Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think it's not appropriate for school trip to include a visit to a bullring?

109 replies

Merula · 07/11/2023 14:22

Interested to hear your views. Our school have announced a trip to Madrid, which will include a visit to a bullring. Obviously it will not be while a bull fight is occurring, but there is a fee to visit the bullring, so in effect, by paying for my child to attend, we will be supporting bullfighting. A previous trip to Spain included a visit to a dolphinarium. Would you be ok with this or would you question the appropriateness with the school?

OP posts:
Naimee87 · 07/11/2023 15:52

I would refuse to pay. I agree with your feelings on this and my DS wouldnt want to visit either. What an awful place to go sight-seeing to on a school trip...

Merula · 07/11/2023 15:50

CremeEggThief · 07/11/2023 15:49

I think this is ok from a historical perspective to be honest and I'm known for my strong views on animal rights!

So you're happy to contribute towards bullfighting?

OP posts:
Merula · 07/11/2023 15:50

Haydenn · 07/11/2023 15:47

We “cancelled” and banned fox hunting in this country because people didn’t agree with it. If fact we banned bear fighting, badger baiting and dog fighting too. We campaign to end international whaling and the fur trade.

So of course you can not go to things. Coupled with this there is an entry fee which will be going to support the venue where this event happens. It would be like me saying I don’t support whaling, but here let me buy some diesel for your boat…

if they want to learn from a cultural POV they can see the building from outside, use books, online resources and videos. There’s plenty of ways to learn that doesn’t financially support the event

This is what I'm trying to get across. By paying a fee, I am funding bullfighting.

OP posts:
CremeEggThief · 07/11/2023 15:49

I think this is ok from a historical perspective to be honest and I'm known for my strong views on animal rights!

Haydenn · 07/11/2023 15:47

Prebtaf · 07/11/2023 15:36

It's part of the culture and history. An unsavoury part, Yes, but you can't just cancel and ignore everything you don't agree with. Why not go and learn about the building, the history, the architecture and then I'm sure they'll have a better understanding on which to debate why bullfighting is wrong.

We “cancelled” and banned fox hunting in this country because people didn’t agree with it. If fact we banned bear fighting, badger baiting and dog fighting too. We campaign to end international whaling and the fur trade.

So of course you can not go to things. Coupled with this there is an entry fee which will be going to support the venue where this event happens. It would be like me saying I don’t support whaling, but here let me buy some diesel for your boat…

if they want to learn from a cultural POV they can see the building from outside, use books, online resources and videos. There’s plenty of ways to learn that doesn’t financially support the event

Merula · 07/11/2023 15:47

AnnaMasse · 07/11/2023 15:43

I've been to a bull ring, not when a bullfight was going on. It's part of history, and I didn't feel I was betraying my principles (I didn't have to pay). My Spanish friend who is passionately opposed to bullfighting came with me.

I would be ok with her going if it was free.

OP posts:
AnnaMasse · 07/11/2023 15:43

I've been to a bull ring, not when a bullfight was going on. It's part of history, and I didn't feel I was betraying my principles (I didn't have to pay). My Spanish friend who is passionately opposed to bullfighting came with me.

Prebtaf · 07/11/2023 15:36

It's part of the culture and history. An unsavoury part, Yes, but you can't just cancel and ignore everything you don't agree with. Why not go and learn about the building, the history, the architecture and then I'm sure they'll have a better understanding on which to debate why bullfighting is wrong.

AnnaMagnani · 07/11/2023 15:33

Am sure the bullring does put on a nice tour for school kids but not out of the goodness of their hearts.

It's an income stream for a business.

If this was just about debating pros and cons the tour bus could drive past, have a look at the building and the teacher could talk about it.

Merula · 07/11/2023 15:31

skyofdiamonds · 07/11/2023 15:24

I visited a bullring in Madrid with my secondary school in year 9.
It was extremely interesting and explored a lot of Spanish history.
The teachers and us pupils were not pro bull fighting but simply learning about this part of their culture.
It was part of a whole trip to Madrid that included visiting lots of the landmarks, including the football stadium.

Let your child go and discover their own thoughts and opinions without their parent controlling their thoughts and sabotaging their experiences.
They’re old enough to question the humanity behind it and no doubt it will be discussed with their peers and teachers.

It's not about 'controlling my daughter's thoughts'- she's quite free to make up her own mind. It's about paying money to a business that tortures thousands of animals every year for fun!

