Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be sad at the lack of compassion

138 replies

Gifgirl · 07/11/2023 10:16

Reading through some threads makes me so sad (and mad) sometimes.

Excluding teenagers from homes due to MH conditions, being cross about flags on stickers cos they are rainbows, encouraging your kids to not date someone cos they have a disability.. etc etc.

Acceptance and kindness is a wonderful thing and would make the world a much lovelier place.

Please encourage your kids to accept and include people even if they are different to you. We won't move on until this happens.

OP posts:
StephanieSuperpowers · 07/11/2023 13:03

MavisMcMinty · 07/11/2023 12:59

I’d rather be an awful woman than a mansmaid.

Just as bloody well, eh?

Oh god yeah.

MavisMcMinty · 07/11/2023 12:59

I’d rather be an awful woman than a mansmaid.

Just as bloody well, eh?

RocketPanda · 07/11/2023 12:59

It's always women and girls who have #bekind shoved in their faces. No one is telling the men who post death and rape threats to women every single day to be kind. No one is telling Barbie Kardashian to be kind. No one is telling Andrew Miller to be kind. No one is telling Sarah Jane Barker to be kind. Only reserved for the ones who want to safeguard children.

I'll #bekind when TRAs and misogynists stop threatening women.

Helleofabore · 07/11/2023 12:56

Applebottomjeenz

"Yes this! I'm not especially young but defo not transphobic! The awful women on here are OBSESSED to the detriment of everything else!"

I think your own deep prejudice about women who don't agree with you is clearly on show here today. Thank you for showing all reading along who might be the narrow minded ones on the thread.

MavisMcMinty · 07/11/2023 12:55

YouJustDoYou · 07/11/2023 12:40

"Oh @Gifgirl. Nobody on Mumsnet that I’ve ever seen feels hatred towards trans people, especially not the mixed-up kids being corralled into terrible experimental physical treatment for what is essentially poor mental health.There’s a justifiable fear and anger towards trans rights activists, most of whom are even trans themselves, threatening violence, rape and death to “TERFS”. I have never seen a gender critical poster wish violence, rape or death upon a trans person. Have you?"

Exactly. in all the years I've been on here, I've not once seen someone wish anything bad happen to trans people. I have however seen on here much, MUCH vitriol and ridicule and hope of death/violence against women and men who quote facts ie you can't change sex, and who want safe spaces for females.

Gah! Just noticed my typo, should say “most of whom AREN’T even trans themselves”.

Helleofabore · 07/11/2023 12:51

MattDillonsEyebrows · 07/11/2023 12:29

The problem is @LadyGrinningSoul85 , it's likely that those you describe as 'narrow minded, pearl clutching arsehole' who are more likely to be the ones who protect your trans son.

I was a probation officer for almost 20 years, and can tell you that if your trans son, ever got in with the wrong crowd and ended up in prison, you would not want them to go to a male jail. In a true Stonewall utopia, your trans son would go to a male jail, and a transwoman would go to a female one, can you honestly not see the issue here?

People often talk about trans men and trans women as though they are the same, and they really aren't. Trans men simply don't have the same threat of danger to others that transwomen do. The sad truth is that people with penis's are more likely to be sex offenders, violent or fetishists, no matter what they cover that penis with, the threat remains much higher than with women.

As for the 'be kind' brigade, like most people, I will be kind to anyone on a personal level. As the mother of a very hyperactive girl, who rarely gets invited to parties, I am very mindful of their conduct around others and accepting behaviour but I am very clear to them that be kind does not mean 'shut up' or 'pipe down' and I will fight all the way for women and single sex spaces.

Edited

Yes MattD

There is a huge difference from feminists working for all female people to receive the support and the health care that they need (not necessarily what they 'want') and 'narrow minded, pearl clutching arseholes'. I think it takes a special type of 'narrow minded deeply entrenched prejudice' to frame valid concerns in that way. And I have not seen any posts on this thread, or maybe they were referring to the other thread about the flags, that warrant that description from that poster made before they posted that here on this thread.

It is almost like the Cass Interim report was never published.

It is here by the way, for any readers who are not quite up to date on just why so many feminists, and parent groups, and clinicians and others are worried about simply 'accepting' children and adolescents as their identity. I also have many more links that show that the current treatment plans following 'affirming only' has not worked and is harmful. Including just how many of these patients end up either desisting before hormones or surgery or detransitioning after (and despite the misinformation about detransition rates, it is not the low 1% activists want us all to believe).

cass.independent-review.uk/wp-content/uploads/2022/03/The-Cass-Review-Interim-Report-Final-Bookmarked.pdf

However, feminists are hugely concerned by things such as single sex spaces that include all female people, including prisons, and single sex sports and support for female people who need that additional support to overcome millennia of negative sexist discrimination that female people are still subject to. Regardless of their gender.

Just as they are hugely concerned with the extreme negative side effects of transitioning not being clearly stated and shown to be understood by the patients involved. Fred McConnell was a university student or graduate when they had their double mastectomy and then told the world that they never understood that it meant they couldn't breast feed. There are so many stories out there just like that. But the media keeps glamourising double mastectomies and dismissing the evidence about the huge negative impact on female bodies of puberty blockers and testosterone.

But, apparently, flagging concerns is now pearl clutching and being narrow minded, hateful and phobic and a whole slew of accusations from people declaring that they are the most tolerant and compassionate and inclusive people in the world. The hypocrisy is very clear.

StephanieSuperpowers · 07/11/2023 12:45

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

So inclusive, so tolerant.

Applebottomjeenz · 07/11/2023 12:45

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

LimePi · 07/11/2023 12:44

Generally it’s ok but I would not lump dating someone with disability into this category, sorry. People should date because they fancy someone, not because of compassion

StephanieSuperpowers · 07/11/2023 12:41

I'm extremely compassionate. Sadly, it's the unfashionable kind of compassion that extends, in the first instance, to women and girls.

YouJustDoYou · 07/11/2023 12:40

"Oh @Gifgirl. Nobody on Mumsnet that I’ve ever seen feels hatred towards trans people, especially not the mixed-up kids being corralled into terrible experimental physical treatment for what is essentially poor mental health.There’s a justifiable fear and anger towards trans rights activists, most of whom are even trans themselves, threatening violence, rape and death to “TERFS”. I have never seen a gender critical poster wish violence, rape or death upon a trans person. Have you?"

Exactly. in all the years I've been on here, I've not once seen someone wish anything bad happen to trans people. I have however seen on here much, MUCH vitriol and ridicule and hope of death/violence against women and men who quote facts ie you can't change sex, and who want safe spaces for females.

Deadringer · 07/11/2023 12:36

I wasn't on any of the threads you mention op but as pp said, it's not that black and white. I wouldn't exclude my adult dc with mental health issues from my home, UNLESS they tried to hurt my other dc. I wouldn't discourage my dc from dating someone with a disability UNLESS I really believed that they couldn't handle it and it would affect their own health/mental health negatively. I don't have an issue with rainbow flags or whatever UNLESS I feel it is part of a campaign aimed at children and young people to normalise and encourage something that is potentially very damaging for them.

arethereanyleftatall · 07/11/2023 12:32

Mumsnet has, millions of mums on it, from all sectors of society. From any of these threads it is abundantly clear that most mums believe sex is immutable. Mums talk to their kids. Mums are teachers. Mums make up the vast majority of the teaching for children.

So, if you are silly enough to lie to your child that they are in the wrong body; then whether you like it or not, your child will very quickly come across someone who believes sex is immutable. Again and again and again. That ain't gonna be nice for them. Bit confusing.

Don't lie to your kids. It isn't kind.

@LadyGrinningSoul85

Helleofabore · 07/11/2023 12:30

YouJustDoYou · 07/11/2023 12:13

It's horrific. Just like the poor girl in the volleyball match who was given a fractured skull and brain injuries by the male who smashed the ball into her. It's "be kind to males". We wouldn't want to hurt their feelings now would we by not allowing them to play sports with people weaker and smaller and slower than them (aka "females").

And the teenaged girls in the rugby match a year or so ago who were seriously injured when a male was allowed to join the female team and injured several female players in the competing team.

MattDillonsEyebrows · 07/11/2023 12:29

The problem is @LadyGrinningSoul85 , it's likely that those you describe as 'narrow minded, pearl clutching arsehole' who are more likely to be the ones who protect your trans son.

I was a probation officer for almost 20 years, and can tell you that if your trans son, ever got in with the wrong crowd and ended up in prison, you would not want them to go to a male jail. In a true Stonewall utopia, your trans son would go to a male jail, and a transwoman would go to a female one, can you honestly not see the issue here?

People often talk about trans men and trans women as though they are the same, and they really aren't. Trans men simply don't have the same threat of danger to others that transwomen do. The sad truth is that people with penis's are more likely to be sex offenders, violent or fetishists, no matter what they cover that penis with, the threat remains much higher than with women.

As for the 'be kind' brigade, like most people, I will be kind to anyone on a personal level. As the mother of a very hyperactive girl, who rarely gets invited to parties, I am very mindful of their conduct around others and accepting behaviour but I am very clear to them that be kind does not mean 'shut up' or 'pipe down' and I will fight all the way for women and single sex spaces.

HowsOneToKnowItsTime · 07/11/2023 12:26

VickyEadieofThigh · 07/11/2023 12:19

I'm lesbian. That is EXACTLY what the flag with the pink, gray (etc - stay awake, because they keep on adding bits to it) bits means to me now.

Don't forget how in many lesbian communities you're now labelled as transphobic for not wanting to date TW or even, god forbid, know that someone is T beforehand. People say it's "their personal medical history" and they're afraid of violence but of course no one cares about the woman having full consent.

JaxiiTaxii · 07/11/2023 12:24

Does #bekind extend to putting the phone down, getting off ones backside and using your valuable free time giving practical help and support to vulnerable groups?

Making an actual difference to people in your community is kind and compassionate.

Typing vagueries on social media chastising others is #doingnothing.

Chanelbasketballandchain · 07/11/2023 12:21

it's a dog-eat-dog world. Don't teach your kids to "be kind", teach them to stand up for themselves, and not being bullied.

It's never the "kind" child who will be picked up at school for sports tournaments, for competitions, for the lead role in a play. It doesn't pay to be the "kind boy" or the "kind girl", it only brings upset kids.

We shouldn't be bullied for defending women's rights, and be called "transphobic" for it, but "be kind" takes us nowhere.

HowsOneToKnowItsTime · 07/11/2023 12:20

AtrociousCircumstance · 07/11/2023 10:53

No such thing as a trans child. There’s a boy or girl who is gender non confirming, which is awesome. But Trans is a pathway that encourages medicalisation and surgery to kids who just don’t want to align themselves to gender stereotypes (and seeing through gender stereotypes is great, I shall say again). Adults have a lot to answer for in reframing non conforming kids as kids who need to deny their own bodies.

I couldn't agree with you more. I've always been a tomboy. Even till this day most of my clothes come from the "men's" section and I have stereotypically masculine hobbies and style. People nowadays tend to automatically assume I'm either trans or NB. It's incredibly demoralising because it brings me back to being a kid and hearing about what things/clothes/hobbies are for girls and which ones are for boys. What happened to the idea that girls can be however they are? Gender roles and stereotypes are in vogue once again.

VickyEadieofThigh · 07/11/2023 12:19

MinnieL · 07/11/2023 11:40

So let’s just forget about people are gay, lesbian, bisexual and so on huh? Pride all of a sudden represents men who are allowed in women’s changing rooms? Get a grip

I'm lesbian. That is EXACTLY what the flag with the pink, gray (etc - stay awake, because they keep on adding bits to it) bits means to me now.

Ffsnotaconference · 07/11/2023 12:19

Gifgirl · 07/11/2023 10:16

Reading through some threads makes me so sad (and mad) sometimes.

Excluding teenagers from homes due to MH conditions, being cross about flags on stickers cos they are rainbows, encouraging your kids to not date someone cos they have a disability.. etc etc.

