Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to expect the majority of adults to use technology?

188 replies

gdaysport · 07/11/2023 12:36

The majority of UK households will have had the internet in some form for the last 20 years. We have had smartphones which have been common for at least 15 years.

AIBU to expect most adults to be able to use the internet etc to navigate the world by now?

For example, living in zone 4 London with frequent bus services, at least a few times a week there will be a bewildered adult asking the bus driver where they need to get off, if the bus (with the massive sign on front saying 'Woolwich' goes to Woolwich, or the train station. You can use google maps, TFL app, bus apps, all which tell you which way to go.

Bus drivers of course, rarely give a shiny shit and I normally step in to help and tell people where they need to go, but I just don't understand the frequency in which I need to do this?

I even extend this criticism to my own parents who have such poor technological literacy they panic at the very idea of checking what time a train leaves.

At a recent hospital stay, two women on the ward in their mid 50s with me, both of their families encouraged them to borrow and use ipads so they could watch their soaps etc to pass the time but they batted them away saying they cant use them. They would have been in their 30s when ipads were introduced. So instead they would just sit bored staring at a wall rather than be shown how to use the app.

Technology is only going to become more ingrained in our lives, should we not be encouraging people to become sufficient in using it, rather than being cut off from the world? Stranded at bus stops as they dont know where to go, not knowing how to book a GP appointment online which is quicker etc.

Preparing to be flamed!

OP posts:
LylaLee · 07/11/2023 14:50

Badbadbunny · 07/11/2023 14:47

Twice last month, DS went to different cities by train (places he'd never been to before) for work meetings/courses. On the way back, complete shambles in railway stations, first due to a broken down train, second due to bad weather stopping the trains. Some trains were running, others weren't - he hadn't a clue whether it was better to get on "any" train heading in the general direction and change somewhere, or whatever. If he'd relied on train staff to tell him how to get home, he'd probably have had to sleep on the streets overnight. There were huge queues for the ticket office, rail staff in the concourse hadn't a clue when he asked them how to get home - they just shrugged and said they didn't know!

He found a quiet corner, and Googled, He brought up station destination boards which showed which were running from other various "big" stations, checked the real time trains website to try to gauge where the blockages were, and managed to pick a way through it all, googled for which train companies were accepted tickets from other operators, etc. Once he'd worked out a plan of action, he got himself home, and not too badly delayed, just a couple of hours.

No amount of waiting in huge queues and constantly trying to find train staff who could actually give him some information would have produced a better outcome. Some of his colleagues who'd gone to the same places ended up having to stay overnight in hotels because they had trouble finding train staff to ask and were told duff information. It was only that DS is a train spotter that he knew all the various apps and websites available!

Why didn't your son share the information with his colleagues?

cheapskatemum · 07/11/2023 14:50

@gdaysport that pp was me Grin. The course I'm doing was organised by women who realised, via the NextDoor app that there was a need for it.

Badbadbunny · 07/11/2023 14:47

Mrsjayy · 07/11/2023 13:59

I live in a historical tourist city , you get people asking all the time where Is this or that which stop to get off our buses don't tell you where to get off ( trains do ) most people are helpful bus drivers will shout this is your stop, I think maybe people have started to rely on their phones too much and have stopped communicating with people and this is what's causing a problem.

Twice last month, DS went to different cities by train (places he'd never been to before) for work meetings/courses. On the way back, complete shambles in railway stations, first due to a broken down train, second due to bad weather stopping the trains. Some trains were running, others weren't - he hadn't a clue whether it was better to get on "any" train heading in the general direction and change somewhere, or whatever. If he'd relied on train staff to tell him how to get home, he'd probably have had to sleep on the streets overnight. There were huge queues for the ticket office, rail staff in the concourse hadn't a clue when he asked them how to get home - they just shrugged and said they didn't know!

He found a quiet corner, and Googled, He brought up station destination boards which showed which were running from other various "big" stations, checked the real time trains website to try to gauge where the blockages were, and managed to pick a way through it all, googled for which train companies were accepted tickets from other operators, etc. Once he'd worked out a plan of action, he got himself home, and not too badly delayed, just a couple of hours.

No amount of waiting in huge queues and constantly trying to find train staff who could actually give him some information would have produced a better outcome. Some of his colleagues who'd gone to the same places ended up having to stay overnight in hotels because they had trouble finding train staff to ask and were told duff information. It was only that DS is a train spotter that he knew all the various apps and websites available!

Winterjoy · 07/11/2023 14:45

bombastix · 07/11/2023 14:27

I agree this is willed. My father is 84 and is technologically literate. It's a choice that will get harder and harder.

Also, you can't eliminate a spot of attention seeking. Some people hate technology because they get less of it

I've also seen an element of willful ignorance around me, e.g. friends who have managed to learn the things that they enjoy such as keeping up with family on Instagram or online shopping, but as soon as something more mundane comes up, like filling out an online form, it's suddenly "I don't know how to use the Internet/ I'm too old to learn these new things now".

Spendonsend · 07/11/2023 14:45

NotLactoseFree · 07/11/2023 14:27

I think that's slightly over stating things. the UK has an adult literacy level of 99% according to the gov.uk website. With a population of 67mn or so, that's a lot less than 1 mn illiterate adults.

not that any adults should be illiterate, 9 mn adults is not accurate.

I think there are probably a few different measures. The national literacy trust says 7 million in england have very poor literacy skills.

I guess there is a gap between illiterate and poor skills. It says these people can understand short, straightforward texts on familiar topics and sources but unfamiliar sources, topics and longer info causes problems.

My son is like this.. he is not illiterate, but he has difficulties.

LylaLee · 07/11/2023 14:39

gdaysport · 07/11/2023 14:12

I know, my Uncle cannot write and has very basic reading. Worked on a building site his whole life for the same bloke. If that job goes, he knows he will struggle to find work elsewhere. Saying that, he learned how to use the smart TV and Alexa pretty quickly!
There are always exceptions to the rule which is why its also an interesting conversation to have about accessibility.

Edited

So you have a personal example of someone who can't browse the internet.

That's because of not being able to read.

Many others never were able to afford to get online, then felt they had missed the boat.

If you know one, and extrapolate that most people also know at least one person like that, then you can see that there are enormous chunks of the population who cannot access the internet either for financial or literacy reasons.

TigerRag · 07/11/2023 14:38

Because Google never gets it wrong. It once directed me to a bus stop only for the driver to tell me the bus I need is on the other side. I'm not familiar with that area of the city so wouldn't have known Google was correct or not.

Badbadbunny · 07/11/2023 14:34

Octavia64 · 07/11/2023 12:40

I mean you're not wrong, but I have been trying to teach my mother (78) to use a smartphone for the last 5 years and she still can't.

The thing is, if she'd bothered to get "into" tech 10 or 20 years ago, she'd have almost certainly be fine with it and cope.

I think far too many people have just ignored what was obviously going to happen.

After all, cheap "home" computers appeared as early as 1980 (ZX80), so that's over 40 years ago. Computers became widespread in workplaces in the late 1980s. TV remotes became common around the same time, as did digital home appliances such as microwaves, cookers, dishwashers, etc.

Someone 78 today was only 35 when home computers started appearing, as did TV computer games, TV remotes, etc. What rock have they been hiding under for the past 40 years?

My MIL is a case in point. She can't even use a TV remote, is incapable of using anything "digital" at all, needs a microwave and oven etc with dials rather than buttons. She's not even as old as the OP! She regards "hating" electronic things like some kind of demented badge of honour. As time is passing, she expects the benefits of the digital age, but expects "someone else" to actually press the buttons for her!

Thesoleofmyshoe · 07/11/2023 14:32

Some of the 'facts' OP has stated are nonsense, certainly about the prevalence of the internet and smartphones in particular years.

I don't understand what's wrong with people asking where to get off a bus either. What on earth is wrong with that? I'm more than competent technologically, but I'd ask that question. And if someone asked me, I'd happily answer, and probably have a bit of a chat too. Much more life enhancing then looking at your phone all day

bombastix · 07/11/2023 14:27

I agree this is willed. My father is 84 and is technologically literate. It's a choice that will get harder and harder.

Also, you can't eliminate a spot of attention seeking. Some people hate technology because they get less of it

Frequency · 07/11/2023 14:27

Thenewnewme · 07/11/2023 14:17

9 millions adults in the UK are functionally illiterate. If you can’t read then you can’t use the internet.

This is why my dad didn't know he was being charged for Amazon Music. He can read and write but he learned as an adult and struggles a lot with it. He uses messenger and can read and reply to messages from us but it takes him a long time. If he's confronted with a wall of text his immediate reaction is "I can't read that," so he doesn't try.

NotLactoseFree · 07/11/2023 14:27

Thenewnewme · 07/11/2023 14:17

9 millions adults in the UK are functionally illiterate. If you can’t read then you can’t use the internet.

I think that's slightly over stating things. the UK has an adult literacy level of 99% according to the gov.uk website. With a population of 67mn or so, that's a lot less than 1 mn illiterate adults.

not that any adults should be illiterate, 9 mn adults is not accurate.

gdaysport · 07/11/2023 14:25

tellittothemoon · 07/11/2023 14:24

what if you don't have smartphone? what if your battery is dead? what if roaming is off? what if you can't read? what if you are a stranger in the area?

What if people do not read my OP where it states most, not all?

What if what if what if what if

I KNOW.

OP posts:
margotrose · 07/11/2023 14:25

My dad is almost 70 and is pretty rubbish when it comes to technology. He can do it but it doesn't come naturally to him and he'd prefer to do things over the phone.

He wasn't raised with the internet and didn't even learn how to use a computer until he had one my hand-me-downs when I left for university! He doesn't have a smart phone either, just a brick that he never turns on!

My mum on the other hand is only four years younger but used a computer at work everyday so knew how to do the basics. She had a work phone too so knew how to use one from early on.

I do think there's a big divide between people who use/used technology at work and those who didn't.

tellittothemoon · 07/11/2023 14:24

what if you don't have smartphone? what if your battery is dead? what if roaming is off? what if you can't read? what if you are a stranger in the area?

gdaysport · 07/11/2023 14:18

cheapskatemum · 07/11/2023 14:16

Introduced to it - by whom? In my 30s I had 4 DCs. I can assure you that no one was offering to look after my 4 DCs in order to give me a course in how to use my PC.

This is why PP mentioned courses aimed at older women who because they took time out to raise a family, missed the chance to learn a vital skill if they were unable to learn it alone. Another reason why women are often placed at a disadvantage,

OP posts:
Thenewnewme · 07/11/2023 14:17

9 millions adults in the UK are functionally illiterate. If you can’t read then you can’t use the internet.

cheapskatemum · 07/11/2023 14:16

Ponderingwindow · 07/11/2023 13:19

Yanbu

im just about 50. I remember working in a shop when I was 18 and the momentous day the manager got email on his computer. That is 32 years since the workplace changed. Someone who is 65 now would have been introduced to this new world in their 30’s, hardly too old to learn new things.

Introduced to it - by whom? In my 30s I had 4 DCs. I can assure you that no one was offering to look after my 4 DCs in order to give me a course in how to use my PC.

gdaysport · 07/11/2023 14:14

mrswhiplington · 07/11/2023 14:13

Exactly. Why do you think there were protests about the railway ticket offices closing? Sometimes people need help.

Yes, again, thats why I said most, not all.

