Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be sad at the lack of compassion

138 replies

Gifgirl · 07/11/2023 10:16

Reading through some threads makes me so sad (and mad) sometimes.

Excluding teenagers from homes due to MH conditions, being cross about flags on stickers cos they are rainbows, encouraging your kids to not date someone cos they have a disability.. etc etc.

Acceptance and kindness is a wonderful thing and would make the world a much lovelier place.

Please encourage your kids to accept and include people even if they are different to you. We won't move on until this happens.

OP posts:
Sueveneers · 08/11/2023 06:58

Gifgirl · 07/11/2023 10:44

Probably best to give someone a chance to reply to a post before accusing them of ignoring you.

Really sorry to hear of your traumas. I am in the same position; I was sexually and physically abused by my Dad and my cousin.

Whilst I COMPLETELY agree that we need to find a solution regarding shared spaces, I cannot get on board with trans hate. They are people too. And not all of them are out to hurt us.

Women wanting HUMAN RIGHTS is not 'trans hate'. I have not seen any 'hate'. Just women enforcing our boundaries and sex-based NEEDS and RIGHTS.

And people can get to fuck with this 'Be Kind' bullshit, which always means women be kind, at the expense of our needs and rights. Fuck that! 'Be Kind' is why women are in the situation we are in. And it's always women who need to Be Kind. Never men. So just enough now already with the women Be Kind bullshit! ENOUGH.

PriOn1 · 08/11/2023 05:06

NotMyCircusAnymore · 07/11/2023 23:29

But how does saying that we don't agree with mixed spaces, women's refuges, toilets etc actually harms a trans person? A trans person isn't harmed by using the loo for their birth sex. Or if they prefer, they can campaign for a third space or a gender neutral one?

a trans child isn't harmed by parents waiting until they older for allowing them to have surgery.

a trans boy isn't harmed by being told they have to wear trousers instead of a skirt at school. They don't like it. No, and yes it seems unfair considering girls can wear either , but it won't harm them. It's just unfair and annoying.

A trans girl isn't harmed by being told she can't wear a binder until she is older . She will wait and get on with her life in the meantime and if she still wants one when she is older she can have one. Or maybe find a doctor to help her transition.

Bigotry goes both ways. What about that vicar in Yorkshire a few months back when the bank dropped him for saying he didn't think banks needed rainbow flags? What about his beliefs? Isn't this a free country ?

Disagreeing with an ideology is free speech. I am friends with people of different political backgrounds, some are trans, some are lesbian, some are terfs, some don't care. we rub along ok. Because at the end of the day we can agree to disagree.

You have your terminology the wrong way round. A “trans boy” is a girl who claims she’s a boy. She might wear a binder and want a mastectomy.

A “trans girl” is a boy who claims he’s a girl.

salsmum · 08/11/2023 03:27

I'm 61 now but when I was a teen I had the most painful, heavy periods ever! I missed half of my exams because the bleeding and cramps were so bad and every ninth I hoped and prayed I'd wake up a boy just so that I didn't get periods, I'm sure if there would have been a way to change sex and stop the pain my teen brain would have gone for it... I was not attracted to the same sex nor was I suffering from body dysmorphia I was just a teen who hated going through hell every two weeks! I'm so glad that my late mum didn't have the option of putting me on puberty blockers because then I wouldn't have met and married my late husband nor had 2 beautiful kids and grandsons.

SmokeyToo · 08/11/2023 01:49

@Codlingmoths We Aussies are everywhere, eh? Lol!

Thankfully, I was never under Clover's 'dictatorship'. I was very close (geographically) to the city, but on the north side. Nowadays, I'm up in wine country. But I seriously cannot understand how Clover gets away with what she does! And the fact that she keeps getting re-elected. But she's getting on a bit now and has mumbled about 'passing the batton' - which probably means the electorate will get someone worse!

I left Sydney three years ago for the country life and I've never looked back. The deplorable traffic and general attitude of Sydneysiders these days makes it a horrible place to live. Fine if your young, but I backed out at 50 for a quieter life. Besides, they ruined any fun whatsoever with their draconian laws on nightlife, live entertainment etc. How I miss the heady days of Oxford Street in the 90s!

Codlingmoths · 08/11/2023 01:32

@SmokeyToo Hooray for an Aussie! Im really sorry you’ve had clover Moore.

NotMyCircusAnymore · 08/11/2023 01:01

Gifgirl · 07/11/2023 10:16

Reading through some threads makes me so sad (and mad) sometimes.

