Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask a Muslim admin assistant to organise Christams cards

138 replies

Goodfrock · 07/11/2023 14:27

We're a small PR company who sends out lots of Christmas cards. Whether this is worthwhile is up for debate, but the decision has been taken that it will continue for this year at least.

The admin assistant to whom this task falls is a newly appointed Muslim woman I.e
The person in her role has done it previously but it wasn't her last year.

She's not comfortable organising the cards. Was it an unreasonable request? This is very much a genuine question. I'm kicking myself for being insensitive at the same time as thinking it would be daft to get someone more senior to do it.

OP posts:
MinnieL · 07/11/2023 14:48

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Wow what a fucking dick you are

Harella · 07/11/2023 14:47

MrsTerryPratchett · 07/11/2023 14:45

And there it is...

If I moved to a Hindu majority country and took an admin role in a business, I would help out with Diwali celebrations. As I would with Eid celebrations if I moved to a Muslim majority country.

It is not racist to expect people to integrate into basic aspects of the culture of the country they have chosen to live in.

MinnieL · 07/11/2023 14:47

I don’t think anyone is being U tbh. You wasn’t being U to ask but she clearly doesn’t want to have any involvement in anything Christmas related due to her beliefs. I don’t see anything wrong with that.

It’s like saying a Jehovah’s Witness is being U to decline sending out Christmas cards on behalf of the business when they very clearly don’t celebrate Christmas. I think if you push it any further she could have reasonable grounds of discrimination so it may be best to get someone else to do it

Goodfrock · 07/11/2023 14:46

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

I think it will be me who gets sacked if I go with that line.

OP posts:
MissFancyDay · 07/11/2023 14:46

Are they religious cards?

Goodfrock · 07/11/2023 14:46

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Oh, I've been accused of being so sympathetic I'm antisemitic on the other threads. Can't win!

OP posts:
Pelegrinfalcon · 07/11/2023 14:45

what is her objection? It's a simple admin task. Nobody is asking her to celebrate baby Jesus. She is massively unreasonable. You asked her to send out cards, not to engage in any kind of religious worship.

MrsTerryPratchett · 07/11/2023 14:45

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

And there it is...

Zimunya · 07/11/2023 14:45

She's definitely BU. I worked for many years in the Middle East, and frequently sent Ramadan and Eid greetings out on behalf of my employers. We also frequently received Christmas cards from our Muslim clients.

MrsTerryPratchett · 07/11/2023 14:44

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Harella · 07/11/2023 14:44

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

thing47 · 07/11/2023 14:43

Whataretheodds · 07/11/2023 14:38

YANBU.
She is being unreasonable.

Unless the cards are made of bacon

@Whataretheodds 😀😀😀

If your assistant doesn't recognise or celebrate Christmas OP, then they're just cards, aren't they? with no specific meaning as far as she's concerned...

therealcookiemonster · 07/11/2023 14:42

@listsandbudgets your friends situation is totally different though. I can imagine as a vegetarian working even in an abattoir office would be distressing and against her moral and ethical code. I'm a meat eater and even I couldn't do it. but wishing merry Xmas is not against the moral or ethics of being a Muslim, quite the opposite. the equivalent would be a Muslim working in a business that sells alcohol, that would be tough and a lot of Muslims avoid such roles if they can. this is just dumb.

BetsyBobbins · 07/11/2023 14:41

She is the unreasonable one, not you! If the precious flower can't stand being contaminated by a Christmas card, I'd say she is not following the teachings of her own religion.

Mazuslongtoenail · 07/11/2023 14:40

LadyBevvy · 07/11/2023 14:30

Sure, it's reasonable to pass on doing something for reasons of religion and belief.

Other examples might include refusing to use someone's preferred pronouns if they differ from one's biological sex, in the workplace, if this is a sincerely held belief in biological sex. Maya Forstater recently won a court case on this.

A Jewish admin assistance could refuse to pop out and buy bacon sandwiches for a client lunch, as another example.

I'm pretty sure it's a protected characteristic in law.

You weren't unreasonable to ask at all and I don't think you were insensitive. Just move on. Maybe also in future switch to e-cards. Much, much less hassle and cheaper!

This is an interesting example. Refusal to use someone’s preferred pronouns is clear cut (based on the ruling).

But a similar example to the OP might be to enter people’s preferred pronouns from a written list into the HR database E.g office admin.

Would refusal to do that also be protected?

InSpainTheRain · 07/11/2023 14:38

Of course you are not unreasonable to ask her - it sounds exactly the sort of thing admin in a PR company would do! She isn't sending the cards in her personal name, but is probably printing out addresses, sticking them on and putting the cards in an envelope and posting them on the company's behalf. I also don't think it is insensitive to ask her at all.

therealcookiemonster · 07/11/2023 14:38

wtf. that's her job. what a strange attitude.. and I say that as a Muslim. its not like you are asking her to to chug whiskey while sitting in a pile of bacon. honestly!

Whataretheodds · 07/11/2023 14:38

YANBU.
She is being unreasonable.

Unless the cards are made of bacon

caringcarer · 07/11/2023 14:38

It's part of her job role so she's being unreasonable refusing to do so. Lots of Muslins send Xmas cards. If part of my role was to sort out Diwali lights I'd just do it. You're not asking for her to personally send a Xmas card, just to sort them out from business. I'd think she should have a verbal warning or if she's only just started I'd wonder if she's suited to the role and maybe get rid of her and appoint someone more accommodating.

NorthStarRising · 07/11/2023 14:37

Can you accommodate her wishes easily? Then it’d be worth it for the goodwill, showing a bit of sensitivity towards an employee. I presume she won’t be putting in for leave around Christmas, which is handy.
Or you could say that it’s part of the job description, and then she either complies uncomfortably or leaves.
Up to you, but flexibility is a good sign in management.

Maddy70 · 07/11/2023 14:37

She's unreasonable. Loads of my Muslim friends.ds send cards and attend the Xmas do. It's am admin task.

Cincinnatus · 07/11/2023 14:36

It’s just one part of her job really. I don’t think you’re being unreasonable to ask.

BrimfulOfMash · 07/11/2023 14:36

She isn’t being asked to take part in an act of worship, handle pork, include her personal greeting… she is BU.

Are the cards even religious?

Forsakenalmosthuman · 07/11/2023 14:35

She sounds like a walking talking discrimination suit waiting to happen.

Of course it's not an unreasonable request though.

MarjorieTheManager · 07/11/2023 14:35

She’d be doing it in the name of your business, not her personally. I see no issue her doing this task.