Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask a Muslim admin assistant to organise Christams cards

138 replies

Goodfrock · 07/11/2023 14:27

We're a small PR company who sends out lots of Christmas cards. Whether this is worthwhile is up for debate, but the decision has been taken that it will continue for this year at least.

The admin assistant to whom this task falls is a newly appointed Muslim woman I.e
The person in her role has done it previously but it wasn't her last year.

She's not comfortable organising the cards. Was it an unreasonable request? This is very much a genuine question. I'm kicking myself for being insensitive at the same time as thinking it would be daft to get someone more senior to do it.

OP posts:
LaurieStrode · 07/11/2023 15:45

RebekaTuwin · 07/11/2023 15:33

I may have misunderstood. The OP
“The person in her role has done it previously but it wasn't her last year.”

The new Muslim employee could not have done it last year, so it’s not talking about her.

I read this sentence as talking about the previous employee in the role has done the task previously, but she did not do it last year. So an unknown “her” a third employee must have done it last year. Which means this task isn’t always assigned to that admin assistant role.

I interpreted it as "the person in the role has done the cards in the past, but last year the person in the role was not the current employee in the role."

Not that there was a third party doing the cards last year.

RebekaTuwin · 07/11/2023 15:43

See “There's an admin assistant and then the client facing staff and directors.”
One of my admin assistants is client facing (receptionist), the rest are not? So this isn’t clear to me either.

RebekaTuwin · 07/11/2023 15:40

Oganesson118 · 07/11/2023 15:35

There is one admin assistant. The admin assistant always does the job.

Last year this Muslim colleague was not the admin assistant. Someone else was. Now she has left and the Muslim colleague is the admin assistant.

The unknown "her" is the Muslim woman.

Edited

How do you know there is only one admin assistant? Not to be funny, but I have four?

RebekaTuwin · 07/11/2023 15:37

From How Should an Employer Accommodate Religion in the Workplace in England and Wales?

”6. Be Sensitive When Allocating Work DutiesSome workplace duties may not suit staff due to their religion or belief. Likewise, a good employer will think about this before allocating where possible. If a staff member asks not to carry out a duty, you should consider this request where possible.”
https://legalvision.co.uk/employment/religion-in-the-workplace/

Accommodating Religion in the Workplace | LegalVision UK

As an employer, you have a legal duty not to discriminate on the grounds of religion and belief in the workplace. We explain your obligations.

https://legalvision.co.uk/employment/religion-in-the-workplace/

Forsakenalmosthuman · 07/11/2023 15:37

Our Muslim neighbours absolutely hate Halloween. So what. So do I.

It's not relevant to someone performing a fairly generic admin task in a work environment where some degree of professionalism is required.

Oganesson118 · 07/11/2023 15:35

RebekaTuwin · 07/11/2023 15:33

I may have misunderstood. The OP
“The person in her role has done it previously but it wasn't her last year.”

The new Muslim employee could not have done it last year, so it’s not talking about her.

I read this sentence as talking about the previous employee in the role has done the task previously, but she did not do it last year. So an unknown “her” a third employee must have done it last year. Which means this task isn’t always assigned to that admin assistant role.

There is one admin assistant. The admin assistant always does the job.

Last year this Muslim colleague was not the admin assistant. Someone else was. Now she has left and the Muslim colleague is the admin assistant.

The unknown "her" is the Muslim woman.

TheresaCrowd · 07/11/2023 15:33

I hate these threads, they make Muslims look like intolerant idiots when in my vast experience, they're usually anything but.

Won't be long before Facebook groups are full of people claiming we can't say 'Merry Christmas' anymore 🙄🙄

I have yet in all my 50+ years to meet a Muslim in this country who is offended by Christmas or anything to do with Christmas.

RebekaTuwin · 07/11/2023 15:33

EmmaEmerald · 07/11/2023 15:23

@RebekaTuwin I think you might have misunderstood?

or have I?

I thought the current person in post was not at the firm last year? So her predecessor did it?

I may have misunderstood. The OP
“The person in her role has done it previously but it wasn't her last year.”

The new Muslim employee could not have done it last year, so it’s not talking about her.

I read this sentence as talking about the previous employee in the role has done the task previously, but she did not do it last year. So an unknown “her” a third employee must have done it last year. Which means this task isn’t always assigned to that admin assistant role.

Giggorata · 07/11/2023 15:31

Of course it's not unreasonable to ask an admin assistant to do such a task.
I'm pagan, and I'd do it, (even though it's a festival annexed from us.😈)

LaurieStrode · 07/11/2023 15:30

No, she shouldn't be allowed to offload her work onto others, who presumably have their own jobs to do.

I would suggest that a general Seasons Greetings card would be fine. I wish Happy New Year cards would catch on more as I'd like to send them myself, instead of fitting in Christmas cards during the pre-holiday rush.

RebekaTuwin · 07/11/2023 15:29

Toptotoe · 07/11/2023 15:08

Muslims swear on a Christian bible in court as they believe Jesus was a prophet- he is revered in their culture and Mary - Jesus’ mother has a whole chapter in the Q’uran.

It seems to me she is making excuses.

Not usually in the U.K.
Muslims either swear on the Quran or verbally affirm in the names or attributes of God (Allah).

Mostlyoblivious · 07/11/2023 15:29

Out of interest, at interview stage, did she object to taking Christmas Day off?
Does your company send out cards for celebrations such as Eid, Hanukkah, Diwali etc?
I can see both sides. It could be a really interesting conversation, albeit it not one to get your cards sent out

sollenwir · 07/11/2023 15:28

Is it part of the job role or just an add on?

Allthegoodnamesarechosen · 07/11/2023 15:28

therealcookiemonster · 07/11/2023 14:38

wtf. that's her job. what a strange attitude.. and I say that as a Muslim. its not like you are asking her to to chug whiskey while sitting in a pile of bacon. honestly!

That sounds fun, I’ll apply, as long as I’m allowed to eat the bacon!

( people like you lift the spirits in hope for better times to come, Cookie Monster 💐)

Humbugg · 07/11/2023 15:27

YANBU but I would be carful with her looking to pull a discrimination case on you

PurpleChrayne · 07/11/2023 15:23

A Jewish admin assistance could refuse to pop out and buy bacon sandwiches for a client lunch, as another example.

Could they though? I'm Jewish and I'm sure there nothing in Halacha (Jewish law) that prevents a Jew from procuring non-kosher food for others.

EmmaEmerald · 07/11/2023 15:23

@RebekaTuwin I think you might have misunderstood?

or have I?

I thought the current person in post was not at the firm last year? So her predecessor did it?

RebekaTuwin · 07/11/2023 15:20

The admin assistant to whom this task falls is a newly appointed Muslim woman I.e The person in her role has done it previously but it wasn't her last year.

I think on this basis, YABU as it appears that this task hasn’t always fallen to the same admin assistant every year. It was alright to ask, but I don’t think it is reasonable to refuse to use your flexibility to assign to a different admin person which has been done in the past, and after being requested to use it by an employee of a different religion. It isn’t a case of this employee is the only admin assistant or only employee that could do the cards.

She is not being unreasonable to ask you to assign a religiously oriented task to a different admin assistant. It’s religious accommodation and you don’t have the defence of only she can do the task.

Mollymodel · 07/11/2023 15:13

listsandbudgets · 07/11/2023 14:32

She is an admin assistant. This is an admin job. She should do it.

Loads of Muslims send Christmas cards - even our local Mosque posts a card with seasonal greetings through our letter box every year.

You're not asking her to do it in her personal name but on behalf of the company. If you want to make any adjustment at all make them seasons greetings rather than actual Christmas cards but she needs to just get on and do it.

My friend is vegeterian - for a while she had to work in the offices of an abbitorir because the job centre said they'd withdraw her UC otherwise. She was not ecstatic but she did it anyway

Our Muslim friends send Christmas cards - and we send good wishes and sweets for Eid Al-Fitr. It hurts no one - quite the opposite. Good luck with that new worker OP.

I think making a vegetarian person work in an abattoir was cruel though. Abattoirs do hurt animals so it’s not remotely the same.

Crikeyalmighty · 07/11/2023 15:13

She's totally unreasonable- lots of people get asked to do stuff as part of their job that's outside of their religious beliefs

Gymnopedie · 07/11/2023 15:12

Surely there's a simple compromise that doesn't put too much on any one person. OP you choose the design and specify the message. She then deals with the rest because after that it is purely admin.

JustAMinutePleass · 07/11/2023 15:12

Islam isn’t like the other religions mentioned on this thread. It specicifically makes celebrating other religious festivals haraam and the sending of Christmas cards is one of those things. If you’re sending them to Muslims they’ll binned at best, at worst they’ll feel like your company isn’t for them. If this is a marketing opportunity you should rename them Seasons Greetings cards and send them with generic wishes for the entire holiday period.

Birdcar · 07/11/2023 15:12

Unless you're sending out religious themed cards you're not being unreasonable. Otherwise non Christian retail and hospitality workers wouldn't work during the Christmas period when it's all Christmas lunches and Christmas tatt decorations and gifts.

mathanxiety · 07/11/2023 15:09

It's not a religious observance she's being asked to do. It's part of the company's broader client outreach.

She's being unreasonable, particularly if the cards you're sending are secular in design, but even if the feature traditional motifs like Manger scenes, angels, etc, they're still a completely secular tradition.

Could your company find a way to mark what is known in the US as "the holidays" or "the holiday season"? Perhaps some of your clients celebrate Diwali or Hanukkah or just the New Year? It might be a good idea to not restrict yourselves to Christmas greetings.

Mustreadabook · 07/11/2023 15:09

I can see that she might be ‘uncomfortable’ as in not know what is appropriate for the selection of card images and messages for something she has never celebrated. If you choose them would that solve the problem? She just orders and sends.