Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

If you are autistic do people often not answer the question you are asking but give a more generalised answer?

389 replies

Hotandsunny · 07/11/2023 22:20

Just a thought that came to mind. I often find when I ask people questions about something very specific they don't seem to get it and just give you a general answer. I don't know what it is. But I have oftenish been in a situation where people just don't seem to understand what you are asking. So I was wondering if it was an autistic thing.

The example from today was I was doing a school appeal and the school had sent a list of rooms and room sizes as evidence that the school was full. I tried to question the school about what the different rooms were used for, about class sizes and what rooms the 6th form used. All the deputy head could do was repeat that Y7 was full.

I say you haven't answered my question and ask again and get the same reply. A member of the panel says to me I just don't like the reply I'm getting. I don't, because it doesn't answer my question.

This isn't an isolated incident by a long shot.

OP posts:
Highlandsprocker · 09/11/2023 13:02

Highlandsprocker · 09/11/2023 13:00

I don't think anyone has said its wrong but there are many forms of communication, not just verbal and often its these cues that are missed.
Another issue is boundaries.
Repeating a question on and on is a form of boundary crossing.
People have the right to give any answer they like, you don't get to control what other people say or to force them to answer in a way you control.

Wrong quote!
It was to the Op

Highlandsprocker · 09/11/2023 13:00

GoodnightGentlemen · 09/11/2023 00:12

If they don’t give a clear answer then they are withholding information or not engaging anyway, they are just doing in a way that NT people find more socially acceptable.

I don't think anyone has said its wrong but there are many forms of communication, not just verbal and often its these cues that are missed.
Another issue is boundaries.
Repeating a question on and on is a form of boundary crossing.
People have the right to give any answer they like, you don't get to control what other people say or to force them to answer in a way you control.

BertieBotts · 09/11/2023 11:38

OK, I'll try that, thanks :)

Hotandsunny · 09/11/2023 11:37

BertieBotts · 09/11/2023 11:29

YY I think NT people can see the "But what about...?" questions as being seeking a loophole, or trying to find a way around or catch you out, seeking a chink in the armour they can prise open, or trying to "win" or defeat the other person.

But from a ND perspective it's really not meant to be that combative. Actually it's trying to find a win-win solution, or problem solve. In theory this is a good characteristic, in practice (having been on the receiving end of it too) it is often received as "can't accept a no". I wonder if this is also related to NT politeness rules.

(BTW at today's check up for DS2 I was told there are some clear pointers towards ASD and I am so relieved that it is not just me who sees this.)

Someone asked for examples of DS2's questions that I don't understand. There was only one today and I did understand it. We were waiting for the bus and I said "It should be here in three minutes" and he asked "Why?" and my initial reaction was "What do you mean???" but then I stopped and said "Because the time now is 8:01 and the bus is supposed to arrive at 804, and that is three minutes." and he said "Ah!"

Some others that he asks fairly frequently which I don't undertsand how to answer:

Why does the number 3 bus come here?
Why does the number 4 tram go to <destination>?

And another one which comes up fairly frequently: I often make "Mhm" or "Awesome" responses to things that he is saying, when I'm not really interested but I want to show that I'm being polite and listening. He gets very angry about this and insists "That is not nice to say!!"

I think I understand that what he means is that he can tell this is a dismissive, "That's nice dear" sort of response and he doesn't want me to respond that way, but I am also not always enthusiastically interested in what he is saying. I can't say nothing (which is what he says that he wants me to do) because he gets angry and repeats what he wants to say until I respond. Should I literally say "I'm not very interested in that"? This seems so dismissive to a 5 year old. But maybe that's what he wants.

That's good about the check up!

Perhaps for why does the bus come here?
Because there is a plan for the city where different buses go on different routes so people can get everywhere they need to go. The plan says the no 3 has to come down this road.

OP posts:
Hotandsunny · 09/11/2023 11:32

Hughs · 09/11/2023 10:12

A typical example in our house:

Me: what time do you think you'll be back?

DH: hang on a minute, we talked about this and I said I'd be out late and you said it was fine

Me: yes it is fine, I was just wondering what time you'll be back

DH: haha well it won't be any time soon, I haven't even left yet hahaha

Me: hm ok so what time do you reckon then

DH: well I've got to drive there and then do the thing and then get back haven't I?

Me: yes, so any idea what time you might be back?

DH: don't worry I'll go straight there and back, no popping into the pub hahaha

Me: ok, so what time then

DH: well it will be lateish I think

Me: WILL YOU PLEASE USE A NUMBER

DH: oh sorry, probably around 10. I'll text if it's going to be after 11

Me: ok thanks
[goes for a lie down]

Love this! ☺️

OP posts:
BertieBotts · 09/11/2023 11:29

YY I think NT people can see the "But what about...?" questions as being seeking a loophole, or trying to find a way around or catch you out, seeking a chink in the armour they can prise open, or trying to "win" or defeat the other person.

But from a ND perspective it's really not meant to be that combative. Actually it's trying to find a win-win solution, or problem solve. In theory this is a good characteristic, in practice (having been on the receiving end of it too) it is often received as "can't accept a no". I wonder if this is also related to NT politeness rules.

(BTW at today's check up for DS2 I was told there are some clear pointers towards ASD and I am so relieved that it is not just me who sees this.)

Someone asked for examples of DS2's questions that I don't understand. There was only one today and I did understand it. We were waiting for the bus and I said "It should be here in three minutes" and he asked "Why?" and my initial reaction was "What do you mean???" but then I stopped and said "Because the time now is 8:01 and the bus is supposed to arrive at 804, and that is three minutes." and he said "Ah!"

Some others that he asks fairly frequently which I don't undertsand how to answer:

Why does the number 3 bus come here?
Why does the number 4 tram go to <destination>?

And another one which comes up fairly frequently: I often make "Mhm" or "Awesome" responses to things that he is saying, when I'm not really interested but I want to show that I'm being polite and listening. He gets very angry about this and insists "That is not nice to say!!"

I think I understand that what he means is that he can tell this is a dismissive, "That's nice dear" sort of response and he doesn't want me to respond that way, but I am also not always enthusiastically interested in what he is saying. I can't say nothing (which is what he says that he wants me to do) because he gets angry and repeats what he wants to say until I respond. Should I literally say "I'm not very interested in that"? This seems so dismissive to a 5 year old. But maybe that's what he wants.

Hughs · 09/11/2023 10:41

TheBirdintheCave · 09/11/2023 10:35

@Hughs Samesies here. I'm Autistic and husband is ADHD. I'm the one who interrupts in our house though he does go off on wild tangents haha.

Yes in reality that thing I wrote would have been twice as long, with random fascinating interruptions like "do you think this kettle takes ages to boil" and "did I ever tell you about when I wanted to learn the trombone in school and they wouldn't let me" (yes) and "I just can't decide who the best boxer of all time is, what do you think?" etc etc etc

TheBirdintheCave · 09/11/2023 10:35

@Hughs Samesies here. I'm Autistic and husband is ADHD. I'm the one who interrupts in our house though he does go off on wild tangents haha.

Hughs · 09/11/2023 10:27

TheBirdintheCave · 09/11/2023 10:16

@Hughs Yeesh, that sounds so frustrating.

It makes us laugh now that we understand it but over the years we have had a lot of rows over him reacting to something he has wrongly inferred.

I'm autistic and we think he has ADHD, so very different styles of communication. He interrupts and goes off at tangents all the time which I find very discombobulating.
My diagnosis made all the difference though, we understand it better now and are a lot more tolerant of each other.

TheBirdintheCave · 09/11/2023 10:16

@Hughs Yeesh, that sounds so frustrating.

Hughs · 09/11/2023 10:12

A typical example in our house:

Me: what time do you think you'll be back?

DH: hang on a minute, we talked about this and I said I'd be out late and you said it was fine

Me: yes it is fine, I was just wondering what time you'll be back

DH: haha well it won't be any time soon, I haven't even left yet hahaha

Me: hm ok so what time do you reckon then

DH: well I've got to drive there and then do the thing and then get back haven't I?

Me: yes, so any idea what time you might be back?

DH: don't worry I'll go straight there and back, no popping into the pub hahaha

Me: ok, so what time then

DH: well it will be lateish I think

Me: WILL YOU PLEASE USE A NUMBER

DH: oh sorry, probably around 10. I'll text if it's going to be after 11

Me: ok thanks
[goes for a lie down]

Hughs · 09/11/2023 10:00

crackofdoom · 07/11/2023 22:28

Frequently. They answer what they think you are implying by asking that question, rather than just answer the question.
And they think we're the weird ones 🙄

⬆️

This, all day long.

GoodnightGentlemen · 09/11/2023 09:32

Hotandsunny · 09/11/2023 09:21

I love this example - this is definitely my ND DC if I say no to pizza! 😂

😂 I honestly must go through this exact conversation at least one a week- he is bloody obsessed with pizza!

Hotandsunny · 09/11/2023 09:28

BettyBakesCakes · 09/11/2023 09:24

I also find I sometime say something and a nt person will claim I've said something else, even when it's in written form and that's literally not what I wrote. Happens all the time on here. And they say WE have communication problems! I'm not so sure lol.

Yes, as I said up thread I've often been told on here I mean all sorts of things when that wasn't what I wrote. I literally mean what I write!

OP posts:
Hotandsunny · 09/11/2023 09:26

PriOn1 · 09/11/2023 09:22

Yes, I apologize for not reading the whole thread before responding! Obviously your question was wholly appropriate in the circumstances and you were successful. The situations were different. I was good friends with my (probably) autistic colleague, believe it or not. I probably came across as wholly unsupportive but was trying to describe my experience.

I'm pretty sure we're all guilty of not reading a whole thread quite often!

And I appreciate you describing your experience from your viewpoint as it's really useful to understand your reasoning.

OP posts:
BettyBakesCakes · 09/11/2023 09:24

I also find I sometime say something and a nt person will claim I've said something else, even when it's in written form and that's literally not what I wrote. Happens all the time on here. And they say WE have communication problems! I'm not so sure lol.

PriOn1 · 09/11/2023 09:22

Hotandsunny · 09/11/2023 09:17

It's the panel that make the decision not the school. I'm meant to ask the school questions.

I think the thing is when you are autistic you do see all the details/complexities of a situation opposed to ND people see the overall picture. And without being given information on the details it is hard to really understand the overall picture.

So I think in my situation maybe someone NT would have looked at the rooms list and thought oh a good proportion of the rooms are under 60m so the school may struggle for space or whatever conclusion they may draw. But for me I look at that list and I think 'what proportion are under 60?' 'which rooms need more space but for fewer children e.g food tech?', 'how many pupils will be using the communal space?' 'can the smaller groups in 6th form use these small rooms?'

Yes, I apologize for not reading the whole thread before responding! Obviously your question was wholly appropriate in the circumstances and you were successful. The situations were different. I was good friends with my (probably) autistic colleague, believe it or not. I probably came across as wholly unsupportive but was trying to describe my experience.

Hotandsunny · 09/11/2023 09:21

GoodnightGentlemen · 09/11/2023 07:48

@PriOn1 she was probably just wanting to know exactly why the answer was no, and could think of several factors that could affect the decision so wanted to know if/how those factors affected it.

Also, she probably wasn’t trying to brow beat of manipulate a different answer, but rather just seeing if the reasons for ‘no’ could be overcome.

so question
“can I have pizza for dinner?”
“no”.
“Why not?”
“it’s too expensive and you had one already this week”.

some people think this is the end of the discussion- but it doesn’t actually resolve the questions.

so money wise:

”can I have it if I pay for it from my pocket money?”
”can I have it if I have a smaller/cheaper option than usual?”
”could we go halves on the cost?”
”how come I was allowed 2 takeaways last week?”

is it because it’s unhealthy?:

”can I have it if I agree not to have one next week?”
”can I have one if I don’t have chips with it so it’s healthier?”
”can I have it if I don’t have pudding so it’s healthier?”

All of that needs to be discussed before you have a full answer to seemingly a simple question.

I love this example - this is definitely my ND DC if I say no to pizza! 😂

OP posts:
BettyBakesCakes · 09/11/2023 09:20

crackofdoom · 07/11/2023 22:28

Frequently. They answer what they think you are implying by asking that question, rather than just answer the question.
And they think we're the weird ones 🙄

This 😃

Hotandsunny · 09/11/2023 09:19

PriOn1 · 09/11/2023 07:24

Well, OP, now I’ve read all your replies and it would appear I inadvertently proved that the answer to your original question was “yes”.

So it appears that your looking for loopholes in their argument was exactly the task you were meant to be doing in the circumstances and you were successful, which is hopefully good for your daughter.

Ha ha, yes, it is what you have to do! And yes, hopefully my DD will settle in quickly at her new school.

OP posts:
PriOn1 · 09/11/2023 09:17

Yes @GoodnightGentlemen I completely messed up with my first response and accept that part of the problem with my colleague was misunderstanding. I did get better at dealing with it. Often the answer was that it affected other people too much and it would (justifiably) piss them off. I had to be honest about that and just say so, though it wasn’t popular. The staff member struggled with lots of things she had to do as part of her job, but didn’t have a diagnosis (I think perhaps because the system was poor - my own child was diagnosed as a child, which was much easier) so we were in a difficult position when it came to reasonable adjustments.

I thought, having read the whole thread that the OP was maybe right about the new teacher being out of her depth. She may have known that if she answered truthfully that the OP would be found to have a point - and also know that she would be unpopular if she lost the appeal.

Life is often filled with shades of grey we can only guess at.

Hotandsunny · 09/11/2023 09:17

This reply has been deleted

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

It's the panel that make the decision not the school. I'm meant to ask the school questions.

I think the thing is when you are autistic you do see all the details/complexities of a situation opposed to ND people see the overall picture. And without being given information on the details it is hard to really understand the overall picture.

So I think in my situation maybe someone NT would have looked at the rooms list and thought oh a good proportion of the rooms are under 60m so the school may struggle for space or whatever conclusion they may draw. But for me I look at that list and I think 'what proportion are under 60?' 'which rooms need more space but for fewer children e.g food tech?', 'how many pupils will be using the communal space?' 'can the smaller groups in 6th form use these small rooms?'

OP posts:
Hotandsunny · 09/11/2023 09:06

InattentiveADHD · 09/11/2023 03:15

No she doesn't. She's just communicating clearly and explaining her point in the face of loads of NTs who are telling an autistic person they are communicating incorrectly simply because they ask clear questions and want clear answers to the question asked. Honestly the responses on this thread have made it really clear why ND people find society so bloody difficult. NTs are supposed to be good at this and find it easy so why can't you adjust a little to allow some other, slightly different, but not unreasonable ways of communicating into the mix. There's literally no movement on your side. Do it our way or fuck off!!

(Not including the PP who does try to make adjustments- thank you! - but sadly you seem to be in the minority!)

Yes, there's definitely almost a moral judgement against us for communicating differently from the NT or for needing to know what is happening etc.

OP posts:
Hotandsunny · 09/11/2023 09:00

TwoShades1 · 09/11/2023 01:40

I have to say you sound quite difficult and fixated from this thread. Im quite glad I don’t work at your child’s new school, I feel like you will be one of those parents that’s always asking for “more information” or clarification. There’s always one that wants to know precisely what their child will be eating on Tuesday lunchtime of the biology trip that’s still months away.

I've actually always had a great relationship with all my Dd's teachers. I admit I can be difficult in certain situations i.e when I feel I'm not being listened to, but I never felt like that at DD's school.

Have you not thought that parents of ND children need time to prepare their DC for new experiences?

If parents are asking for clarification maybe you haven't been clear? I have to say my Dd's old school were always very clear with their communication so I didn't need to ask for clarification.

OP posts:
GoodnightGentlemen · 09/11/2023 07:48

@PriOn1 she was probably just wanting to know exactly why the answer was no, and could think of several factors that could affect the decision so wanted to know if/how those factors affected it.

Also, she probably wasn’t trying to brow beat of manipulate a different answer, but rather just seeing if the reasons for ‘no’ could be overcome.

so question
“can I have pizza for dinner?”
“no”.
“Why not?”
“it’s too expensive and you had one already this week”.

some people think this is the end of the discussion- but it doesn’t actually resolve the questions.

so money wise:

”can I have it if I pay for it from my pocket money?”
”can I have it if I have a smaller/cheaper option than usual?”
”could we go halves on the cost?”
”how come I was allowed 2 takeaways last week?”

is it because it’s unhealthy?:

”can I have it if I agree not to have one next week?”
”can I have one if I don’t have chips with it so it’s healthier?”
”can I have it if I don’t have pudding so it’s healthier?”

All of that needs to be discussed before you have a full answer to seemingly a simple question.