Excluding teenagers from homes due to MH conditions, being cross about flags on stickers cos they are rainbows, encouraging your kids to not date someone cos they have a disability.. etc etc.

Acceptance and kindness is a wonderful thing and would make the world a much lovelier place.

Please encourage your kids to accept and include people even if they are different to you. We won't move on until this happens.

@Gifgirl excluding teens from homes due to mental health issues really? Which thread is that one ?

NotMyCircusAnymore · 08/11/2023 00:30

LittleGreenDragons · 08/11/2023 00:25

@NotMyCircusAnymore
I know that, I was asking OP to explain.

I think my formatting went a bit wrong. The top half was copied from OPs post, the bottom was my question. Sorry 😬

Edited

No problem, it may have been me that misunderstood it's late and I get a bit hard of thinking when it's late! 😀

LittleGreenDragons · 08/11/2023 00:25

@NotMyCircusAnymore
I know that, I was asking OP to explain.

I think my formatting went a bit wrong. The top half was copied from OPs post, the bottom was my question. Sorry 😬

SmokeyToo · 08/11/2023 00:23

I hate the thought of being "unkind" to anyone. I'm an empathetic person who usually goes out of their way to show compassion to all. However! So many of you have raised great points in this thread and it's very helpful to know that just because I disagree with something, it doesn't make me "unkind".

I grew up in Sydney, Australia in the 80s when gay rights were a huge issue. I had (and have) many gay and lesbian friends that were marginalised in terrible ways and who were openly abused just for being themselves. I hated it and I stood very strongly for gay and lesbian rights because my friends were people first and foremost, just like me.

The rise of the trans agenda is SO worrying. I couldn't care less if someone is trans. But I DO care that an angry and exclusionary trans rights agenda is being shoved down the throats of impressionable kids. And telling straight women and men that we MUST accept whatever they demand, otherwise we're labeled as trans-phobic, sexist, racist blah blah blah. The pendulum has simply swung too far now.

I reiterate that I'm a very kind and compassionate person. But don't tell me I have to accept your agenda - an agenda that impinges on my rights as a woman and the rights of children to grow up without idealistic crap being beaten into them. I will support you IF I THINK IT'S RIGHT. If I don't, you're free to carry on, but you won't find support from me and I won't tolerate your bullshit telling me I'm any sort of "ist" just because I don't agree with you.

NotMyCircusAnymore · 07/11/2023 23:41

@LittleGreenDragons MOST transwomen, same as most other men don't want to hurt us. But we can't tell which of them do, they don't wear a sign identifying themselves!

Transwomen are men and within men as a class there are always a tiny minority that hurt women and children . This is a fact and facts trump ideologies.

NotMyCircusAnymore · 07/11/2023 23:29

But how does saying that we don't agree with mixed spaces, women's refuges, toilets etc actually harms a trans person? A trans person isn't harmed by using the loo for their birth sex. Or if they prefer, they can campaign for a third space or a gender neutral one?

a trans child isn't harmed by parents waiting until they older for allowing them to have surgery.

a trans boy isn't harmed by being told they have to wear trousers instead of a skirt at school. They don't like it. No, and yes it seems unfair considering girls can wear either , but it won't harm them. It's just unfair and annoying.

A trans girl isn't harmed by being told she can't wear a binder until she is older . She will wait and get on with her life in the meantime and if she still wants one when she is older she can have one. Or maybe find a doctor to help her transition.

Bigotry goes both ways. What about that vicar in Yorkshire a few months back when the bank dropped him for saying he didn't think banks needed rainbow flags? What about his beliefs? Isn't this a free country ?

Disagreeing with an ideology is free speech. I am friends with people of different political backgrounds, some are trans, some are lesbian, some are terfs, some don't care. we rub along ok. Because at the end of the day we can agree to disagree.

MavisMcMinty · 07/11/2023 23:28

LittleGreenDragons · 07/11/2023 23:17

Whilst I COMPLETELY agree that we need to find a solution regarding shared spaces, I cannot get on board with trans hate. They are people too. And not all of them are out to hurt us.

The million dollar question that keeps getting asked is how can we tell who are the hurty ones?

We can’t, just as we can’t tell which men are the hurty ones. Which is why we ban all men from our single-sex spaces.

It’s not prejudice, it’s safeguarding women and girls. No hatred, no phobias, it’s just that men are women’s only predators. NOT ALL MEN are predators but enough of them are that we need protection from them at our most vulnerable, e.g. where we may be naked, or sleeping.

EDIT to say I know that you know that @LittleGreenDragons !

millimole · 07/11/2023 23:24

I saw that Primark have seen sense and changed their changing rooms policy. Their previously policy was unisex changing rooms. I had the curtain opened on me by a man.

The new (ish) Primark policy:

We want our stores to be places where everyone feels safe and welcome.
We’re sorry to hear this hasn’t been the experience some people have reported in our fitting rooms.

We’ve listened to feedback from our customers and colleagues and you’ll start to see changes in our UK and ROI stores in the coming weeks.
Here’s what we’re doing:

  1. We will ensure that we offer a *dedicated fitting room area for women,* as well as continuing to offer a combined fitting room area which everyone can use. The set up will vary according to the store layout.
  1. *We are making the cubicles more secure* by introducing longer curtains and a new mechanism to hold the curtains firmly in place.
  1. We are *refreshing our colleague training* in order to ensure that our teams have everything they need to manage the fitting rooms in our stores and support our customers using them.
EtiennePalmiere · 07/11/2023 23:23

Be kind ladies and put your needs aside ! Thanks for the reminder 🤗🤗🤗

LittleGreenDragons · 07/11/2023 23:17

Whilst I COMPLETELY agree that we need to find a solution regarding shared spaces, I cannot get on board with trans hate. They are people too. And not all of them are out to hurt us.

The million dollar question that keeps getting asked is how can we tell who are the hurty ones?

MorrisZapp · 07/11/2023 23:17

Compassion. Another perfectly harmless word that I now have to hate because of tiresome navel gazers.

BitOutOfPractice · 07/11/2023 23:16

We live in a country where the Home Secretary’s plan on homelessness is to ban tents because they’re “unsightly”.

Compassion’s currency is not high in the uk right now.

Dweetfidilove · 07/11/2023 23:13

AtrociousCircumstance · 07/11/2023 10:53

No such thing as a trans child. There’s a boy or girl who is gender non confirming, which is awesome. But Trans is a pathway that encourages medicalisation and surgery to kids who just don’t want to align themselves to gender stereotypes (and seeing through gender stereotypes is great, I shall say again). Adults have a lot to answer for in reframing non conforming kids as kids who need to deny their own bodies.

🙌🏾🙌🏾

RudsyFarmer · 07/11/2023 23:00

I think it’s compassion fatigue. Everyone claims victimhood now and life is hard. People are just getting worn down with the struggle.

AtrociousCircumstance · 07/11/2023 22:53

@MattDillonsEyebrows Is she on instagram? I’m not on TikTok and wondered if I could find her on insta but I haven’t located her.

MattDillonsEyebrows · 07/11/2023 13:51

Whilst no-one will ever surpass the brilliance of Magdalene, there is another young woman on TikTok, called Allison Ellis, who is like a northern version of her.

She credits Magdalene for her GCness and has a similar deadpan, no nonsense fact ridden content. She's rather brilliant and worth checking out.

Waitingfordoggo · 07/11/2023 13:21

Magdalen was so fucking fierce. 🔥

Helleofabore · 07/11/2023 13:20

I was just coming to say that Rocket

Here is a great place to start in case anyone here thinks that lesbians are one homogenous group who are fully accepting that lesbians can have dicks.

It also needs to be said that Nancy Kelly, the previous CEO for Stonewall, equated lesbians who rejected male trans people from their relationship potential pool were akin to sexual racists and some other ridiculous slurs.

Just another reason feminists have included these issues in their campaigning and are not 'narrow minded' for doing so.

There Is No Such Thing as a Lesbian With a Penis!

Lesbian taking issue with the question, "WOULD YOU DATE A LESBIAN WITH A PENIS?" being asked by Arielle Scarcella who hosts a YouTube channel which purports ...

https://youtu.be/qkcCzIc0j2s?feature=shared

RocketPanda · 07/11/2023 13:05

To quote the late great Magdalen Berns
" I'd rather be rude than a fucking liar"

JudgeJ · 07/11/2023 13:03

Menopausalprincess · 07/11/2023 10:50

Um, I’d just like to have access to single-sex changing rooms - why is that ‘trans hate’?

It's deemed 'trans hate' because you're not 100% committed to the beliefs of the judge, jury and executioners, in the same way as any slight deviation from any other agenda has the same effect. It's the trans supporters etc who don't want a fair, balanced world, they want their world and nothing else.