Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

If you are autistic do people often not answer the question you are asking but give a more generalised answer?

389 replies

Hotandsunny · 07/11/2023 22:20

Just a thought that came to mind. I often find when I ask people questions about something very specific they don't seem to get it and just give you a general answer. I don't know what it is. But I have oftenish been in a situation where people just don't seem to understand what you are asking. So I was wondering if it was an autistic thing.

The example from today was I was doing a school appeal and the school had sent a list of rooms and room sizes as evidence that the school was full. I tried to question the school about what the different rooms were used for, about class sizes and what rooms the 6th form used. All the deputy head could do was repeat that Y7 was full.

I say you haven't answered my question and ask again and get the same reply. A member of the panel says to me I just don't like the reply I'm getting. I don't, because it doesn't answer my question.

This isn't an isolated incident by a long shot.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
BannedfromChristmas · 10/11/2023 01:52

"Foibles of neuro typicals". I wouldn't dream of saying "foibles of Autistics".
I've worked out that their problem might be with your attitude.

Redlocks28 · 09/11/2023 22:46

Well, I would say this now is a very identifiable thread, especially for anyone on any sort of SLT social media groups. You are about to start your child at a school where your opinions on their deputy head have been made pretty clear. I would probably consider making a request to have this taken down.

Highlandsprocker · 09/11/2023 22:18

don’t agree that saying you won’t answer a question is rude. You either will or you wont

I wasn't asking you to agree

But also I answered the question but it doesn't always mean you are going to get the answer you want.
Because for the 100th time , you cannot control other people's responses!

Log in | Mumsnet

Mumsnet makes parents' lives easier by pooling knowledge, advice and support on everything from conception to childbirth, from babies to teenagers.

https://www.mumsnet.com/talk/4938027-if-you-are-autistic-do-people-often-not-answer-the-question-you-are-asking-but-give-a-more-generalised-answer/130609106/create-report

GoodnightGentlemen · 09/11/2023 22:10

Highlandsprocker · 09/11/2023 22:06

You implied it.

That I don't understand ND people.
However stating that ND people have one form of communication and NT people another is wrong.
It's incredibly variable and I think it's rude to say I'm not answering that question.
I'm ND and hypervigilant.
I can pick up the smallest elements of body language in humans and animals, it's like reading the words on a page for me.
It's not always a good thing!

The point is the Op is annoyed the teacher didn't answer her questions but no-one can control how others react.
Imho the teacher was simply trying to stop her talking!

I didn’t say or imply anything. And I’m fully aware that not all ND people don’t read tone/body language, which is why I said ‘some’ or ‘many’ before each time I said ND.

I don’t agree that saying you won’t answer a question is rude. You either will or you won’t.

Highlandsprocker · 09/11/2023 22:06

GoodnightGentlemen · 09/11/2023 21:52

I didn’t say you are NT- where did I write that? I said it’s a thread about how NT people often react to direct questions from ND people.

Im aware that communication takes many forms- I’m pointing out that many ND people don’t read expressions/tone/body language very well- therefore a clear answer is a better way of communicating with them. “I will not answer that question, I think it’s rude” is a perfectly valid, clear answer.

You implied it.

That I don't understand ND people.
However stating that ND people have one form of communication and NT people another is wrong.
It's incredibly variable and I think it's rude to say I'm not answering that question.
I'm ND and hypervigilant.
I can pick up the smallest elements of body language in humans and animals, it's like reading the words on a page for me.
It's not always a good thing!

The point is the Op is annoyed the teacher didn't answer her questions but no-one can control how others react.
Imho the teacher was simply trying to stop her talking!

GoodnightGentlemen · 09/11/2023 21:52

Highlandsprocker · 09/11/2023 21:46

Did I say I am NT ?
Bit of an assumption there!

The point is communication takes many forms and socially accepted customs vary from country/ culture.
I didn't say I would pull a face, my face would be serious and so would my tone.
I don't pull faces at people, I'm not a child.

In fact my reply was about boundaries and how people cross them, it was an example of boundary crossing when Op described it as her need/ right to get an answer.

I didn’t say you are NT- where did I write that? I said it’s a thread about how NT people often react to direct questions from ND people.

Im aware that communication takes many forms- I’m pointing out that many ND people don’t read expressions/tone/body language very well- therefore a clear answer is a better way of communicating with them. “I will not answer that question, I think it’s rude” is a perfectly valid, clear answer.

Highlandsprocker · 09/11/2023 21:46

GoodnightGentlemen · 09/11/2023 21:22

Yeah, this thread is about communication with ND people and the tendency of NT people to not answer clear questions with clear answers, and to rely instead on their own opinion of what the person should have asked/was really asking/what they feel the person needs to know etc.

The point is that pulling a face and being cold doesn’t communicate anything to many ND people. There is little point sitting there feeling like your boundaries are being impinged upon and pulling a face and changing your tone- there is no reason not to just say “I am not going to answer that question”.

Did I say I am NT ?
Bit of an assumption there!

The point is communication takes many forms and socially accepted customs vary from country/ culture.
I didn't say I would pull a face, my face would be serious and so would my tone.
I don't pull faces at people, I'm not a child.

In fact my reply was about boundaries and how people cross them, it was an example of boundary crossing when Op described it as her need/ right to get an answer.

GoodnightGentlemen · 09/11/2023 21:29

drspouse · 09/11/2023 20:41

The rules for an appeal are that a school must provide the parents/panel with the information they require for the appeal.

But what information you think you require and what information they think you require may be very different.
To use the example of room size and use: if you are asking about rooms used by other years you may want (or they may think you want) to rearrange the whole school's timetable/room usage to make more room in Y7.
That is something they are definitely not going to be able to do.
For a primary school, maybe they could swap over two rooms if they are equivalent but the year groups are different, but for a secondary school even assuming the Y7s don't move around to different classrooms quite as much, a slight change to one year group would have a knock on effect to the rest of the school.
So as far as they are concerned you probably need to know the number in the Y7 group, possibly the size of the rooms Y7 use regularly, but they are not going to be able to move the sixth form to different rooms (think of how many options they will be doing!) so they aren't going to think you require that information.

Your question implied that they would be doing that and they probably thought it was intrusive/cheeky/not something they wanted to answer due to time taken even just to provide that.

So "the information you require for the appeal" isn't the same as "the information you want for the appeal".

It doesn’t take long to say “I’m not going to provide that information about 6th form rooms because I don’t think it’s relevant”. It doesn’t really take long to say “yes, 6th formers do use the communal areas, but that doesn’t affect the space available for year 7”.

Im sure it took longer for them to go all round the houses avoiding the question and giving vague answers so @Hotandsunny ended up asking 10 clarifying questions.

GoodnightGentlemen · 09/11/2023 21:22

Highlandsprocker · 09/11/2023 20:32

I wouldn't worry about it allConfused
My tone and look would indicate I wasn't discussing it and that I thought the person was very rude.
Not all communication is verbal

Yeah, this thread is about communication with ND people and the tendency of NT people to not answer clear questions with clear answers, and to rely instead on their own opinion of what the person should have asked/was really asking/what they feel the person needs to know etc.

The point is that pulling a face and being cold doesn’t communicate anything to many ND people. There is little point sitting there feeling like your boundaries are being impinged upon and pulling a face and changing your tone- there is no reason not to just say “I am not going to answer that question”.

drspouse · 09/11/2023 20:41

The rules for an appeal are that a school must provide the parents/panel with the information they require for the appeal.

But what information you think you require and what information they think you require may be very different.
To use the example of room size and use: if you are asking about rooms used by other years you may want (or they may think you want) to rearrange the whole school's timetable/room usage to make more room in Y7.
That is something they are definitely not going to be able to do.
For a primary school, maybe they could swap over two rooms if they are equivalent but the year groups are different, but for a secondary school even assuming the Y7s don't move around to different classrooms quite as much, a slight change to one year group would have a knock on effect to the rest of the school.
So as far as they are concerned you probably need to know the number in the Y7 group, possibly the size of the rooms Y7 use regularly, but they are not going to be able to move the sixth form to different rooms (think of how many options they will be doing!) so they aren't going to think you require that information.

Your question implied that they would be doing that and they probably thought it was intrusive/cheeky/not something they wanted to answer due to time taken even just to provide that.

So "the information you require for the appeal" isn't the same as "the information you want for the appeal".

CaramacFiend · 09/11/2023 20:39

Not read the whole thread but I'm dyspraxic with ADHD and was told by an educational psychologist that I also exhibit 'obsessive behaviour' when I was a kid. I often feel the same way but I think it's because I analyse things to a much greater depth than most people and expect a much more specific/nuanced answer.

Highlandsprocker · 09/11/2023 20:32

GoodnightGentlemen · 09/11/2023 20:07

This still doesn’t make sense. If someone asked how much money you have and you don’t want to tell them, why wouldn’t just say it’s none of your business? Or ‘I’m not going to tell you that’ or, ‘ mind your own business’ or ‘I don’t want to talk about it’?

What is the benefit of being weird and vague about it? You are allowed to not discuss your finances- there is no need to worry about it.

I wouldn't worry about it allConfused
My tone and look would indicate I wasn't discussing it and that I thought the person was very rude.
Not all communication is verbal

drspouse · 09/11/2023 20:31

crackofdoom · 07/11/2023 22:28

Frequently. They answer what they think you are implying by asking that question, rather than just answer the question.
And they think we're the weird ones 🙄

I don't think they were in this case - they knew what you were asking but weren't willing to answer that question specifically.
(I'm not autistic but have experienced this kind of answer and it is frustrating, I agree).

GoodnightGentlemen · 09/11/2023 20:07

Highlandsprocker · 09/11/2023 19:33

That must be an exhausting life!

Well it would be if it ever happened but it doesn't.

If my DC cba to answer they would get what they were given

Put it in a different context.
Persons A and B

"how much money have you got" A I wouldn't ask this in the first place.btw

"Plenty thanks "B
( avoids saying MYOB) most people would get the message and stop here.

"How much" Crossing boundary
" As I said, enough"
"HOW MUCH" Crossing boundary
Person B gets up and walks off.

You don't have the right to demand answers to any questions you choose to ask.

This still doesn’t make sense. If someone asked how much money you have and you don’t want to tell them, why wouldn’t just say it’s none of your business? Or ‘I’m not going to tell you that’ or, ‘ mind your own business’ or ‘I don’t want to talk about it’?

What is the benefit of being weird and vague about it? You are allowed to not discuss your finances- there is no need to worry about it.

Zwellers · 09/11/2023 19:49

XDownwiththissortofthingX you sound intolerant pedantic and rude.

Highlandsprocker · 09/11/2023 19:33

That must be an exhausting life!

Well it would be if it ever happened but it doesn't.

If my DC cba to answer they would get what they were given

Put it in a different context.
Persons A and B

"how much money have you got" A I wouldn't ask this in the first place.btw

"Plenty thanks "B
( avoids saying MYOB) most people would get the message and stop here.

"How much" Crossing boundary
" As I said, enough"
"HOW MUCH" Crossing boundary
Person B gets up and walks off.

You don't have the right to demand answers to any questions you choose to ask.

Aydahayda · 09/11/2023 19:29

InattentiveADHD · 09/11/2023 18:22

😂😂😂😂

GAAAAAAHHH same!!

InattentiveADHD · 09/11/2023 18:22

Hughs · 09/11/2023 10:12

A typical example in our house:

Me: what time do you think you'll be back?

DH: hang on a minute, we talked about this and I said I'd be out late and you said it was fine

Me: yes it is fine, I was just wondering what time you'll be back

DH: haha well it won't be any time soon, I haven't even left yet hahaha

Me: hm ok so what time do you reckon then

DH: well I've got to drive there and then do the thing and then get back haven't I?

Me: yes, so any idea what time you might be back?

DH: don't worry I'll go straight there and back, no popping into the pub hahaha

Me: ok, so what time then

DH: well it will be lateish I think

Me: WILL YOU PLEASE USE A NUMBER

DH: oh sorry, probably around 10. I'll text if it's going to be after 11

Me: ok thanks
[goes for a lie down]

😂😂😂😂

Hotandsunny · 09/11/2023 16:20

Highlandsprocker · 09/11/2023 14:54

As I said above I replied to you in error
It was to the Op

But it still stands. Why not just say if you can't/won't answer? Why not just make it so everyone is clear what is happening?

OP posts:
Hotandsunny · 09/11/2023 16:17

Highlandsprocker · 09/11/2023 13:00

I don't think anyone has said its wrong but there are many forms of communication, not just verbal and often its these cues that are missed.
Another issue is boundaries.
Repeating a question on and on is a form of boundary crossing.
People have the right to give any answer they like, you don't get to control what other people say or to force them to answer in a way you control.

The rules for an appeal are that a school must provide the parents/panel with the information they require for the appeal. By deliberately not answering you are going out of your way to jeopardize an appeal. It's not very fair and you're on potentially shaking ground by deliberately doing it. It seems much more controlling to me to deliberately withhold information. Not sure how I'm being controlling by asking a question and simply expecting a truthful reply. How on earth do you go about life asking people questions that they have a 'right' to not answer or lie.

I mean it's like me asking my DC '
what would you like for dinner?'
'I refuse to answer!'
'sausages or chicken?'
'fish'
'we don't have fish. Would you like sausages or chicken?'
'how dare you try and control me by getting me to reply in a way that suits you?!'
'well, it's just so I know if you'd like sausages or chicken?'
'you are seriously crossing boundaries by asking me that again!'

That must be an exhausting life!

OP posts:
GoodnightGentlemen · 09/11/2023 15:14

Highlandsprocker · 09/11/2023 14:54

As I said above I replied to you in error
It was to the Op

Sorry I missed that!

GoodnightGentlemen · 09/11/2023 15:13

BertieBotts · 09/11/2023 11:29

YY I think NT people can see the "But what about...?" questions as being seeking a loophole, or trying to find a way around or catch you out, seeking a chink in the armour they can prise open, or trying to "win" or defeat the other person.

But from a ND perspective it's really not meant to be that combative. Actually it's trying to find a win-win solution, or problem solve. In theory this is a good characteristic, in practice (having been on the receiving end of it too) it is often received as "can't accept a no". I wonder if this is also related to NT politeness rules.

(BTW at today's check up for DS2 I was told there are some clear pointers towards ASD and I am so relieved that it is not just me who sees this.)

Someone asked for examples of DS2's questions that I don't understand. There was only one today and I did understand it. We were waiting for the bus and I said "It should be here in three minutes" and he asked "Why?" and my initial reaction was "What do you mean???" but then I stopped and said "Because the time now is 8:01 and the bus is supposed to arrive at 804, and that is three minutes." and he said "Ah!"

Some others that he asks fairly frequently which I don't undertsand how to answer:

Why does the number 3 bus come here?
Why does the number 4 tram go to <destination>?

And another one which comes up fairly frequently: I often make "Mhm" or "Awesome" responses to things that he is saying, when I'm not really interested but I want to show that I'm being polite and listening. He gets very angry about this and insists "That is not nice to say!!"

I think I understand that what he means is that he can tell this is a dismissive, "That's nice dear" sort of response and he doesn't want me to respond that way, but I am also not always enthusiastically interested in what he is saying. I can't say nothing (which is what he says that he wants me to do) because he gets angry and repeats what he wants to say until I respond. Should I literally say "I'm not very interested in that"? This seems so dismissive to a 5 year old. But maybe that's what he wants.

when my son is rabbiting on about boring things I try and find one element I can make a genuine comment on- like I think the sniffers in Minecraft are very cute.

Failing that I say I’m very glad you have something you find really interesting, you seem to really enjoy doing/talking about it, but I’m afraid I don’t really enjoy it.

Seems less dismissive but is also honest. He just rolls his eyes now and goes and tells someone else!

He has severe adhd as well as autism and is really affected by Rejection Sensitive Dysphoria so it’s a difficult path to tread.

Highlandsprocker · 09/11/2023 14:54

GoodnightGentlemen · 09/11/2023 14:50

I know that- I was saying that if someone can’t/doesn’t want to/doesn’t think it’s appropriate to answer a particular question, then the obvious thing to do is say exactly that.

If they ignore the question/ give a vague non answer/ answer a question that hasn’t been asked instead of the one that has then people will ask again or try and ask in a different way in case they haven’t understood the question.

As I said above I replied to you in error
It was to the Op

GoodnightGentlemen · 09/11/2023 14:50

Highlandsprocker · 09/11/2023 13:00

I don't think anyone has said its wrong but there are many forms of communication, not just verbal and often its these cues that are missed.
Another issue is boundaries.
Repeating a question on and on is a form of boundary crossing.
People have the right to give any answer they like, you don't get to control what other people say or to force them to answer in a way you control.

I know that- I was saying that if someone can’t/doesn’t want to/doesn’t think it’s appropriate to answer a particular question, then the obvious thing to do is say exactly that.

If they ignore the question/ give a vague non answer/ answer a question that hasn’t been asked instead of the one that has then people will ask again or try and ask in a different way in case they haven’t understood the question.

PriOn1 · 09/11/2023 13:43

I have a friend who has the opposite problem as he gets the answer to the question he asked, but not the information he was angling for.

So he’ll ask his wife “Do you know where my shoes are?”

and she replies

”Yes”.

Of course what he’s actually asking is where his shoes are, assuming she knows…

Swipe left for the next trending thread