OP posts:
Katiesaidthat · 07/11/2023 15:31

It must be Las Ventas. It is actually a very impressive historical building. And I say that as a Spaniard who hasn´t attended a bullfight in her 49 years on planet Earth. I visited the Ronda 18th century bullring and found it really fascinating. Few people attend actual bullfights and they take place at certain times during the year only, like the San Isidro fair. Bullfighting was a very important cultural expression and had important influence on the arts at one time and it is still important for the countryside and rural life in certain areas of the country. It will die a natural death once there aren´t enough ticket buyers to sustain them. Right now most bullrings are used for shows and concerts. I remember the last survey I read in Spain as for and against was 49 against-51 for. It is best to let them make up their own opinion, and chill out.

Haydenn · 07/11/2023 15:29

I absolutely wouldn’t pay and I’m sure enough kids and their parents would agree that bullfighting is a barbaric custom that a contingent of kids could do an alternative activity whilst this is going on.

dolphin hunts are a part of Faroese culture and I wouldn’t expect to support that either

Coyoacan · 07/11/2023 15:29

I've lived in a country where there is bullfighting for nearly fifty years and, alongside the vast majority of the population oppose it and have never felt the need to visit a bullring

Palmasailor · 07/11/2023 15:28

Why not let them visit it and see what goes on.

Thay can debate it.

You can’t cover their eyes forever.

Gerrataere · 07/11/2023 15:26

No I wouldn’t support this at all. And ‘culture’ is often code for ‘doing shitty things that you can’t call them out on for because it’s their ‘culture’.

skyofdiamonds · 07/11/2023 15:24

I visited a bullring in Madrid with my secondary school in year 9.
It was extremely interesting and explored a lot of Spanish history.
The teachers and us pupils were not pro bull fighting but simply learning about this part of their culture.
It was part of a whole trip to Madrid that included visiting lots of the landmarks, including the football stadium.

Let your child go and discover their own thoughts and opinions without their parent controlling their thoughts and sabotaging their experiences.
They’re old enough to question the humanity behind it and no doubt it will be discussed with their peers and teachers.

Chocolatecoveredshitpig · 07/11/2023 15:22

No I wouldn't be happy about this at all. Can you enlist some other like minded parents and approach the school as a group to outline your objections and possibly suggest an alternative?
When I was 10 I went skiing with my primary school, (mid eighties), and one evening the 'planned activity' was a tour of the local abattoir! My parents thought I was joking when I got home and told them! 😂😂

HeddaGarbled · 07/11/2023 15:18

It will be glorified, because they're not going to be showing the prolonged cruelty of it at the bullring - they want to promote it

I think the young people will be able to form their own opinions and it may actually raise awareness.

cheezncrackers · 07/11/2023 15:14

I think if you're studying Spanish and visiting Spain as a student of the Spanish language and culture then a visit to a bullring is justified, because it is an important part of Spanish culture. You may not personally support bullfighting, but that doesn't diminish its importance to Spanish culture. I would question the need to ever visit a dolphinarium for any reason at all, but IMO visiting a bullring is different.

AnnaMagnani · 07/11/2023 15:14

A balanced approach to bullfighting would surely start with that it is only popular with a tiny and dwindling minority.

Or for a school trip doing something else that actually represents Spain.

Maddy70 · 07/11/2023 15:12

Bullring are architecturally stunning. It's good for them to see everything. They don't have to agree with bull fighting and ot will raise interesting discussions for the students. (Which is probably one of the objectives )

Honeysuckle16 · 07/11/2023 15:10

Under no circumstances would I endorse a visit to a bullring and I can’t believe that a school thinks this is appropriate. If they want the pupils to learn about bullfighting, this can be done through educational materials. A visit to the bullring, especially paying a fee to do so, is endorsing animal cruelty. Same with the dolphinarium visit.

AnnaMagnani · 07/11/2023 15:09

Bullfighting is a much smaller part of Spanish culture than it used to be.

Only 2% of the population actually attends bull fights.

So not only do I not think its appropriate for a school trip, it's actively misrepresenting the culture they are supposed to be learning about. And no doubt the bullring makes money from these school trips.

As for the dolphinarium, if it's too cruel to have in the UK, schools should not be taking kids to it abroad.

PosteriorPosterity · 07/11/2023 15:01

I’d rather the bullring than the dolphinarium.

Bull fighting is a large part of Spanish culture. And every moment of the trip doesn’t need to be balanced, a “pro-bullfighting” trip then followed by a debate (which will almost certainly be part of any GCSE or A Level curriculum) is a good balance. I think ignoring it goes on is much worse than understanding and forming personal views.

The dolphinarium, however, is more insidious in its cruelty, has no deep cultural link, and when I was last involved in education was not actively debated in classrooms.

Merula · 07/11/2023 14:59

Fallenangelofthenorth · 07/11/2023 14:57

I wouldn't want to visit either a bullring or a dolphinarium tbh. Both are very cruel.

I agree. I mentioned the dolphinarium to highlight that they've made questionable decisions with regards to school trips in the past.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread