Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

If you are autistic do people often not answer the question you are asking but give a more generalised answer?

389 replies

Hotandsunny · 07/11/2023 22:20

Just a thought that came to mind. I often find when I ask people questions about something very specific they don't seem to get it and just give you a general answer. I don't know what it is. But I have oftenish been in a situation where people just don't seem to understand what you are asking. So I was wondering if it was an autistic thing.

The example from today was I was doing a school appeal and the school had sent a list of rooms and room sizes as evidence that the school was full. I tried to question the school about what the different rooms were used for, about class sizes and what rooms the 6th form used. All the deputy head could do was repeat that Y7 was full.

I say you haven't answered my question and ask again and get the same reply. A member of the panel says to me I just don't like the reply I'm getting. I don't, because it doesn't answer my question.

This isn't an isolated incident by a long shot.

OP posts:
PlantMum23 · 07/11/2023 23:50

Op, I think you are getting caught up by what it means for a school to be “full”

Yes, I could theoretically cram some
more kids into some of my classes. However, the classes with “room” in them might have a higher proportion of kids with ASN (who would be negatively impacted by a larger class size)
There is probably enough rooms in the school to throw in a full other class, by splitting up current classes. However, we are already working at our maximum number of contact periods, therefore it wouldn’t be possible to staff it.
Rooms also have different purposes. I could probably take my older kids to a smaller room; however the technical resources I need for my lesson are in my classroom - and I also use it with another lot of pupils where the class size is too large to use the smaller room
(and the equipment is large and heavy, so can’t be moved safely)
It is also on my risk assessment that I’m only allowed to teach on the same floor as my classroom due to an injury.

XDownwiththissortofthingX · 07/11/2023 23:49

@EveSix

Perfect examples of what I'm describing 😃

You could have answered question 1 with "Yes", and question 2 just as succinctly, so neither me nor your DP can comprehend the need for you to "show your workings", it's just needless brain-clutter and waffle to us

RelationshipOrNot · 07/11/2023 23:49

daylightplease · 07/11/2023 23:46

In terms of answering questions it is also important to understand the power dynamics.

You want something that a state resource has.
This gives them more power in the conversation, they have a wanted thing and they are a state backed body.

It is socially expected that that the person with the most power in the conversation will have more control over it.

I also really agree with this and forgot to include it in my reply! It has taken me DECADES to understand that not everyone is "allowed" an equal say in all meetings or situations, and even now having thought about it a lot, I still slip up in the heat of the moment.

Hotandsunny · 07/11/2023 23:48

tescocreditcard · 07/11/2023 22:52

They don't' have to answer your question. it's not a legal requirement.

Having said that, I don't think autism has anything to do with it. It happens A LOT. I think some people just love to hear themselves speak.

So what's the point of the appeal if the school refuse to engage in it?

OP posts:
feedyourheed · 07/11/2023 23:46

I have this all the time, so much so that I've mentioned it to others to see if it happens to them.

A good example of when it happens to me is in an academic setting, say at uni. Others will ask a question and the tutor answers what they asked. I ask a question (very specific and nuanced) and they NEVER answer what I am actually asking about. I used to try to clarify, and clarify but they never 'get' it. So frustrating.

It's like people have an idea of what they think I am asking and answer that instead of thinking about the very precise thing I am querying. But it doesn't seem to happen to others, so I have to think it's just me (strong ASD traits with 2 autistic children here).

There are lots of other examples, and usually it's people doing a job rather than family that misunderstand me. It also happens when I write a post about something and people pick up on something I didn't even mean or imply. I get tired of trying to say - no, you're wrong. I didn't say nor mean that.

daylightplease · 07/11/2023 23:46

In terms of answering questions it is also important to understand the power dynamics.

You want something that a state resource has.
This gives them more power in the conversation, they have a wanted thing and they are a state backed body.

It is socially expected that that the person with the most power in the conversation will have more control over it.

Fionaville · 07/11/2023 23:44

XDownwiththissortofthingX · 07/11/2023 23:35

I can empathise entirely with your son when it pertains to a matter that I've decided IS actually wholly important. The agenda becomes all-consuming and I need to know specifics, so someone waffling or going off plan is not just a source of irritation, but it makes me extremely uncomfortable, and if I don't check it straightaway and let it fester it usually leads to meltdowns/shutdowns. I'm getting better at dealing with the foibles of neurotypicals as I get older, but it's still not easy.

I know this sort of autistic behaviour and thinking must sound mad to people who don't share the same thought patterns, but conversely, I find people who make long term career plans, or think about going to university when they are in early teens, or want to get married and have children when they 'grow up' utterly daft because you could well get hit by a bus tomorrow, and what's happening an hour from now seems far more pertinent, no?

I don't disagree with you. I'm not a planner at all and actually hate to be pinned down by a schedule or plans. So as you can imagine, life in our house can be fun at times!
We are adapting to our differences with give and take. I try to have a rough schedule for him, which is harder now hes an adult. And I make the effort to have the answer to "What's for tea tonight?" at 8am 😅 And he's learning to understand that I can't always give him an exact answer. I've explained to him that sometimes I'm worried about giving him an answer when plans might change, because it aggravates him. Which he accepts a lot of the time now. He's also getting more accepting of an 'ish' time. We are muddling through together.

Totaly · 07/11/2023 23:44

Because OP you are being a dog with a bone! People have given you reasons why this might be the case and yet the only question you are asking - we can’t actually answer, you’ve framed it like a general question when you want a specific answer.

Why didn’t they answer? We don’t know - not it could be …. Yet still you keep asking the same questions

Teachers understand autism, they really do, and they k ow that if they say X you’ll argue Y.

But you don’t want that answer.

like PP said, school is full, there’s too many children and not enough rooms, or teachers or budgets, or other staff, no money for supplies.

100 less 6th formers doesn’t not make the school less full. 6th form is a different budget and a different curriculum-

If shop A is only using half its floor space or doesn’t give shop B the right to use the other half. Even if 6th form isn’t using ‘their’ areas doesn’t mean you can.

Hotandsunny · 07/11/2023 23:43

WillowCraft · 07/11/2023 22:51

The school started it by sending a list of rooms and class sizes to justify why they were full... Your example isn't right, it should be more like saying "I can't give you a lift as my car is full because I have a load of long planks in the passenger seat" and the other person then says "is there still space in the back" and the first person just replies "I haven't got space for you" instead of directly answering the question. The reason they are evading the question is that they don't want to give you a lift!

I find it often happens when people are defensive and trying to pre empt criticism... Or sometimes they just aren't listening .

Yes, this is exactly it. I think the school teacher was being very defensive and I assume found it quite hard. I'm not sure how much was being a bit sly like deliberately not answering to cover things up or if she was just genuinely out of her depth.

OP posts:
RelationshipOrNot · 07/11/2023 23:40

XDownwiththissortofthingX · 07/11/2023 23:35

I can empathise entirely with your son when it pertains to a matter that I've decided IS actually wholly important. The agenda becomes all-consuming and I need to know specifics, so someone waffling or going off plan is not just a source of irritation, but it makes me extremely uncomfortable, and if I don't check it straightaway and let it fester it usually leads to meltdowns/shutdowns. I'm getting better at dealing with the foibles of neurotypicals as I get older, but it's still not easy.

I know this sort of autistic behaviour and thinking must sound mad to people who don't share the same thought patterns, but conversely, I find people who make long term career plans, or think about going to university when they are in early teens, or want to get married and have children when they 'grow up' utterly daft because you could well get hit by a bus tomorrow, and what's happening an hour from now seems far more pertinent, no?

Agreed. Becoming upset and shutting down because of plans going off-kilter is such a point of stress in my life, and no amount of rationalising can stop it happening. I guess if I could rationally think my way out of being autistic, I wouldn't be autistic anymore.

EveSix · 07/11/2023 23:39

My, this thread is eye-opening.

DP (ND) can be like this at times of heightened anxiety; asking very specific questions and expecting answers which fall precisely within his expected parameters. He gets bothered if, within the first couple of syllables of responding, it looks like an answer might be other than expected.

Example:

DP: "Are we going out straight after Dan comes home from football?"

Expected answer: yes or no.

Usual context: Dan always comes home from football at 18:30.

New, unknown to DP, development: Dan's lift has bailed so he'll be walking home, ETA 19:00.

Reasonable reply by me: "Dan just messaged me. His lift has bailed so he'll be walking home, ETA 19:00. We'll leave straight after that."

DP: (usually by the time I've hit the 3rd unexpected word) "Oh my days, just 'yes' or 'no', that's aaaaaall I ask! exasperated sigh", failing to take in the change of circumstance.

Lots of situations like these:
"Are we taking the A59 or shall we go up Houghton Way?"
(I've checked traffic updates and seen delays which promt considering a 3rd route, so I venture:)
"I've just checked the AA traffic updates, and as there are severe delays on both those routes, I'd suggest -"
"Jeesus, what is wrong with just answering the question the way I've asked it!? A59 or Houghton Way!?", again missing relevant information.

It is a deep reluctance to acknowledge that communication is a two-way process where both parties, unless one is under interrogation in a witness box, are able to respond with a reasonable degree of autonomy. I get furious with him -I don't owe him comms compliance-, but remind myself that he processes language so differently to anyone I know (paradoxically, he's an inspired lyricist and poet).

Hotandsunny · 07/11/2023 23:39

Bruisername · 07/11/2023 22:49

Just because you can ask a question doesn’t mean they have to answer though. They didn’t think it was a relevant question so they didn’t answer it

So at an official hearing you can just avoid answering any questions by pretending they are all irrelevant. Wow. I didn't do that with the questions I was asked, I answered them all honestly. A couple seemed irrelevant to me but I assume had some relevance as otherwise why would they ask me the question?

OP posts:
RelationshipOrNot · 07/11/2023 23:37

I am autistic, and have, many times, asked questions or made statements that turned out not to be appropriate, or were viewed as rude or overstepping the mark.

My interpretation of this situation, which may or may not be correct, and am happy to be set straight by neurotypical people, is this:

They are confident in their expertise with regard to assessing the capacity of their school. They see you asking these questions as an outsider trying to tell them how to do something which they have knowledgeable about and have experience of; they see the questions you're asking as information-gathering in advance of an attack on a system they have already decided works. They did not answer, therefore, because they didn't want to be in a position where they would feel like they had to justify and argue their decision-making regarding their area of expertise to an outsider, who has taken a couple of pieces of information and then decided they can see the whole picture "better" than them. I am not saying I agree with them, but I suspect their thought processes may have been something like this.

Hotandsunny · 07/11/2023 23:36

EmmaEmerald · 07/11/2023 22:47

OP "If they don't want to answer questions then why ask parents to ask them?"

it's good PR. Like places asking for feedback forms and never looking at them.

But it's an official school appeal hearing. Surely they have to follow procedure and answer questions?

OP posts:
XDownwiththissortofthingX · 07/11/2023 23:35

Fionaville · 07/11/2023 23:27

I have this problem with my autistic son. He'll ask me what time we are doing something and I can't always give a straight answer. Lots of things may need to fall in place for us to leave at X time. I can give a time we're aiming to leave, but I don't know. For example, what time are we leaving a family gathering/meal out. I can't answer that, because it depends on so many things. I've learned I have to be vague because if we don't leave at the exact time, then he gets anxious and annoyed, because in his head plans have changed.
As I've explained to him many times, life doesn't run to his requirements alone and he has to learn to be flexible and understand that people aren't robots. We don't always have the specific answers immediately, sometimes we need time to work it out and sometimes we just can't give it.

I can empathise entirely with your son when it pertains to a matter that I've decided IS actually wholly important. The agenda becomes all-consuming and I need to know specifics, so someone waffling or going off plan is not just a source of irritation, but it makes me extremely uncomfortable, and if I don't check it straightaway and let it fester it usually leads to meltdowns/shutdowns. I'm getting better at dealing with the foibles of neurotypicals as I get older, but it's still not easy.

I know this sort of autistic behaviour and thinking must sound mad to people who don't share the same thought patterns, but conversely, I find people who make long term career plans, or think about going to university when they are in early teens, or want to get married and have children when they 'grow up' utterly daft because you could well get hit by a bus tomorrow, and what's happening an hour from now seems far more pertinent, no?

Hipnotised · 07/11/2023 23:32

I don't ask a question if it's not relevant.

To you - it may be irrelevant to others. The issue is that you think x is important and expect it to be answered as such, directly and in the communication style you prefer.

You need to understand this is not everyone's style and it's not wrong to not give an x or y answer.

Shades of grey, not black and white and all that...

Hotandsunny · 07/11/2023 23:32

All2Well · 07/11/2023 22:44

I'm not autistic but I am neurodiverse and get frustrated when people don't answer the bloody question.

Example: What time are we leaving?

"Well, I've got to wash my hair and dry it and then Fred might want a lie in, he can get up anytime between 7 and 10, I dunno. He might want to go to the gym. And then Theo has a nap mid morning ish so best bet might be sometime after coffee but before lunch."

Is it that hard to just say 12 or whatever?

Is there anything in particular I can make for dinner, I need an idea for what to cook?

"I've been really off my food recently. I don't want anything with pork or creamy and I can't stand rice at the moment. I just feel really sick and everything is turning my stomach. Something small but filling. I'm off chicken. And beef. And fish. Nothing with gravy. So whatever you feel like making?

I end up feeling more stressed and for some reason saying, "Please just tell me exactly what I can make you that you'll eat.' either still doesn't get an answer or gets an upset/angry answer.

All that being said, I have also skirted around giving direct answers when people ask me questions I am not comfortable with. For example, strangers (usually men) who want to know exactly where I live...saying the town doesn't seem enough, they want to know what street. I'm not telling a stranger that. I'll say "near Big Sainsbury's" or "not far from the ambulance station" rather than "Oak Park Lane".

I think in your case, the answer seems irrelevant and unnecessarily time consuming for staff when you are appealing for a Year Seven place. Schools are busy, timetabling and room booking is a nightmarish jigsaw puzzle that could fall apart with the slightest change. From their perspective, it's a strange question and won't affect their decision.

So why send a list of rooms and room sizes as evidence of their case and then be surprised when people ask questions about it!

OP posts:
Hotandsunny · 07/11/2023 23:32

All2Well · 07/11/2023 22:44

I'm not autistic but I am neurodiverse and get frustrated when people don't answer the bloody question.

Example: What time are we leaving?

"Well, I've got to wash my hair and dry it and then Fred might want a lie in, he can get up anytime between 7 and 10, I dunno. He might want to go to the gym. And then Theo has a nap mid morning ish so best bet might be sometime after coffee but before lunch."

Is it that hard to just say 12 or whatever?

Is there anything in particular I can make for dinner, I need an idea for what to cook?

"I've been really off my food recently. I don't want anything with pork or creamy and I can't stand rice at the moment. I just feel really sick and everything is turning my stomach. Something small but filling. I'm off chicken. And beef. And fish. Nothing with gravy. So whatever you feel like making?

I end up feeling more stressed and for some reason saying, "Please just tell me exactly what I can make you that you'll eat.' either still doesn't get an answer or gets an upset/angry answer.

All that being said, I have also skirted around giving direct answers when people ask me questions I am not comfortable with. For example, strangers (usually men) who want to know exactly where I live...saying the town doesn't seem enough, they want to know what street. I'm not telling a stranger that. I'll say "near Big Sainsbury's" or "not far from the ambulance station" rather than "Oak Park Lane".

I think in your case, the answer seems irrelevant and unnecessarily time consuming for staff when you are appealing for a Year Seven place. Schools are busy, timetabling and room booking is a nightmarish jigsaw puzzle that could fall apart with the slightest change. From their perspective, it's a strange question and won't affect their decision.

So why send a list of rooms and room sizes as evidence of their case and then be surprised when people ask questions about it!

OP posts:
Hotandsunny · 07/11/2023 23:29

EmmaEmerald · 07/11/2023 22:43

In most cases, yes

in this particular case, it may be the questions you asked are irrelevant in terms of permitted student numbers.

No, my questions weren't irrelevant.

OP posts:
XDownwiththissortofthingX · 07/11/2023 23:28

DryRobeWanker · 07/11/2023 23:25

I do exactly what your sister does because I am dreadful at making decisions and giving times, I get a kind of brain block about it.
So in those examples I'm looking for the other person to suggest a time/somewhere to eat which enables me to move on and have a conversation about it.

Partner is the same. "What will we eat tonight?" would result in starvation all around. It drives me nuts, especially so when it's something that is ultimately inconsequential and they STILL can't make a decision, and then start waffling on about all sorts of stuff...

Hotandsunny · 07/11/2023 23:28

Fionaville · 07/11/2023 22:40

In this situation I think a general answer is acceptable. Listing what each room is used for would be both a waste of her time and a pointless exercise. The year is full. It doesn't matter which room is used for English and maths etc
My adult autistic son often asks me very specific questions that are pointless. Nothing that is going to gain any knowledge (I'll always find out how many dogs there are in the UK for example, because we are both information nerds) More things specific to his/our situations that are hard to answer and won't help. He gets very annoyed when I am vague. Even if I say "I dont know" he cant accept that and asks me to guess. But some questions just don't have an easy answer. I think perhaps it's an autistic issue around not getting the answer you want/a specific answer. Rather than a people being too general/vague problem.

Edited

I didn't ask her to list what each room was used for. But I asked do the 6th form have a specific area/set of rooms. They don't they use the whole school. Therefore 100 less pupils in sixth form will mean the corridors will be quieter than if they were at full capacity. How are the classes divided they are divided into 6 so this tells me 1 will be a class of 30 and the rest 29 so I could suggest there is a room for my DD. Just as an example.

I don't ask a question if it's not relevant.

OP posts:
Fionaville · 07/11/2023 23:27

XDownwiththissortofthingX · 07/11/2023 23:02

It's why I don't tolerate it or entertain it when people start rambling in response.

The question was not an invitation to begin a broader conversation, as it didn't ask something subjective. If I want to instigate a conversation I can ask something along the lines of "what do you think about xxx?"

The question "What time is/are we?" only has one relevant answer, i.e. a time of the day, and anything else is irrelevant waffle that I'm neither interested in or willing to sit through. Just respond to the direct question with an appropriate, relevant answer. That's all I want. What is so bloody difficult?

I have this problem with my autistic son. He'll ask me what time we are doing something and I can't always give a straight answer. Lots of things may need to fall in place for us to leave at X time. I can give a time we're aiming to leave, but I don't know. For example, what time are we leaving a family gathering/meal out. I can't answer that, because it depends on so many things. I've learned I have to be vague because if we don't leave at the exact time, then he gets anxious and annoyed, because in his head plans have changed.
As I've explained to him many times, life doesn't run to his requirements alone and he has to learn to be flexible and understand that people aren't robots. We don't always have the specific answers immediately, sometimes we need time to work it out and sometimes we just can't give it.

MyGooseisTotallyLoose · 07/11/2023 23:26

Hotandsunny · 07/11/2023 23:20

Well, honestly what's the point of an appeal if they can just avoid any questions by pretending they are irrelevant (or maybe they really believe it). I wonder what the teacher would have thought it if I said her questions to me were irrelevant.

I doubt she'd have cared. You're the one demanding a service from her employer.

DryRobeWanker · 07/11/2023 23:25

PestilencialCrisis · 07/11/2023 22:33

My sister does this regularly! I find it infuriating! Eg. I'll ask "what time are we going out?" And she'll say "DH is getting home at 6" and I'll say that doesn't answer the question (are we going out the second her DH is getting home? Are we having a cuppa while he gets changed and ready? Is anyone else coming here first? Have you booked a table for a particular time? I don't know!!!)

Or I'll say "where shall we go for dinner?" And she'll reply "I had quite a big lunch" (That doesn't answer the question!!!!)

I have dozens of these examples and they make me loopy. I don't think it is to do with autism though, just a difference in communication styles.

I do exactly what your sister does because I am dreadful at making decisions and giving times, I get a kind of brain block about it.
So in those examples I'm looking for the other person to suggest a time/somewhere to eat which enables me to move on and have a conversation about it.

CaramelMac · 07/11/2023 23:24

I would imagine in this situation the school are required to allow an appeal as a matter of policy, however there is no reason that they would accept to actually allow the appeal to be successful, so they don’t want to waste time by giving you information you can use to argue your point with them, because they will then have to find another way to justify saying no.