Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think Coram Boy is not a suitable book for year 7s

280 replies

vegetaria · 06/11/2023 21:50

My 11 year old had night mares last night and is afraid to go to sleep tonight.

For anyone who doesn't know it is about a man who buys unwanted children in the UK in the 1700s, and sells them into slavery if they are above 5, or kills them by burying them alive if they are younger, and it describes several scenes of babies being buried alive and other harrowing events

Its the class book at the moment

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
EnidSpyton · 10/11/2023 22:45

CecilyP · 10/11/2023 18:36

We can’t avoid children having to deal with feelings and emotions when they read. It’s about knowing your class and working with them to help them contextualise and manage their emotional response to fictional events in a healthy and productive way.

Would an English teacher really know her class this early on in Y7?

I don't see why not.

English is a core subject and in many schools this means you see them once per day.

They've been in school for over two months now. That's plenty of time to get to know a class.

I know my Year 7s well already. We've had parents' evening, so I've met all of their parents and discussed their likes/dislikes about English with them and their family. We've done plenty of getting to know you activities. I've taught them about 30-odd lessons so that's been plenty of time to observe their behaviour, listen to their contributions to class discussion, chat to them individually about their work, and so on. I've heard lots of things about them from colleagues in other subjects that have helped to build a broader picture of their personalities and interests. I've also spent a week on a residential trip with the year group, so that was pretty good as a get to know you activity 😂And obviously anything that might be an issue in terms of personal life situations that may impact their response to something being learned at school are all recorded on our safeguarding systems.

Teachers are well practised at observing and getting the measure of children quickly, and colleagues are constantly discussing and sharing information about students to help build a bigger picture. By the first half term, we do know our kids pretty well. You can't teach effectively until you do, so the process has to happen quickly.

CecilyP · 10/11/2023 18:36

We can’t avoid children having to deal with feelings and emotions when they read. It’s about knowing your class and working with them to help them contextualise and manage their emotional response to fictional events in a healthy and productive way.

Would an English teacher really know her class this early on in Y7?

electriclight · 10/11/2023 16:42

I'm a teacher who had an 11 year old pupil unable to sleep after watching Lion King, according to their parents. There will always be wimpy kids and overbearing parents (assuming no trauma or SEN). I think reasonable adjustments and support are fair expectations but changing the curriculum for everyone, because one child can't cope or process a negative emotion, is not reasonable.

DifferentView · 10/11/2023 12:20

@EnidSpyton Most of what you say can be proven with the exception of your last sentence. Not only cannot you not prove that but having a dig at the parent who asked the initial question is unnecessary to support your response. For all those who have done this, you made yourselves look unprofessional. It is important to understand that many parents work in sectors outside of education so don't assume all parents know how decisions on book choices are made. Good communication is key to ensuring parents understand what's happening in relation to their child's education at school.

EnidSpyton · 10/11/2023 08:37

@DrBlackbird
A book being selected for GCSE has no relation to its age appropriateness.

A Christmas Carol is regularly taught in Year 7 - in fact, according to recent research by End Sexism in Schools, it’s one of the most popular texts taught at that age group. The same with Of Mice and Men.

At the same time, A Christmas Carol is the most popular set text at GCSE. Of Mice and Men used to be before Gove took all non British literature off the list.

GCSE Literature is being increasingly dumbed down with its text choices to reflect the fact that in many schools now it’s compulsory and there are a large proportion of young people for whom English Literature is a huge struggle. Being able to teach a text designed for much younger readers - i.e. Coram Boy - gives those students who struggle a better chance of being able to pass, because the content and language are not as challenging.

Coram Boy is generally appropriate for children aged 11+ but as with all forms of media, it is not for everyone at that age. It does have some distressing content, but handled sensitively and alongside a teaching of the historical context to ensure children understand this is not something that could happen now, it can be taught well and enjoyably to a Year 7 class.

Literature as a medium allows us to explore a whole range of experiences outside of our own. In a class there will always be children for whom some of those experiences discussed in a text will hit home more than others or trigger upsetting memories or so on. We can’t avoid children having to deal with feelings and emotions when they read. It’s about knowing your class and working with them to help them contextualise and manage their emotional response to fictional events in a healthy and productive way. If we never expose children to things they find upsetting or hard to cope with, they will never build resilience.

That being said, if the OP is genuine, I would imagine her rather highly strung approach to life has rubbed off on her daughter, which will have contributed to her response to Coram Boy.

Pooooochi · 09/11/2023 22:50

Its a well written, fictional book which deals sensitively with historical themes.

Descriptions are not gory.

A 12 year old isn't a little child. They should have the emotional intelligence to start exploring more serious themes.

Yabvu.

Shelby2010 · 09/11/2023 22:40

sunglassesonthetable · 08/11/2023 18:21

*Not quite what I mean 🤔

At a publishing house, presumably there must be some set objective criteria by which you evaluate whether the subject matter is appropriate for which age?

Something like the BBFC classification guidelines. The Guardian review is by Livloves2read, not sure what makes her qualified to suggest a reading age of 9+ without further information.

Surely the decision to classify a reading age is not based only on a matter of opinion of those who get to sit around the table 😉*

@DrBlackbird

Presumably and Surely doing a lot of heavy lifting here.

We're going right back to questioning the knowledge and experience of a publishing house to set age ranges now.

What sort of scientific criteria are you looking for? What studies would you consider appropriate?

These are the criteria for how films are classified, I think the question is ‘are there similar, published, guidelines for books?’.

I think it’s a valid point that publishers will have an incentive to give books a wider age rating because they’ll make more profit.

to think Coram Boy is not a suitable book for year 7s
TheOnlyLivingBoyInNewCross · 09/11/2023 06:47

Butteredtoast55 · 08/11/2023 23:28

This may have been mentioned earlier in the thread but I'd wholeheartedly recommend The Coram Museum in Bloomsbury to get the true picture of the Coram children. It's fascinating, sad and uplifting at the same time.

Sadly, I don’t think the OP had any interest in actually finding anything out or helping her DC do so. She just wanted to froth about how disgusting it is.

Butteredtoast55 · 08/11/2023 23:28

This may have been mentioned earlier in the thread but I'd wholeheartedly recommend The Coram Museum in Bloomsbury to get the true picture of the Coram children. It's fascinating, sad and uplifting at the same time.

gingersnappz · 08/11/2023 22:54

@Justonemorecoffeeplease agree about Junk - upsetting but brilliant.

sunglassesonthetable · 08/11/2023 22:31

What I genuinely don’t understand is why you take such offence at anonymous posters raising concerns about it being age appropriate for 11 yr olds.

Bit disingenuous. Theres 'raising concerns' and there's attributing a mental health crisis to 'books like this' and generally slagging off teachers.

Justonemorecoffeeplease · 08/11/2023 21:59

Not ‘retribution’ at all @DrBlackbird honestly I’m not the villainous type. It’s just reminded me thinking about it today what a lovely text it is and I’ve done some exploring regarding schemes of work and we are genuinely looking to freshen up our texts. I certainly don’t have the time or inclination to write a whole teaching plan just to get back at Mums netters.

I shall now withdraw and leave it up to those who’ve read the book to judge for themselves.

Hotandsunny · 08/11/2023 20:28

Hereinthismoment · 07/11/2023 07:10

We recently did one with Year 9 which contained a graphic description of sexual assault. I was quite Confused reading it but luckily my group found it funny rather than disturbing.

There are loads of upsetting ones and while we would be hard pushed to find literature with no upsetting parts at all I do think schools should be mindful of their ‘audience’ so to speak. I have to admit I was disturbed as hell by the BBCs Gunpowder a few years ago; it actually looked fascinating but the torture scenes were so horrendous I just couldn’t get through it.

Would that not be a worry DC finding sexual assault funny?

Hotandsunny · 08/11/2023 20:11

steff13 · 06/11/2023 22:19

Missing the point, but why would you pay for a child only to bury it alive?

That was my first question?!

Thisismynewusernamedoyoulikeit · 08/11/2023 20:10

vegetaria · 07/11/2023 10:16

look at yourselves!

you think it is ok to force 11 year olds to read descriptions of babies being tortured and murdered.

Clearly this is VERY not OK, and clearly you need to be very seriously questioning yourself if you think that it is.

You've posted on a forum that asks "am I being unreasonable?"

Then you've disparaged the 53% of people (currently) who said "yes, you are being unreasonable."

So I assume you chose the forum by accident, as you weren't interested in discussing whether you were unreasonable.

DrBlackbird · 08/11/2023 20:08

sunglassesonthetable · 08/11/2023 18:21

*Not quite what I mean 🤔

At a publishing house, presumably there must be some set objective criteria by which you evaluate whether the subject matter is appropriate for which age?

Something like the BBFC classification guidelines. The Guardian review is by Livloves2read, not sure what makes her qualified to suggest a reading age of 9+ without further information.

Surely the decision to classify a reading age is not based only on a matter of opinion of those who get to sit around the table 😉*

@DrBlackbird

Presumably and Surely doing a lot of heavy lifting here.

We're going right back to questioning the knowledge and experience of a publishing house to set age ranges now.

What sort of scientific criteria are you looking for? What studies would you consider appropriate?

Missed your next post. But to be clear, I’m not flustered by the book and am not disputing its award winning nature. What I genuinely don’t understand is why you take such offence at anonymous posters raising concerns about it being age appropriate for 11 yr olds. I also find your passive aggressive comment that you’re now considering introducing the book for your KS3 as retribution for a MN discussion thread deeply disturbing.

Justonemorecoffeeplease · 08/11/2023 18:30

Well, bear in mind this was over twenty years ago so things may well have changed. Experienced professional commissioning editors with knowledge of children’s development and maturity would discuss and explore the text and we’d reach a decision. Unlike the BBFC there wasn’t a prescriptive list of for example how many swear words you could get away with. That I would suggest falls very much into Mary Whitehouse territory if you can remember her.

Anyway if you want a more shocking novel to really get flustered over I direct you to Junk by Melvin Burgess which is also read by young readers but probably Y9 up.

To be honest, if you’re not going to be persuaded by the fact it won the Whitbread Children’s Book award as a testament of its merit, I’m not sure I can offer anything further - other than my judgement that it’s a wonderful book which deserves its accolades and I’m now going to consider if I should teach it at KS3 as we are looking for a change.

Reflecting on this today has made me realise how much more we label things today and attach some moral value to literature, art etc. We seem so much more prescriptive over what should be ‘allowed’ in school. Not sure I welcome that.

sunglassesonthetable · 08/11/2023 18:21

*Not quite what I mean 🤔

At a publishing house, presumably there must be some set objective criteria by which you evaluate whether the subject matter is appropriate for which age?

Something like the BBFC classification guidelines. The Guardian review is by Livloves2read, not sure what makes her qualified to suggest a reading age of 9+ without further information.

Surely the decision to classify a reading age is not based only on a matter of opinion of those who get to sit around the table 😉*

@DrBlackbird

Presumably and Surely doing a lot of heavy lifting here.

We're going right back to questioning the knowledge and experience of a publishing house to set age ranges now.

What sort of scientific criteria are you looking for? What studies would you consider appropriate?

DrBlackbird · 08/11/2023 18:05

Justonemorecoffeeplease · 08/11/2023 17:10

The contents of the book funnily enough! 🤣The vocabulary and subject matter.

Not quite what I mean 🤔

At a publishing house, presumably there must be some set objective criteria by which you evaluate whether the subject matter is appropriate for which age?

Something like the BBFC classification guidelines. The Guardian review is by Livloves2read, not sure what makes her qualified to suggest a reading age of 9+ without further information.

Surely the decision to classify a reading age is not based only on a matter of opinion of those who get to sit around the table 😉

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 08/11/2023 17:54

in situations where children do not have a choice, parents are usually asked for consent

I don't think this applies in a school situation. The parents can't possibly be asked to consent to each and every little aspect of the school day. Their consent is implicit in that they send their child to the school to be educated, and in doing this, they delegate a lot of the day-to-day decision-making to the school staff, who use their professional judgement to determine what's appropriate and what's not.

Of course, the parents have the right to complain if they think that the school is not exercising its duties diligently enough. If complaints are received, then they will be investigated and it is for the school to determine whether or not they are upheld. If a complaint is upheld, then hopefully the matter will be addressed to the parent's satisfaction. If it isn't, then the parent has the right to accept the school's decision, move the child to another school or home educate.

