Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to expect the majority of adults to use technology?

188 replies

gdaysport · 07/11/2023 12:36

The majority of UK households will have had the internet in some form for the last 20 years. We have had smartphones which have been common for at least 15 years.

AIBU to expect most adults to be able to use the internet etc to navigate the world by now?

For example, living in zone 4 London with frequent bus services, at least a few times a week there will be a bewildered adult asking the bus driver where they need to get off, if the bus (with the massive sign on front saying 'Woolwich' goes to Woolwich, or the train station. You can use google maps, TFL app, bus apps, all which tell you which way to go.

Bus drivers of course, rarely give a shiny shit and I normally step in to help and tell people where they need to go, but I just don't understand the frequency in which I need to do this?

I even extend this criticism to my own parents who have such poor technological literacy they panic at the very idea of checking what time a train leaves.

At a recent hospital stay, two women on the ward in their mid 50s with me, both of their families encouraged them to borrow and use ipads so they could watch their soaps etc to pass the time but they batted them away saying they cant use them. They would have been in their 30s when ipads were introduced. So instead they would just sit bored staring at a wall rather than be shown how to use the app.

Technology is only going to become more ingrained in our lives, should we not be encouraging people to become sufficient in using it, rather than being cut off from the world? Stranded at bus stops as they dont know where to go, not knowing how to book a GP appointment online which is quicker etc.

Preparing to be flamed!

OP posts:
MigGirl · 07/11/2023 13:12

Oh and OP I maybe prity tech savy, having used it a lot. But I'm also dyslexic, can't read the boards at the railway station as they filp over to fast and have had to ask for help when I've had no phone signal. It's frustrating when it doesn't work. I'm also fed-up of being forced to have apps 9n my phone because they don't do it any other way anymore. It's getting ridiculous making things way more complicated then they need to be.

Dixiechickonhols · 07/11/2023 13:11

Our new dishwasher tells husband it has finished (I didn’t download app as I didn’t see need) he has never shown so much interest in the dishwasher!
Part of it is reassurance so even if bus says x double checking verbally as probably been caught out before.
Some is just wanting human contact.
Your hospital example - learning a new skill when ill or in pain is never going to go well.

Hoardasurass · 07/11/2023 13:11

KombuchaKalling · 07/11/2023 12:56

It’s not unreasonable. I think often a contributing factor is poor motivation and learned helplessness. It’s not necessarily as ageist thing l don’t think. My parents and in-laws are early 70’s and can negotiate most things. Husbands grandma is nearly 90 and she’s technologically savvy -can probably operate Teams better than my boss who is mid 50’s 🤣 Yet at work my husband regularly meets people mid 40’s who struggle with technology basics

Most of us who are in our forties were unfortunate enough to have to use the shit early systems, and computers such as bbcs and comal coding which really put us off using computers.
Add to that the fact that everything we learned at school about computers was obsolete within a few years so have had to unlearn everything we knew and relearn the new systems, it's put our small group at a disadvantage with our skills and motivation to learn as there's always something new

C8H10N4O2 · 07/11/2023 13:09

gdaysport · 07/11/2023 12:55

And obviously I know there will be plenty of people who are unable to use technology because of disabilities etc, That's why I said the majority, and not ALL.

Oh come on, this is yet another thinly disguised "bashing" thread which conveniently ignores that not everyone has the same life experiences and advantages.

BTW, hate to burst your bubble but you can't actually book GP appointments online for a great many GPs as they don't offer it (or have withdrawn it).

So congratulate yourself on your superiority and think about what you can do to help those people rather than sneer at them.

TeenDivided · 07/11/2023 13:09

The problem is. some tech just gets in the way of life.

I wanted to park at a station car park the other week. The only way to pay was to download an app and then do who knows what with it. No ability to pay with cash or even credit card.

Tech is meant to help, to increase choice, not make life harder. I shouldn't need an app to park at a railway station.

I went elsewhere.

Onethingatatime23 · 07/11/2023 13:07

I am very good with tech but find buses very confusing (even where to get on in London is confusing), and would certainly be checking they go where I think they do.

I also find Google Maps for walking even more confusing than regular maps and often set off in the wrong direction- though I get there in the end!

Good with tech, sense of direction - pretty poor. I have to go somewhere ten times in short order to remember my way around and also have to be driving or otherwise self-directing and therefore paying attention.

The weird things is ten minute after I arrive anywhere new to me I get asked for directions, and I am so bad at giving directions even when it's somewhere I know well. But clearly, I look like I know where I'm going.

AutumnCrow · 07/11/2023 13:06

at least a few times a week there will be a bewildered adult asking the bus driver where they need to get off, if the bus (with the massive sign on front saying 'Woolwich' goes to Woolwich, or the train station.

The amazing thing about technology, OP, is that you can use it to type a sentence in which an opening bracket is paired with a closing bracket, thus allowing it to be correct and make sense.

EnterFunnyNameHere · 07/11/2023 13:05

cheapskatemum · 07/11/2023 12:51

You are being ageist. People who have grown up with technology surrounding them are far more likely to have an affinity with it than people who grew up with pen, paper, books etc
Furthermore, people of a certain demographic, for example women aged 60+ are less likely to have been offered training in IT to bridge this gap. How do I know this? I am a woman in my 60s who struggles to use IT. I have recently joined a local class to learn some of the basics and it is populated with women my age & older. I suspect men of this age have kept up to date with IT through work. Women were more likely to have taken maternity leave & gone back to work part-time, or been SAHM when the use of computers and associated technology became widespread.

This is such a good point, and one I'd not considered in depth before. But yes if you were a SAHM during the rise of technology it must be a really challenging and scary world at times trying to get up to speed - not least because it would also further preclude you getting back in the workplace after your kids are adults.

Really intereting/insightful comment @cheapskatemum (and well done for taking action to learn, as God knows that is not always easy either!).

AgnesX · 07/11/2023 13:05

I've worked around technology for nearly 30 years so thank god I'm reasonably clued up (50s). My mother is atrocious (late 80s) Hates anything digital except the Sky box, refuses to use a smartphone or a tablet and relies on my sister who is very tolerant at helping...

My in laws (early 80s) are pretty sharp. So, I think it really varies.

mayorofcasterbridge · 07/11/2023 13:04

gdaysport · 07/11/2023 13:02

Is this so you can control it when you are not at home?

Wild! Not sure I would be that bothered to learn how to use that one myself!

I can't think of one single good reason to do that? I mean, you'd have to leave it switched on at the mains, surely, and you can't load it remotely?

(I would definitely go for remote loading though, if that were an option!!)

MigGirl · 07/11/2023 13:04

YABU, there are many reasons why some people may not be able to use or access technology. I understand this even though I was an early user of a lot of tech. Late 40's and used PC's at high school, had Internet at university (when most only had limited access to dial up).

Those older then me will have mostly only come across it with work. I'm also fedup with the assumption that everyone has a smart phone (your overestimating how popular they are my first one I only got 13 years ago). I have a colleague who can't use them due to sensory issues.

Some people don't find it easy to pick this stuff up either. Most who use these technologies have no actual idea how they work or what to do if things go wrong. 🤔 which is OK most of the time, but I always say technology is great when it works.

gdaysport · 07/11/2023 13:02

mayorofcasterbridge · 07/11/2023 13:01

My new dishwasher appears to be WiFi enabled.

I am baffled as to why I would want to operate my dishwasher from my phone???

Is this so you can control it when you are not at home?

Wild! Not sure I would be that bothered to learn how to use that one myself!

OP posts:
mayorofcasterbridge · 07/11/2023 13:01

My new dishwasher appears to be WiFi enabled.

I am baffled as to why I would want to operate my dishwasher from my phone???

gdaysport · 07/11/2023 13:00

Catza · 07/11/2023 12:57

There may be several reasons why adults can't get this information without asking. Maybe some people like to talk to others, maybe they don't have a smartphone, maybe they don't have internet connection/credit on smartphones they do have, maybe they run out of battery. The ipads came out 30 years ago but I could only afford one in 2015. They are not exactly cheap/were cheap when they first came round. Maybe the "women in their 50s" who were offered ipads "to watch their soaps", actually had other options besides watching a soap or staring at the wall that they were more interested in, like talking, reading, having quiet time...
When I drive with my partner, he stops me from using sat nav and asks me to look at road signs. He says that I should not rely on technology to move around, I should learn the routes because I may find myself in the situation where technology won't be available and I need to be able to find my way out. We are both confident with technology but he has a bloody good point (as much as I hate driving without satnav).

That is actually an excellent point - we should still be teaching skills such as map reading because should we lose the internet tomorrow, can we trust people also have the skills to go about their day to day lives? Handwriting, map reading, even being able to hold face to face conversations because we are so used to socialising online.....

OP posts:
gotomomo · 07/11/2023 12:59

Not my experience at all, I work with a lot of elderly people and the vast majority (o can think of only one exception) use smartphones, tablets and laptops. Some are in their 90's and work them better than me! I'm the age of the ladies you describe in hospital op and I certainly do use an iPad and I certainly don't watch soaps! Maybe they were a lot older than you thought

muddyford · 07/11/2023 12:59

The mobile signal here is useless for speech, let alone anything to do with the internet. I can only do emails and webby stuff at home on Wi-Fi so many apps are useless. And many people have not had the internet for 20 years.

Deliaskis · 07/11/2023 12:58

I would also imagine, although I don't have data, but would imagine that by and large, the demographic mix of people travelling on buses probably contains a higher proportion of people who might find it challenging to fully access all that tech has to offer.

gdaysport · 07/11/2023 12:57

Hoardasurass · 07/11/2023 12:53

Unfortunately for those with certain disabilities can't use most of these apps and websites.
There's also many more luddites around than you would think.
As for your Ipad comment they were (and still are) ridiculously expensive so many people didn't get 1, if they did get an android tablet and learn to use it many more won't be comfortable with an Ipad.
I won't go into the useless waste of time that our local bus app is or how often the bus has the wrong destination on it because its "broken"

I've never had an ipad either because of expense. I also know that I would not be against someone giving me a quick demo on how to use it? I think there is a big fear factor for some people that they assume they wont understand it so do not try.

OP posts:
Catza · 07/11/2023 12:57

There may be several reasons why adults can't get this information without asking. Maybe some people like to talk to others, maybe they don't have a smartphone, maybe they don't have internet connection/credit on smartphones they do have, maybe they run out of battery. The ipads came out 30 years ago but I could only afford one in 2015. They are not exactly cheap/were cheap when they first came round. Maybe the "women in their 50s" who were offered ipads "to watch their soaps", actually had other options besides watching a soap or staring at the wall that they were more interested in, like talking, reading, having quiet time...
When I drive with my partner, he stops me from using sat nav and asks me to look at road signs. He says that I should not rely on technology to move around, I should learn the routes because I may find myself in the situation where technology won't be available and I need to be able to find my way out. We are both confident with technology but he has a bloody good point (as much as I hate driving without satnav).

Cornettoninja · 07/11/2023 12:56

gdaysport · 07/11/2023 12:42

Lol maybe! Perhaps in the future, I will just let them get on with it. Perhaps eventually they will find their way home.

Yes, you probably should.

it’s not like you’re describing situations where people have come directly to you for help, you’ve took it upon yourself to help out and then get the hump over it. Clearly these people have enough about them to know where it’s appropriate to direct their query, they haven’t sought to impose themselves on you.

Same with the ladies in hospital, their choice was not really proportionate for you to have held onto as an example.

KombuchaKalling · 07/11/2023 12:56

It’s not unreasonable. I think often a contributing factor is poor motivation and learned helplessness. It’s not necessarily as ageist thing l don’t think. My parents and in-laws are early 70’s and can negotiate most things. Husbands grandma is nearly 90 and she’s technologically savvy -can probably operate Teams better than my boss who is mid 50’s 🤣 Yet at work my husband regularly meets people mid 40’s who struggle with technology basics

Branster · 07/11/2023 12:56

Another point to make, those born at a time when tech was already established are, of course, used to it. It is a 'language' and a tool they understand and can use.
But, most importantly, they are never ever worried about breaking something, causing a malfunction.
Previous generations are a bit more reticent at times because they know full well, breaking something will possibly require specialist help or full replacement and , in most cases, this is not a negligible expense. A bit more cautious if you like.

mayorofcasterbridge · 07/11/2023 12:56

Well I am in my 60s and I absolutely do know people who struggle with tech. I can and do use it - I am a whizz at online shopping!! - but it doesn't come entirely naturally? I use spreadsheets/Sharepoint etc for work but it's a PITA.

My generation wasn't reared with it, unlike my kids. Sometimes I just CBA, but then I am someone who doesn't have the patience to read instructions. I am shit with Google maps but I am shit at map reading full stop.

I think most people give it a go though. I was impressed by my 90 year old auntie FaceTiming.

Leave people be to do what they are comfortable with, and don't patronise them!

Deliaskis · 07/11/2023 12:56

I think the issue is in the generalisations...yes most people have smartphones and wifi at home, but not all do. There are always outliers. I work in a field related to developing tech solutions for healthcare, like apps to track how you are doing with symptoms and medication etc. When we talk to potential users, the questions they raise often relate to access: what if a person is visually impaired and doesn't effectively use their smartphone, what if a person is on a very restricted data plan and has no money to top up, or has nowhere to sensibly charge their phone, what if a person is also struggling with literacy or is not a first language English speaker.

There are a lot of things that can stand in the way of some people having a smooth and easy experience using technology. It's brilliant, and I expect the gap to narrow over the next decade or so, but it isn't simple and easily accessible for everybody.

gdaysport · 07/11/2023 12:55

And obviously I know there will be plenty of people who are unable to use technology because of disabilities etc, That's why I said the majority, and not ALL.

OP posts: