Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

What do you think the end of Western civilisation will look like?

184 replies

curiousabouttheaesthetics · 07/11/2023 17:59

Am hopeful it won't be for a good while yet Grin

But with the whole world being so uncertain at the moment, with climate change and resource wars and mass migration on the horizon, I guess who knows what the coming decades could be like?

Hopefully though human ingenuity can find ways of muddling along as long as possible. If we can't, and if in 100 years high wet bulb temperatures and flooding and antimicrobial resistance has pretty much whittled down half or more of the world's population - do you think then the remaining people would set aside geopolitical differences? To get their smartest people working together to solve environmental problems? And with the rich everywhere pitching in resources?

Or do you think rich countries will just continue to try to hog resources until the bitter end of humanity?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Supersimkin2 · 10/11/2023 22:12

@Hyperion100

Some of us humans already reached that conclusion. The racist march tomorrow shows us 500,000 problems to be ‘fixed’.

Supersimkin2 · 10/11/2023 22:10

A pink-haired stupid saying ‘Israel is a war crime’.

Cringingly, it was female. Shitty uk education is helping decline no end.

Guess the only thing they taught them was not to drool.

curiousabouttheaesthetics · 10/11/2023 22:05

I mean has anyone seen the AI generated Heidi film trailer?

It's terrifying Grin

OP posts:
curiousabouttheaesthetics · 10/11/2023 22:04

Hyperion100 · 08/11/2023 14:26

I think AI will solve the majority of the problems we have right now.

The biggest problem we face is when the AI's decide that we humans are the problem and decide to fix the issue.

Well, quite. I mean, it wouldn't be wrong of AI to come to that conclusion, depressing as that is.

Although I think we are a fairly long time from AI being capable of that surely?

I think the real danger of AI is the potential for complete confusion and chaos.

OP posts:
TripleDaisySummer · 08/11/2023 16:21

End of Western civilisation would be slow decline with increasing inequality reduction in living standards aging inadequate infrastructure slowly crumbling with minimal investment in upkeep. Rest of globe other areas with younger populations and workforces start to pull ahead but it depends on demographics and global climate changes and how they interact. We may be at the start.

Wider civilization collapse - much worse prospect - mass starvation, war loss and loss of knowledge and no technological improvements.

Newport city centre had £17m thrown at it since 2018 in regeneration so on one hand it's odd it's named on here as I do know many worse city/town centers - on other hand it is on a decline with less and less footfall and does serve as an example of money being spent of wrong things at wrong time having limiting effect on decline.

bombastix · 08/11/2023 16:16

It's not a bad answer! A country might well take in new labour but I don't think the UK has really thought about mass migration properly recently, and what 600,000 looks like. This is Legal migration- asylum isn't what I would focus on, the figures are tiny. That is dog whistle stuff.

I remain concerned about the expression of religion in the U.K. That is a challenge on so many levels to what is "civilised" in the U.K. Cultural identity rooted in religious practice can undermine a lot of the law I think underpins social progress in the UK.

It's a mark of how reductive the debate can get which is to say multiculturalism is innately good. I don't agree. It's something you have to examine and say, is it working? Is the UK better or stronger or what can we do to build cohesiveness.

spookehtooth · 08/11/2023 15:58

@bombastix humans have always migrated, people only complain about the less well off. On its own, it's not really a problem.

The thing to analyse is who is migrating and why. War & poverty primarily. What I'm arguing is acknowledging the causes, and taking action. Stop doing the harmful things we do today, and take remedial action with regards to past harms that play a huge role in extreme differences in circumstances.

I don't imagine for a second it's a quick and easy fix, but I think it's clear our safety and comfort depends on it. It's acknowledged already at a national level. The NHS and social security aren't acts of charity and goodwill, but self interest for a stable and prosperous society. I'm not responsible for my neighbours health or wealth, but if they're in good physical health and not starving then I'm safer, and they won't give me a preventable transmissible disease

RubberPlantGirl · 08/11/2023 14:42

spookehtooth · 08/11/2023 14:16

@RubberPlantGirl not at all hysterical no? Nobody's shutdown. You're trying tho, by suggesting I'm wrong for expressing a strong disagreement with someone else 😂 If you got your way and I didn't or wasn't allowed to speak ... is that freedom to you? Be very careful when try telling people not to speak, you might get your wish and all the things you claim to fear on top

Thank you for proving my point. As I thought, You are unable to have an open discussion or entertain opposing viewpoints without putting a spin on my words which suit your narrative.

Hyperion100 · 08/11/2023 14:26

I think AI will solve the majority of the problems we have right now.

The biggest problem we face is when the AI's decide that we humans are the problem and decide to fix the issue.

bombastix · 08/11/2023 14:21

But here's one for you @spookehtooth, why would a society be any the stronger for migration? I don't mean in the abstract, I mean in reality.

Makemydaypunk · 08/11/2023 14:21

I really recommend everyone listens to this podcast hosted by Steven Bartlett, (Diary of a CEO)
It’s frightening but we really need to be aware and educate ourselves on AI. It really is a superb podcast.

EMERGENCY EPISODE: Ex-Google Officer Finally Speaks Out On The Dangers Of AI! - Mo Gawdat | E252

If You Enjoyed This Episode You Must Watch This One With Mustafa Suleyman Google AI Exec: https://youtu.be/CTxnLsYHWuI0:00 Intro 02:54 Why is this podcast im...

https://youtu.be/bk-nQ7HF6k4?si=CMADalyp06UdL8uI

spookehtooth · 08/11/2023 14:16

@RubberPlantGirl not at all hysterical no? Nobody's shutdown. You're trying tho, by suggesting I'm wrong for expressing a strong disagreement with someone else 😂 If you got your way and I didn't or wasn't allowed to speak ... is that freedom to you? Be very careful when try telling people not to speak, you might get your wish and all the things you claim to fear on top

Angrycat2768 · 08/11/2023 14:15

Dotjones · 08/11/2023 13:23

It'll go one of two ways, both resulting in a more repressive/totalitarian regime. Either we continue as we are and a small elite will have control over everything, or we will violently revolt against the small elite and a new elite will emerge that has control over everything.

The rich/poor gap will widen considerably, as a PP said there will be a small group who have all the power and live in obscene luxury whilst the majority will struggle to survive. Not as in the present struggle to survive people have because they live on benefits or low-paid, insecure jobs, but an actual struggle to survive - clean water, energy and any kind of permanent home.

It's easy to blame outside forces - China, Russia and Islam - but even if we are not conquered or colonized from outside, AI will destroy us from within. AI will take away most jobs. Pretty much any job will be able to be done by AI and robots within the next couple of decades. Better than humans can do in most cases. There will soon be a point where there is mass unemployment because there is simply not enough work to go round. The only hope for a "nice" future is that government will decide to pay its citizens a reasonable basic universal income, and AI "workers" enable this to be affordable.

I find that unlikely however, simply because it would represent a major redistribution of relative wealth downwards. Why would the elite countenance that, when they won't countenance it NOW when people are actually working for them, actually doing the work that builds further wealth for those at the top?

I think the thing that will stop that is that the rich mainly make money out of others. So if no one has any money, no one can buy stuff. AI won't be buying things or going to the cinema or watching TV or buying houses, and without that, the rich cannot make more money. Its why we are so much debt to China. We couldn't afford their tat so they lent the government money to give to us so we could continue buying tat and make them more money. We may end up with a Universal Basic Income just for that purpose, with rich people getting robots to do everything, but who will programme and maintain the robots? Why should techies and programmers work when the rich and the poor aren't? There will have to be some way to engineer jobs for people who can't sit around maintaining AI systems.

funbags3 · 08/11/2023 13:54

I think AI could mean the end of humanity’s role as the dominant species on the planet. Our brief time on this planet will be over.

funbags3 · 08/11/2023 13:49

@LadyBevvy I have a love/hate relationship.😂Was born there and lived there for many years. It's sad to see the decline in the high street.

LadyBevvy · 08/11/2023 13:44

@funbags3 leave our Casnewydd alone diolch!!

I think it looks like what we're seeing now:

  • Declining faith and trust in underpinning and unifying institutions such as parliamentary democracy and the church
  • Lack of unified identity underpinned by shared myths and beliefs
  • Declining birth rate
  • Declining productivity, export and manufacturing
  • Declining technological innovation
  • Declining mental health and reported levels of happiness
  • Declining participation in civic and community events and institutions
  • Declining sense of responsibility towards our families, friends and neighbours

I'd say this is happening all over Western Europe (NOT Central, eastern or southern Europe) and has been since the end of WW1. In the US, I'd say the decline started after the Vietnam War but has been more precipitous.

Civilisational decline takes centuries and so will ours so there's no need to worry. It's not a moral thing, it's no one's fault. Civilisations rise and fall. We don't deserve to be at the top of the heap just cos we're westerners and we've had a good 500 or so years at the top. It is what it is.

Dotjones · 08/11/2023 13:23

It'll go one of two ways, both resulting in a more repressive/totalitarian regime. Either we continue as we are and a small elite will have control over everything, or we will violently revolt against the small elite and a new elite will emerge that has control over everything.

The rich/poor gap will widen considerably, as a PP said there will be a small group who have all the power and live in obscene luxury whilst the majority will struggle to survive. Not as in the present struggle to survive people have because they live on benefits or low-paid, insecure jobs, but an actual struggle to survive - clean water, energy and any kind of permanent home.

It's easy to blame outside forces - China, Russia and Islam - but even if we are not conquered or colonized from outside, AI will destroy us from within. AI will take away most jobs. Pretty much any job will be able to be done by AI and robots within the next couple of decades. Better than humans can do in most cases. There will soon be a point where there is mass unemployment because there is simply not enough work to go round. The only hope for a "nice" future is that government will decide to pay its citizens a reasonable basic universal income, and AI "workers" enable this to be affordable.

I find that unlikely however, simply because it would represent a major redistribution of relative wealth downwards. Why would the elite countenance that, when they won't countenance it NOW when people are actually working for them, actually doing the work that builds further wealth for those at the top?

RubberPlantGirl · 08/11/2023 13:23

spookehtooth · 08/11/2023 12:21

You ignore the problems that your lovely homogeneous society created, or at least exuberated, in the world @bombastix
Our lives, even today, in rich countries depends on vast numbers living and working in poverty or "relatively okay" by a standard whose measurement involves pretending they don't know how poor they are compared to wealthy nations and how grossly unfair it is. The biggest privilege of all in this world is the luck of being born in the "right" country and family. Nobody strives hard to earn that

I guess you also don't know the lives of many people who migrate to these shores. A brief forum post wouldn't do justice to the kinds of experiences that I'm aware of.

It's not our fault we were born into a world like this, it is our fault if we ignore and justify it, and then complain about the consequences of doing so

You're exemplifying exactly what is wrong with society right now, by swiftly seeking to shut down a person's differing opinion and not allowing space to talk! You know best, you know it all and the West is to blame for absolutely everything wrong in the world. Can you not see that there is much more to it than that? This is why people in Europe are increasingly voting for extreme right wing parties because their voices are not being listened to and they're scared to speak out in fear of being labelled racist or islamaphobic, so they put their little cross in the box anonymously and suddenly, you have a load of fascists in power ! Without clear dialogue and discourse this is what we're heading towards.

bombastix · 08/11/2023 13:09

With you @Angrycat2768. The UK spent a lot of time effectively liberalising and removing religious morality from its law in the 1960s and 70s. I don't want it back.

Angrycat2768 · 08/11/2023 13:05

bombastix · 08/11/2023 12:59

Yes I think this is possible. But I doubt whether it is possible if you decide there are religious aspects to your life in the West that are more important. Then it falls apart very quickly. You don't need to look far into UK history to see this as a problem and one with violent results

Yes that's what I mean that we need to have overriding values that say ' no, we do not accept that, no matter who you are' and not be afraid to say that some things are unacceptable. For the protection of everyone, including people from within those communities. People have been prosecuted for taking children for FGM for example. If you adhere to that, then crack on. It does require strong political and enforcement systems, which in this country are creaking.

bombastix · 08/11/2023 12:59

Yes I think this is possible. But I doubt whether it is possible if you decide there are religious aspects to your life in the West that are more important. Then it falls apart very quickly. You don't need to look far into UK history to see this as a problem and one with violent results

Angrycat2768 · 08/11/2023 12:56

I think you can have a homogenous and multi cultural society, as long as you have strict values that everyone has to adhere to that protecs everyone, equally. People belong to different communities - religious, cultural, sporting, hobbies, etc. As long as your belonging to one community doesn't infringe on the rights of others, there is no reason we can't have multicultural communities. Many communities over the years have jntegrated well while keeping hold of their own traditions. I always thought the US way of ' African-American' etc was a good way of saying you are part of the x communities but you are also American was good but they seem to have worse problems, then export them here. Identity politics harms all people from.all communities by sowing division where for most people, none exists.

bombastix · 08/11/2023 12:25

@spookehtooth - I am one person! How do I account for the past? I can't. My observation is still a valid one. A homogeneous society will have other problems but it does not have the problems of multiculturalism without an effective supervening identity, which is not a new idea but something Western society has used for a long time to varying degrees.

spookehtooth · 08/11/2023 12:21

You ignore the problems that your lovely homogeneous society created, or at least exuberated, in the world @bombastix
Our lives, even today, in rich countries depends on vast numbers living and working in poverty or "relatively okay" by a standard whose measurement involves pretending they don't know how poor they are compared to wealthy nations and how grossly unfair it is. The biggest privilege of all in this world is the luck of being born in the "right" country and family. Nobody strives hard to earn that

I guess you also don't know the lives of many people who migrate to these shores. A brief forum post wouldn't do justice to the kinds of experiences that I'm aware of.

It's not our fault we were born into a world like this, it is our fault if we ignore and justify it, and then complain about the consequences of doing so

bombastix · 08/11/2023 12:00

These are the problems of a society that is multicultural and less homogeneous. A homogeneous society can rely on informal social rules to regulate what happens. The less homogenous, the more law, more formal rules you can end up having and it is done by politicians rather than a society that regulates itself. I definitely prefer a society that does that for itself as far as possible, because it is easier for me to live in. It is one of the major attractions of the UK. Is it undermined by identity politics or multiculturalism as "my community next to your community" then yes it is.

Swipe left for the next trending thread