Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be sad at the lack of compassion

138 replies

Gifgirl · 07/11/2023 10:16

Reading through some threads makes me so sad (and mad) sometimes.

Excluding teenagers from homes due to MH conditions, being cross about flags on stickers cos they are rainbows, encouraging your kids to not date someone cos they have a disability.. etc etc.

Acceptance and kindness is a wonderful thing and would make the world a much lovelier place.

Please encourage your kids to accept and include people even if they are different to you. We won't move on until this happens.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
PabloandGustheGreySquirrels · 09/11/2023 15:03

Gifgirl · 07/11/2023 10:16

Reading through some threads makes me so sad (and mad) sometimes.

Excluding teenagers from homes due to MH conditions, being cross about flags on stickers cos they are rainbows, encouraging your kids to not date someone cos they have a disability.. etc etc.

Acceptance and kindness is a wonderful thing and would make the world a much lovelier place.

Please encourage your kids to accept and include people even if they are different to you. We won't move on until this happens.

Please may you link the one where someone has discouraged their DC from dating someone with a disability? Thats appalling

Helleofabore · 09/11/2023 10:58

Ereshkigalangcleg · 09/11/2023 10:44

They wanted to have their cake and eat it, pretend to have female only changing rooms to their customers but have an "inclusive" policy.

The customer service team attempted to portray my concerns as me being hateful when I all I did was talk about the man who sat beside me in front of a cubicle that was completely inadequately provisioned for the degree of privacy needed for a mixed sex changing space using very carefully chosen and neutral language. I mentioned that mixed sex changing spaces needed lockable floor to ceiling doors and the signage was needed to make any person aware that it was a mixed sex space.

Primark are most definitely not interested in listening to the complaints of women unless that complaint is publicised. There have now been numerous publicised incidents and all they seem to have done is say they are 'rolling out' more robustly closing curtains. This is years after my first email and I doubt I was the first.

Helleofabore · 09/11/2023 10:53

MrsSkylerWhite · 09/11/2023 10:30

”…. that the policy was now inclusive so anyone at all could use the cubicles. There was absolutely no signage to say this.”

Ah, that explains it.

Most major stores now have no single sex changing spaces including M&S. And many women are still completely unaware that these stores have made policy changes. I don't think many make the changes known.

I have tried to continue emailing Primark because the issue is that there is curtains still and they are not interested and will not escalate any dialogue about it. As I said, even after incidents have been reported.

Many teenage girls use those changing rooms and come out in various states of dress to show each other. I doubt that they are aware that they are no longer in a single sex space.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 09/11/2023 10:44

They wanted to have their cake and eat it, pretend to have female only changing rooms to their customers but have an "inclusive" policy.

MrsSkylerWhite · 09/11/2023 10:30

”…. that the policy was now inclusive so anyone at all could use the cubicles. There was absolutely no signage to say this.”

Ah, that explains it.

Helleofabore · 09/11/2023 09:54

MrsSkylerWhite · 09/11/2023 09:39

millimole · 07/11/2023 23:24

I saw that Primark have seen sense and changed their changing rooms policy. Their previously policy was unisex changing rooms. I had the curtain opened on me by a man.”

I’ve been going into Primark stores since the first one opened and never seen unisex changing rooms 🤷‍♀️

Three years ago I was in what I thought was the female changing rooms with someone and was waiting outside the cubicle on a bench in the changing room corridor. A man sat beside me supposedly waiting for their friend around the bend of the changing room corridor. But the man was in front of a cubicle where a woman was changing. And she had left a gap in the curtain as often happens as they don’t also close neatly.

He could see in and the reflection in her mirror. I jumped up and closed the curtain and checked my friends curtain. I also complained and was told that the policy was now inclusive so anyone at all could use the cubicles. There was absolutely no signage to say this.

I tried to complain to head office and have been robbed off repeatedly. Even after the Wandsworth incident.

All the Primark main changing rooms are unisex and still with curtains.

MrsSkylerWhite · 09/11/2023 09:40

Actually, having said that, I’ve never seen a man in the queue so maybe they are and I’ve just not noticed.

MrsSkylerWhite · 09/11/2023 09:39

millimole · 07/11/2023 23:24

I saw that Primark have seen sense and changed their changing rooms policy. Their previously policy was unisex changing rooms. I had the curtain opened on me by a man.”

I’ve been going into Primark stores since the first one opened and never seen unisex changing rooms 🤷‍♀️

lemmein · 08/11/2023 15:43

Hobnobswantshernameback · 07/11/2023 11:22

And having young adult children I can assure you a hefty proportion of them particularly the young women they mix with aren't buying into all the trans religion.
They see it for what it is

Same - in my adult DDs peer groups there is only one who is fully signed up to the #bekind club. The rest are very much 'cool, but keep out of our single-sex spaces!'. All in their mid to late 20s.

SmokeyToo · 08/11/2023 10:30

@Helleofabore yes, that's who I was talking about. Couldn't think of her name!

SmokeyToo · 08/11/2023 10:15

@Helleofabore Thank you - yes, you're correct. My terminology is lacking! I meant a male who is transitioning/has transitioned to a female. Without the surgery. And yep, I was specifically referring to the Lia Thomas situation. That particular situation angers me greatly!

I completely understand what you're saying about missing people not places. It was probably more along those lines for me, too. But I've always been glad to come home to Australia whenever I travel. It's just a lot less 'complicated' down here - a bit backward, but in a good way (mostly!). Also, being at the arse end of the earth does make it feel a bit safer, considering what's going on in the rest of the world right now!

Thanks again for the discussion and research links - I'm not working at the moment, so I'll get my teeth into it! Enjoy your day/evening. 😀

StephanieSuperpowers · 08/11/2023 10:08

This is a great article which includes some thoughts about kindness and the costs associated with it for women:

She/her/or/else | Victoria Smith | The Critic Magazine

She/her/or/else | Victoria Smith | The Critic Magazine

No one should be forced to use preferred pronouns…

https://thecritic.co.uk/she-her-or-else/

Helleofabore · 08/11/2023 09:57

SmokeyToo · 08/11/2023 09:20

I so agree, @Sueveneers. What happened to Moira Deeming was horrendous! Same with the British lady (whose name escapes me!) who came down here to speak about women's rights. The one whose event got hijacked by that idiot Lidia Thorpe.

All my life I've been happy to be a girl/woman. I'm so grateful to the women before me who fought the fight so that I have the rights that I have today. But those rights are being eroded now and it's really distressing!

Moira is visiting London at the moment with Holly Lawford-Smith an awesome feminist from Melbourne.

The English woman you are referring to is Kellie Jay Keen. And the Vic Libs used Wikipedia which contains false information from articles that were again not quite correct to try to suspend her. Very disappointing to see an Australian political party not due their due diligence.

https://m.youtube.com/@KellieJayKeen

And you don’t have to agree with her on everything to gain knowledge and understanding from listening to her. But what is important is her live feeds where women and girls speak for themselves. The Australian events are also on her YouTube. Under the live videos I think.

Before you continue to YouTube

https://m.youtube.com/@KellieJayKeen

JamSandle · 08/11/2023 09:54

Prelapsarianhag · 07/11/2023 11:04

Agree with you OP. There is a lot of transphobia on mumsnet. Fortunately most younger women are much more accepting of diversity - many would not join mumsnet because of its tolerance of transphobia.

It's not a phobia.

Helleofabore · 08/11/2023 09:52

SmokeyToo · 08/11/2023 09:07

@Helleofabore Thank you for putting together such a comprehensive and thoughtful reply - I really do appreciate it. I haven't investigated the links just yet, but I definitely will.

You are so correct about 'kindness, tolerance, compassion' etc. becoming weaponised words. I think that if I was younger, I'd probably be affected a lot more if I were accused of NOT being any of these things. But I guess I've reached the age where I think what I think, I believe what I believe and, although I am always willing to listen to and debate other's opinions, I can now agree to disagree. Or the opposite.

When I was in my late teens and 20s, 30s etc., gay and lesbian rights were something I was REALLY passionate about. I marched in the Sydney Gay and Lesbian Mardi Gras, defended their rights with all that I had. I still do, but as my gay and lesbian friends say, most of that fight for rights and acceptance is now over - they won. It kind of amuses me that the current activists don't seem to give a thought to the struggles that their predecessors fought. I don't want to put anyone down and say those were much more important struggles, but they really were! Gay men were getting bashed on the streets and murdered back then, just because they were gay. There was a whole series of murders in the 80s (bashing gay men and throwing them off coastal cliffs) in Sydney! Gay and lesbian people had no civil rights, they couldn't marry or be recognised as their partner's life partner. It was a very dangerous time to be homosexual and they fought long and hard - through a great deal of danger - to get these rights and laws. I'm sorry, but people getting pissy because someone calls them him or her when they prefer "they" doesn't really cut it in my book.

I don't care what people want to call themselves or what they identify as, although I still believe there are only two genders. But if a guy wants to wear a dress and heels and call himself a lady, that's fine by me. More power to you! But when that starts impinging on the rights of those born female, it's game over as far as I'm concerned. I don't want to be in a public changeroom and have some guy with his dick out in front of me - that's just wrong. And when it comes to children's rights to also not be exposed to that, I'm way invested. It just shouldn't happen! Women and children have a right to be able to comfortably go about their business without some guy's dick in their face. It's both inappropriate at best and dangerous at worst.

As for natural born males competing in women's sports teams, it's unforgivable. Nothing short of that. To hear about talented sportswomen all over the world giving up on their dreams because some teenage guy decided he's a girl and therefore equal to women is an absolute travesty! I am particularly affected by what female swimmers have been going through. Not only do they have no hope of beating biological males because they're simply not as strong and don't have the same muscle mass, they are told to use the same change rooms as these trans men! I read about one swimmer saying it takes them a good 15 minutes to wriggle themselves into competition swimwear and how humiliating and threatening it was to have to do it in front of a guy with a penis. That broke my heart - why on God's green earth can this be allowed to happen to women??

I have done nowhere near the research you've done, but I read and watch a lot. And frankly, I'm disgusted by what's happening to women. Women that have fought for basic rights for literally centuries! It seems that, at the silly whims of some men, all of our fights have gone out the window. It's not right, it's not fair and nobody can convince me otherwise.

Yep, I'm in the beautiful HV! How are you finding London? Do you miss the weather here? I have a couple of relatives who live there now and they both have to be treated for Seasonal Depressive Disorder. As much as I bitch about the heat here, I think I'd miss it if it was gone. I lived in North America for a couple of years, so I know all about surviving frigid winters! As wonderful as my time away was, I was happy to come home to good old, backward Australia.

Thank you again for your thoughtful reply. 😊

No worries. I hope you don’t think I am nit picking but I think you meant either male transperson or transwoman when discussing swimming. Is that correct? Trans ‘men’ are female people and, unless they take testosterone, are free to compete in female sports. I am thinking you are referring to Lia Thomas and the fact that the female swimmers needed 30-45 minutes to get into their compression suits. It was either Paula Scanlon or Riley Gaines or one of the other brave women who said this in their declaration to one of the committees.

but here is Paula discussing the impact of having a male in her locker room:

https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-12471635/amp/Paula-Scanlan-attacks-Democratic-trans-rights.html

If you are interested, there is a thread on the feminist board that was sectioned off to discuss all ‘sex and gender issues’ that is a useful one for links that might be useful to start with. It is a long running thread that has been used to stash research links but the first half is also interesting to read for background too.

https://www.mumsnet.com/talk/womens_rights/3145470-Break-it-down-for-me?latest=0

The important thing to know is that you are not alone thinking something is not quite as being described. That feminist board is full of women, some from Australia, who are full of the same questions as the rest of us. And we are always up for learning and gaining better understanding of what is happening and why.

And thanks for asking, I love the weather over here. I don’t find it much different weather wise to when I lived in Canberra for a few years, but wetter. And growing up surrounded by constant drought in other parts of Oz, I love the green! I know the HV quite well. I miss people but not places at this time iykwim.

Paula Scanlan slams Democratics for putting 'trans rights' above fears

In a scathing opinion piece, Scanlan, 23, shared her frustration and concerns around transgender athletes entering woman-only spaces.

https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-12471635/amp/Paula-Scanlan-attacks-Democratic-trans-rights.html

SmokeyToo · 08/11/2023 09:20

Sueveneers · 08/11/2023 08:15

Another fellow Aussie here. I am disheartened at what is happening, even in the Victorian Liberal party with Moira, and I'm a Labor voter and member.

I so agree, @Sueveneers. What happened to Moira Deeming was horrendous! Same with the British lady (whose name escapes me!) who came down here to speak about women's rights. The one whose event got hijacked by that idiot Lidia Thorpe.

All my life I've been happy to be a girl/woman. I'm so grateful to the women before me who fought the fight so that I have the rights that I have today. But those rights are being eroded now and it's really distressing!

SmokeyToo · 08/11/2023 09:07

Helleofabore · 08/11/2023 08:03

Oh yay! More of us on MN!!

Whereas you moved to HV (I am supposing), we moved to the ‘huge smoke’ of London. And we lived ‘north’ of Clover’s jurisdiction too.

I am horrified that so much harm has been done in Australia with so much uncertainty because Julia Gillard slipped in gender into the anti-discrimination act. No one has tested it, yet Kieran Perkins referred to it as a basis for the Sports Australia decision.

https://www.mumsnet.com/talk/womens_rights/4873436-australian-legislation-discussion-to-avoid-derailing-other-threads?reply=128581747

So now we also have lesbians in some states not being able to hold meetings and events that exclude men who believe they too are lesbians. And we have a continuous stream of people on MN such as OP and others who, it seems, would declare that it is the lesbians who are intolerant and lack compassion.

I see you have stressed that you are kind and compassionate and tolerant all through your post. And I am sure you are using the original meaning of the words as much you have described is what so many posters also support. However, I have learned reading on MN that these words, just like the word woman and girl and now female (yes, this too is now a word used by males to describe themselves), have been dramatically changed to now include the opposite meaning of the original intended meaning.

That the words are used by the very people to describe themselves, such as OP, who display the opposite values towards those who don’t agree with them. Which is the very opposite of kindness or tolerance or compassion. So, I now accept the supposed insults flung at me for my posts on MN, that I am ‘intolerant’, ‘unkind’ and ‘lacking compassion’. Because people like the OP make such declarations about those raising valid and researched concerns as ‘hate’.

These days posts such as the OP’s shine the light where those determined to be ‘kind’ don’t want it shone. Because then they are forced to start to discuss and understand where their attempts at silencing and scolding those who see the issues and concerns lead society. To a place that lacks high quality health care for children and adolescents who deserve better and evidence based care, and a society that lacks robust safeguarding for women and girls. Often their ‘compassion’ and ‘kindness’ excludes compassion for women and girls.

So, now if someone tells me I lack compassion because I raise concerns about children and adolescent health care, or sports for women and girls, or raise the exploitative nature of surrogacy, or that we still need single sex spaces to be single sex, I understand that they choose not to do the depth of research to think critically through these issues. And it takes a long time to do that research. Because these days you cannot quite trust the ABC or most Australian mainstream media on this topic. They often lack balance. In saying that occasionally you get gems like this:

Here, the BBC also cannot be fully trusted either and every article needs to go back to original source to understand the real story. For instance, Caster Semenya is a male athlete with a DSD yet that is not reported on the BBC despite promoting Semenya’s book- how kind is that to the women that athlete’s inclusion negatively impacted.

So, finding the facts and evaluating those does make it harder. I understand that the time is just not available to others. It is the attitude of those who react with the hyperbole that the OP and others do though that shows perhaps the ‘ignorance’ is not quite the direction they are pointing. It is rarely ‘hate’ that causes people to disagree with people like the OP. The thread they referred to was about a sticker for a child that had a political symbol on a cute cartoon animal. Here is the link:

https://www.mumsnet.com/talk/am_i_being_unreasonable/4937464-transpride-flag-in-childrens-stickers?page=1

It is a crazy world, Smokey, when kindness and compassion have become such misused words.

@Helleofabore Thank you for putting together such a comprehensive and thoughtful reply - I really do appreciate it. I haven't investigated the links just yet, but I definitely will.

You are so correct about 'kindness, tolerance, compassion' etc. becoming weaponised words. I think that if I was younger, I'd probably be affected a lot more if I were accused of NOT being any of these things. But I guess I've reached the age where I think what I think, I believe what I believe and, although I am always willing to listen to and debate other's opinions, I can now agree to disagree. Or the opposite.

