Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

If you are autistic do people often not answer the question you are asking but give a more generalised answer?

389 replies

Hotandsunny · 07/11/2023 22:20

Just a thought that came to mind. I often find when I ask people questions about something very specific they don't seem to get it and just give you a general answer. I don't know what it is. But I have oftenish been in a situation where people just don't seem to understand what you are asking. So I was wondering if it was an autistic thing.

The example from today was I was doing a school appeal and the school had sent a list of rooms and room sizes as evidence that the school was full. I tried to question the school about what the different rooms were used for, about class sizes and what rooms the 6th form used. All the deputy head could do was repeat that Y7 was full.

I say you haven't answered my question and ask again and get the same reply. A member of the panel says to me I just don't like the reply I'm getting. I don't, because it doesn't answer my question.

This isn't an isolated incident by a long shot.

OP posts:
XDownwiththissortofthingX · 07/11/2023 23:23

Tukmgru · 07/11/2023 23:16

@XDownwiththissortofthingX
a) love your name on here
b) why aren’t you suggesting the time to go out? In this scenario why is it on your interlocutor? Why can’t you ask ‘why don’t we go out at 6?’ Rather than demanding they give a precise answer when they might feel you’re putting them on the spot. Idk, if you’re this direct I’d be worried you’d get annoyed with the answer I gave unless I showed my working, and would probably also think out loud 🤷

to respond to b) -

I probably sound a lot more like a tyrant than I am in reality. It's just a particular bugbear than when I ask a very simple, succinct, direct question that only ever requires a very succinct answer, people commonly go off on a tangent and provide a whole load of irrelevant information, and ultimately don't even answer what was a very straightforward and simple request 😄

I don't always leave every decision to everyone else. If I think it's perfectly appropriate for me to take the decision I'll say something along the lines of "I planned for us to leave at 6. Is that ok?", so again, there's an inherent invitation to discuss there, whereas when I say "what time are we leaving?" I'm implying that I don't particularly have any preference and I'm happy to do whatever the other party has decided.

I don't have a problem at all with "I haven't thought about it, what do you think?" as that's a perfectly reasonable response. It's the "well my mum usually gets home at 3 and feeds the cats......" FFS, I didn't ask about your mum or her bloody cats!!! 😂

Bruisername · 07/11/2023 23:21

XDownwiththissortofthingX · 07/11/2023 23:15

Yes, because that is a clear, unambiguous request for a specific piece of information, i.e. a time, so there's no reason to conclude it's a request to enter into a discussion.

"What time do you think we should go out at?" is a request to open up a discuission.

bit Why is it their responsibility to decide? Why not you? So, shall we leave at 6? Or even, we should leave at 6.

what if it is their decision but they haven’t decided yet or they’re not sure?

human interactions can’t always be black and white

Hotandsunny · 07/11/2023 23:20

Bruisername · 07/11/2023 22:39

No - it’s a way of saying your question is irrelevant and doesn’t need to be answered

Well, honestly what's the point of an appeal if they can just avoid any questions by pretending they are irrelevant (or maybe they really believe it). I wonder what the teacher would have thought it if I said her questions to me were irrelevant.

OP posts:
Superbroom · 07/11/2023 23:20

Hotandsunny · 07/11/2023 22:45

But part of the process is that parents can ask questions. If they don't want to answer questions then why ask parents to ask them? Also why would there be an argument if they answer the question that has been asked. Surely the argument comes when they refuse to answer a question asked of them at an official hearing?

What rooms sixth form used was not immaterial as the 6th form was 100 pupils undersubscribed. They had made their argument based on rooms so therefore I would have thought they could expect questions on this?

Why do you want to know how the rooms are allocated, if not to challenge the way the school operates.
Surely you don’t want to know just for the sake of knowing ?

Katbum · 07/11/2023 23:20

They are avoiding answering that question, as they don’t want to go down the inevitable path where the answer to that question will lead. If those rooms were empty and they tell you that, they then have to have a pointless conversation about why year 7 is still, none the less, full (beyond rooms there is likely capped funding for forced intake/limited teacher budget/not room in the timetable etc). General answers or different answers are an attempt to direct or close down conversation - cues that NT would understand signal ‘this is now done’

Hotandsunny · 07/11/2023 23:17

MadeOfAllWork · 07/11/2023 22:37

I understand what you are asking, but when you want to get a child into year 7 it doesn’t matter how big the 6th form room is. People don’t answer questions that are irrelevant.

It’s like if you asked me if you could have a lift somewhere and said that you couldn’t because the car was full, and then you asked what colour my car is. It doesn’t matter to the problem in hand so why would I answer.

The point is there were no specific 6th form rooms. They used classrooms all over the school. I wouldn't have asked the question if it didn't matter.

So to explain simply

Some of the classrooms were smaller however they can be fully utilised by the small 6th form classes, by small SEND groups and small lower set classes.

OP posts:
Tukmgru · 07/11/2023 23:16

XDownwiththissortofthingX · 07/11/2023 23:10

Perhaps, but I'm not trying to come to an agreement, I'm simply requesting a piece of salient information.

