Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

FiL wants all our data

758 replies

HighlandCowSaysBooNotMoo · 06/11/2023 23:54

My father in law works in a government role.
Today he put a message in the family WhatsApp group asking if we could send him our addresses, d.o.bs, mothers maiden names, our place of birth, our address history, previous maiden names etc.
Apparently he needs this info from his 4 adult children, their spouses (me included) , his own siblings and his siblings spouses, grandchildren, his in laws etc. Basically he is covering every member of the family and spouses etc over the age of 18.
He has put something light hearted about it being needed for an enhanced security check that he's been told he needs for his job.
He is not changing jobs or position in the company. He has been in this job for since my husband was a wee kid!!
A couple of people have responded straight away with their data.
DH says IABU not to share mine with his dad
What do I do?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
fatchilli123 · 09/11/2023 13:49

They wanted same stuff off me . He is doing new type of work within the department probably. These are standard security questions . You are perfectly at liberty to refuse him the info. They will just take longer to get the information and he will not do the job they are maybe wanting him for till they complete his checks to their satisfaction. Bearing in mind he has been there a long time they may have already got the information anyway but forms have to be completed and checked .

justteanbiscuits · 09/11/2023 13:49

Thistlewoman · 09/11/2023 13:46

Like I said, you do you. However-if I was going to ask people-family or friends-for information I would speak to them personally either f2f or on the phone, as a matter of courtesy. It would also enable anyone being requested to provide their personal info to ask questions about the reason etc. Maybe thats just me-but I think a request of that nature demands more than a group WhatsApp message🤷🏼‍♀️.

See, I would message on the family whatsapp, and those that wanted to reply 1:1 would do so, those who wanted to phone me with the info would do, and those you didn't mind sharing it with their family would do so. But, it seems, I married into a lovely, caring family that don't wear tin foil hats.

justteanbiscuits · 09/11/2023 13:48

HamBone · 09/11/2023 13:44

No, the friends and family of the person being vetted don't have a right to ask what the job is as they literally can't be told. Anyone who answers "yes, I am a spy" when being asked isn't a spy.

@justteanbiscuits 🤣🤣

Yes, an actual spy is hardly going to say that they’re the real life equivalent of James Bond!

My understanding is that people with top security clearance can never tell their families anything about their work, even if it was 30 years ago. Not even their spouses.

IRL, I believe I may have met an actual spy, but I’m never going to know. All I’ll say is that they were the polar opposite of sexy film portrayals, which is probably far more effective at blending in. 😜

"IRL, I believe I may have met an actual spy, but I’m never going to know. All I’ll say is that they were the polar opposite of sexy film portrayals, which is probably far more effective at blending in. "

That made me LOL so hard!! 😆

Thistlewoman · 09/11/2023 13:46

Like I said, you do you. However-if I was going to ask people-family or friends-for information I would speak to them personally either f2f or on the phone, as a matter of courtesy. It would also enable anyone being requested to provide their personal info to ask questions about the reason etc. Maybe thats just me-but I think a request of that nature demands more than a group WhatsApp message🤷🏼‍♀️.

HamBone · 09/11/2023 13:44

No, the friends and family of the person being vetted don't have a right to ask what the job is as they literally can't be told. Anyone who answers "yes, I am a spy" when being asked isn't a spy.

@justteanbiscuits 🤣🤣

Yes, an actual spy is hardly going to say that they’re the real life equivalent of James Bond!

My understanding is that people with top security clearance can never tell their families anything about their work, even if it was 30 years ago. Not even their spouses.

IRL, I believe I may have met an actual spy, but I’m never going to know. All I’ll say is that they were the polar opposite of sexy film portrayals, which is probably far more effective at blending in. 😜

rwalker · 09/11/2023 13:22

Thistlewoman · 09/11/2023 13:07

Asking for it in a shared whatsapp group doesn't indicate to me that he has a high level of understanding about how to request/handle/store personal data! If that seems ok to you-thats fine-you do you. But it isn't ok to me.

It makes perfect sense to ask everyone at once in what’s app
reply in any format your happy with just because your asked in WhatsApp doesn’t mean you have to reply on it

enough people on here have judged him and written him off as creepy for asking in the first place
fuck me a private message or call off him asking you’d here the screams from space

I’d reply on what’s app as this information is in the public domain any to anyone will the skills and patience to look for it

Notenoughtime23 · 09/11/2023 13:16

Yeah I’d been really concerned if my in laws and family found out my name, date of birth and address in a what’s app group! Can you imagine the implications 😂

Thistlewoman · 09/11/2023 13:07

Asking for it in a shared whatsapp group doesn't indicate to me that he has a high level of understanding about how to request/handle/store personal data! If that seems ok to you-thats fine-you do you. But it isn't ok to me.

justteanbiscuits · 09/11/2023 12:57

Thistlewoman · 09/11/2023 12:54

I wouldn't give my data to ANYONE who cant/wont/doesn't understand how to keep it secure. Period. And I wouldn't advise anyone else to either.

Where does she say her FIL doesn't know/won't/can't keep her information secure??

Thistlewoman · 09/11/2023 12:54

I wouldn't give my data to ANYONE who cant/wont/doesn't understand how to keep it secure. Period. And I wouldn't advise anyone else to either.

Dottydoll · 09/11/2023 12:26

He needs it for a security clearance check. I had to do it often in my previous job. What do you think will happen to you if you give this basic info? 🙄

justteanbiscuits · 09/11/2023 12:19

This is such an MN thread. People who have experience of having had Enhanced DV explaining this is normal, just respond in a direct whatsapp message. That "the company" don't request these details, the employee being vetted literally puts them on a form. Yes, they can get all of this information, but why make it hard for them? You can say "not sure" about specific addresses, like when at Uni and you simply don't remember it - just say why.

So, to reiterate. Yes, this is normal for DV and Enhanced DV. Yes the person being vetted is asked to supply this information. No, the vetting company don't reach out and ask for it. Yes, it is renewed at regular intervals, and while not changing a job a new project or similar can often require it where SC was only required beforehand. No, the friends and family of the person being vetted don't have a right to ask what the job is as they literally can't be told. Anyone who answers "yes, I am a spy" when being asked isn't a spy. You will think they have some quite dull job. You're not so special to that person that they will tell you.

justteanbiscuits · 09/11/2023 12:18

Thistlewoman · 09/11/2023 12:14

But how will HE store the info when he gets it-after he's passed it on to 'the Govt'? If its sent to him electronically he also has a responsibility to handle that data in accordance with gdpr. And simply deleting it from WhatsApp or email is no guarantee of it being securely disposed of. I wouldn't trust my personal details to ANYONE who asks for it via WhatsApp!! And I wouldn't care if 'the govt' wants this info from him for his security vetting. If they wanted information about me for whatever reason they can flipping well request it themselves. Judging by the levels of unquestioning compliance demonstrated by so many responses on here, its no wonder scammers get away with it so often. Treat your personal data as a private & confidential-never hand it over to a third party-even if it's your FIL-without a full understanding of why its needed, and how the info will be used, stored, and for how long in accordance with gdpr.

He will complete a form with the information. He doesn't have an obligation to the sender under GDPR as he isn't a data handler. They asked a relative for their information in order to complete a form.

He can however request a copy of the vetting companies privacy / GDPR policy for the OP.

justteanbiscuits · 09/11/2023 12:15

bemusedmoose · 09/11/2023 10:08

He can take a long skip off a short pier!

Ive worked for the government and have enhanced security and never needed any of that!! He is up to something.

Unless he is secretly undercover for MI5 and even then i think they do the searching as no one suspicious is going to hand over details!

You've had enhanced DV and the form didn't ask for any of those details?

Suuuuure you've had EDV.

Thistlewoman · 09/11/2023 12:14

But how will HE store the info when he gets it-after he's passed it on to 'the Govt'? If its sent to him electronically he also has a responsibility to handle that data in accordance with gdpr. And simply deleting it from WhatsApp or email is no guarantee of it being securely disposed of. I wouldn't trust my personal details to ANYONE who asks for it via WhatsApp!! And I wouldn't care if 'the govt' wants this info from him for his security vetting. If they wanted information about me for whatever reason they can flipping well request it themselves. Judging by the levels of unquestioning compliance demonstrated by so many responses on here, its no wonder scammers get away with it so often. Treat your personal data as a private & confidential-never hand it over to a third party-even if it's your FIL-without a full understanding of why its needed, and how the info will be used, stored, and for how long in accordance with gdpr.

CrabbiesGingerBeer · 09/11/2023 11:45

SharonEllis · 09/11/2023 09:44

This was what I was going to say. You don't do your own vetting. I think its very weird that he is collecting the data. Anyone collecting the data should send you their gdpr and privacy policies and tell you exactly what they will do with the data, and how long they are holding it for.

But that’s how it works? He puts the information in a form, the vetting agency (not the company) uses it for whatever checks they need to make.

Grammarnut · 09/11/2023 11:39

I doubt the MoD etc send out their privacy policies to random people. Also, obviously in-laws are needed as well as blood relatives for security. Why is everyone so niave?

VanGoghsDog · 09/11/2023 10:55

The clearances are currently taking up to two years to come through as well (unless expedited for particular roles) so be prepared for the information to need to be collected again in that time!

Zeborah · 09/11/2023 10:48

This is perfectly normal for high level security clearance. It would not be shared beyond his government department & would be stored securely.

helloimchangingmynamegain · 09/11/2023 10:16

bemusedmoose · 09/11/2023 10:08

He can take a long skip off a short pier!

Ive worked for the government and have enhanced security and never needed any of that!! He is up to something.

Unless he is secretly undercover for MI5 and even then i think they do the searching as no one suspicious is going to hand over details!

Literally tens of people in this thread have explained that this is needed for DV / eDV vetting, with explanatory links. I am DV vetted and went through this exact process.

Pinkie89 · 09/11/2023 10:13

I’ve been through an enhanced security check and they do ask for the information he’s asked for. I think you’re being unreasonable unless there’s a specific reason/previous experience which explains why you’re reluctant

bemusedmoose · 09/11/2023 10:08

He can take a long skip off a short pier!

Ive worked for the government and have enhanced security and never needed any of that!! He is up to something.

Unless he is secretly undercover for MI5 and even then i think they do the searching as no one suspicious is going to hand over details!

penjil · 09/11/2023 10:05

SunCreamQueenie · 07/11/2023 12:34

Tell him to f off. Immediately!

🙄

penjil · 09/11/2023 09:57

LittleMouse10 · 07/11/2023 06:07

Sounds really weird. I moved to the US from the UK and they didn't need all that info for a visa. Like parents only and not even my step father.
I personally would not be handing over all that info to anyone, really suspicious and I would need to see the reason why it was needed especially as you are not an immediate blood relative.

A visa?!

Well, no, they wouldn't need that information for a visa!

But to work with British state secrets and top secret government information, you do need to be highly vetted and background searched.