Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to expect the majority of adults to use technology?

188 replies

gdaysport · 07/11/2023 12:36

The majority of UK households will have had the internet in some form for the last 20 years. We have had smartphones which have been common for at least 15 years.

AIBU to expect most adults to be able to use the internet etc to navigate the world by now?

For example, living in zone 4 London with frequent bus services, at least a few times a week there will be a bewildered adult asking the bus driver where they need to get off, if the bus (with the massive sign on front saying 'Woolwich' goes to Woolwich, or the train station. You can use google maps, TFL app, bus apps, all which tell you which way to go.

Bus drivers of course, rarely give a shiny shit and I normally step in to help and tell people where they need to go, but I just don't understand the frequency in which I need to do this?

I even extend this criticism to my own parents who have such poor technological literacy they panic at the very idea of checking what time a train leaves.

At a recent hospital stay, two women on the ward in their mid 50s with me, both of their families encouraged them to borrow and use ipads so they could watch their soaps etc to pass the time but they batted them away saying they cant use them. They would have been in their 30s when ipads were introduced. So instead they would just sit bored staring at a wall rather than be shown how to use the app.

Technology is only going to become more ingrained in our lives, should we not be encouraging people to become sufficient in using it, rather than being cut off from the world? Stranded at bus stops as they dont know where to go, not knowing how to book a GP appointment online which is quicker etc.

Preparing to be flamed!

OP posts:
gdaysport · 08/11/2023 17:45

Again - I am well aware of the myriad of reasons why many folks would struggle - if I lost my glasses I would not be able to use my phone for example as I have sight issues. These are not the folks I am talking about. At no point (for the millionth time) have I said all adults should be able to use it.

I think however based on this thread there are also a wide section of society who just let themselves fall behind and then struggle to navigate the world, have confidence issues, or sometimes just lazy. I sent own own mother a fb video of a company to show her a gift she may like to buy her GC, and she replies back 'Thats not the link to buy it.'
Its like the idea of problem solving that (clicking on the companies profile page and clicking the link to their website) for some reason was beyond her. She is only in her 50s. She has no real reason to be that tech illiterate.

I mean its also a well known trope that senior management on 100K a year ask you how to rotate a PDF. I know, I have worked with many!

OP posts:
Busephalus · 08/11/2023 17:14

Hereforthebunfights, doesn't Google maps have local bus info?

Busephalus · 08/11/2023 17:13

Is there really any reason for name calling?

Badbadbunny · 08/11/2023 17:09

Ariela · 08/11/2023 13:18

In the past I would have said YANBU.
However I have a friend who due to severe mental health issues is absolutely unable to use a computer. She'd dearly love to but it sends her into a tailspin. Even automatic checkouts are beyond her, not only does it severely impact her life but also she misses out on masses of opportunities for cheaper things online

With respect, disabled people are a different kettle of fish. Many would struggle with "non high tech" daily life, such as setting an old fashioned central heating timer, or driving an old fashioned car, or even setting an old fashioned VHS video recorder. It's no surprise that some disabled people (mental or physical) can't cope with the latest tech, because many would have struggled to cope with old-fashioned "tech" too. Hence why they need family or carers.

CruCru · 08/11/2023 16:13

maddiemookins16mum · 07/11/2023 13:39

I work with a lady, we are both within 5 years of the same age, so I’m nearly 60 and she is approaching 64.
The difference between us technology wise is vast.
I’m pretty good, online shopping, nifty at excel, uploading docs, creating groups on Teams etc etc (all pretty ‘basic’ stuff you’d think). Spend all day at work using inhouse systems and creating documents that I can edit, filter etc etc. I use an Ipad, have a decent smartphone, have online banking etc.
’Susan’ - has a 13 year old mobile phone. No other technology in the house.
Never orders online for anything. Refuses to use Teams unless someone else answers the call for her and practically puts her headphones on.
She’s simply not interested in it.
All well and good except the rest of the team find it very frustrating as we end up ‘carrying’ her to an extent, for example cannot upload documents to a shared folder from her desktop so someone else has to.
Frequent training sessions, one to one support, step by step (Dummies Guide style) notes all done for her. Nope, tries it, messes it up, cries, tantrums, etc etc. More training, nope still cannot do it. Just when we see a little bit of improvement, it’s the weekend and we’re back to square one on Mondays.
I’m really fond of her but hate to admit there is a bit of ‘I don’t want to do it’ involved.
Her background was a more manual tasked role in the office, dealing with post, filing etc, all well and good 15 years ago, now not so needed.
’

I think this is the problem. Someone who can't use technology or just refuses to use it will then need someone else to do that stuff for them. Refusing to answer calls on Teams and put headphones on sounds like bloodymindedness.

I wouldn't expect most people to be able to write computer code but they should be able to do what their job requires of them.

MintJulia · 08/11/2023 13:24

Also OP, having had chemo for breast cancer, I can vouch for the fact that it can give you brain fog, and things that are perfectly clear to others, just won't gel. A bit like baby-brain but worse. Thankfully they both pass, but they really aren't helped by people like you.

People are different. Their brains work differently. I hope you are never ill !

MintJulia · 08/11/2023 13:22

OP, I can think of a few simple reasons.

Phone out of data, flat battery, poor signal, left their glasses at home, just too stressed to cope, being a complete stranger to the area, so directions don't actually mean anything to them. Are you always so intolerant?

If you'd been on our local train line recently, you'd know NOT to trust the announcements, but to find a station attendant and ask.

I spend my entire life on tech - it's my job - but I'd rather drill my own teeth than use Google maps. I've found an effective alternative that doesn't keep changing scale or telling me where the nearest McDonalds is.

Ariela · 08/11/2023 13:18

In the past I would have said YANBU.
However I have a friend who due to severe mental health issues is absolutely unable to use a computer. She'd dearly love to but it sends her into a tailspin. Even automatic checkouts are beyond her, not only does it severely impact her life but also she misses out on masses of opportunities for cheaper things online

tpxqi · 08/11/2023 13:11

You are not wrong OP. Some people don’t want to make the effort, but expect the rest of the world to slow down to accommodate them.

tpxqi · 08/11/2023 13:10

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Then why are you taking it so personally?

TripleDaisySummer · 08/11/2023 12:46

ButtonFork · 07/11/2023 23:34

Ime young folk can be surprisingly limited in using tech - a lot of them don't know how to google what they're specifically looking for, for eg. They might be on their phones a lot but they don't always explore very much. It's often us old dinosaurs - who entered a tech-less workplace, had technology creep onto our desks and had to find a way to make it work for us, mainly without training - that are more inclined to get a bit creative.

Edited

DD1 went though a phase like this - struck us as odd what it seemed to be was less tech savvy school staff getting angry when the kids explored or played round - oddly seen similar attitude round maths with some teachers.

It happened less to younger kids I think as one was male and DD2 was taken to know things because he did - I don't know if we were particularly unlucky but we did encounter some very dated sexist attitudes in their primary years,

NotLactoseFree · 08/11/2023 11:21

ButtonFork · 07/11/2023 23:34

Ime young folk can be surprisingly limited in using tech - a lot of them don't know how to google what they're specifically looking for, for eg. They might be on their phones a lot but they don't always explore very much. It's often us old dinosaurs - who entered a tech-less workplace, had technology creep onto our desks and had to find a way to make it work for us, mainly without training - that are more inclined to get a bit creative.

Edited

Absolutely this. I was horrified about 10 years ago to discover that 18 year old nephew couldn't do basic email, word processing etc.

And it goes back to my earlier point - tech literacy MUST be treated as seriously as we treat regular literacy becuase this IS the world they are living in.

gdaysport · 08/11/2023 11:16

Oh absolutely. There was a thread here not long ago that went viral because a student asked on here if the planes fell out the side of the twin towers.

All the information in the world in our hands and we are not any smarter as a species.....

OP posts:
cheapskatemum · 08/11/2023 10:12

@mayorofcasterbridge (great novel!) thank you. I feel vindicated by this thread. I feel OP is BU, but also agree with PPs who point out that some people are more interested &/or have a greater affinity with technology than others. I feel it's part of the different intelligences debate. My husband is tech savvy, but can't get his head around putting the duvet cover on from inside out.

JustGotToKeepOnKeepingOn · 07/11/2023 23:50

I think you're either interested in technology or you're not. One family member in her 80s can't use a mobile phone. She wouldn't know where to start with online banking or sending an email. But another who's almost 90 is perfectly capable of doing all these things.

I can do what I need to do... but wouldn't know how to order an Uber or use ringing as I've never needed to. Does that make me not able to use technology? No, of course not. I just use the technology I need to make my life easier.

Eike · 07/11/2023 23:43

I have an older family member who asks me to fix her phone for her every so often as she somehow moves apps around the home screen on to extra pages, sometimes there will be blank "home pages" and then a random app on a page and then two more further across etc. She duplicates apps as well. I don't know how she does it and she swears blind she doesn't do anything! She gets confused by all the accounts, so she has Google and Samsung account as has an android, and she can't really understand the difference very well, like when Samsung said she'd lose her cloud files she thought she would lose all her photos. I had to explain she only has her Samsung photos on her phone, not the Samsung cloud, and all her photos back up automatically to her Google photos cloud, so she didn't need to worry. I still don't think she really understand what I'm saying. She's never used a laptop but is open to a tablet for browsing for the larger screen. Her husband uses the laptop and does all the stuff on there.

