Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Could exh take me to court...

39 replies

rougeroses · 07/11/2023 13:01

Second thread about him in 24 hours. Please bear with me.

I've spoken to social services this morning in regard to exh seeing our son.

Exh is an abusive narcissist. Called the police about him recently. Got him blocked on everything except an email address.

Exh wanted to see ds tonight but as I am not ready too see him yet, I have suggested next week would be better instead - through email. He has not seen ds for 10 days and has only seen him a few times since September. We have no arrangement for childcare so I am not breaking anything by saying he can see ds next week instead.

Exh has replied that he doesn't want to see ds until all our other things are sorted and he is going to take me to court for the following:

I was given a house through a housing association (very lucky I know) and it was in a terrible state. At this time, things between exh and myself were good. He came to view the house and offered to do it up for me. I did not ask. I did not have to pay him for labour (I offered many times but he declined) just materials.

The work began and over the months I thought I saw a real change in exh. He was in therapy and looked to be sorting his issues. We decided that we would give it a year and then he would move in if things were good. He carried on doing the work - this did take up all of his time. It was a lot of work. He also paid for odd materials which again, I never asked him too. I always said no I would pay….but as we were getting on I thought it was ok. He also paid no maintenance towards our son at this time too. But there was no issues at this point.

I then moved into the house and exh started to stay here on occasions. I bought a bunk bed for my step son too stay here (exh son). Exh had some belongings here and he also set his sky tv account up here and his broadband.

Soon after I moved in, exh was back to his old abusive ways. He left me and asked for his stuff and gave me back his keys. It’s been shit since then and I’ve had to call the police . He will not leave me alone and is a nasty piece of work.

I will have many text messages saying that he wants to do the work for free. That he is going to class it as his home. His son classes it as his home.

We are still married. Not filled for divorce yet - too scared too. He is not on the tenancy or bills apart form the sky tv.

He is now demanding I pay him money for all the labour he did on my home and for the materials he paid for. He is threatening to take me to court if I don’t pay.

Apparently he spoken to citizens advice and he has a good case.

Anyone advice? So sorry this is so long. It’s all just another threat. I know I was stupid for letting him do the work in the first place but please believe when I say, he is very very persistent and persuasive!

OP posts:
FSTraining · 07/11/2023 14:24

You're married so a lot of the detail that you have provided is not relevant (a lot of the facts would become relevant if you were not married). I'm not sure if you own the house or are a tenant but if you do own it then it is a marital asset and will be divided accordingly. Some explanation and questions to follow:

I've spoken to social services this morning in regard to exh seeing our son.

Who got social services involved, you or EXH?

Exh is an abusive narcissist. Called the police about him recently.

Diagnosed or your opinion? Police involvement due to DV?

We have no arrangement for childcare so I am not breaking anything by saying he can see ds next week instead.

He might consider taking you to court for a Child Arrangement Order, although I note he has also said he won't see DS until other things are sorted (seems a bit odd of him but okay).

I was given a house through a housing association (very lucky I know) and it was in a terrible state. At this time, things between exh and myself were good. He came to view the house and offered to do it up for me. I did not ask. I did not have to pay him for labour (I offered many times but he declined) just materials.

If you were not married and you owned the property this might be relevant to whether he is a beneficiary of a constructive trust in the property for the work performed. It may be interpreted on the balance of probabilities that there was a common intention to share the property. However, you are married so this is irrelevant. What is relevant is that it is a marital asset in the pot for division based on your respective needs and the court has full discretion about how it is divided.

It was a lot of work. He also paid for odd materials which again, I never asked him too. I always said no I would pay….but as we were getting on I thought it was ok.

Same as above.

He also paid no maintenance towards our son at this time too. But there was no issues at this point.

Okay, so you were separated but not divorced throughout this time?

I then moved into the house and exh started to stay here on occasions.

This means it started becoming the family marital home.

I bought a bunk bed for my step son too stay here (exh son).

Then a little more....

Exh had some belongings here and he also set his sky tv account up here and his broadband.

And that pretty much sealed it. All assuming you own it of course.

He left me and asked for his stuff and gave me back his keys.

So he has now moved out and not moved back in? He will still have matrimonial home rights unless you have an NMO in place, do you?

That he is going to class it as his home. His son classes it as his home.

He seems to be right about that.

We are still married. Not filled for divorce yet - too scared too. He is not on the tenancy or bills apart form the sky tv.

When you say tenancy, what do you mean? Do you mean you hold the legal title or you are a leaseholder? And if a leaseholder, is that long or short term? As in, is this an assured or fixed term tenancy?

He is now demanding I pay him money for all the labour he did on my home and for the materials he paid for. He is threatening to take me to court if I don’t pay.

If the house is not owned then I doubt there is much he will be able to do about it. If you do own it, then it will be considered a marital asset and fighting over who spent what on it is pointless because that's not how a FMH is divided.

Apparently he spoken to citizens advice and he has a good case.

Possibly, if it is owned. He probably does have a case if you are only a tenant but not as strong a case.

rougeroses · 07/11/2023 13:55

Ffs sake....he's just sent me another email saying it doesn't have to be like this....he's not a bad person and as he is now in a new relationship (🎉🥳🍾 he expects me to be devastated 😂) and moving forward with them, he just wants things right for our son.

This is an hour after he said he doesn't wish to see him.

What an absolute wanker.

Not replying to that either.

Sorry everyone - I just can't get over this idiot that I married.

When will I learn not to take his empty threats seriously 🙄😂

OP posts:
rougeroses · 07/11/2023 13:27

Octavia64 · 07/11/2023 13:21

You are married.

He was staying over there, as was his son.

You have evidence he intended to do the work for free.

His case will be laughed out of court.

He is trying to manipulate you.

No court in the land would say you needed to pay.

I'm actually really glad I haven't filed for divorce. I don't know if it would count as evidence or not but I've got hundreds of messages from him saying he loves me and wants this to work. He will do anything. He will change etc etc.....I've got it all. As well as 2 calls to the police, calls to social services, working with the domestic abuse charity. He also now fully admits he doesn't want to see his son. He is vile.

I'm doing a course on domestic abuse at the moment through a women's charity. It's absolutely amazing. I'm sure the charity does free legal advice so I'll see if I can have a chat with them too.

I know everyone is right here - I truly am just so fed up of this.

OP posts:
Octavia64 · 07/11/2023 13:21

You are married.

He was staying over there, as was his son.

You have evidence he intended to do the work for free.

His case will be laughed out of court.

He is trying to manipulate you.

No court in the land would say you needed to pay.

rougeroses · 07/11/2023 13:17

He also put in the email that he cannot believe that I am playing the victim.

The last time I saw him he took my phone off me and looked through it. He is convinced I am in a new relationship. I'm not. This is in my home.

He refused to leave when I asked him too. Kept asking me over and over 'why are you being like this?'

Then told me he was going to kill himself and it would be all my fault as he eventually left.

OP posts:
rougeroses · 07/11/2023 13:14

Quitelikeit · 07/11/2023 13:08

Sadly you are still caught in the cycle of abuse.

Each time you communicate with this man you are feeding him.

Advise him that you have electronic proof he agreed to complete the works for free and that will be presented in court if he takes you there.

Tell him you will check your email once a week on a Friday from here on in

I know, it's crap.

I have literally spent all morning on the phone to social services and my local domestic abuse charity and I've followed their advice about cancelling tonight's visit.

I sent him in email saying we can start it next week and I don't wish to speak about anything other than ds. I knew I would get a shitty response from him. And I know there will be more to come.

I didn't quite have enough evidence for a non molestation order when calling the police sadly.

OP posts:
CathyAnne91 · 07/11/2023 13:11

He hasn’t got a leg to stand on by the sounds of it. This is just another form of abuse he’s trying.

Allocate 1 hour / time frame to deal with your email correspondence with him and that’s that. Xx

Willyoujustbequiet · 07/11/2023 13:10

It's bluff.

You are married. Any outstanding financial issues will be dealt with under the consent order. 50/50 asset split is the starting point but as you are the resident parent it's highly likely to be weighted in your favour. CAB will have told him that.

Either wait for him to petition you or start it yourself. Apply to CMS separately. If you are low income you can be exempt from court fees. If there is DA you may be eligible for legal aid too.

rougeroses · 07/11/2023 13:10

I've literally got messages from him only 2 weeks ago saying he will come and complete the last pieces of work on the house and I don't need to worry about anything.

This is all just because I'm trying to stand up for myself and escape him.

He is up to his eyeballs in debt so I doubt very much he would take me to court. I'm expecting he will email me with a figure that he wants. I'll then say we can deal with it through the courts.

At least I now have proof that he doesn't want to see his son. All this is just because I have cancelled tonight's visit because I don't feel exh is mentally well enough and i feel very very uncertain. This is the response I get.

OP posts:
Quitelikeit · 07/11/2023 13:08

Sadly you are still caught in the cycle of abuse.

Each time you communicate with this man you are feeding him.

Advise him that you have electronic proof he agreed to complete the works for free and that will be presented in court if he takes you there.

Tell him you will check your email once a week on a Friday from here on in

Ibravedaflood · 07/11/2023 13:08

File for divorce.. Claim cms. And laugh in his face about what YOU owe HIM..

rougeroses · 07/11/2023 13:06

xILikeJamx · 07/11/2023 13:04

Sounds like a load of bollocks. There was presumably no contracts in place, no invoicing, no receipts, no bookkeeping, etc, etc, etc. so he's almost certainly just talking shit.

Yeah nothing at all. I have receipts of the materials that I have paid for and proof in my bank statements.

Definitely no invoices or anything like that. He didn't take it on as a job. He took it on to help me out.

OP posts:
WhamBamThankU · 07/11/2023 13:04

You have message evidence that he was essentially gifting you his time and materials. Let him take you to court.

xILikeJamx · 07/11/2023 13:04

Sounds like a load of bollocks. There was presumably no contracts in place, no invoicing, no receipts, no bookkeeping, etc, etc, etc. so he's almost certainly just talking shit.