Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Being frustrated with my students

36 replies

loosenmymynd · 06/11/2023 21:14

I'm a BAME lecturer in one of these universities where education has been commodified and students from developing countries are their target market - think South Asia.
I have passion for impactful teaching, but I've been doing some soul-searching and I do not like who I'm becoming around my students.
Teaching is hard, frustrating and almost impossible due to limitations on the part of my students. And I am now seeing myself resenting the very people who you would have called 'my people'.
Some of examples:

  1. Students have in some way (which I can't wrap my head around) have gained admission based on having first class/ second class upper degrees from their home countries and have passed the English Language test, yet they can't communicate - cannot understand simple conversations, can't communicate, can't read or write.
  2. Students don't show up to class as expected. If they did, they are not 'present' - have no pen or notepad/ laptop (well most can't write anyway) and cannot engage in simple subject discussions. A postgraduate lecture often derails from the subject matter to explaining basic English.
Say for example, the topic for the day is Ethical dilemmas in legal cases, we'd end up spending the time just explaining what a dilemma is.
  1. Some don't even know how to log onto a computer.
Yesterday, I was teaching a masters student how to do Ctrl+alt+del.
  1. They turn up late to lectures and meetings (think 1-1.5hrs late) and feel offended if they're told off for this. No willingness to unlearn and learn new ways.
  2. Don't show up to meetings and don't communicate. Don't respond to emails.
If at all, they suggest an alternative time that they would be happy to meet as though all has to be at their convenience. Isn't the primary reason for being in the UK to study?
  1. Do not do assignments or meet deadlines.
  2. Display misogynistic behaviours, for example, some males feel frustrated when been told off by a female lecturer and I can see their rage in the way they shrug their arms in the air or stomp their foot when sat down as though they're about to fly off the handle.
  3. Just always making excuses. Never making effort to pull their weight. File complaint when they don't pass or blame you for not teaching them when they fail.
  4. Expect you to give them a 50% pass mark to get them over even if they've done nothing to deserve it.
10. Can't send a proper email yet they complain that they're not exposed to the industry or doing experiential learning. I'm not confident to take them anywhere is the honest truth.

These examples are 0.1% of what I'm dealing with. But I have come to a place where I'm now resenting most of my students and other than my contractual obligation, I have zero respect for them in the professional sense.
I don't know why. I've lost empathy for them.

YABU Be mad at the systems which have failed these people and our system which is taking advantage of them.
YANBU They are really not making an effort to meet the standards expected of a UK graduate programme.

If anyone has any good advice on how to cope with this (excluding speaking to senior management- they don't care; they just want these people's money), please share.

OP posts:
ColleenDonaghy · 06/11/2023 22:25

loosenmymynd · 06/11/2023 22:21

I'm baffled by how some of my students gained admission. Lots just don't add up.
I feel that our system sometimes turns a blind eye when there's money to be made off people and that's just sad.

I understand that it can be very easy to cheat in the language exams, and that that was even more the case during covid.

loosenmymynd · 06/11/2023 22:22

Fordian · 06/11/2023 21:46

Sorry, not adding anything, but bookmarking (phone app).

I feel your pain.

I'm v recent ex NHS. Working alongside people being paid the same as me (B6, 'senior') who were 100% evidently not in any way qualified.

I'm sorry for your experience Flowers

OP posts:
loosenmymynd · 06/11/2023 22:21

Toddlerteaplease · 06/11/2023 21:50

I once had an overseas student. She was very sweet, but I have no idea how she got on the course. She had barely any functional English and her written communication made no sense.

I'm baffled by how some of my students gained admission. Lots just don't add up.
I feel that our system sometimes turns a blind eye when there's money to be made off people and that's just sad.

OP posts:
loosenmymynd · 06/11/2023 22:16

ColleenDonaghy · 06/11/2023 21:52

I'm teaching my first ever cohort that's majority international this year OP and I feel you. Many are wonderful, engaged students but there are some who won't even say hello to me in a tutorial and pretend they're getting on fine.

Sounds like you're burnt out, when you're not feeling as exhausted it's easier to focus on the good students and brush off the difficult ones. Any prospect of a break at the end of the semester?

Thank you for the advice.
Certainly, I'm burnt out. I intend to take a rest over the Christmas break and return next semester with some indifference.
I teach over 100 students in a cohort. I've identified only 4-5 average-good students I can focus on.
It's unfortunate.

OP posts:
Fordian · 06/11/2023 22:04

Honestly, the smiley, lovely (mostly, the Nigerian men's misogyny wasn't great) staff group I left, because they were endangering my own state registration, really, really couldn't communicate in English.

In a health-care situation. 'Quick! Get the crash team! Now!'- 'What is this team?' etc.

Fordian · 06/11/2023 22:01

My DS had his uni graduation recently. B.Sc. Middle of the road Uni (Bournemouth). Solid enough subject. Worked hard, 1:1, now employed in a proper post grad job.

But, at his graduation, also graduating there were all the 'Masters' students doing 'Cyber security'; 50 of them. All 100% Nigerian. (With a massive cheer -squad of family and friends 😂).

How is this? What is going on?

I gather the ability to import your entire family, as a Masters STUDENT, is a draw.

But isn't anyone going 🤔 about this 'hugely successful' cohort?

I was NHS. I left recently because of how unsafe it was becoming. Band 6 CT 'radiographers' with 'post graduate certificates' (sure) in CT, from third world countries, who couldn't identify basic, first year students' requirement anatomical structures on scans.

Our public institutions, unis and hospitals, are apparently okay with this subterfuge.

Most people don't have a clue about this.

ColleenDonaghy · 06/11/2023 21:52

I'm teaching my first ever cohort that's majority international this year OP and I feel you. Many are wonderful, engaged students but there are some who won't even say hello to me in a tutorial and pretend they're getting on fine.

Sounds like you're burnt out, when you're not feeling as exhausted it's easier to focus on the good students and brush off the difficult ones. Any prospect of a break at the end of the semester?

Toddlerteaplease · 06/11/2023 21:50

I once had an overseas student. She was very sweet, but I have no idea how she got on the course. She had barely any functional English and her written communication made no sense.

Fordian · 06/11/2023 21:46

Sorry, not adding anything, but bookmarking (phone app).

I feel your pain.

I'm v recent ex NHS. Working alongside people being paid the same as me (B6, 'senior') who were 100% evidently not in any way qualified.

loosenmymynd · 06/11/2023 21:41

Halfemptyhalfling · 06/11/2023 21:26

You are small cog in the wheel and you are funding UK students to do the more expensive degrees eg lab based.

You only live once (YOLO) so you need to decide if this is how you want to spend your life.

There are growing university opportunities in east Asia so the ones who come here are not likely to be the highest caliber.

If you have to stay at least in the short term I would match them with your effort so it doesn't damage your mental health.

You're right; they're not of top calibre.
My mental health is already being affected.
I feel irritable, unproductive and frustrated by default.
Thank you for the advice.
I will reset how much of me I give to teaching although it'll be painful since this is what I love doing.
I'm also going into therapy as I feel mentally drained.

OP posts:
Halfemptyhalfling · 06/11/2023 21:26

You are small cog in the wheel and you are funding UK students to do the more expensive degrees eg lab based.

You only live once (YOLO) so you need to decide if this is how you want to spend your life.

There are growing university opportunities in east Asia so the ones who come here are not likely to be the highest caliber.

If you have to stay at least in the short term I would match them with your effort so it doesn't damage your mental health.

Swipe left for the next trending thread