Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think it's not appropriate for school trip to include a visit to a bullring?

109 replies

Merula · 07/11/2023 14:22

Interested to hear your views. Our school have announced a trip to Madrid, which will include a visit to a bullring. Obviously it will not be while a bull fight is occurring, but there is a fee to visit the bullring, so in effect, by paying for my child to attend, we will be supporting bullfighting. A previous trip to Spain included a visit to a dolphinarium. Would you be ok with this or would you question the appropriateness with the school?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
LlynTegid · 12/11/2023 11:28

I don't think it is. You should question this.

If the school won't change the itinerary, at the very least they should provide for children to opt out and do something else.

Fourfurrymonsters · 12/11/2023 11:01

Twoshoesnewshoes · 10/11/2023 09:55

Agree with @QPWO
I do understand the issue with bull fighting, and sympathize with OP and this dilemma.
but, as a similarly wishy washy vegetarian, the bullfight is ONE COW.

How many cows does an average meat eater have killed for their enjoyment each year?

Why is one cow not important but a bull is? To me personally it feels hypocritical to oppose bullfighting but eat a burger. Let’s not pretend that the death in an abattoir is any less painful or distressing than a bullfight.
so I’m not radically opposed to bullfighting or blood sports because I don’t really feel I have a leg to stand on.

If you don’t understand the difference between animal slaughter for food, and torturing and prolonging an animal’s death purely for entertainment, then I’m not sure anyone here can help you.

Twoshoesnewshoes · 10/11/2023 18:46

@Lifeinlists i don’t want to divert from the OP’s thread. Just to say I grew up and currently live in farming communities.
I can hear the cows wailing when their calves are taken.
Did you see a wagon of cattle unloaded and brought into the abbatoir? Have you witnessed the panic as they smell fear and death?
There’s a great documentary called ‘Cow’ which is worth a watch .
im not saying anyone should care or prioritise these animals experiences. I don’t particularly. But equally I wouldn’t be very anti a bullfight either, cos to me animal cruelty is animal cruelty.

Lifeinlists · 10/11/2023 18:39

@Twoshoesnewshoes I think if my burger was produced by first chasing a terrified animal to exhaustion round a large ring in front of many thousands of people shouting and screaming,whilst several men slowly stick a variety of sharp implements into its back until it eventually bleeds to death, then I might decline it.

I'm not sure how you equate that with a UK slaughterhouse. I've been round one as part of my job. It wasn't like a Spanish bull ring, safe to say. Yes the animal ends up dead but there was no prolonged torment for sport and entertainment.

BertieBotts · 10/11/2023 11:36

Yes exactly that. I think it was supposed to be thought provoking, rather than being something that you just have a theoretical opinion about, actually see it and make the judgement for yourself.

Perhaps for the boys they hoped that going through sober and being fully cognizant to see the reality would provide a counter to an experience where they might get very drunk and end up there on a stag do etc.

Plus of course we went at about 10am on a wet grey Tuesday or something like that, so it wasn't like it was full of leery drunk men.

QPWO · 10/11/2023 11:11

BertieBotts · 10/11/2023 10:14

It depends on the age of the DC I think. When I went on a school (college, 16+) trip to Amsterdam we walked through the red light district and there was a visit to the Anne Frank museum.

The red light district was intended to be a sort of "this is a different culture, see what it is like" IIRC. Though honestly, looking back as an adult, it seems like a very strange thing to do! And I remember my female teacher saying she felt uncomfortable leading a group of teenage, mostly girls there.

That is definitely weirder than a bullring visit! Although it was wandering through the red light district at a similar age while interrailing and meeting the eye of a girl who looked my age in a shop window and how sad and completely defeated she looked that turned me instantly from a one-of-the-guys-cool-girl completely against the sex industry in all its guises. So that would be an argument for letting teenagers see the world a bit as part of them making sense of things and forming their own values. Perhaps thinking about the brutality of a bullfight will create an animal rights activist or two! I do think it’s important that the question isn’t one of a personal boycott - I don’t think I would go, but of making that decision on behalf of an adolescent.

BertieBotts · 10/11/2023 10:14

It depends on the age of the DC I think. When I went on a school (college, 16+) trip to Amsterdam we walked through the red light district and there was a visit to the Anne Frank museum.

The red light district was intended to be a sort of "this is a different culture, see what it is like" IIRC. Though honestly, looking back as an adult, it seems like a very strange thing to do! And I remember my female teacher saying she felt uncomfortable leading a group of teenage, mostly girls there.

Megifer · 10/11/2023 10:11

Twoshoesnewshoes · 10/11/2023 09:55

Agree with @QPWO
I do understand the issue with bull fighting, and sympathize with OP and this dilemma.
but, as a similarly wishy washy vegetarian, the bullfight is ONE COW.

How many cows does an average meat eater have killed for their enjoyment each year?

Why is one cow not important but a bull is? To me personally it feels hypocritical to oppose bullfighting but eat a burger. Let’s not pretend that the death in an abattoir is any less painful or distressing than a bullfight.
so I’m not radically opposed to bullfighting or blood sports because I don’t really feel I have a leg to stand on.

