Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

If you are autistic do people often not answer the question you are asking but give a more generalised answer?

389 replies

Hotandsunny · 07/11/2023 22:20

Just a thought that came to mind. I often find when I ask people questions about something very specific they don't seem to get it and just give you a general answer. I don't know what it is. But I have oftenish been in a situation where people just don't seem to understand what you are asking. So I was wondering if it was an autistic thing.

The example from today was I was doing a school appeal and the school had sent a list of rooms and room sizes as evidence that the school was full. I tried to question the school about what the different rooms were used for, about class sizes and what rooms the 6th form used. All the deputy head could do was repeat that Y7 was full.

I say you haven't answered my question and ask again and get the same reply. A member of the panel says to me I just don't like the reply I'm getting. I don't, because it doesn't answer my question.

This isn't an isolated incident by a long shot.

OP posts:
Hotandsunny · 08/11/2023 02:08

JaninaDuszejko · 08/11/2023 00:05

NT people answer the perceived subtext. That's not always an exact answer to the precise words in a question.
Answering constant questions is exhausting and makes a conversation unbalanced. I have a work colleague who told a group of us we were just talking about ourselves, completely missing that we were sharing information and making connections. He never shares information, it makes him come across as untrustworthy.
People don't have to answer your questions, even in a formal situation.

But if you're in an appeal at the point everyone gets to ask their questions, you can"t be too surprised that there will be a lot of questions and that there will be a expectation they are answered and if you refuse to do so it will affect your case plus make you look pretty unprofessional.

OP posts:
Hotandsunny · 08/11/2023 02:04

MyGooseisTotallyLoose · 08/11/2023 00:02

So whatever they do/say isn't good enough unless you get the answer you want?
If you're not hearing what you want the staff are either sly or out of their depth can't imagine why you're not someone they're Jumping through fire hoops to admit to their school!

I think you're being very unkind. My DD has been through a lot and still is. This is the school that can meet her needs. This is really important to her.

I also think it's just a bit mean to criticise me about my autism in a thread I started to ask people with autism a question. They can see it from my point of view. And due to that agree with me.

I don't mind what they say as long as they actually answer the question. It has been suggested on here by more than one person that not answering can be used as a tactic. She certainly omitted mentioning things that would support my case. I think in general though she was a bit out of her depth and didn't know how to answer a lot of questions from me and others. The panel and clerk had to keep helping her which I'm sure isn't allowed.

OP posts:
Hotandsunny · 08/11/2023 01:55

Boomboom22 · 08/11/2023 00:01

Its not very clear what you mean or how it could be relevant though. Sixth form is separate so their numbers are irrelevant. Quieter corridors can be made as a point but doesn't follow really as sixth form have frees, possibly leave the site, can be late etc.
Also why do you keep saying school teacher? Teachers are not involved in any appeals, governor, head and the panel not teachers.

I think I've answered this enough. The specialists I spoke to see it as relevant as did others at the appeal today. There was a deputy head teacher giving the school's case. So teachers must be involved.

OP posts:
Hotandsunny · 08/11/2023 01:52

NotMyCircusAnymore · 08/11/2023 00:00

Severe Borderline PD, OCD and complex PTSD.

So it would seem to be a neuro divergent thing then.

OP posts:
Hotandsunny · 08/11/2023 01:50

feedyourheed · 07/11/2023 23:53

Also to add as someone who has been through two (LA conceded) SEND tribunals for schools, I totally get why you need that very specific information and I have acquired and used similar information myself. SEND tribunals DO want to know where there is space in the school, if new classrooms can be formed, if extra children can be accommodated with additional funds (where there is physical space).

The school probably knows this hence their being obstructive. A tribunal could look at the answers to those questions and decide that space can be found, so I get where you are coming from, whereas others in this thread won't have that experience or know why the questions are very relevant.

Yes, it's very obvious that most people on this thread have no clue about these school appeals. Thank you for backing me up.

OP posts:
Hotandsunny · 08/11/2023 01:47

Allthegoodnamesarechosen · 07/11/2023 23:50

@RelationshipOrNot

I think you have explained precisely what has happened here.

also : if the OP had been as tenacious in her demands to the panel for what appears to most people to be irrelevant information as she has been in her responses to her original post, the ‘reluctance’ to engage with this point is understandable.

(I expect they wanted to go home sometime that night.)

The meeting would have been much quicker if they answered the question the first time and didn't have to be asked 3 times after saying their pat phrase each time. A member of panel had the same issue, he gave up on his question after asking 3 times. I then took it up and on the second time of asking she finally answered it. Maybe his questions were irrelevant to?

