Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to expect the majority of adults to use technology?

188 replies

gdaysport · 07/11/2023 12:36

The majority of UK households will have had the internet in some form for the last 20 years. We have had smartphones which have been common for at least 15 years.

AIBU to expect most adults to be able to use the internet etc to navigate the world by now?

For example, living in zone 4 London with frequent bus services, at least a few times a week there will be a bewildered adult asking the bus driver where they need to get off, if the bus (with the massive sign on front saying 'Woolwich' goes to Woolwich, or the train station. You can use google maps, TFL app, bus apps, all which tell you which way to go.

Bus drivers of course, rarely give a shiny shit and I normally step in to help and tell people where they need to go, but I just don't understand the frequency in which I need to do this?

I even extend this criticism to my own parents who have such poor technological literacy they panic at the very idea of checking what time a train leaves.

At a recent hospital stay, two women on the ward in their mid 50s with me, both of their families encouraged them to borrow and use ipads so they could watch their soaps etc to pass the time but they batted them away saying they cant use them. They would have been in their 30s when ipads were introduced. So instead they would just sit bored staring at a wall rather than be shown how to use the app.

Technology is only going to become more ingrained in our lives, should we not be encouraging people to become sufficient in using it, rather than being cut off from the world? Stranded at bus stops as they dont know where to go, not knowing how to book a GP appointment online which is quicker etc.

Preparing to be flamed!

OP posts:
shoeawsome · 07/11/2023 13:47

Oh and I love a parking App - what I hate is getting to a car park somewhere & it's a different App!

shoeawsome · 07/11/2023 13:45

I don't think technology particularly helps with public transport especially if you don't use it very often.

You can use as much IT as you like but I that doesn't stop that feeling of 'am I on the right train' or finding your stop & asking the person already stood there ' does this bus go to'

So I think that's a confidence thing , not an IT thing!

TheJubileePortrait · 07/11/2023 13:45

gdaysport · 07/11/2023 13:39

I think this does raise some great examples of where technology just isnt needed, e.g parking apps, or where our reliance on it can be detrimental.

My mum is a smart woman, but she was completely overwhelmed at the idea of having to use public transport to visit me in hospital. I just do not want to get to that stage in my life where being afraid of using technology closes off my options from the world. PP is right - I think confidence and not wanting to look silly comes into pay alot.

Parking apps are needed. The ability to add extra time if you’re going to be longer than intended without having to go back to your vehicle is a game changer.

Trailstunning · 07/11/2023 13:45

hotcandle · 07/11/2023 13:39

Some people on this thread complaining that they can't work out what their new car has on offer or how they set up an app...

READ THE MANUAL / INSTUCTIONS!!!!

It's what every other sensible person does.

They are on line nowadays lol!

To the OP, why should anyone learn anything in regards to tech? its surely up to them, its not (yet) the law.

CranfordScones · 07/11/2023 13:44

I don't think those people are any more cut off from the world just because more technology has come along.

What you seem to really want isn't "the majority" of adults to use technology, it's every last person to use technology up to a level that meets with your personal approval.

That isn't going to happen. There may be lots of reasons why each of these events happen including people having lost or broken their phone, or they have some other impediment that may not be obvious to a casual observer. A valid reason would also be because they don't want to engage with the technology, or don't want to take a phone everywhere.

Mrsjayy · 07/11/2023 13:43

gdaysport · 07/11/2023 13:39

I think this does raise some great examples of where technology just isnt needed, e.g parking apps, or where our reliance on it can be detrimental.

My mum is a smart woman, but she was completely overwhelmed at the idea of having to use public transport to visit me in hospital. I just do not want to get to that stage in my life where being afraid of using technology closes off my options from the world. PP is right - I think confidence and not wanting to look silly comes into pay alot.

I mean that's a mum issue most bus stops and train stations have time tables it wasn't technology letting your mum down it was her confidence having an app won't cure that.

KimberleyClark · 07/11/2023 13:42

At a recent hospital stay, two women on the ward in their mid 50s with me, both of their families encouraged them to borrow and use ipads so they could watch their soaps etc to pass the time but they batted them away saying they cant use them. They would have been in their 30s when ipads were introduced. So instead they would just sit bored staring at a wall rather than be shown how to use the app.

I'm 62 and fully capable of using an iPad to do just about anything. Don't think I'm that unusual. And no they would not have been on their 30s when the first iPad came out in 2010.

gdaysport · 07/11/2023 13:42

AutumnCrow · 07/11/2023 13:41

My mum is a smart woman, but she was completely overwhelmed at the idea of having to use public transport to visit me in hospital.

Maybe that the best excuse she could come up with, as it fed into your beliefs.

What would her reasoning be?

OP posts:
AutumnCrow · 07/11/2023 13:41

My mum is a smart woman, but she was completely overwhelmed at the idea of having to use public transport to visit me in hospital.

