

I completely get this. I'm very curious too and often been told that by asking a very genuine question that I actually meant all sorts of nasty things! No, I literally just mean what I typed!

OP posts:
Hotandsunny · 09/11/2023 00:16

Triplixate · 08/11/2023 23:29

So many NT people on this thread just refusing to accept ND people’s perspectives as valid… and yet we’re the ones with “poor theory of mind” 🙄 It just highlights how biased the world is to NT communication styles.. no wonder we’ve been labelled as socially deficit when no one can possibly consider if our viewpoints and experiences are valid.

There seem to be some people have come onti the thread that are interested in looking at both sides.

But yes, so many people initially just trying to say ND people's style of communication is wrong!

OP posts:
Hotandsunny · 09/11/2023 00:12

Ger1atricMillennial · 08/11/2023 23:26

Then they could be perceived by other individuals of withholding information or not engaging. You are only viewing this from your point of view not the point of view of the officials in the room who have to manage everyones expectations.

Also, you have to ask what 6th Form rooms have to do with Yr 7 applications. If someone was asking that, I would be seeking to move on as there might be some more relevent questions.

But if they're withholding information they are doing that no matter how they dress it up.
If Y7 use the same rooms as the 6th form it is relevant.

OP posts:
GoodnightGentlemen · 09/11/2023 00:12

Ger1atricMillennial · 08/11/2023 23:26

Then they could be perceived by other individuals of withholding information or not engaging. You are only viewing this from your point of view not the point of view of the officials in the room who have to manage everyones expectations.

Also, you have to ask what 6th Form rooms have to do with Yr 7 applications. If someone was asking that, I would be seeking to move on as there might be some more relevent questions.

If they don’t give a clear answer then they are withholding information or not engaging anyway, they are just doing in a way that NT people find more socially acceptable.

Hotandsunny · 09/11/2023 00:08

BertieBotts · 08/11/2023 23:21

I think also in NT communication it's considered rude to say "I won't answer that question" - I don't really know why actually. So I think people try to come up with an answer they can give in order not to be rude but also not answer the question they don't want to answer.

And saying I can't answer or I don't know is seen as avoidant or even evidence that the person is incompetent or stupid, so again people generally try to avoid saying that and will instead either try to come up with an indirect way to answer the question so that they can give an answer, but also sometimes people just make stuff up! Which is really annoying if you find it out later, but most of the time people don't find out, so it stays as an uncorrected habit and people keep doing it all their lives.

I actually think being seen to be polite is a big reason English people end up not being clear. Autistic people are often are seen as being rude for being direct, although to me it's just telling the truth.

OP posts:
GoodnightGentlemen · 09/11/2023 00:02

GoodnightGentlemen · 09/11/2023 00:01

Yeah people do do that, you’re right.

It isn’t just the inference that people take from questions which I find interesting, it’s the way they respond.

So, If asked, for example- did you sleep train? If so, Didn’t it upset you when your baby cried?

many people would get defensive and upset about their choice BUT some people would take the line of ‘both choices are valid, it depends what works for that family’.

I find that almost a vague way of thinking because in my head a) clearly I think my way of doing it is best- if I thought your way was better then I would have done that instead.
b) given that I think my way is the best way, I wouldn’t feel defensive if people thought the other way was better- I would think they were wrong (I accept people are allowed to do things the Wrong Way).

@Hotandsunny sorry, I’ve gone off on a tangent there!

GoodnightGentlemen · 09/11/2023 00:01

BertieBotts · 08/11/2023 23:35

One thing I find really interesting that I didn't get my head around for ages and ages is that there is a fairly common, (I think), ND (maybe just ADHD?) sense of curiosity about why people do things differently, but in NT communication the same exactly worded question is a veiled insult.

So for example on MN every so often you get a thread that is something like "Why do people choose to go through natural childbirth?" or "Why do some people not try breastfeeding?"