When I was in my late teens and 20s, 30s etc., gay and lesbian rights were something I was REALLY passionate about. I marched in the Sydney Gay and Lesbian Mardi Gras, defended their rights with all that I had. I still do, but as my gay and lesbian friends say, most of that fight for rights and acceptance is now over - they won. It kind of amuses me that the current activists don't seem to give a thought to the struggles that their predecessors fought. I don't want to put anyone down and say those were much more important struggles, but they really were! Gay men were getting bashed on the streets and murdered back then, just because they were gay. There was a whole series of murders in the 80s (bashing gay men and throwing them off coastal cliffs) in Sydney! Gay and lesbian people had no civil rights, they couldn't marry or be recognised as their partner's life partner. It was a very dangerous time to be homosexual and they fought long and hard - through a great deal of danger - to get these rights and laws. I'm sorry, but people getting pissy because someone calls them him or her when they prefer "they" doesn't really cut it in my book.

I don't care what people want to call themselves or what they identify as, although I still believe there are only two genders. But if a guy wants to wear a dress and heels and call himself a lady, that's fine by me. More power to you! But when that starts impinging on the rights of those born female, it's game over as far as I'm concerned. I don't want to be in a public changeroom and have some guy with his dick out in front of me - that's just wrong. And when it comes to children's rights to also not be exposed to that, I'm way invested. It just shouldn't happen! Women and children have a right to be able to comfortably go about their business without some guy's dick in their face. It's both inappropriate at best and dangerous at worst.

As for natural born males competing in women's sports teams, it's unforgivable. Nothing short of that. To hear about talented sportswomen all over the world giving up on their dreams because some teenage guy decided he's a girl and therefore equal to women is an absolute travesty! I am particularly affected by what female swimmers have been going through. Not only do they have no hope of beating biological males because they're simply not as strong and don't have the same muscle mass, they are told to use the same change rooms as these trans men! I read about one swimmer saying it takes them a good 15 minutes to wriggle themselves into competition swimwear and how humiliating and threatening it was to have to do it in front of a guy with a penis. That broke my heart - why on God's green earth can this be allowed to happen to women??

I have done nowhere near the research you've done, but I read and watch a lot. And frankly, I'm disgusted by what's happening to women. Women that have fought for basic rights for literally centuries! It seems that, at the silly whims of some men, all of our fights have gone out the window. It's not right, it's not fair and nobody can convince me otherwise.

Yep, I'm in the beautiful HV! How are you finding London? Do you miss the weather here? I have a couple of relatives who live there now and they both have to be treated for Seasonal Depressive Disorder. As much as I bitch about the heat here, I think I'd miss it if it was gone. I lived in North America for a couple of years, so I know all about surviving frigid winters! As wonderful as my time away was, I was happy to come home to good old, backward Australia.

Thank you again for your thoughtful reply. 😊

MattDillonsEyebrows · 08/11/2023 08:25

AtrociousCircumstance · 07/11/2023 22:53

@MattDillonsEyebrows Is she on instagram? I’m not on TikTok and wondered if I could find her on insta but I haven’t located her.

I‘M not sure if she’s on Instagram or not, she’s had a few accounts banned in TikTok for telling facts, I think she’s on Alison.no.5 but number 4 was reinstated! She might be on YouTube, but I’ve not looked.

For anyone reading this who hasn’t scrolled up, there’s a woman on TikTok called Alison who is very similar in presenting style to Magdalene. She credits Magdalene for the GC views and is very no nonsense, matter of fact and pretty great.

Merrymouse · 08/11/2023 08:23

I chose you are being unreasonable because I think you are over simplifying things. Leaving aside trans vs women’s rights issues (plenty of people have explained this), MH and addiction issues are complicated. There are various reasons why it might be necessary to exclude somebody from the family home.

I think the thing you miss is that there isn’t a neat way to be compassionate/kind to everyone when people’s needs and wishes conflict. This touches a nerve because ‘just be kind’ is often used a a simple formula to silence women.

Sueveneers · 08/11/2023 08:15

SmokeyToo · 08/11/2023 01:49

@Codlingmoths We Aussies are everywhere, eh? Lol!

Thankfully, I was never under Clover's 'dictatorship'. I was very close (geographically) to the city, but on the north side. Nowadays, I'm up in wine country. But I seriously cannot understand how Clover gets away with what she does! And the fact that she keeps getting re-elected. But she's getting on a bit now and has mumbled about 'passing the batton' - which probably means the electorate will get someone worse!

I left Sydney three years ago for the country life and I've never looked back. The deplorable traffic and general attitude of Sydneysiders these days makes it a horrible place to live. Fine if your young, but I backed out at 50 for a quieter life. Besides, they ruined any fun whatsoever with their draconian laws on nightlife, live entertainment etc. How I miss the heady days of Oxford Street in the 90s!

Another fellow Aussie here. I am disheartened at what is happening, even in the Victorian Liberal party with Moira, and I'm a Labor voter and member.

Helleofabore · 08/11/2023 08:10

MPY24 · 08/11/2023 07:18

Not all men are out to hurt women either. But we still separate based on the fact some are and will. My partner wouldn't hurt any woman ever. Can he come in the women's loo and changing room etc?

They don’t quite think their words through. They never quite extrapolate the concept out to see the wider picture.

It is like the ridiculous ‘most families have a mixed sex toilet at home, why are all complaining about sharing toilets with male people’.

Yes. The reality is most male people will not attack women and girls in a space, but they are ALL kept out because of the ones who are not safe.

And not one person on MN across many threads now has ever produced one shred of peer reviewed evidence that a male with a trans identity has a lower risk of committing a sex offence than the rest of the UK male population. Not one poster! Yet we are constantly told that this special group should be allowed into female single sex spaces by people claiming to be ‘kind’, ‘tolerant’ and ‘compassionate’.

littleripper · 08/11/2023 08:09

acceptance and kindness are constantly expected of WOMEN. I want acceptance and kindness from men. Acceptance that women are allowed to define themselves and kindness to give us single sex spaces.

Helleofabore · 08/11/2023 08:03

SmokeyToo · 08/11/2023 01:49

@Codlingmoths We Aussies are everywhere, eh? Lol!

Thankfully, I was never under Clover's 'dictatorship'. I was very close (geographically) to the city, but on the north side. Nowadays, I'm up in wine country. But I seriously cannot understand how Clover gets away with what she does! And the fact that she keeps getting re-elected. But she's getting on a bit now and has mumbled about 'passing the batton' - which probably means the electorate will get someone worse!

I left Sydney three years ago for the country life and I've never looked back. The deplorable traffic and general attitude of Sydneysiders these days makes it a horrible place to live. Fine if your young, but I backed out at 50 for a quieter life. Besides, they ruined any fun whatsoever with their draconian laws on nightlife, live entertainment etc. How I miss the heady days of Oxford Street in the 90s!

Oh yay! More of us on MN!!

Whereas you moved to HV (I am supposing), we moved to the ‘huge smoke’ of London. And we lived ‘north’ of Clover’s jurisdiction too.

I am horrified that so much harm has been done in Australia with so much uncertainty because Julia Gillard slipped in gender into the anti-discrimination act. No one has tested it, yet Kieran Perkins referred to it as a basis for the Sports Australia decision.

https://www.mumsnet.com/talk/womens_rights/4873436-australian-legislation-discussion-to-avoid-derailing-other-threads?reply=128581747

So now we also have lesbians in some states not being able to hold meetings and events that exclude men who believe they too are lesbians. And we have a continuous stream of people on MN such as OP and others who, it seems, would declare that it is the lesbians who are intolerant and lack compassion.

I see you have stressed that you are kind and compassionate and tolerant all through your post. And I am sure you are using the original meaning of the words as much you have described is what so many posters also support. However, I have learned reading on MN that these words, just like the word woman and girl and now female (yes, this too is now a word used by males to describe themselves), have been dramatically changed to now include the opposite meaning of the original intended meaning.

That the words are used by the very people to describe themselves, such as OP, who display the opposite values towards those who don’t agree with them. Which is the very opposite of kindness or tolerance or compassion. So, I now accept the supposed insults flung at me for my posts on MN, that I am ‘intolerant’, ‘unkind’ and ‘lacking compassion’. Because people like the OP make such declarations about those raising valid and researched concerns as ‘hate’.