Maybe that the best excuse she could come up with, as it fed into your beliefs.

gdaysport · 07/11/2023 13:41

BarborousBarbra · 07/11/2023 13:20

In my home town, there are a lot of people with learning difficulties who are not being helped at all and cannot either afford a phone or work out how to use them, and I imagine it's the same in other places too. So, although in an ideal world, it would be great, it's never going to happen unless people are given more support.

Absolutely agree, and this is the issue I think when we make everything 'online.' I personally avoid cashless shops because I disagree with them, they alienate and discriminate against those who for a myriad of reasons, do not have access to a bank account.

OP posts:
crackofdoom · 07/11/2023 13:40

Bus apps are only of use if they are remotely accurate (side eyes First Great Western 👀).

The danger is also that, having double checked everything on the app you are lulled into a false sense of security and don't, for example, pay attention to station announcements in a foreign language and are so engrossed in bollocking your offspring to notice that everyone else waiting for the express to Munich has suddenly melted away and reappeared 4 platforms over (side eyes Deutsche Bahn👀 ,although it was obviously also my fault for not triple checking the platform screens).

hotcandle · 07/11/2023 13:39

Some people on this thread complaining that they can't work out what their new car has on offer or how they set up an app...

READ THE MANUAL / INSTUCTIONS!!!!

It's what every other sensible person does.

gdaysport · 07/11/2023 13:39

I think this does raise some great examples of where technology just isnt needed, e.g parking apps, or where our reliance on it can be detrimental.

My mum is a smart woman, but she was completely overwhelmed at the idea of having to use public transport to visit me in hospital. I just do not want to get to that stage in my life where being afraid of using technology closes off my options from the world. PP is right - I think confidence and not wanting to look silly comes into pay alot.

OP posts:
WhatATimeToBeAlive · 07/11/2023 13:39

ipads have only been around since 2010 (yeah, old git here managed to Google it) so YABU in saying that someone in their 50s has had that technology for 20 years because they have only been mainstream for about 10 years. Not everyone is comfortable or likes technology and there should be an alternative, ie, talking to a real-life person. As we all age it will actually become more difficult to use technology and this needs to be considered.

maddiemookins16mum · 07/11/2023 13:39

I work with a lady, we are both within 5 years of the same age, so I’m nearly 60 and she is approaching 64.
The difference between us technology wise is vast.
I’m pretty good, online shopping, nifty at excel, uploading docs, creating groups on Teams etc etc (all pretty ‘basic’ stuff you’d think). Spend all day at work using inhouse systems and creating documents that I can edit, filter etc etc. I use an Ipad, have a decent smartphone, have online banking etc.
’Susan’ - has a 13 year old mobile phone. No other technology in the house.
Never orders online for anything. Refuses to use Teams unless someone else answers the call for her and practically puts her headphones on.
She’s simply not interested in it.
All well and good except the rest of the team find it very frustrating as we end up ‘carrying’ her to an extent, for example cannot upload documents to a shared folder from her desktop so someone else has to.
Frequent training sessions, one to one support, step by step (Dummies Guide style) notes all done for her. Nope, tries it, messes it up, cries, tantrums, etc etc. More training, nope still cannot do it. Just when we see a little bit of improvement, it’s the weekend and we’re back to square one on Mondays.
I’m really fond of her but hate to admit there is a bit of ‘I don’t want to do it’ involved.
Her background was a more manual tasked role in the office, dealing with post, filing etc, all well and good 15 years ago, now not so needed.
’

ruby1957 · 07/11/2023 13:39

gdaysport · 07/11/2023 12:55

And obviously I know there will be plenty of people who are unable to use technology because of disabilities etc, That's why I said the majority, and not ALL.

You still seem convinced that it is the majority rather than ALL - if you believe that you obviously don't know many people who can use technology when it suits them but prefer to have the option to do things the way they have always done them.

Back in the 1970s I worked in IT when a computer footprint could be the size of half a football pitch. I am no Luddite.

There are many things that can be done without using a smartphone - I can read a map and plot a journey in my head without using SATNAV!
Also consider that many people of any age cannot necessarily afford the latest Iphone and the monthly charges.
YABU to belittle those who only use a mobile for phone calls and texts.