I guess I see it similar to going to church.

IME (again as an ex staunch church goer) those who go to church don't generally care why others go, whether it's to get a kid into a school, get christened, or just for the tea and chat, we (now them) we're just happy to see people there, getting involved and coming together in the community, whatever the reason.

For me, if a meat eater is opposed to bull fighting (for e.g ) that's great isn't it, one more person caring? Yes they eat meat and support that industry, but I don't think that should discount them from opposing other areas of animal cruelty. Otherwise the alternative is total apathy towards any animal cruelty, which then means even less people caring, which feels like (us vegans) cutting our noses off to spite our face.

Twoshoesnewshoes · 10/11/2023 09:55

Agree with @QPWO
I do understand the issue with bull fighting, and sympathize with OP and this dilemma.
but, as a similarly wishy washy vegetarian, the bullfight is ONE COW.

How many cows does an average meat eater have killed for their enjoyment each year?

Why is one cow not important but a bull is? To me personally it feels hypocritical to oppose bullfighting but eat a burger. Let’s not pretend that the death in an abattoir is any less painful or distressing than a bullfight.
so I’m not radically opposed to bullfighting or blood sports because I don’t really feel I have a leg to stand on.

GuessItsANameChange · 08/11/2023 21:50

saraclara · 08/11/2023 10:30

Well if OP tries to either stop her DC from going on that part of the trip, or her complaint prevents the entire school party from going, then she IS trying to control her DC's experiences.

No, she’s refusing to financially support something that she is opposed to. Were it free entry (or if DC was somehow paying), and the OP was still objecting, that would be an entirely different matter.

QPWO · 08/11/2023 11:39

Megifer · 08/11/2023 10:35

As a recent convert to veganism (so probably at the most militant stage 🤣 I think saying "you shouldn't care about any animal cruelty whatsoever because you like bacon." is a very strange point to make. Like its ok then if op kicks puppies because she eats meat, because at least she's not a hypocrite?

It's a really bizarre argument.

No it’s more about what’s your own moral responsibility and what’s up to others. As a mere wishy washy vegetarian, I wouldn’t tell my partner not to eat a bacon butty when out while I still buy dairy products. Similarly I personally wouldn’t instigate or join in with this trip but I would let a teenager make their own decisions about it because it would be hypocritical to interfere when I could have a bigger impact on animal welfare by tightening up my own dietary hypocrisies.

WimpiestMum · 08/11/2023 11:16

I misread your title and thought you meant the bull ring shopping centre in Birmingham and was going to say yes that's a bit of a pointless trip but no big dea

Anyway, I understand your misgivings but I think it's an important part of their culture (and I'm sure as many Spanish disagree with bull fighting as those that support it or more) and a great learning opportunity. It will also inspire the kids to think and to come to their own conclusions or have a debate about animal rights and that is always a good thing.

I do understand that you don't want to support it by paying the entrance fee and I think that's a valid point as well.

So to summarize I'm not sure what you should do and my post is almost as pointless as a school trip to the bullring (in Birmingham) would be. :-)

I'd let me kids go though.

coolkatt · 08/11/2023 10:52

i wouldn't be doing anything that even acknowledges bullfighting exsists. don't give a shot about culture they should all be pulled down. i would not allow my child there to even experiance a visit to one. they can read about the cruelty that happens there without actually stepping into one.

Bluedabadeeba · 08/11/2023 10:48

JustWhatWeDontNeed · 08/11/2023 10:15

You are sadly mistaken.

From the venue website:

The bullfighting season
It starts at the end of March and ends in mid-October. During those months a total of more than 70 festivities are celebrated, normally every Sunday (except in Summer when it takes place on Thursdays), except for the two great annual fairs.
The most important Fair that is celebrated at Las Ventas bullring is the one of San Isidro, patron of Madrid, in which there are 30 festivities during the months of May-June.
For more information on schedules and fares, see the website www.las-ventas.com

It's an active and horrific part of the Spanish culture and one that struggles to get outlawed. There are few areas which have banned it and Catalonia's ban was overturned. Bull runs are equally awful and still happen every year. It's a barbaric "sport" with no tangible benefit to anyone other than breeders.

You can learn about both sides of the coin without funding it. I'd send her to Spain but I'd not pay to enter an actively used bullring.

Oh dear. Sorry about that - I stand corrected. Horrified to see how frequently it happens!

Half my family is Spanish, so I think I was just going off the fact that most of them find it as awful as we do - I guess I need to do some solid research about it before spouting off anecdote-based opinions 😣

I'll definitely be asking around to see what they think though. Not sure how it can still be happening in this day and age!!

Megifer · 08/11/2023 10:35

QPWO · 07/11/2023 21:16

Unless you’re vegan then you’re probably supporting animal cruelty far more directly than this (no judgement, I’m not a vegan), so I would personally take your child’s lead on it.

As a recent convert to veganism (so probably at the most militant stage 🤣 I think saying "you shouldn't care about any animal cruelty whatsoever because you like bacon." is a very strange point to make. Like its ok then if op kicks puppies because she eats meat, because at least she's not a hypocrite?

It's a really bizarre argument.

saraclara · 08/11/2023 10:30

GuessItsANameChange · 08/11/2023 03:03

If the thread was about the OP wanting to control her daughter’s thoughts or experiences, this would be a relevant response.

Well if OP tries to either stop her DC from going on that part of the trip, or her complaint prevents the entire school party from going, then she IS trying to control her DC's experiences.

JustWhatWeDontNeed · 08/11/2023 10:15

Bluedabadeeba · 07/11/2023 19:38

What a fantastic way of opening a debate and critical thought. Hopefully it will be used as an opportunity for a cultural understanding of the history AND the debate surrounding it. Let's see how the young people make up their minds!

(FWIW) I actually went to SEE a bullfight when I was 11 where they didn't kill the bull as it was a 'kids' showing', shortly before I became a vegetarian for life. In my 20s, living in the south, my entire group of friends went to see one (for the first time) and I declined.. most of them came out feeling quite traumatised by the experience.

Anyway, not sure, but I think in Madrid, it's very rarely practiced these days - I get the impression most people are against it there. Mostly very cultural entrenched in the south though, from what I understand. Either way, part of the Spanish culture nevertheless.

You are sadly mistaken.

From the venue website:

The bullfighting season
It starts at the end of March and ends in mid-October. During those months a total of more than 70 festivities are celebrated, normally every Sunday (except in Summer when it takes place on Thursdays), except for the two great annual fairs.
The most important Fair that is celebrated at Las Ventas bullring is the one of San Isidro, patron of Madrid, in which there are 30 festivities during the months of May-June.
For more information on schedules and fares, see the website www.las-ventas.com

It's an active and horrific part of the Spanish culture and one that struggles to get outlawed. There are few areas which have banned it and Catalonia's ban was overturned. Bull runs are equally awful and still happen every year. It's a barbaric "sport" with no tangible benefit to anyone other than breeders.

You can learn about both sides of the coin without funding it. I'd send her to Spain but I'd not pay to enter an actively used bullring.

ginasevern · 08/11/2023 09:50

@spirit20

You'd send a curt email to a parent with concerns about a notoriously controversial subject? I'm afraid you'd get a curt email back in that case. Sounds like you're in the wrong job.

DiscoBeat · 08/11/2023 03:06

I really wouldn't be happy with this either. Raise it with the school.

GuessItsANameChange · 08/11/2023 03:03

saraclara · 07/11/2023 22:38

Let your child go and discover their own thoughts and opinions without their parent controlling their thoughts and sabotaging their experiences.
They’re old enough to question the humanity behind it and no doubt it will be discussed with their peers and teachers.

100% that. You cannot control all your child's experiences and all their opinions. It's the experiences they have without you, and the opinions and conclusions that they form for themselves from those experiences, that are the deepest and most valuable

If the thread was about the OP wanting to control her daughter’s thoughts or experiences, this would be a relevant response.

saraclara · 07/11/2023 22:38

Let your child go and discover their own thoughts and opinions without their parent controlling their thoughts and sabotaging their experiences.
They’re old enough to question the humanity behind it and no doubt it will be discussed with their peers and teachers.

100% that. You cannot control all your child's experiences and all their opinions. It's the experiences they have without you, and the opinions and conclusions that they form for themselves from those experiences, that are the deepest and most valuable

Whatsgoingon12345 · 07/11/2023 22:19

*visited a bullring in Madrid with my secondary school in year 9.
It was extremely interesting and explored a lot of Spanish history.
The teachers and us pupils were not pro bull fighting but simply learning about this part of their culture.
It was part of a whole trip to Madrid that included visiting lots of the landmarks, including the football stadium.

Let your child go and discover their own thoughts and opinions without their parent controlling their thoughts and sabotaging their experiences.
They’re old enough to question the humanity behind it and no doubt it will be discussed with their peers and teachers.*
this. They are going to Spain to learn about Spain. Not some watered down Disney fied version that suits our current societies cultural mores.

stickygotstuck · 07/11/2023 21:53

QPWO · 07/11/2023 21:16

Unless you’re vegan then you’re probably supporting animal cruelty far more directly than this (no judgement, I’m not a vegan), so I would personally take your child’s lead on it.

And this! (also not a vegan)

stickygotstuck · 07/11/2023 21:51

Maddy70 · 07/11/2023 16:15

The building is incredible. So much artwork inside it. It's almost like a museum-art gallery. They aren't going to a bull fight. they are going on a tour of a very famous building

Its spectacular and opens debate which serves educationally.

I hate kids being kept in boxes and being told what to think. Let them decide for themselves

I couldn't agree more.

BrokenButNotFinished · 07/11/2023 21:43

I went to the bullring when I was in Madrid, as an adult. It thought it culturally interesting, whilst at the same time finding animal cruelty and blood sports abhorrent.

Some of the 'finest' bull specimens are stuffed and displayed throughout - and the holding pens absolutely stink of the urine of animals that I would conclude are under stress.

There is not much glamour to it, to my mind, something which will likely be evident to those attending. That's still not a reason not to go. One school trip is not going to have much financial impact on the event - & it's part of being educated in the Humanities to explore and comprehend ideas you may not actually agree with.