Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

If you are autistic do people often not answer the question you are asking but give a more generalised answer?

389 replies

Hotandsunny · 07/11/2023 22:20

Just a thought that came to mind. I often find when I ask people questions about something very specific they don't seem to get it and just give you a general answer. I don't know what it is. But I have oftenish been in a situation where people just don't seem to understand what you are asking. So I was wondering if it was an autistic thing.

The example from today was I was doing a school appeal and the school had sent a list of rooms and room sizes as evidence that the school was full. I tried to question the school about what the different rooms were used for, about class sizes and what rooms the 6th form used. All the deputy head could do was repeat that Y7 was full.

I say you haven't answered my question and ask again and get the same reply. A member of the panel says to me I just don't like the reply I'm getting. I don't, because it doesn't answer my question.

This isn't an isolated incident by a long shot.

OP posts:
EveSix · 08/11/2023 01:11

Thank you, Sage. It's easy to tie oneself in knots over communication as it's important to get it right when the stakes are high, as is often the case when anxiety is involved.
On the flip side, DP can occasionally decide he's in some kind of chatty flow-state of dazzling wit, and express dismay when I seem wooden, blunt and monosyllabic -I'm just trying to not f* up! Language processing differences at their finest.

Hotandsunny · 08/11/2023 01:07

Katbum · 07/11/2023 23:20

They are avoiding answering that question, as they don’t want to go down the inevitable path where the answer to that question will lead. If those rooms were empty and they tell you that, they then have to have a pointless conversation about why year 7 is still, none the less, full (beyond rooms there is likely capped funding for forced intake/limited teacher budget/not room in the timetable etc). General answers or different answers are an attempt to direct or close down conversation - cues that NT would understand signal ‘this is now done’

The trouble is they are making an argument based on room size so as the parent I have to question/argue against it. They were trying to avoid talking about how under capacity they are. But it's an important point as it effects all year groups. And the point is I have to argue that there is space for 1 more child - that is literally the point of the appeal.

OP posts:
pizzaHeart · 08/11/2023 01:07

Hotandsunny · 07/11/2023 22:47

Yes! And they almost start answering before you've finished! It's so weird!

I’ve got this all the time and I’m not autistic (as far as I know and DH swears that I’m not) I re read my draft emails with questions literally 10 times to make sure that there is no chance to assume anything different out of them. I do let it go often when I’ve got wishy washy answer but if I really need it, I dig further.
I think people do it for various reasons: they don’t want to give you information, they don’t know details, they don’t listen you properly and just react on a few key words.

I don’t think your question about use of rooms is irrelevant by the way, the numbers might show that they don’t use rooms optimally and can change the usage to get more students in year 7.

SageLavenderThyme · 08/11/2023 01:02

@EveSix sorry, didn't mean to imply you were not communicating effectively. I really meant some people prefer a much more extended version of what you were talking about, i.e. some people might give a lot more context to build to the point. Some people also prefer to hear all the context and get offended by a yes or no without a narrative.

DilemmaDelilah · 08/11/2023 01:01

@XDownwiththissortofthingX I'm exactly the same - people think I am pedantic but actually I find it very difficult to know what I should be doing without the correct information, and that distresses me. On the flip side - I now have a reputation at work for being able to bore down into the facts and to ascertain exactly what is necessary, so that we don't waste time doing things that don't need to be done. I am known for my attention to detail!

Disturbia81 · 08/11/2023 01:00

You say "meet her needs" so I assume she has additional needs. So it's not just adding 1 child to a class of 29.

Hotandsunny · 08/11/2023 01:00

BannedfromChristmas · 07/11/2023 23:15

They probably have a million and one other things to be doing and don't understandably want to gave you scrutinising their use of rooms. I'm not quite sure how you think the capacity of the sixth form room is relevant though?
Schools timetable different groups in different rooms according to capacity and year group they are nit going to re timetable tge entire school so its a complete non argument. Just because you want your child in the school doesn't mean you will be able berate them into it.
Maybe a backup plan is required:)

They may have other things to do but this is part of their job and is always going to involve discussing rooms. I suppose I would expect the teacher to act professionally. I would think the school would want her to do so too? As I've already said multiple times there are no 6th form rooms. They share rooms. I very much doubt they need to re timetable an entire school for one child. If it's a non-argument - why is it part of the appeal process? Why is the school asked to argue this point? Why is the parent asked to argue against it? Why do appeals get won on this point? Who have I berated??🤨

OP posts:
EveSix · 08/11/2023 00:59

debrianna, see my post re the PAN. They could just be full. Galling, OP, when named school says no, for whatever reason. Ensuring a suitable education for one's SEN child shouldn't have to be a fight. I'm doing the same -it's exhausting.

debbrianna · 08/11/2023 00:56

What if the one space you calculated went to another child during the same appeal process?

EveSix · 08/11/2023 00:54

Sage, I honestly try to keep things as terse and to the point as I can; I hardly call a short subordinate clause 'telling a story' (fwiw, DM and DSis do that, and it drives me potty).

I do often feel like I've been inadvertently 'set up' to fail by DP's rigidity of questioning. I sometimes have to say "I can't answer that question" when it's a closed question and one or both of the binaries is a wrong assumption on his part. Damned if I do, damned if I don't, he'll struggle either way.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 08/11/2023 00:53

ComtesseDeSpair · 07/11/2023 22:27

They understand what you’re asking but they view the questions as irrelevant: as far as they’re concerned they’ve told you the school doesn’t have the capacity to accept your DC. What rooms the sixth form uses is immaterial to that and they’re not willing to get into an argument with you over it.

Yes, people often answer questions in general terms, though I don’t have a problem with it particularly.

This.

SageLavenderThyme · 08/11/2023 00:53

@IBlinkThereforeIAm some people do. For example, if my mum asked me if she should visit tomorrow and I just said 'no', she would be offended. However, if I were to provide a long winded narrative around what I was doing and why I couldn't fit a visit in, she would be more satisfied with my answer, even though both mean 'no'.

debbrianna · 08/11/2023 00:53

IBlinkThereforeIAm · 08/11/2023 00:48

The person is thinking aloud and sharing their thought process with you so you can agree a time together

They weren't asked to share their stream of consciousness, though! Who wants to hear that?!

That's what a conversation is

Woman2023 · 08/11/2023 00:52

I do hope you win your appeal. I do get what you're saying about people not answering directly, I think most responses were trying to see if there was a reasonable explanation. It could just be the school being obstructive or them not explaining clearly what the problem is.

IBlinkThereforeIAm · 08/11/2023 00:48

The person is thinking aloud and sharing their thought process with you so you can agree a time together

They weren't asked to share their stream of consciousness, though! Who wants to hear that?!

Nepmarthiturn · 08/11/2023 00:45

The thing is, people don't have to communicate on your terms

I recommend autistic people repeat this back over and over again to NT people who moan about how we communicate.

Can't have it both ways... 😁

Ger1atricMillennial · 08/11/2023 00:45

Hotandsunny · 08/11/2023 00:41

Because that's what an appeal is. They have to present their case and I have to argue against it. They can't just say we are full end off.

Why am I appealing. I am having to home educate my DD as the school she was given can't meet her needs. This school can meet her needs and it is questionable if the should have let her in in the first place actually. But basically the effect of her not going to this school on her emotional well-being and my mental health is greater than the effect of adding one more child to a class of 29.

Its a difficult situation OP, but in this instance, it seems like their current decision is final. As admirable as it is that you are pushing for a good education for your child, asking for more and more detailed answers thinking you are going to get a "gotcha" moment is not a good way to build a relationship with this school.

Is there a way that you could develop a better relationship so you will be first on their list when a space does become available?

SageLavenderThyme · 08/11/2023 00:45

Another reason this could have happened was that the teacher didn't know all of the information, but just wanted to finish the meeting on one day, and didn't want to have continued back and forth about it?

I don't think that people are necessarily answering your direct questions in a general way because you are autistic. People do this a lot, I am not autistic and have noticed this frequently.

Some people also like to almost 'set the scene' or 'tell the story' to lead in to a point. Example would be pp with autistic husband above.

My preferred communication style would be to answer the question directly, then explain. But this is definitely one of many styles of answering I have noticed.

debbrianna · 08/11/2023 00:44

Hotandsunny · 07/11/2023 23:48

So what's the point of the appeal if the school refuse to engage in it?

I think the op is looking for an answer that the thread is not answering/giving. Going around in circles does not change the outcome of what you are looking for. Plenty of examples have been given.

Recheck your post and see where you would have gotten a different answer. Sometimes being completely direct without explaining why before the question you asked (as explained in your op) might be why the school was able to cut you off.

Hotandsunny · 08/11/2023 00:41

ithinkthatmaybeimdreaming · 07/11/2023 23:11

I agree, they didn't answer your question because it isn't relevant. They've told you there is no space, end of. I imagine they really don't want to get into an argument about it. Why won't you just accept their decision?

It's nothing to do with you being autistic btw.

Edited

Because that's what an appeal is. They have to present their case and I have to argue against it. They can't just say we are full end off.

Why am I appealing. I am having to home educate my DD as the school she was given can't meet her needs. This school can meet her needs and it is questionable if the should have let her in in the first place actually. But basically the effect of her not going to this school on her emotional well-being and my mental health is greater than the effect of adding one more child to a class of 29.

OP posts:
SageLavenderThyme · 08/11/2023 00:40

I do get your frustration. I think that sharing the room information with dimensions etc probably confused matters as it seemed to suggest those rooms and dimensions were relevant to the decision in a way it seems that they were not.

Hotandsunny · 08/11/2023 00:37

Bedofroses2 · 07/11/2023 23:09

People communicate using maxims of conversation that make it successful or unsuccessful. If one party believes the other is labouring an irrelevant point, the communication breaks down and becomes uncooperative on both sides.

The question about sixth form rooms is irrelevant, unless your child is joining a sixth form class. A smaller cohort does not necessarily mean fewer lessons or classrooms being used, whether there are 10 or 25 in an A Level Biology class they still need a classroom and a teacher for each lesson. Capacity in sixth form does not make space for a year 7, if all of the year 7 classes are full.

The sixth form has smaller class sizes. What rooms they use are relevant as if they use for example the 4 smaller rooms, that frees up the larger rooms for Y7 etc. It is also relevant in terms of the school being under capacity by 100 in 6th form. Would these extra 100 be using the same corridors and communal spaces as Y7? If so an argument can be made that these areas can't be crowded if they have 100 less people using them than when the school is at capacity.

OP posts:
IBlinkThereforeIAm · 08/11/2023 00:37

Bruisername · 07/11/2023 22:49

Just because you can ask a question doesn’t mean they have to answer though. They didn’t think it was a relevant question so they didn’t answer it

Lol. Then in future for Q&A sessions the audience should receive in advance a pre-approved list of questions that the presenters deem worthy of an answer.

Somewhat defeats to purpose of the meeting...

EveSix · 08/11/2023 00:34

With regard to the question you asked, OP (although I predictably find the general premise of your post more interesting), schools have a PAN, a published admissions number, for admissions to Reception, Y7 and Y12. Once they meet PAN, they're full, irrespective of how pupil numbers are arranged in individual classes within the year group. There are guidelines for maximum numbers of pupils in a class, but the bottom line is the PAN for the year group. I am willing to bet that this is what the person referred to when he said, without qualifying why, that Y7 was 'full'. A school proposes each academic year's PAN to the LA well in advance, and it is on this basis that places are offered each March.

Edited to insert a space.

Hotandsunny · 08/11/2023 00:30

EmmaEmerald · 07/11/2023 23:09

Yes

And the room size thing might be their tactic to avoid other questions.

it sounds like you are expecting efficiency and logic from professionals. No experience of schools but logic and professionalism seem to be at an all time low in 2023.

Yes, I do expect logic and professionalism. Maybe that's my problem.

OP posts: