Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

FiL wants all our data

758 replies

HighlandCowSaysBooNotMoo · 06/11/2023 23:54

My father in law works in a government role.
Today he put a message in the family WhatsApp group asking if we could send him our addresses, d.o.bs, mothers maiden names, our place of birth, our address history, previous maiden names etc.
Apparently he needs this info from his 4 adult children, their spouses (me included) , his own siblings and his siblings spouses, grandchildren, his in laws etc. Basically he is covering every member of the family and spouses etc over the age of 18.
He has put something light hearted about it being needed for an enhanced security check that he's been told he needs for his job.
He is not changing jobs or position in the company. He has been in this job for since my husband was a wee kid!!
A couple of people have responded straight away with their data.
DH says IABU not to share mine with his dad
What do I do?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
Keeper11 · 10/11/2023 08:36

This is standard procedure for certain positions even if they don’t appear high security to you. No the employer initially wont do they donkey work, why should they? The employee has to disclose details of certain family members. And it is unlikely that the employee can get hold of the data internally himself. Unless you have serious issues with your father in law, you would be very rude/unkind/inconsiderate to refuse. What do you have to loose? Unless, as I say, you don’t trust your father in law.

Islandgirl68 · 10/11/2023 08:30

Well in this day and age that is not acceptable, it's not hard to have a secure electronic system to request and store valuable information like all your personal details. So to say but that is the way it is is really not good enough.

Stroopwaffels · 10/11/2023 08:29

As millions of other posters have said, this is super common for developed vetting roles. Yes things like MOD and higher level civil service jobs, also things like working in a nuclear power plant or air traffic control.

It will blow some people's minds but - any genealogist, even with fairly basic knowledge, can find out your mother's maiden name free of charge in about 30 seconds.

I had a temp job the summer I left school at Edinburgh Castle. I had to complete a form with all of my details, all of my parents details, my sister's details. Because it was an Army base at the time, the IRA were still active, and they wanted to check out the background of everyone with access.

FrangipaniBlue · 10/11/2023 06:14

EDV just involves additional checks on the applicant.

It's literally all listed on the .gov website.

(I also deal with this for a living but hey, what do I know)

FrangipaniBlue · 10/11/2023 06:12

You fill in the same form for DV and EDV.

notlucreziaborgia · 10/11/2023 00:30

FrangipaniBlue · 10/11/2023 00:01

People who have experience of having had Enhanced DV explaining this is normal

99% of the oysters on this thread are talking shite.

DV does not require details of your adult children, their partners/spouses nor their grandchildren. See attached from the actual guidance.

I have no idea why the OPs FIL has asked for her details but it certainly isn't required for DV.

There’s DV and then there’s also enhanced DV. They can also come back and request further information in addition to what they ask on the forms.

FrangipaniBlue · 10/11/2023 00:01

People who have experience of having had Enhanced DV explaining this is normal

99% of the oysters on this thread are talking shite.

DV does not require details of your adult children, their partners/spouses nor their grandchildren. See attached from the actual guidance.

I have no idea why the OPs FIL has asked for her details but it certainly isn't required for DV.

FiL wants all our data
saraclara · 09/11/2023 23:40

Islandgirl68 · 09/11/2023 22:21

Well if they want my data, they need to ask for it in a more professional way, and not through what's app. If a government department are updating someones security clearance. That department needs to email me from an official email, and attach an official from. No way am I giving all these details on what's app. Its 2023 for goodness sake.

I'm at the point where I need to hit my head on my desk.

This. Is. Not. How. It. Works. And many many many people have already said that on this thread. It's down to the person being vetted to gather all the information and put it into the form. Partly because they then take responsibility for it and declare at the end that they're being honest and that it's accurate. So if anything turns out not to be, it's on them, and they have to face the music.
There is no facility for them to ask the department to send some kind of proof that it's needed.

The FIL has asked people to provide the information he needs to put on his form, to make sure it's accurate. He's asked them all via the whatsapp group, but there's no indication that he wants them to send the info that way.

CrabbiesGingerBeer · 09/11/2023 22:35

Islandgirl68 · 09/11/2023 22:21

Well if they want my data, they need to ask for it in a more professional way, and not through what's app. If a government department are updating someones security clearance. That department needs to email me from an official email, and attach an official from. No way am I giving all these details on what's app. Its 2023 for goodness sake.

That’s not how it works. Maybe it shouldn’t work the way it does but at present, there is no facility to ‘attach an official form from an official email’. Bearing that in mind, are you saying you are willing to risk a family member’s job so as not to give him information that multiple government departments already have?

Islandgirl68 · 09/11/2023 22:21

Well if they want my data, they need to ask for it in a more professional way, and not through what's app. If a government department are updating someones security clearance. That department needs to email me from an official email, and attach an official from. No way am I giving all these details on what's app. Its 2023 for goodness sake.

VanGoghsDog · 09/11/2023 22:02

Thistlewoman · 09/11/2023 13:07

Asking for it in a shared whatsapp group doesn't indicate to me that he has a high level of understanding about how to request/handle/store personal data! If that seems ok to you-thats fine-you do you. But it isn't ok to me.

It's not about "handling or storing personal data", he's just a family member. Like all of us, he'll have addresses and birthdays written in random places - address books, notes, emails, calendar entries. I keep a note of birth dates on the fridge - can I be sued for GDPR breach? No. Because I'M NOT A DATA CONTROLLER.

This is just a member of the family ensuring he has the right information to fill in his security check form.

Yes, the people he passes it to are data controllers, have to comply with the law and have a privacy notice. But the father in law does not have to do that.

MarsandVenus · 09/11/2023 22:00

My DH used to work on a UK military base. He had to be vetted for security clearance in this way & so did his colleagues. He was interviewed about one of his colleagues by a member of the security team. They asked my DH ‘Is (colleague) gay?’ My husband trying to be funny quipped ‘No, but all his friends are’. Fortunately he got across that he was just being facetious. Btw this was about 30 years ago, when being gay in a high security role (particularly if not publicly ‘out’) was considered a potential security / blackmail risk.

Moonflower12 · 09/11/2023 21:05

@CaveMum
Having worked on an RAF base, that video is very true!

Moonflower12 · 09/11/2023 20:57

My late steo father always joked he was a cleaner at GCHQ. It was only when he died suddenly we found out that he was much more than that.
I suppose it was unlikely that the cleaner spoke 7 languages including Mandarin, Afrikaans and Arabic!

When my mum married him, we were all positively vetted including my grandmother in deepest darkest wales.

When a friend, who I regard as a brother, worked for the 'weasels' as he refers to them, I had to answer all sorts of intrusive questions as a referee-type of thing, including questions all about his sex life!

listsandbudgets · 09/11/2023 18:30

I believe I know a spy but obviously I'm not going to ask her (anyway I like the intrigue)

I have just always found it hard to believe that a woman with a double first from Cambridge in French and Arabic has gone to work in the civil service shuffling some kind of paperwork for the health department. Anyway she'd make a great spy - everyone wants to talk to her and she's really really good at making you feel listened to in at least 3 languages

CaveMum · 09/11/2023 18:04

People with genuine involvement in sneaky-beaky stuff NEVER talk about it. My uncle was in SAS (left just before the Falklands War), if you ever try and ask him about it he just changes the subject. He's 78 years old now, wouldn't say boo to a goose. My dad says he remembers times when his brother disappeared for months on end without saying anything about where he was off to, and barring an occasional "I'm alright mum" postcard sent home, they had no idea when he'd be back or what he'd been up to.

Now pilots on the other hand, let's just say there's a RAF saying - "How do you know if a man is a fighter pilot? Don't worry, he'll tell you!"

Jet Pilot music video

http://phobos.apple.com/WebObjects/MZStore.woa/wa/viewAlbum?id=279044190&s=143461A classic bit of aviation comedy by some crazy kiwi.

https://youtu.be/1BzU1sYPjzo?si=-mKIG2VrobLVj4pf

crispcreambun · 09/11/2023 17:45

It's quite clear that, given the advances in technology and the methods that scammers employ, they need a new system. I don't voluntarily hand out that information and I'd imagine a lot of people who are privacy/security minded wouldn't.

It's unreasonable for the gov to tell the public on the one hand to be extra cautious with their data while on the other telling them they must hand over data for someone else to progress in their career. It's the exact thing that could be easily exploited by a scammer. Combined with a little social engineering and your bank account is wiped or your identity stolen.

Government needs to keep up with the times and adopt a new method of obtaining this information if it's so necessary.

camperjam · 09/11/2023 17:02

If he needs DV clearance then yes he will need all that information. Completely normal for those roles.

MarsandVenus · 09/11/2023 16:55

Strewth. There are some seriously paranoid/ naive/ ignorant/ misinformed people on this thread! I am shocked.

What the OP’s FIL has asked for is v v normal part of gov security checks. He just could have been clearer & more sensitive in the way he asked for the information.

herewegoagain7 · 09/11/2023 16:02

@bemusedmoose you are talking such complete and utter rubbish

Akiddleydiveytoo · 09/11/2023 14:41

I work for the civil service and I had to go through a similar process a few years ago when they suddenly decided that I needed to have enhanced security clearance for a job I'd been doing for the last 15 years.

It's genuinely nothing sinister, it's just to determine he's not associated with any 'dodgy' characters that could be using him for nefarious purposes.

I also wouldn't read too much into the timing of it. Government policy is changing all the time and various jobs drop in and out of needing enhanced security checks all the time. As I said, I'd been doing the job for 15 years before they decided my role needed one.

Out of interest, what nefarious purpose do you think these details of yours (which the Government already hold in various guises) will be used for?

Thistlewoman · 09/11/2023 14:17

Ok. Bored with this now. Bye, and have a nice afternoon.

justteanbiscuits · 09/11/2023 14:14

Thistlewoman · 09/11/2023 13:59

But you do sound rather defensive about this subject! Why try to insult my family by calling them tin foil hatters (they're not)? You sound quite an angry person based on your replies, and not able to accept that some of us do things differently from you & yours. My family are caring and helpful too-but I like to treat them with respect. And I dont need to insult your family in order to do so. I think we have said all we need to on this. Please just accept that I do things differently from you and that you & yours aren't better/warmer/more helpful than me & mine.

I'm pleased you have time to ring all the family members you would need to speak to.

Not angry just very eye rolling at half of this thread!! From very incorrect information, to a lot of very misleading information to people quite happy to slow down the OP's FIL's start on probably a new project.

Luckily, there are plenty of people giving out correct information who actually know the answer and have experience of it. But so many just making it up and declaring there is NO WAY they would give a beloved father in law fairly basic information. I find it pretty sad.

Oh. And also bored sat in a teams meeting no one else has turned up to so killing time.

saraclara · 09/11/2023 14:05

The voting at the top of this thread is really depressing. It doesn't say much for the intelligence* and general awareness of the average mumsnetter.

*no pun intended

Thistlewoman · 09/11/2023 13:59

But you do sound rather defensive about this subject! Why try to insult my family by calling them tin foil hatters (they're not)? You sound quite an angry person based on your replies, and not able to accept that some of us do things differently from you & yours. My family are caring and helpful too-but I like to treat them with respect. And I dont need to insult your family in order to do so. I think we have said all we need to on this. Please just accept that I do things differently from you and that you & yours aren't better/warmer/more helpful than me & mine.