And of course, if a child has mental health problems or additional needs etc, then the parent has every right to request reasonable adjustments and the school has a legal duty to put reasonable adjustments in place. That still doesn't mean that the parents have to consent to anything and everything. If they don't consent to the school's approach, then they have the right to remove the kids and educate them elsewhere.

I'm not saying that schools shouldn't be mindful of the needs of kids with fragile mental health or that they shouldn't make efforts to prevent those kids from getting upset. Of course they should. However, I don't think parental consent is particularly relevant in cases like this. Parents are free to withdraw their consent at any time by removing their kids from the school, but they don't get to keep their kids at the school while dictating every tiny detail.

Justonemorecoffeeplease · 08/11/2023 17:10

The contents of the book funnily enough! 🤣The vocabulary and subject matter.

DifferentView · 08/11/2023 17:10

A parent started by asking if it is unreasonable to think Coram Boy is unsuitable for year 7s. I'm grateful to this parent for raising this debate as I have a primary school child who loves reading but this has made me think of what I could do if my child read a book that left them shocked, upset and resulted in nightmares. Regardless of whether people think the answer to this question is yes or no, it is not unreasonable to raise this question as (in this situation) the child did not have a choice over whether to read the book (ok there's a lot of things we don't have choices over) but in situations where children do not have a choice, parents are usually asked for consent. I am not suggesting that schools should ask consent for focusing on certain books but it is important to address parents' concerns with the focus on the child (not the parent) if the parent thinks that a school activity (in which the child has little choice but to participate) left or will leave their child feeling distressed. It's easy to say the majority don't have a problem with the activity but every child is different and here lies the problem with saying that all children of a certain age will be ok with something or can consent to something. There's evidence to show that all children of a certain age don't necessarily understand or interpret things in the same way. Sadly, certain legislation around consent does not reflect this.

DrBlackbird · 08/11/2023 16:50

I was literally in the meetings when we discussed who should read this book when it was published

Really interesting to hear from you then. Do you recall what the criteria or evidence was used to base the reading age decision?

Justonemorecoffeeplease · 08/11/2023 16:01

Have you read it?

It might be on the GCSE for Edexcel but it’s listed on Scholastic for 12+. Christmas Carol, Romeo and Juliet, Sherlock Holmes are also on the GCSE syllabus but are still taught in younger years by many, many schools.

As I’ve said previously it’s intended as a 12+ book and is suitable for use in a Year 7 class whether you or the OP think so or not. Opinion does not outweigh educational merit. I was literally in the meetings when we discussed who should read this book when it was published. The Guardian review suggested readers over 9 years old…

I really hope that the HOD in this case can just get on with actually teaching.

DrBlackbird · 08/11/2023 15:21

Justonemorecoffeeplease · 08/11/2023 11:27

Not emotional at all just responding to your statement that those challenging the OP were using hyperbole. However, I am inwardly sighing at how teachers who are acting in good faith teaching English with a well respected novel are being critiqued. I’m not being defensive just expressing my thoughts - and bringing my experience to the discussion.

It is a fact that teacher numbers are falling off a cliff and this type of complaint just adds to the daily stress. I am honestly concerned about who on earth will be left in the profession soon. A bit emotional there perhaps but that’s because I believe education is a vital cornerstone to any society. That education may well entail challenging concepts but if we can’t teach children to respond to challenge then we really are doomed.

As for your comment about my our lack of ‘comprehension’…🙄I would say that OP was very much using ‘inexperienced’ as a criticism.

Yes, I appreciate your perspective as well @Justonemorecoffeeplease in terms of teachers being criticised and seemingly not being able to do right for doing wrong. As a fellow educator, I completely support the view that education is a vital cornerstone. That does warrant some strong feelings. And also, I certainly wasn’t singling you out for a lack of comprehension. That was, for example, in relation to one PP getting 11 as an age and Year 11 mixed up.

My wider point is that there are also a lot of teachers (at every level) with a limited grasp of pedagogical knowledge and/or forced to employ fads eg ‘learning styles’ that can result in poor teaching. You sound like a thoughtful and informed teacher, but I’m sure you’ve experienced others who are less so.

Re the OP’s point, Coram Boy is a set text for Pearson Edexcel’s GSCE curriculum, not year 7. I am all for exposing children to challenging concepts, but also agree with the OP that this book is not an age appropriate for 11 year olds. It seems that on this matter, we have to agree to disagree.