OP posts:
mrswhiplington · 07/11/2023 14:13

VickyEadieofThigh · 07/11/2023 12:53

"For example, living in zone 4 London with frequent bus services, at least a few times a week there will be a bewildered adult asking the bus driver where they need to get off, if the bus (with the massive sign on front saying 'Woolwich' goes to Woolwich, or the train station. You can use google maps, TFL app, bus apps, all which tell you which way to go."

And if you're partially sighted, have literacy difficulties, have begun to suffer dementia or other cognitive issues, suffer from anxiety...

Exactly. Why do you think there were protests about the railway ticket offices closing? Sometimes people need help.

NotLactoseFree · 07/11/2023 14:13

Broadly, I actually agree that tech literacy should be prioritised in the same way we prioritise regular literacy - this IS the world we live in and in the same way that people who can't read are massively disadvantaged, we need to have the same focus on tech literacy.

Having said that, one of the problems with being at the relative start of the technology journey, is that a lot of tech just doesn't work that well yet. Bus apps being a really really good example - it never ceases to amaze me that I can text the bus company for an update and, more and more, get an updated time of arrival via an app, but any kind of real time tracking or map feature that would allow me to plan a route still seems to be hit and miss and difficult to use.

Ditto parking apps - they're getting better by and large but I recently had to load up a new one for NCP and it was a disaster.

On the other hand, online shopping apps, which have received a great deal of R&D from many private companies (both the retailers themselves and third parties) are, nowadays, largely very very user friendly and intuitiveThere are also the big tech companies like Google, Amazon etc who are increasingly building platforms on which other developers can piggy back so that they can make their services easier.

Also, AI is getting smarter and better and will adapt more quickly. My brother has never really done online shopping etc, so Amazon for him is the equivalent of being dumped into the world's largest shopping mall and told to go find a pair of diamond earrings with no guidance or maps. But as he uses it, it will learn more quickly what he likes/doesn't like and in the not too distant future, he'll find it easier and easier.

gdaysport · 07/11/2023 14:12

LylaLee · 07/11/2023 14:09

You'd be surprised at how many adults in the UK can't read and write. Not people 'from abroad', but people who 'fell through the cracks' of the educational system.

They can't use technology.

I know, my Uncle cannot write and has very basic reading. Worked on a building site his whole life for the same bloke. If that job goes, he knows he will struggle to find work elsewhere. Saying that, he learned how to use the smart TV and Alexa pretty quickly!
There are always exceptions to the rule which is why its also an interesting conversation to have about accessibility.

OP posts:
missskinnylegz · 07/11/2023 14:12

We've got friends who refuse to use any tech. They won't even have a credit card. If they need to book a hotel they have to ring the hotel and post a cheque. If they want to go to a concert we buy the tickets and they give us cash when they see us. If he goes to the bar to pay for a round and they don't take cash he can't have a drink. It's incredibly limiting. Both work in full time jobs. Both in their early sixties. Infuriating.

LylaLee · 07/11/2023 14:09

You'd be surprised at how many adults in the UK can't read and write. Not people 'from abroad', but people who 'fell through the cracks' of the educational system.

They can't use technology.

Neriah · 07/11/2023 14:08

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Kind of with you on the sentiment. Ableist as well - maybe the adult who can't read the bloody big sign, can't SEE the bloody big sign.

I'm 66. When I went to school calculators were "new technology" and if you were in the top streams you weren't allowed to choose typing for a course because you'd never need it. But I am more proficient with technology than many of our 20 year olds. Oh, they can use Tik Tok or WhatsApp yes. But can they actually use the technology for anything useful? Half of them can't. And don't even get me on the subject of the fact that they think text speak is English and suitable for reports and application forms; or can't speak on a phone to someone because they aren't used to talking to people in real life and think business is conducted by text.

There is a huge difference between knowing how to watch YouTube or send a text message and being familiar or competant with technology.

Swipe left for the next trending thread