Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask a Muslim admin assistant to organise Christams cards

138 replies

Goodfrock · 07/11/2023 14:27

We're a small PR company who sends out lots of Christmas cards. Whether this is worthwhile is up for debate, but the decision has been taken that it will continue for this year at least.

The admin assistant to whom this task falls is a newly appointed Muslim woman I.e
The person in her role has done it previously but it wasn't her last year.

She's not comfortable organising the cards. Was it an unreasonable request? This is very much a genuine question. I'm kicking myself for being insensitive at the same time as thinking it would be daft to get someone more senior to do it.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
RhiWrites · 08/11/2023 14:12

Send generic “happy holidays” cards and tell her she can choose non representational ones. That’s much more inclusive anyway.

CharlotteRumpling · 08/11/2023 13:50

I am not Christian or from British culture, but I manage to send out Xmas cards with robins, wreaths or snowmen. Not rocket science.

Unbelievably precious.

enchantedsquirrelwood · 08/11/2023 13:26

With your update, I can sort of see her point. You are not asking her to perform a purely administrative task, which would definitely be reasonable, but in fact you are asking her to suggest the design and messaging on an event that is not part of her culture

Yes I have a little more sympathy now.

But I still think she is being a bit precious. Getting secular cards that say Season's greetings and asking her to shove them in an envelope and send is simple admin.

But even if she is asked to find a design and message it doesn't have to be religious - find a card with snowy winter scene (avoid a church, something like a postbox will do), and add Seasons Greetings from [OP's company]. Done. No religious input required.

Tartareistasty · 08/11/2023 11:39

I think it's the design, chosing text etc rather than just simply sending out cards.

HattieBrown · 08/11/2023 11:32

So any work you do geared towards christian celebrations eg Christmas/Easter etc she wont do as its not her religion? Shes automatically excluded from doing the work? Thats not right. She will take the holiday time off tho, will she participate in Christmas work lunch/party and secret santa if you do one?? You need HR guidance on this

im atheist, ill do any admin work asked of me! This is ridiculous. This is taking quietly quitting to a whole new level

She will be complaining about the office Christmas tree next/Christmas Jumpers 🤦🏻‍♀️🤣

Pelegrinfalcon · 08/11/2023 11:24

I just don't get what her objection is. Sorting Xmas cards on behalf of the employer is hardly religious worship. What exactly is the problem?

LaurieStrode · 08/11/2023 10:43

People can choose whatever boundaries they wish but if that means they are incompatible with the fundamental tasks of the job, they need to be prepared for the consequences.

Religion is voluntarily chosen, it's not something immutable like a physical disability.

WearingTheHardHat · 08/11/2023 10:20

LaurieStrode · 07/11/2023 21:14

There is if she is refusing to do her job.

We have a vegan assistant; she doesn't protest when she has to serve our chicken salads and burgers at working lunches.

Conversely I know one who wouldn't do that.

I think the point is there are plenty of 'spectrums' involved in things like religions and beliefs, and hard lines for some people are non-existent for others. There's plenty of Muslims happy to engage with Christmas traditions, but plenty who wouldn't.

In this case, we really don't have much option but to take their reasons at face value - none of us know this person and their beliefs, and one perfectly valid version of being a Muslim would be to refrain from engaging with this. I think probably the 'blur' here is it's being done as a corporate thing, so it's quite an interesting question to me and can see plenty of arguments for and against.

valadon68 · 08/11/2023 08:59

Surely the solution is to get her to organise a solution by authorising her to try and swap tasks with someone else. If she can't find someone to do it, then she does it. Either way, the responsibility for making sure the cards are sent somehow is hers.

tooloudly · 08/11/2023 07:41

I had a Muslim colleague who would come for afterwork drinks, she’d have non alcoholic cocktails but insisted on standing a round of alcoholic drinks for everyone else.

A friend worked for a company owned by two Jewish men. The were less observant than some, more observant than others and every year they threw a legendary “Christmas” party. The firm was racially/ethnically diverse and everyone attended.

JustAMinutePleass · 07/11/2023 22:33

Forsakenalmosthuman · 07/11/2023 15:37

Our Muslim neighbours absolutely hate Halloween. So what. So do I.

It's not relevant to someone performing a fairly generic admin task in a work environment where some degree of professionalism is required.

A lot of Hindus think Halloween isn’t taken seriously enough. We spend Hindu Halloween dodging cars at crossroads to feed demons lol

LaurieStrode · 07/11/2023 21:14

Lavender14 · 07/11/2023 19:47

I feel like a lot of people are missing that point that not all people practice religions in the same way. As a Christian I have no issue celebrating Halloween or drinking or doing yoga. But there are lots of Christians who would see each of those as something they cannot do due to their faith. Each person should be afforded room to practice their faith as they see fit. So while there may be Muslims who wouldn't mind doing this particular task, the point is that this particular individual feels its something she can't in good conscience do in how she practices her own personal faith. And there is nothing wrong with that.

There is if she is refusing to do her job.

We have a vegan assistant; she doesn't protest when she has to serve our chicken salads and burgers at working lunches.

RosesAndHellebores · 07/11/2023 20:01

You aren't being unreasonable to ask but I hope as a company you would also mark Diwali, make adjustments for Ramadan, Jewish New Year, etc. That would demonstrate inclusively for all your stakeholders.

Lavender14 · 07/11/2023 19:47

I feel like a lot of people are missing that point that not all people practice religions in the same way. As a Christian I have no issue celebrating Halloween or drinking or doing yoga. But there are lots of Christians who would see each of those as something they cannot do due to their faith. Each person should be afforded room to practice their faith as they see fit. So while there may be Muslims who wouldn't mind doing this particular task, the point is that this particular individual feels its something she can't in good conscience do in how she practices her own personal faith. And there is nothing wrong with that.

Oganesson118 · 07/11/2023 19:22

RebekaTuwin · 07/11/2023 16:01

Where? I’ve read all the posts and…not clear that there is only person who can be assigned the task.

"Why surely? It's a small company. There's an admin assistant and then the client facing staff and directors."

AN admin assistant. That's singular.

It is in the admin assistant's remit. Not to add to someone else's because the admin assistant doesn't fancy it.

RebekaTuwin · 07/11/2023 16:12

EmmaEmerald · 07/11/2023 15:46

@RebekaTuwin yes, we've interpreted that differently but your version of another person being available doesn't strike me from any OP posts.

I may have the wrong end of the stick. Regardless, the OP should try and accommodate the request as it is based on the religious beliefs of her employee. Practices of Islam are as varied as Judiaism and Christianity, even before we take into account personal levels of religious adherence, so we cannot say that because other Muslims do it, then she is unreasonable.

CharlotteRumpling · 07/11/2023 16:12

CharlotteRumpling · 07/11/2023 16:10

Absolutely unreasonable. Am not Christian either and would be happy to do this.

I meant unreasonable of her to refuse!

Tartareistasty · 07/11/2023 16:10

Sending them out to clients, fine. But this is lots of involvement so I get why she said no kind of.

There were number of fatwas going either way on Christmas greetings exchange. Iirc Muslim World League did let out that exchange is permissable so not haram

CharlotteRumpling · 07/11/2023 16:10

Absolutely unreasonable. Am not Christian either and would be happy to do this.

RebekaTuwin · 07/11/2023 16:09

Toptotoe · 07/11/2023 15:54

in my 25 years of working in a crown court I have never seen one Muslim aware on the Q’uaran. I have asked several why they don’t and they say the bible is a sacred book to them.

Odd. It’s quite clear it’s standard practice in an English court per Hajj Ahmad Thomson, a barrister who is head of Wynne Chambers, and Deputy Chairman of the Association of Muslim Lawyers.
On page 6 of his FAQ on the practice he states as much (see screenshot).
https://www.wynnechambers.co.uk/pdf/Swearing_an_Oath.pdf

To ask a Muslim admin assistant to organise Christams cards
RebekaTuwin · 07/11/2023 16:01

Oganesson118 · 07/11/2023 15:51

Because OP has said so?

Where? I’ve read all the posts and…not clear that there is only person who can be assigned the task.

Toptotoe · 07/11/2023 15:54

in my 25 years of working in a crown court I have never seen one Muslim aware on the Q’uaran. I have asked several why they don’t and they say the bible is a sacred book to them.

Oganesson118 · 07/11/2023 15:51

RebekaTuwin · 07/11/2023 15:40

How do you know there is only one admin assistant? Not to be funny, but I have four?

Because OP has said so?

NurseButtercup · 07/11/2023 15:47

YABU
Instead of having a conversation with your colleague to understand what aspects of this task they are uncomfortable with, you start a thread on Mumsnet.

You then reveal that you've asked a Muslim person, who is also new to your organisation to pick cards in terms of the image and the message. YABVVU

I suggest you pick the cards in terms of the image and message and delegate the task of stuffing envelopes to your colleague. The laborious part of this project is stuffing the envelopes. You've completely blown this out of proportion.

EmmaEmerald · 07/11/2023 15:46

@RebekaTuwin yes, we've interpreted that differently but your version of another person being available doesn't strike me from any OP posts.