These days posts such as the OP’s shine the light where those determined to be ‘kind’ don’t want it shone. Because then they are forced to start to discuss and understand where their attempts at silencing and scolding those who see the issues and concerns lead society. To a place that lacks high quality health care for children and adolescents who deserve better and evidence based care, and a society that lacks robust safeguarding for women and girls. Often their ‘compassion’ and ‘kindness’ excludes compassion for women and girls.

So, now if someone tells me I lack compassion because I raise concerns about children and adolescent health care, or sports for women and girls, or raise the exploitative nature of surrogacy, or that we still need single sex spaces to be single sex, I understand that they choose not to do the depth of research to think critically through these issues. And it takes a long time to do that research. Because these days you cannot quite trust the ABC or most Australian mainstream media on this topic. They often lack balance. In saying that occasionally you get gems like this:

Here, the BBC also cannot be fully trusted either and every article needs to go back to original source to understand the real story. For instance, Caster Semenya is a male athlete with a DSD yet that is not reported on the BBC despite promoting Semenya’s book- how kind is that to the women that athlete’s inclusion negatively impacted.

So, finding the facts and evaluating those does make it harder. I understand that the time is just not available to others. It is the attitude of those who react with the hyperbole that the OP and others do though that shows perhaps the ‘ignorance’ is not quite the direction they are pointing. It is rarely ‘hate’ that causes people to disagree with people like the OP. The thread they referred to was about a sticker for a child that had a political symbol on a cute cartoon animal. Here is the link:

https://www.mumsnet.com/talk/am_i_being_unreasonable/4937464-transpride-flag-in-childrens-stickers?page=1

It is a crazy world, Smokey, when kindness and compassion have become such misused words.

Australian legislation discussion, to avoid derailing other threads | Mumsnet

Since this has come up in a few threads, to avoid derailing them here is a new Oz-specific thread. The key document to note is the federal Sex Discr...

https://www.mumsnet.com/talk/womens_rights/4873436-australian-legislation-discussion-to-avoid-derailing-other-threads?reply=128581747

Sueveneers · 08/11/2023 07:33

Prelapsarianhag · 07/11/2023 11:04

Agree with you OP. There is a lot of transphobia on mumsnet. Fortunately most younger women are much more accepting of diversity - many would not join mumsnet because of its tolerance of transphobia.

@Prelapsarianhag What do you define 'transphobia' as? Because it seems to be any woman having human rights is 'transphobia'. Maybe you and others have femphobia? Rape survivors needing single-sex spaces is not 'transphobia'. Acknowledging no one can change sex, and that sex is real and immutable, is not 'transphobia'. Acknowledging that women are oppressed based on sex, and not 'gender identity', is not 'transphobia'. Acknowledging that all human rights and safeguarding women have is based on our sex class, is not 'transphobia'. Diversity means accepting many views, not just one. If you attack vulnerable women as 'transphobic', despite our needs, you're intolerance, not accepting of diversity.

Thankfully it's a minority of younger girls that are caught up in the religion of Gender Ideology, women elders that have seen it all, gone before us and fought for our rights because we know the realities of what men are like, are making headway into the Gender Ideology religion and bringing vulnerable and impressionable, and lacking in experience, girls back into reality. Women are winning this war and the Gender Ideologists and men are getting increasingly desperate as they sense defeat. Thankfully views like yours will soon be seen as the regressive, hateful, misogynistic and harmful views they are.

MPY24 · 08/11/2023 07:18

Gifgirl · 07/11/2023 10:44

Probably best to give someone a chance to reply to a post before accusing them of ignoring you.

Really sorry to hear of your traumas. I am in the same position; I was sexually and physically abused by my Dad and my cousin.

Whilst I COMPLETELY agree that we need to find a solution regarding shared spaces, I cannot get on board with trans hate. They are people too. And not all of them are out to hurt us.

Not all men are out to hurt women either. But we still separate based on the fact some are and will. My partner wouldn't hurt any woman ever. Can he come in the women's loo and changing room etc?

Swipe left for the next trending thread