Eike · 07/11/2023 23:38

I've sometimes freaked when out because my phone has died or because I've run out of data so I can't use the apps I need. It might not always be lack of ability to understand the tech.

ButtonFork · 07/11/2023 23:34

Ime young folk can be surprisingly limited in using tech - a lot of them don't know how to google what they're specifically looking for, for eg. They might be on their phones a lot but they don't always explore very much. It's often us old dinosaurs - who entered a tech-less workplace, had technology creep onto our desks and had to find a way to make it work for us, mainly without training - that are more inclined to get a bit creative.

OldPerson · 07/11/2023 23:27

Yes you are being unreasonable. Some of us look at the young, glued to their phones, as they sit in groups or at dinner, and think how sad! Some of us see the artificially enhanced photos people post of themselves, and think how delusional! Some of us don't do social media, because we don't want to look at/"like" endless photos of children and grandchildren we don't know, because our purpose is not to bolster the egos of other people with too much time on their hands. And everyone's eyesight deteriorates in their 40's. So smartphones - even enlarging text - are frustratingly inconvenient. Not to mention tiny keyboards for our arthritic fingers. But I'm sure technology will evolve to cater for older people. But hey, I have intelligent tech-happy young people who look at my android smartphone and don't have a clue how it works if I ask a question.

ButtonFork · 07/11/2023 23:20

Yabu.

Public transport apps are glitchy and clunky, mobile data is patchy across the UK (including in London - pretty much every time I listen to radio 4 there will be at least one call dropped), and when you're out and about on the go especially in an unfamiliar city (London gets a lot of visitors) it's much quicker and easier to just ask a question face to face and get an answer.

Technology is supposed to be a tool, not an instruction to end all in person interaction.

templeking · 07/11/2023 18:00

The bus driver put the wrong location on the bus once. It said it was going to my towns hospital. The bus stopped in my towns bus station. I asked the bus driver why have we stopped, it said Hospital. He said he put the wrong one. I used to judge people asking the bus driver where the bus is going despite it clearly saying on the outside. No I don't. I find the bus app rubbish as well.

my dad is in his 60s and can't use a computer. Luckily with an iPhone he can send messages. But before iPhone, as children we had to reply to texts for him. I hate how everything is online. When you'd go to the hospital for a blood test you'd pick up a ticket and wait to be called. Now you've got to book it online and it's annoying.

mayorofcasterbridge · 07/11/2023 17:51

Badbadbunny · 07/11/2023 14:34

The thing is, if she'd bothered to get "into" tech 10 or 20 years ago, she'd have almost certainly be fine with it and cope.

I think far too many people have just ignored what was obviously going to happen.

After all, cheap "home" computers appeared as early as 1980 (ZX80), so that's over 40 years ago. Computers became widespread in workplaces in the late 1980s. TV remotes became common around the same time, as did digital home appliances such as microwaves, cookers, dishwashers, etc.

Someone 78 today was only 35 when home computers started appearing, as did TV computer games, TV remotes, etc. What rock have they been hiding under for the past 40 years?

My MIL is a case in point. She can't even use a TV remote, is incapable of using anything "digital" at all, needs a microwave and oven etc with dials rather than buttons. She's not even as old as the OP! She regards "hating" electronic things like some kind of demented badge of honour. As time is passing, she expects the benefits of the digital age, but expects "someone else" to actually press the buttons for her!

Oh come off it, people in general had very very little access to tech 40 years ago!!! I know, I was there! I worked in London in the late 80s for what was then one of the 'big five' - we had email but very many organisations had no access to tech. When I moved jobs out of London, and went into the public sector, there were very basic information systems, and no email - that was in the early- mid 90s!!

mayorofcasterbridge · 07/11/2023 17:47

cheapskatemum · 07/11/2023 14:16

Introduced to it - by whom? In my 30s I had 4 DCs. I can assure you that no one was offering to look after my 4 DCs in order to give me a course in how to use my PC.

If you weren't working in an office environment, then you obviously got left behind. I have a friend who was out of the workplace for 20 years and only managed to get back in by taking computing and other classes to update her skills.

BodegaSushi · 07/11/2023 16:20

Your OP is talking about different issues though. If a person is unable to figure out that the Woolwich bus is going to Woolwich, that’s nothing to do with refusing to engage with technology.

Badbadbunny · 07/11/2023 14:53

LylaLee · 07/11/2023 14:50

Why didn't your son share the information with his colleagues?

They weren't in contact. He didn't know their mobile phone numbers. He works for a big firm and he only knew most of them by "nodding" sight. They didn't actually work "together" as in the same room or adjoining offices.