OP posts:
Schlurp · 08/11/2023 01:45

At risk of annoying you, are you actually wanting to chat about the general point re communication styles, or address the specific problem of getting an answer re the rooms?

We had quite a bruising experience with the LA going through the EHCP process. Nothing to do with autism at all, they just completely stonewall all emails from parents. The answer wasn't adapting our communication style, it was forcing their hand by sending IPSEA letters reminding them of legal obligations, submitting multiple formal complaints and a Subject Access Request. Although not identical, you do have a kind of similar adversarial situation going on. I wonder if the problem is more about that than the fact that it's an autistic person making a request of an NT person. It's definitely the case that shorter emails and quick tasks are more likely to get a response, especially from SLT who will probably have a lot of emails incoming every day. But sometimes it's more structural.

But perhaps that is me being annoyingly NT and answering a different question from the one you asked!

I would say it's worth spelling out to him why you feel he is obliged to answer your question, preferably quoting from an appeals code or somesuch, and phrase it so it is as easy to digest and as simple to execute as you can.

Hotandsunny · 08/11/2023 01:43

PlantMum23 · 07/11/2023 23:50

Op, I think you are getting caught up by what it means for a school to be “full”

Yes, I could theoretically cram some
more kids into some of my classes. However, the classes with “room” in them might have a higher proportion of kids with ASN (who would be negatively impacted by a larger class size)
There is probably enough rooms in the school to throw in a full other class, by splitting up current classes. However, we are already working at our maximum number of contact periods, therefore it wouldn’t be possible to staff it.
Rooms also have different purposes. I could probably take my older kids to a smaller room; however the technical resources I need for my lesson are in my classroom - and I also use it with another lot of pupils where the class size is too large to use the smaller room
(and the equipment is large and heavy, so can’t be moved safely)
It is also on my risk assessment that I’m only allowed to teach on the same floor as my classroom due to an injury.

But I haven't argued that. I have spoken about corridors and communal facilities. I've been given advice on this so my arguments are sound. But whatever I have to argue against this because that's what an appeal is all about.

OP posts:
daylightplease · 08/11/2023 01:42

It doesn't mean you shouldn't push OP it just realistically reduces the chances of you being successful.

daylightplease · 08/11/2023 01:41

There wasn't really that dynamic as the teacher seemed out of her depth and the panel and clerk were having to help her. They're meant to be impartial.

I would argue that the teacher may well have been personally out of depth but she had more power in the meeting due to her status.

The fact the other impartial people helped her would support that for me.

Hotandsunny · 08/11/2023 01:40

RelationshipOrNot · 07/11/2023 23:49

I also really agree with this and forgot to include it in my reply! It has taken me DECADES to understand that not everyone is "allowed" an equal say in all meetings or situations, and even now having thought about it a lot, I still slip up in the heat of the moment.

So is that the case for a school appeal? A parent should take a back seat?

It contradicts all the advice given to me by specialists in this area, as does people telling me not to mention 6th form etc.

OP posts:
Hotandsunny · 08/11/2023 01:37

feedyourheed · 07/11/2023 23:46

I have this all the time, so much so that I've mentioned it to others to see if it happens to them.

A good example of when it happens to me is in an academic setting, say at uni. Others will ask a question and the tutor answers what they asked. I ask a question (very specific and nuanced) and they NEVER answer what I am actually asking about. I used to try to clarify, and clarify but they never 'get' it. So frustrating.

It's like people have an idea of what they think I am asking and answer that instead of thinking about the very precise thing I am querying. But it doesn't seem to happen to others, so I have to think it's just me (strong ASD traits with 2 autistic children here).

There are lots of other examples, and usually it's people doing a job rather than family that misunderstand me. It also happens when I write a post about something and people pick up on something I didn't even mean or imply. I get tired of trying to say - no, you're wrong. I didn't say nor mean that.

Oh absolutely this is exactly it. It's feels like they're never really listening at a deeper level and then we get frustrated because they're not answering our question and they get frustrated because they think they are!!

It's definitely an autistic thing to look at things in fine detail and I think this leads from that. So many autistic people recognise this.

OP posts:
halesie · 08/11/2023 01:34

(And many allistic teachers really don't understand autism IME.)

Hotandsunny · 08/11/2023 01:32

daylightplease · 07/11/2023 23:46

In terms of answering questions it is also important to understand the power dynamics.

You want something that a state resource has.
This gives them more power in the conversation, they have a wanted thing and they are a state backed body.

It is socially expected that that the person with the most power in the conversation will have more control over it.

Hmm..interesting.

There wasn't really that dynamic as the teacher seemed out of her depth and the panel and clerk were having to help her. They're meant to be impartial.