To me I always took these at face value and assumed ok, here's someone being curious, they made a choice that was different and it seemed so obvious to them that they are curious about what might make somebody lean the other way. But a lot of MNers will react with anger towards these types of thread and want to shut them down as being goady. Because to them, the implicit, unwritten line is "Only stupid idiot people would want to go through childbirth pain. Give me your reasons, so I can mock and laugh at them and feel superior that I made a better choice!"

I thought they were being weirdly defensive about this for years, and then I started to realise that they're right in some cases, because threads like that do attract some handwringing about why those poor other people made that obviously terrible choice.

But I think it's a shame because I always find it really interesting to read about why and how people make decisions and come to conclusions especially when they're different to what I'd have come to.

Yeah people do do that, you’re right.

It isn’t just the inference that people take from questions which I find interesting, it’s the way they respond.

So, If asked, for example- did you sleep train? If so, Didn’t it upset you when your baby cried?

many people would get defensive and upset about their choice BUT some people would take the line of ‘both choices are valid, it depends what works for that family’.

I find that almost a vague way of thinking because in my head a) clearly I think my way of doing it is best- if I thought your way was better then I would have done that instead.
b) given that I think my way is the best way, I wouldn’t feel defensive if people thought the other way was better- I would think they were wrong (I accept people are allowed to do things the Wrong Way).

cardibach · 08/11/2023 23:51

Hotandsunny · 08/11/2023 17:56

How many people do you know who have won appeals? I was actually really nervous as many people told me they found out in the case they had won on the same day. The panel make their decision there and then I believe. So no rather late by the sounds of it!!

You remember I’m a teacher? Appeals interviews can be over several days and there has to be discussion. I’d say it’s rare to get a decision the same/next day.

RelationshipOrNot · 08/11/2023 23:48

BertieBotts · 08/11/2023 23:35

One thing I find really interesting that I didn't get my head around for ages and ages is that there is a fairly common, (I think), ND (maybe just ADHD?) sense of curiosity about why people do things differently, but in NT communication the same exactly worded question is a veiled insult.

So for example on MN every so often you get a thread that is something like "Why do people choose to go through natural childbirth?" or "Why do some people not try breastfeeding?"

To me I always took these at face value and assumed ok, here's someone being curious, they made a choice that was different and it seemed so obvious to them that they are curious about what might make somebody lean the other way. But a lot of MNers will react with anger towards these types of thread and want to shut them down as being goady. Because to them, the implicit, unwritten line is "Only stupid idiot people would want to go through childbirth pain. Give me your reasons, so I can mock and laugh at them and feel superior that I made a better choice!"

I thought they were being weirdly defensive about this for years, and then I started to realise that they're right in some cases, because threads like that do attract some handwringing about why those poor other people made that obviously terrible choice.

But I think it's a shame because I always find it really interesting to read about why and how people make decisions and come to conclusions especially when they're different to what I'd have come to.

This is one I've fallen foul of many times! Also when trying to show sympathy for someone in a bad situation - my natural response, as with many autistic people, is to relate using a similar experience I've had. I've learnt that NT people don't like that, so try to ask questions instead because I don't know what to say. Which is often a mistake because then I don't know how to follow up when they answer or think that I was using my question to make a point with subtext.

BertieBotts · 08/11/2023 23:35

One thing I find really interesting that I didn't get my head around for ages and ages is that there is a fairly common, (I think), ND (maybe just ADHD?) sense of curiosity about why people do things differently, but in NT communication the same exactly worded question is a veiled insult.

So for example on MN every so often you get a thread that is something like "Why do people choose to go through natural childbirth?" or "Why do some people not try breastfeeding?"

To me I always took these at face value and assumed ok, here's someone being curious, they made a choice that was different and it seemed so obvious to them that they are curious about what might make somebody lean the other way. But a lot of MNers will react with anger towards these types of thread and want to shut them down as being goady. Because to them, the implicit, unwritten line is "Only stupid idiot people would want to go through childbirth pain. Give me your reasons, so I can mock and laugh at them and feel superior that I made a better choice!"

I thought they were being weirdly defensive about this for years, and then I started to realise that they're right in some cases, because threads like that do attract some handwringing about why those poor other people made that obviously terrible choice.

But I think it's a shame because I always find it really interesting to read about why and how people make decisions and come to conclusions especially when they're different to what I'd have come to.

GoodnightGentlemen · 08/11/2023 23:35

Hotandsunny · 08/11/2023 23:30

Yes, that's the thing. I think by not clearing explaining why you don't want to answer or whatever and by instead saying something unrelated to the question makes me think you've not listened to the question/misheard it or don't understand it. So I'll keep repeating it.

I think there is also the issue of people not liking to admit they don’t know the answer- so they say vague nothingness in an effort not to loose face.

Hotandsunny · 08/11/2023 23:32

Ger1atricMillennial · 08/11/2023 23:18

It is about setting expectations. When you work with people they grasp onto numbers as facts. Then if things don't conform to the expectation that they have been set with they respond with "well you told me that it would take x number of weeks." or they become anxious if they have been told that "normal" is a certain number of weeks.

Interesting, I'll have to look out for that.

OP posts:
GoodnightGentlemen · 08/11/2023 23:31

Ger1atricMillennial · 08/11/2023 23:18

It is about setting expectations. When you work with people they grasp onto numbers as facts. Then if things don't conform to the expectation that they have been set with they respond with "well you told me that it would take x number of weeks." or they become anxious if they have been told that "normal" is a certain number of weeks.

Do they? I don’t think so. People become anxious if they don’t understand or know what to expect- giving a clear answer, including the fact that you can’t be absolutely exact because it varies from person to person, is the best way to put people’s mind at rest.

“4-6 weeks usually, but people do heal at different rates so I can’t tell you exactly. You don’t need to worry unless it’s yellow/pussy/still bleeding profusely after 8 weeks- in that situation ring this number and we will get you in”. Seems simple to me.

Im a social worker- I’ve had to explain all sorts of complicated procedures/legal waffle etc to people who are in a state- short sentences built for clarity are what works best.

Hotandsunny · 08/11/2023 23:30

GoodnightGentlemen · 08/11/2023 23:14

The thing with that that I don’t get, is why not just say it. So “do 6th form use communal areas?” Answer “I am not going to answer that question because of xyz”.

Then everyone knows where they stand and can act accordingly. No one gains anything from obfuscating and vagaries.

Yes, that's the thing. I think by not clearing explaining why you don't want to answer or whatever and by instead saying something unrelated to the question makes me think you've not listened to the question/misheard it or don't understand it. So I'll keep repeating it.

OP posts:
Triplixate · 08/11/2023 23:29

So many NT people on this thread just refusing to accept ND people’s perspectives as valid… and yet we’re the ones with “poor theory of mind” 🙄 It just highlights how biased the world is to NT communication styles.. no wonder we’ve been labelled as socially deficit when no one can possibly consider if our viewpoints and experiences are valid.

Ger1atricMillennial · 08/11/2023 23:29

Hotandsunny · 08/11/2023 23:24

The appeal is in 2 parts. Basically the first part is the school arguing they are full and the parent arguing they aren't and then the panel assessing whether they think it is full or not. It is weird because you would think it either is or it isn't but that's not how it works. Then the second bit is about your individual child.

It is very difficult but the bit I'm actually angry about is the whole process rather than the school.

I think that is fair enough I know that school intake is rife with anxiety. I don't understand why you are being dragged into a LEA debate. Especially making you go through the process when it doesn't sound like it is productive for anyone.
Like you stated either they have room, or they haven't. That was what I think I was trying to get to it doesn't sound like an issue with you at all.

Maybe a teacher on here can explain?

Hotandsunny · 08/11/2023 23:26

Ger1atricMillennial · 08/11/2023 23:08

I tried to question the school about what the (1) different rooms were used for, (2) about class sizes and (3) what rooms the 6th form used.

Yes, but that was 3 different questions, not one.

OP posts: