Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to not drive partner to work while on maternity leave during bus strike?

282 replies

AmIclutchingpearls · 07/11/2023 14:50

My partner can't drive and so can't get to work during the current bus strikes.

He usually works 1 day a week at home and 4 in the office. He works in finance and can do his job entirely remotely. Unfortunately his employer (large company) are insisting he goes in at least 3 days - the reasons given are that his contract doesn't allow full homeworking and apparently one colleague has asked why he should get 'special treatment'.

We live in a rural location so no transport option other than me driving him there then picking him up (total 4 hours driving per day, 12 hours per week). I am on maternity leave so could theoretically do it but I really don't want to if it can be avoided!

Partner's uncle and sister both live close to his work so I have suggested he could ask if he could stay with one of them 2 nights a week (or 1 night each) meaning I would only have to drive him there Tuesday morning and pick him up Thursday after work. He is close to them and they regularly stay over at our house at weekends but he won't even ask them!

AIBU to say he asks his family to put him up 1 or 2 nights a week temporarily or finds his own alternative?

Also, any other advice around dealing with his employer or other options more than welcome!

Thank you all!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
mayorofcasterbridge · 12/11/2023 17:40

AmIclutchingpearls · 12/11/2023 17:33

Thank you for all the replies. Partner has got a car share sorted for some days in the short term so huge relief and still hoping to persuade work for more flexibility but not confirmed yet - fingers crossed!

Best of luck! x

AmIclutchingpearls · 12/11/2023 17:33

Thank you for all the replies. Partner has got a car share sorted for some days in the short term so huge relief and still hoping to persuade work for more flexibility but not confirmed yet - fingers crossed!

OP posts:
Blondeshavemorefun · 12/11/2023 14:52

So @AmIclutchingpearls what's the outocome

Train and bike/taxi

You

Staying at relatives

c0vb1rd · 11/11/2023 11:44

Has he thought about putting an official flexible work request in because they can't reject it really if he has proven he can do his whole job from home. This would safe guard him for future years as well. Strikes are unpredictable and you don't actually know how temporary they are this current climate.

Bean83ts · 11/11/2023 11:27

It’s 4 hours a day with a newborn in a car???

LakieLady · 10/11/2023 16:27

Could he book a CBT course and get a small motorbike that he can ride on a provisional licence?

Loads of people round my way commute by motorbike, because it's quicker than driving and parking's easier.

NoThanksymm · 10/11/2023 16:14

I think the employer is being unreasonable. As is your partner that spent drive.

sorry, bus strike, I’m working from home or off.

If you’re on mat leave I’m sure your partner doesnt want to leave for that many days.

but 4 hours of driving a day is totally an unreasonable demand. You def shouldn’t be doing that.

Catkin51 · 10/11/2023 11:48

Can’t he get a motorbike? You can drive one up to 250cc on a provisional licence without having to pass a driving test first.

DeeCeeCherry · 10/11/2023 11:05

Can he cycle to work? Im incredulous that you live rurally and he can't drive so, all driving is down to you. If you weren't home on Mat leave and were at work - I bet he'd have soon found a way to get to work

Wick55 · 10/11/2023 11:02

It’s not just about getting to work though - all driving falls on her, school, hospital, family days out… absolutely everything. Not related to the post necessarily but it is an unfair burden. Our public transport system isn’t good enough to not have a license sadly.

Birch101 · 10/11/2023 10:48

That much time in the car on a daily basis with possibly a crying baby would be too much for me.
Your solution is the smarter choice
assuming they are happy to have him.

And yes he needs to learn to drive assuming there are no medical reasons he can't otherwise everything will fall to you by default, e.g. Children's parties, Dr trips,

DuckbilledSplatterPuff · 10/11/2023 10:45

ElleCapitaine · 07/11/2023 17:13

I think that’s unfeasible with a small baby. You’ll be exhausted as you’ll likely be up at night and probably unsafe to drive for that long. You’ll be spending half the day driving with a small baby - that could be really stressful if baby starts crying. I don’t think he should even be asking you. He needs to ask his employer to work at home or stay over.

This!!!

If you had to potentially do this for up to five days a week for between 6-12 weeks, I think it would be really difficult. two round trips a day for DH and then two round trips a day for DC with small baby.

He needs to articulate his travel options during the strike to his employer.
Particularly as you say his job could be easily and effectively be done remotely. Perhaps he could negotiate maybe one day a week in office? and the rest at home until strike is over?

Its not your DH fault that transport he's happily been using until now is unavailable. And your husband has been investigating all alternative options. If others in his office complain of "special treatment" that is a problem for management to sort out. If in fact they have and its not just a case of management pre empting it.
They could complain of any thing. Its a temporary issue . The other staff should be glad of employer flexibility when they have sick leave, paternity leave, or other personal issues which might need a bit of wfh time. It doesn't mean stay at home and do nothing after all. If he left because of this, they would lose a team member and have to make up his work whilst a new person was recruited and trained afterall... so its in the managements interest to be flexible.

His employers probably don't realise the extent of why the "wife drives" option is not really an option for YOU at this volume of driving.

I had to do something similar when we were waiting to move into new house and DC had already started school in new area. So i can tell you, Its not only new baby in car seat for many hours, unable to really stretch or move, sleeping too much, unstimulated and therefore awake more at night, unable to get into routine, but also having to pull over somewhere on route to breast or bottle feed and nappy change - further delaying return home.
It was really difficult and exhausting and you feel the whole day is just in the car, not to mention petrol as you say. I developed painful mastitis and was exhausted with very little time to get everything done as I was always in the car.

SecondUsername4me · 10/11/2023 10:42

Wick55 · 10/11/2023 10:40

This was exactly my first thought. If there was no baby in tow maybe it would be different. Also he needs to learn to drive sorry but my FIL has used my MIL as a personal chauffeur for his whole life and it really makes me angry on her behalf.

The OPs partner makes use of the extensive bus service so she isn't his chauffer. However there are 3 months of strikes on all busses - certainly not a typical occurrence!

Wick55 · 10/11/2023 10:40

This was exactly my first thought. If there was no baby in tow maybe it would be different. Also he needs to learn to drive sorry but my FIL has used my MIL as a personal chauffeur for his whole life and it really makes me angry on her behalf.

kiki50 · 10/11/2023 09:36

my husband and I both drive, but deliberately moved to a small town with a train station so we had access to good public transport links. Your dh needs to get a driving license and perhaps moving away from the rural location too.

RedCoffeeCup · 10/11/2023 09:29

@Deathbyfluffy the OP has answered this. The drive is one hour (and 1.5 hours by bus). The 4 hours is because she has to drive there and back, twice a day.

SecondUsername4me · 10/11/2023 09:11

Deathbyfluffy · 10/11/2023 08:45

OP, how long is the journey? If he does it by bus 4 times a week I can’t help but feel 4 hours a day is a slight exaggeration!

My wife’s commute is 55 mins by bus but a 20 minute drive as it’s more direct.
Have you mapped the route?

The roads into Newcastle are a fucking nightmare during commuting times. And nearly every road is one lane cars and another Bus Route - so the busses are usually faster, especially if you only need to take one and not wait for a connection.

If I drive into my own office (via the city centre as I need to do) it takes 15mins to drive in the middle of the day, and 50-60mins during rush hours.

Deathbyfluffy · 10/11/2023 08:45

OP, how long is the journey? If he does it by bus 4 times a week I can’t help but feel 4 hours a day is a slight exaggeration!

My wife’s commute is 55 mins by bus but a 20 minute drive as it’s more direct.
Have you mapped the route?

Deathbyfluffy · 10/11/2023 08:43

YaWeeFurryBastard · 07/11/2023 15:10

Is there a medical reason he can’t drive? If not then he needs to pull his finger out and get his licence so he can appropriately take care of his family.

Why is it his job to take care of the family? It’s not 1920 anymore.

BorrowersAreVermin · 10/11/2023 08:41

I think YABU here. He wouldn't go to work if he didn't have to and that's two nights a week you're asking him to spend away from his family.

LoveAutumnColours · 09/11/2023 14:28

This isn’t really a sustainable solution, him staying with relatives while your home is out in the middle of nowhere, particularly with a baby/maternity leave.

Clearly not much can be done in the right here/right now but ether he had to drive to work or you guys live where there is transport available with options that if one method is down, it’s not too disruptive in the short term for alternative**. That could be public transport, riding a bike or his getting s ride with a Co-worker (and giving them petrol money).

** for us, if the trains are not running, they’ll likely put on replacement buses OR we pay for taxi/Uber to either another line OR closest tube. We specifically bought our home with commuting options in mind.

SallyWD · 09/11/2023 14:06

ASandwichNamedKevin · 09/11/2023 09:24

Someone being unable to drive as an adult can be indicative of poverty, a poor background even though they seem to be doing okay now.
Care experienced young adults don’t have parents giving driving practice and helping out with the cost of lessons, they might not have anyone at all to practice with.
There are young people who have rarely been inside a car never mind learning to drive one themselves.

Regular working people with low-paying jobs and bills to pay might find driving lessons have to come low on the priority list after basic living expenses. Of course not having a driving licence is another barrier to securing a better-paid job in some cases.

The OP has said they jointly decided that it wasn’t the right time financially for them to find lessons. No point saying well he should pay, if it’s family money and has become a family issue to address. It doesn’t sound like they have a lot spare just now.

Not driving is usually anxiety related from my observations. Every adult I know who can't drive is scared of driving. I don't blame them. I find driving scary. I put it off until I was 35 then I learnt because I knew I couldn't expect DH to do all the driving, especially after having children.

potatoheads · 09/11/2023 13:42

Busephalus · 07/11/2023 20:02

Potstoheads, him driving or not is massively pertinent to this discussion, he's chosen a job that puts massive pressure on his family if the one mode of transport there goes wrong, a long commute is bad enough

But why he can't drive is if precisely zero help in solving this current dilemma. Fact is he can not drive. How does you knowing why help the OP in any way?

notagoodidea · 09/11/2023 13:32

Why marry someone who cannot drive then choose to live in a rural location. Makes no sense

ASandwichNamedKevin · 09/11/2023 09:24

Missedvocation · 09/11/2023 06:51

What you have described is a medical limitation on driving. Which is completely fair enough. I’m not talking about that, I’m talking about people who seem intimidated by taking responsibility for themselves. Relying on your partner to drive you is selfish and ridiculous. They aren’t an equal partner, they are just another child. A complete non-starter for me, as someone not driving as an adult is indicative of so many things!

Someone being unable to drive as an adult can be indicative of poverty, a poor background even though they seem to be doing okay now.
Care experienced young adults don’t have parents giving driving practice and helping out with the cost of lessons, they might not have anyone at all to practice with.
There are young people who have rarely been inside a car never mind learning to drive one themselves.

Regular working people with low-paying jobs and bills to pay might find driving lessons have to come low on the priority list after basic living expenses. Of course not having a driving licence is another barrier to securing a better-paid job in some cases.

The OP has said they jointly decided that it wasn’t the right time financially for them to find lessons. No point saying well he should pay, if it’s family money and has become a family issue to address. It doesn’t sound like they have a lot spare just now.