"What time are we" is a wholly different question to "what time shall we", which I would ask if I wanted to get into a discussion. Like I said, I'm very specific with language for good reason because I don't want to leave room for ambiguity. The problem is other people ignoring the unambiguous language and supplying information I didn't request in the first place.

@XDownwiththissortofthingX
a) love your name on here
b) why aren’t you suggesting the time to go out? In this scenario why is it on your interlocutor? Why can’t you ask ‘why don’t we go out at 6?’ Rather than demanding they give a precise answer when they might feel you’re putting them on the spot. Idk, if you’re this direct I’d be worried you’d get annoyed with the answer I gave unless I showed my working, and would probably also think out loud 🤷

XDownwiththissortofthingX · 07/11/2023 23:15

Bruisername · 07/11/2023 23:12

But if you ask ‘what time are we going out?’ Is it always clear cut that the time you are going out is the other persons responsibility?

Yes, because that is a clear, unambiguous request for a specific piece of information, i.e. a time, so there's no reason to conclude it's a request to enter into a discussion.

"What time do you think we should go out at?" is a request to open up a discuission.

BannedfromChristmas · 07/11/2023 23:15

They probably have a million and one other things to be doing and don't understandably want to gave you scrutinising their use of rooms. I'm not quite sure how you think the capacity of the sixth form room is relevant though?
Schools timetable different groups in different rooms according to capacity and year group they are nit going to re timetable tge entire school so its a complete non argument. Just because you want your child in the school doesn't mean you will be able berate them into it.
Maybe a backup plan is required:)

cardibach · 07/11/2023 23:14

XDownwiththissortofthingX · 07/11/2023 23:10

Perhaps, but I'm not trying to come to an agreement, I'm simply requesting a piece of salient information.

"What time are we" is a wholly different question to "what time shall we", which I would ask if I wanted to get into a discussion. Like I said, I'm very specific with language for good reason because I don't want to leave room for ambiguity. The problem is other people ignoring the unambiguous language and supplying information I didn't request in the first place.

They aren’t ignoring it. They just aren’t noticing it. For a NT person, although they are obviously aware that ‘when shall we’ and ‘when are we’ are grammatically slightly different, the two questions are the same in practical ways. They want to involve you in the decision, not dictate it.

Bruisername · 07/11/2023 23:12

But if you ask ‘what time are we going out?’ Is it always clear cut that the time you are going out is the other persons responsibility?

ithinkthatmaybeimdreaming · 07/11/2023 23:11

I agree, they didn't answer your question because it isn't relevant. They've told you there is no space, end of. I imagine they really don't want to get into an argument about it. Why won't you just accept their decision?

It's nothing to do with you being autistic btw.

XDownwiththissortofthingX · 07/11/2023 23:10

cardibach · 07/11/2023 23:06

The person is thinking aloud and sharing their thought process with you so you can agree a time together. If you understand other things that are going on you can see the range of times possible for your activity then chime in your own limitations.

Perhaps, but I'm not trying to come to an agreement, I'm simply requesting a piece of salient information.

"What time are we" is a wholly different question to "what time shall we", which I would ask if I wanted to get into a discussion. Like I said, I'm very specific with language for good reason because I don't want to leave room for ambiguity. The problem is other people ignoring the unambiguous language and supplying information I didn't request in the first place.

Bedofroses2 · 07/11/2023 23:09

People communicate using maxims of conversation that make it successful or unsuccessful. If one party believes the other is labouring an irrelevant point, the communication breaks down and becomes uncooperative on both sides.

The question about sixth form rooms is irrelevant, unless your child is joining a sixth form class. A smaller cohort does not necessarily mean fewer lessons or classrooms being used, whether there are 10 or 25 in an A Level Biology class they still need a classroom and a teacher for each lesson. Capacity in sixth form does not make space for a year 7, if all of the year 7 classes are full.

EmmaEmerald · 07/11/2023 23:09

Hotandsunny · 07/11/2023 22:51

So it was a tactic? They'd waste the question time allowed by avoiding answering questions so they didn't get to be scrutinized?

Yes

And the room size thing might be their tactic to avoid other questions.

it sounds like you are expecting efficiency and logic from professionals. No experience of schools but logic and professionalism seem to be at an all time low in 2023.

cardibach · 07/11/2023 23:08

WillowCraft · 07/11/2023 23:01

A lot of people also struggle with reading comprehension (as seen from this site and even this thread, the number of people saying that room sizes are not relevant to your situation when it clearly states in the OP that this is the exact reason the school has provided for being unable to meet your request). That could explain written questions not being answered.

No, the rooms and room sizes were to show the school is full, not the year group. They help to show that they can’t accommodate another Y7 class, for both rooming and staffing reasons (the staff being busy teaching the other years too).

cardibach · 07/11/2023 23:06

XDownwiththissortofthingX · 07/11/2023 23:02

It's why I don't tolerate it or entertain it when people start rambling in response.

The question was not an invitation to begin a broader conversation, as it didn't ask something subjective. If I want to instigate a conversation I can ask something along the lines of "what do you think about xxx?"

The question "What time is/are we?" only has one relevant answer, i.e. a time of the day, and anything else is irrelevant waffle that I'm neither interested in or willing to sit through. Just respond to the direct question with an appropriate, relevant answer. That's all I want. What is so bloody difficult?

The person is thinking aloud and sharing their thought process with you so you can agree a time together. If you understand other things that are going on you can see the range of times possible for your activity then chime in your own limitations.

cardibach · 07/11/2023 23:04

But rooming isn’t the reason you can’t have more in Y7 surely? If it’s full it’ll mean the x number of classes in the year all have the max number they want in them (say 32). You can’t add another one even if you have a room, because that would mean more staff, and they can’t afford to staff a whole new Y7 class. If they could, they would have one.

Bruisername · 07/11/2023 23:03

Hotandsunny · 07/11/2023 23:02

But I'm talking about situations like today. Where there is an expectation that an answer is given. Or like at formal meeting at my son's college. The point being to get my queries answered. Why do people put themselves in these situations if they don't want to answer questions?

You believe your question is deserving of an answer. They do not. In some cases you may be right and in other cases they may be.

Hotandsunny · 07/11/2023 23:03

PestilencialCrisis · 07/11/2023 22:33

My sister does this regularly! I find it infuriating! Eg. I'll ask "what time are we going out?" And she'll say "DH is getting home at 6" and I'll say that doesn't answer the question (are we going out the second her DH is getting home? Are we having a cuppa while he gets changed and ready? Is anyone else coming here first? Have you booked a table for a particular time? I don't know!!!)

Or I'll say "where shall we go for dinner?" And she'll reply "I had quite a big lunch" (That doesn't answer the question!!!!)

I have dozens of these examples and they make me loopy. I don't think it is to do with autism though, just a difference in communication styles.

This doesn't seem like the same thing I'm talking about, tbh.

OP posts:
XDownwiththissortofthingX · 07/11/2023 23:02

Hotandsunny · 07/11/2023 22:57

Yes, I ask a very precise question because I want a precise answer. If I wanted the answer you are giving me I would have asked that question! I did keep asking my question and trying to explain it in different ways. But as a previous poster said people seem to imagine in their head you're asking something different and they answer that. Then they get fed up and claim they have answered you multiple times. When they have only answered their imaginary question.

It's why I don't tolerate it or entertain it when people start rambling in response.

The question was not an invitation to begin a broader conversation, as it didn't ask something subjective. If I want to instigate a conversation I can ask something along the lines of "what do you think about xxx?"

The question "What time is/are we?" only has one relevant answer, i.e. a time of the day, and anything else is irrelevant waffle that I'm neither interested in or willing to sit through. Just respond to the direct question with an appropriate, relevant answer. That's all I want. What is so bloody difficult?

TheYearOfSmallThings · 07/11/2023 23:02

Yes, I ask a very precise question because I want a precise answer.

The thing is, people don't have to communicate on your terms. You could ask a thousand questions about room size, and they could waste a lot of time answering questions that will have no bearing on the outcome, or they can fob you off rather than get into that cycle.

Bruisername · 07/11/2023 23:02

mimblewimble · 07/11/2023 22:54

Hi OP, I have an autistic child and this sounds quite familiar to me but from the other side. He often gets frustrated with me because I have not answered his questions.

From my perspective, he asks a lot of questions about very specific details, which I don't always have the energy or headspace to answer and which to me seem irrelevant to the situation.

When he pushes it, it feels as if he is trying to corner me or get me to slip up on some detail so he can prove a point. However, he maintains that he just likes to/needs to know information so that he understands.

Yes my ADHD child can be like this. It can be quite exhausting sometimes and it can feel like a lot of demands are being made of me and that I don’t get a break.

Hotandsunny · 07/11/2023 23:02

Bruisername · 07/11/2023 22:37

I would say in your sisters case she is starting a conversation - so you ask where you are going for dinner and she says she had a big lunch so you would then say ‘so shall we go to the ‘light food’ place and she says probably but I really fancy Indian food etc

it’s a different form of communication

on the OP - not all questions deserve an answer and no one owes you an answer so when they answer the way you suggest, they are just trying to shut things down because they don’t want to continue that conversation (not necessarily your example though - generally)

But I'm talking about situations like today. Where there is an expectation that an answer is given. Or like at formal meeting at my son's college. The point being to get my queries answered. Why do people put themselves in these situations if they don't want to answer questions?

OP posts:
Eggscellent · 07/11/2023 23:02

I agree with the asking of the question and understand why you wanted the answer as it was your way in. I would also be massively frustrated by this as I it seems so black and white, I ask a question and they are not answering it at all and really just causing more confusion.

I don't think the handling of the situation was inclusive for you or for anyone who maybe neurodiverse. I have ADHD and I would become very infuriated by the this and how I was not able to represent my case because they clearly refused to answer the question in any meaningful way or without adding confusion into the situation.

It doesn't matter if they think it's an irrelevant question, they should have stated this rather than just repeating the same answer.