Dixiechickonhols · 07/11/2023 13:38

My mil in her 70s uses technology in limited way eg can use Facebook but often locked out of things as forgets passwords and worried re scams.
My mum late 70s won’t use anything as a deliberate lifestyle choice. She stopped working late 90s. She has never needed tech for job - she was a teacher reports were handwritten. She deliberately chose not to engage with society norms - no videos in 80s, last house in street to have microwave, no broadband. It’s part snobbishness, part stubbornness. She also enjoys the personal connection. She can walk and likes talking on phone so usually can navigate a way around. She has been given a smart phone she won’t use. She misses out eg photos, messaging grandchildren and she’d be one asking bus driver but she can live her life. All her elderly neighbours are same.
For shopping she uses Iceland you go in and do shop and then delivery man brings and 10% off on a Tuesday for pensioners means it’s extremely popular- online shipping with no online.
Bank she goes in person.
Holidays she books by phone or goes in travel agent.
Rail ticket she books in person.
Gp/nurse she books by phone or in person.
Bus she looks at timetable on shelter or enquires at information.
Tradesmen word of mouth or from those local magazines they push through.

Mrsjayy · 07/11/2023 13:38

My surgeries booking system is shit you have to phone or go in!

imagine being so impatient that you don't have time for people Infront of you talking to an actual person.

Orangeandgold · 07/11/2023 13:36

You have a point.

Sometimes the phone dies or you need the 5% that’s left to make it home.

Tech fails too. I’ve had tech completely fail me and then I’ve asked a human to help.

Example - my sat nav tells me my journey home but didn’t account for the road closures, bus diversion, where the rail replacement buses are or a diversion. In those moments (which seem to happen often with TFL and train strikes and repairs). During moments like this I might ask someone or a bus driver.

Sometimes addresses and postcodes haven’t been put onto Google maps yet so I have to use a mix of common sense or asking someone.

Tech is great but every now and then we need a human.

verdantverdure · 07/11/2023 13:35

I think that even though something exists it's quite possible not to have been able to afford it, have had the time to learn it, or have seen the need for it.

The internet and smart phones cost money. When my friend lost her job in the pandemic she got £75 a week in benefits. It didn't cover the essentials. let alone luxuries. Carers allowance is even less.

Eyesight is a factor too. If you don't wear prescribed glasses who looks at your retinas to detect glaucoma etc. Lots of people just buy "readers" so cataracts, glaucoma and other eye issues go undiagnosed.

Do people who have never needed to learn Excel know Excel?

Do people who aren't really interested in VR invest in the equipment and learn how to use it?

Mrsjayy · 07/11/2023 13:35

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

I'm early 50s modern technology started with us we endured the dial up and having to ration data etc etc the Op is being am agiest arsehole I hope her next bus is late and she will get all " the old dears" bothering her 😂

My parents don't use the Internet the manage fine day to day.

gdaysport · 07/11/2023 13:35

C8H10N4O2 · 07/11/2023 13:09

Oh come on, this is yet another thinly disguised "bashing" thread which conveniently ignores that not everyone has the same life experiences and advantages.

BTW, hate to burst your bubble but you can't actually book GP appointments online for a great many GPs as they don't offer it (or have withdrawn it).

So congratulate yourself on your superiority and think about what you can do to help those people rather than sneer at them.

I mean, show me where I said all? You would have to be pretty dense to think my examples applied to every single person ever.

In my GP practice, we have econsult. If you send the form through, you get a callback normally the same day.

And yet when I go in for an appointment I listen to the receptionists dealing with poorly and upset people who will only or can only book appointments over the phone. If they can, they need to be taught (self or by others) how to use it.

There is an option for those unable to use econsult but you need a reason eg disability, language issues etc.

Do I think this means every single GP practice uses it? Erm...no?

OP posts:
hotcandle · 07/11/2023 13:34

I volunteer for a local charity that teaches people how to use smartphones and the like. People are welcome to book in an after class and bring specific devices.

In the past 5 years I've seen more 50 plus women coming in for the classes than any other demographic.

I find that many pensioners already know how to use their devices, they pay with their phones and generally have a lot more patience to learn new technologies. They'll come to the after class for very specific queries but they make a major effort to troubleshoot first.

I find that our main demographic of women are too afraid to make mistakes and therefore, don't try. I'm sure there is some reason for it but it always baffles me a little.

RiderOfTheBlue · 07/11/2023 13:31

Nicesalad · 07/11/2023 13:23

Exactly!! I don't have enough space on my phone to download several parking apps and I don't have enough data to download the apps while out and about. I think it's really wrong to expect everyone to have a smartphone. A lot of the time it needs to be a fairly new phone as well for the apps to work. What a waste!

I agree. I don't want my phone cluttered up with various parking apps. Or to wait around while an app downloads, then having to register, sign in etc. I just want to put a coin in a machine or tap my debit card and get on with my day. There should be a choice of how to pay. Why should we just accept the method that is less work for the company involved?

GasPanic · 07/11/2023 13:30

I know someone who for years resisted the smartphone.

However it got to the stage where they cannot live their lives without it because of needing to do things on apps etc.

I used to moan because it was expensive to keep in touch with them (foreign text for example rather than Whatsapp)

They got an iphone about six months ago.

Now when I work with them their nose is glued to the iphone about 75% of the time.