Acceptance and kindness is a wonderful thing and would make the world a much lovelier place.

Please encourage your kids to accept and include people even if they are different to you. We won't move on until this happens.

I think you are completely wrong.

Teens shouldn’t be put out of a house simply because they have mental health issues. I would bet money no one has said that. I would bet that people have advised it may have to be an option due to the emotional and/physical impacts on others living in the house.

How is there no compassion in suggesting that? You are saying that it’s only compassion if your sympathy is only with the teen with mental health issues. What about compassion for the people who are being traumatised by having that teen in the house? Why don’t you have any for them?

The rainbow sticker situation isn’t how you described it. On the trans issue, I have lots of compassion. For women.

On the not wanting your child to date someone disabled. Whats the actual issue there?

I am going to guess it’s a case (again) of you simply believing people aren’t being compassionate to the people (or in the way) you think they should.

MavisMcMinty · 07/11/2023 12:16

Oh @Gifgirl . Nobody on Mumsnet that I’ve ever seen feels hatred towards trans people, especially not the mixed-up kids being corralled into terrible experimental physical treatment for what is essentially poor mental health.

There’s a justifiable fear and anger towards trans rights activists, most of whom are even trans themselves, threatening violence, rape and death to “TERFS”. I have never seen a gender critical poster wish violence, rape or death upon a trans person. Have you?

There’s a perfectly healthy suspicion of full-grown adult men who suddenly declare they’re trans and have been all their lives (apart from the decades spent fathering their children and husbanding their wives). Never-mentioned-before gender dysphoria is just their excuse to [redacted].

There is also righteous disapproval of allowing men into women-only spaces. It may not matter to some women but it bloody well matters to others, and you don’t get to over-rule them.

Even here, in rural farming Devon, surrounded by cows/bulls, ewes/rams, cocks/hens, boars/sows, there’s a factory that summarily dismissed a worker who accidentally asked the transwoman in the office what she’d liked to do when she was a boy.

It can seem as though trans identity is the ONLY protected characteristic in the Equalities Act, going by the hundreds of employment tribunals where gender critical women have been fired for believing there are only two sexes.

If supporting women’s rights is “transphobic” that’s because there’s a clash of rights. Supporting trans rights - and can you tell us what rights they don’t have, I wonder? - is misogynistic, in the same sense.

Codlingmoths · 07/11/2023 12:16

I teach my children to accept everyone they meet, I ask them what do you think x thought to remind them the children at school with additional needs think about things just like them. I would never allow them to think another child is right if they told them they could change sex, since you can’t. I’d say when you’re older you can identify as whatever you like but honestly we will support you to be the best version you can be of who you want to be and when people are happy with who they are and express themselves however they want to, whether it’s more like typical boys or more like typical girls, then that’s the best outcome. That’s being kind. But I will teach my daughter especially that she matters and to stand up for what she wants and believes in, and if others disagree then tough shit, you need friends but you do not need everyone to like you. Enough with the hate accusations, go do something to genuinely support a fellow human being op.
And yes mumsnet is often extremely kind and supportive and caring for people in their time of need.

unsync · 07/11/2023 12:14

Hobnobswantshernameback · 07/11/2023 10:51

So everyone has been polite and reasonable
but then someone has to call us "narrow minded arseholes"
oh the irony

You forgot the pearl clutchers? Can they not be outraged too? #bekind 🙄

YouJustDoYou · 07/11/2023 12:13

arethereanyleftatall · 07/11/2023 12:09

Did anyone see the video doing the rounds at the moment of a girls teeth being knocked out in a hockey match by a male? In a girls match.

Please could someone on the be kind/tolerant side articulate to me what is kind about that? Because I really don't get it.

It's horrific. Just like the poor girl in the volleyball match who was given a fractured skull and brain injuries by the male who smashed the ball into her. It's "be kind to males". We wouldn't want to hurt their feelings now would we by not allowing them to play sports with people weaker and smaller and slower than them (aka "females").

Swipe left for the next trending thread