OP posts:
MrsTerryPratchett · 08/11/2023 01:32

Disturbia81 · 08/11/2023 01:00

You say "meet her needs" so I assume she has additional needs. So it's not just adding 1 child to a class of 29.

I suspect this is part of it.

OP I often have clients asking me pages of questions about process at work. Many of them are ND and/or trauma impacted. I have about 4000 clients. I simply don't have time to respond to every single query (many of which are irrelevant and/or appear to be designed to try to get me to vary the procedures). People feel that I am not answering. For example, someone asks about a process. I say, "sorry you aren't eligible for that process". I'm right. I then get queries about the policy. I send the policy. They query a completely irrelevant piece and say, "you didn't do this". Well, no I didn't but it wouldn't make any difference to eligibility. They want a meeting to discuss it. Taking more time. I give a list of reasons it won't make a difference. They nitpick one of the reasons, they aren't interested in the other 19 which preclude them. They want this in writing, double spaced, in 18 font, notarised. I supply it, taking hours of my time. They then escalate to my boss, the Board, the MP, taking more time. Pointing out the irrelevancies.

At the very beginning of the process, I'd actually like to say, "I'm right, you aren't eligible, I'm the expert and all of this effort is for nothing" but I can't because of customer service standards.

I suspect the school feels they can't meet your child's needs, they don't have capacity and they have many reasons. Room size was floated because it's the least contentious. You think it's the one to deal with. It's not.

halesie · 08/11/2023 01:31

Damian Milton's double empathy problem is well worth looking up, both for autistic and non-autistic people. It may be especially useful for those of you who have autistic relatives and are finding it a struggle to communicate effectively with each other.

OP, good luck with the appeal. We're trying to get a place at a specialist school for one of our DC atm and are expecting the response to be that the suitable schools are "full", even though that isn't a valid reason to turn a child with an EHCP away. So I suspect I may be asking similar questions soon Grin

Hotandsunny · 08/11/2023 01:30

Totaly · 07/11/2023 23:44

Because OP you are being a dog with a bone! People have given you reasons why this might be the case and yet the only question you are asking - we can’t actually answer, you’ve framed it like a general question when you want a specific answer.

Why didn’t they answer? We don’t know - not it could be …. Yet still you keep asking the same questions

Teachers understand autism, they really do, and they k ow that if they say X you’ll argue Y.

But you don’t want that answer.

like PP said, school is full, there’s too many children and not enough rooms, or teachers or budgets, or other staff, no money for supplies.

100 less 6th formers doesn’t not make the school less full. 6th form is a different budget and a different curriculum-

If shop A is only using half its floor space or doesn’t give shop B the right to use the other half. Even if 6th form isn’t using ‘their’ areas doesn’t mean you can.

I asked autistic people if they asked a specific question do others just give a general answer. Autistic people have managed to answer that question fine.

However many people seem to want to talk about my appeal including you. What do you mean teachers understand autism??

But you are just like this person just keep repeating the same things over and over. I have said countless times the 6th form has no separate area it shares all facilities and rooms with the whole school.

OP posts:
Hotandsunny · 08/11/2023 01:22

EveSix · 07/11/2023 23:39

My, this thread is eye-opening.

DP (ND) can be like this at times of heightened anxiety; asking very specific questions and expecting answers which fall precisely within his expected parameters. He gets bothered if, within the first couple of syllables of responding, it looks like an answer might be other than expected.

Example:

DP: "Are we going out straight after Dan comes home from football?"

Expected answer: yes or no.

Usual context: Dan always comes home from football at 18:30.

New, unknown to DP, development: Dan's lift has bailed so he'll be walking home, ETA 19:00.

Reasonable reply by me: "Dan just messaged me. His lift has bailed so he'll be walking home, ETA 19:00. We'll leave straight after that."

DP: (usually by the time I've hit the 3rd unexpected word) "Oh my days, just 'yes' or 'no', that's aaaaaall I ask! exasperated sigh", failing to take in the change of circumstance.

Lots of situations like these:
"Are we taking the A59 or shall we go up Houghton Way?"
(I've checked traffic updates and seen delays which promt considering a 3rd route, so I venture:)
"I've just checked the AA traffic updates, and as there are severe delays on both those routes, I'd suggest -"
"Jeesus, what is wrong with just answering the question the way I've asked it!? A59 or Houghton Way!?", again missing relevant information.

It is a deep reluctance to acknowledge that communication is a two-way process where both parties, unless one is under interrogation in a witness box, are able to respond with a reasonable degree of autonomy. I get furious with him -I don't owe him comms compliance-, but remind myself that he processes language so differently to anyone I know (paradoxically, he's an inspired lyricist and poet).

Thank you for that.

I had to do the appeal over Zoom when I'd requested in person. Over Zoom means it is just even harder to follow. Lots of talking over people etc.

OP posts:
IBlinkThereforeIAm · 08/11/2023 01:21

SageLavenderThyme · 08/11/2023 00:53

@IBlinkThereforeIAm some people do. For example, if my mum asked me if she should visit tomorrow and I just said 'no', she would be offended. However, if I were to provide a long winded narrative around what I was doing and why I couldn't fit a visit in, she would be more satisfied with my answer, even though both mean 'no'.

Edited

God, how exhausting!! You have to give her a full day run down and account for your time before she can accept ypu have said "no, I am busy"?

IBlinkThereforeIAm · 08/11/2023 01:19

That's what a conversation is

It really isn't!! Do you say everything that you think?!

DontLeanOnTheKeyboard · 08/11/2023 01:17

OP, kindly, it’s none of your business what they do with classrooms in the school. Oversubscribed isn’t just about Real estate, there’s many more complexities. Your question was not appropriate as it could come across as arrogant with you giving the impression you don’t think they’re doing things very well. From your perspective they’re not, but you aren’t, and don’t need to be privy to all the plans and arrangements for everything the school does.

Avoiding the question is a social habit for situations where the person can’t say ‘stop fucking asking, mind yer own’ or doesn’t want to come across as rude, so they just go vague news. I’m a bit obsessed with where people live, and really have to hold myself back from trying to nail them down to their Road etc. I’m fascinated with houses and people’s decor.

It’s just more of the unwritten rule thing. If the answer is vague it prob means that’s all you’re getting.

Hotandsunny · 08/11/2023 01:17

RelationshipOrNot · 07/11/2023 23:37

I am autistic, and have, many times, asked questions or made statements that turned out not to be appropriate, or were viewed as rude or overstepping the mark.

My interpretation of this situation, which may or may not be correct, and am happy to be set straight by neurotypical people, is this:

They are confident in their expertise with regard to assessing the capacity of their school. They see you asking these questions as an outsider trying to tell them how to do something which they have knowledgeable about and have experience of; they see the questions you're asking as information-gathering in advance of an attack on a system they have already decided works. They did not answer, therefore, because they didn't want to be in a position where they would feel like they had to justify and argue their decision-making regarding their area of expertise to an outsider, who has taken a couple of pieces of information and then decided they can see the whole picture "better" than them. I am not saying I agree with them, but I suspect their thought processes may have been something like this.

I just can't understand someone taking part in an appeal if they fundamentally don't agree with the process. And how can they get away with refusing to engage? I just don't understand.

OP posts:
Nepmarthiturn · 08/11/2023 01:13

what if it is their decision but they haven’t decided yet or they’re not sure?

Ummm... they could just say that, as you have above! This is the purpose of language, what words are for and why they have defined and specific meanings: so that people can communicate accurately what they actually mean using the corresponding words, rather than say something else entirely and expect people to guess what they meant to say, and then often get cross if you guess incorrectly. The presumption that anybody has the time, energy or inclination to attempt to read their minds is so rude and self-important. And usually it is these same obsfucating types who will also pretend the words someone else has said to them also have alternative meanings to what was actually said, and then get offended by their own fantasies about imagined meanings in those words, which bear no resemblance to the actual definitions of those words.

Tiresome in the extreme. It's almost impossible to conduct any meaningful conversation with such people without giving yourself a stomach ulcer or a nervous breakdown. Such people never seem to improve their communication abilities over time either in my experience so it's best to avoid them once you've identified them. Sadly, there are many!

.

Hotandsunny · 08/11/2023 01:13

Hipnotised · 07/11/2023 23:32

I don't ask a question if it's not relevant.

To you - it may be irrelevant to others. The issue is that you think x is important and expect it to be answered as such, directly and in the communication style you prefer.

You need to understand this is not everyone's style and it's not wrong to not give an x or y answer.

Shades of grey, not black and white and all that...

Yes, I do struggle with that.

OP posts:
Hotandsunny · 08/11/2023 01:12

Superbroom · 07/11/2023 23:20

Why do you want to know how the rooms are allocated, if not to challenge the way the school operates.
Surely you don’t want to know just for the sake of knowing ?

The school gives their case and then parents have to ask questions/argue against their case. If the case is as it would always be about rooms/class sizes/ staffing then to argue against it I need to have some information. So no, I don't want to know for the sake of knowing but because of course I want to win the appeal.

OP posts: