Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I got angry with nursery staff today

138 replies

angrym · 06/11/2023 20:09

My DD wasn't allowed to come into nursery today because she's on antibiotics and it hadn't been 48 hours since she started the course - although she has actually been on antibiotics since Wednesday..

In any case, they have a rule which states that even though she's been on antibiotics since Wednesday, because they she was put on a different one on Saturday- that's what counts and it's therefore counted as if she only started Saturday - hence Monday morning makes it less that 48 hours.

Official websites suggest you need to stay off work / school for 24 hours after starting antibiotics.

In any case, I lost my cool a bit. No shouting by any means but I showed that I was less than impressed. I said something like ' it's just not good enough and a ridiculous rule '.

I've never done anything like that before with nursery as I am usually very very nice/ complaint with them, as they look after my precious baby. I was feeling super stressed as I missed a lot of work last week due to the illness and I'm really falling behind and had a lot of important meetings today, so really needed DD in nursery.

Would you apologise or just ignore ?

OP posts:
TheRealLilyMunster · 06/11/2023 21:51

You should apologise.
I doubt the person you got arsey with made the rules.

Emeraldrings · 06/11/2023 21:49

48 hours where I work and it's 48 hours because some parents will lie about how long their child's been on medication. By saying 48 we are pretty much guaranteed that the child has been taking it for at least 24 hours.
Also it can sometimes take a while for side effects to appear. It's nothing to do with if it's contagious or not, it's about a child having a bad reaction to the medication.
Also her medication changed so side effects could have happened with the new medicine which is why it's another 48 hours
I know it's a pain because I have a preschool child too and it's a nightmare when hes ill. Unfortunately children in nursery tend to get I'll frequently.
The staff will really appreciate it if you decide to apologise.

Pancakefam · 06/11/2023 21:48

That's not rude, it's assertive! NHS guidance is a good place to start when challenging nursery rules that don't seem to make sense.

Bendysnap · 06/11/2023 21:28

Stupid rule for it to be 48hrs. If you’ve got the energy I’d follow up to see if it can be revised to match nhs/other nurseries and schools’ policy of 24 hrs

Starmoonsu · 06/11/2023 21:27

yanbu. I’ve had similar. They’re always happy to continue taking the money though.

It’s a stupid rule because your child probably caught the infection at nursery and would have spread it around further by the time you picked up on it. I don’t blame you for being annoyed.

Cantgetausername87 · 06/11/2023 21:24

And let's face it. If they were required to refund you the fees that policy would not exist!

Cantgetausername87 · 06/11/2023 21:23

I would ignore. It doesn't sound like you were directly rude to the nursery staff. Nursery is expensive and when you add in loss of wages it's understandable that you got a bit cross. Don't be so hard in yourself. You're human and what you said is hardly bad - yes it's a stupid rule!

Zanatdy · 06/11/2023 21:23

I can understand your annoyance as I missed so much work when mine were at nursery, and I’d say at least 30% was when they weren’t actually sick. You’ve got every right to feel frustrated when you’re paying God knows how much per day and they won’t let your child attend. Especially since the official rule is 24hrs after commencing a new one not 48hrs. I don’t think that rule was around when mine were at nursery or that percentage would be higher!

Coffeerum · 06/11/2023 21:20

motherofawhirlwind · 06/11/2023 20:56

I used to take my DD to the GP in the morning, get the antibiotics dispensed and drop her straight off at Nursery with the bottle....

There is a reason policies move on. This sounds horrendous for your DD, horrendous for the other families with children in the same nursery and unfair on the staff.

Mariposista · 06/11/2023 21:19

As someone currently sat up in a hotel room on day 2 of a conference with antibiotics for a chest infection, can't sleep as feeling rubbish, and 3 days still to go, I totally sympathise with you OP. And no, I couldn't have backed out of it. And your daughter is now pretty much well?
But yes, if you were short with them, then do apologise as it is the decent thing to do. Just give a heavenwards eye roll as you head into the car park.

Sameasyounow · 06/11/2023 21:16

FallingFeathers · 06/11/2023 21:05

It completely depends on what the antibiotics are for.
Strep throat, fair enough she should stay off and you need to just apologise.
Infected eczema or an ear infection, no reason for her to be off, and apologise for the reaction but ask for a meeting with management to discuss the policy.

If it’s strep throat it’s 24 hrs it’s on the nhs website

RoomOfRequirement · 06/11/2023 21:16

Just guessing - some illnesses need 48 hours on antibiotics to no longer be contagious, so are they just using that blanket rule for all bacterial illnesses? The change of medicine makes sense as they'd usually change it because the first one wasn't working effectively for their illness so the first few days don't 'count' as treated.

I'm sure the worker just rolled their eyes and forgot about it but if you feel you were rude and they're good with your DD usually I'd apologise to make yourself feel better.

Beseen22 · 06/11/2023 21:15

Think I'd need more detail to make a judgement. On the face of it a blanket must be on 48h abx before coming back to nursery would be ridiculous as for example a UTI or soft tissue infection isn't going to be contagious. If we are speaking about tonsillitis or strep throat where there is a risk of spreading then I don't necessarily think it's outrageous. Depends on the reason for the switch on Saturday, if it was because symptoms were not improving then the infection was not responding to the abx so it's been <48 hours appropriate treatment and if that is their policy I don't necessarily think they were unreasonable. If the symptoms had improved but your DD had developed an intolerance or allergy to the abx and that is why the abx was switched then I agree she should have been able to go to nursery as there has been 48h treatment and she is no longer symptomatic and well in herself.

We have a child undergoing chemo and one who has had open heart surgery in the past year in my DSs nursery and we have stricter infection control policies than perhaps nurseries which don't have children who are so immunocompromised and I am quite happy to support that so I couldn't get riled up about that but then again my nursery hours are funded and I work nights so keeping DS at home isn't a problem for me.

AllllTheQuestions · 06/11/2023 21:12

angrym · 06/11/2023 20:15

I didn't shout at anyone

Off point… however… Welcome to 2023, not everyone that works in a nursery is a lady.

You can even get female police officers nowadays 🫢@Tweddle

rockpoolingtogether · 06/11/2023 21:08

OP check your private messages. N

Goldbar · 06/11/2023 21:07

I would have been annoyed too. Some nurseries are very quick to take your money but fail to provide the service you pay for. Nurseries are expensive and parents aren't made of money. Often having a reliable nursery with reasonable policies (applied reasonably) is the difference between one parent remaining in the workforce or being forced out.

And I never understand why, just because they care for your children, nursery/ nannies are automatically in the right and parents in the wrong on many MN threads. Even if they've been feeding your kids junk/ sticking them in front of the TV all day/ not changing nappies. You tend to get "what do you expect? It's a hard job. They can't possibly provide the service they're contracted to". This doesn't happen in other sectors/professions.

Strictlyfanoftenyears · 06/11/2023 21:06

I dont understand how they knew it was a different antibiotic?

Mumof2teens79 · 06/11/2023 21:05

There is no official blanket 48hour antibiotic rule.
There is a rule for specific infections that you can go back 48hours after ABs, if you haven't got antibiotics you can't go back with those infections at all (or until several weeks later)

zeibesaffron · 06/11/2023 21:05

Resetting the clock to the start of a new antibiotic beginning is fair enough - the old one is clearly not working or has not worked well enough so the child could potentially still be ill or infectious. Its up to the nursery what rules they make around illness NHS guidance is just what it says ‘guidance.’ You do need to apologise and perhaps find a different nursery if you don’t agree with their rules.

FallingFeathers · 06/11/2023 21:05

It completely depends on what the antibiotics are for.
Strep throat, fair enough she should stay off and you need to just apologise.
Infected eczema or an ear infection, no reason for her to be off, and apologise for the reaction but ask for a meeting with management to discuss the policy.

Notimeforaname · 06/11/2023 21:05

I was feeling super stressed as I missed a lot of work last week due to the illness and I'm really falling behind and had a lot of important meetings today, so really needed DD in nursery.

I understand that is stressful but it's your child and not their fault you have to juggle work and a sick child. All parents do.

I agree 24hours makes more sense than 48 but, their rules are their rules.

SofiaAmes · 06/11/2023 21:05

Presumably there is a list of the rules in your contract with the nursery. They and you have to abide by these. If the rules state "antibiotics and 48 hours" then that's the rule. If the rule states that the clock restarts if the type of antibiotics is changed, then that's the rule. If it doesn't, then they are in breach of contract. If they have breached the contract by imposing different made up verbal rules, then you are probably within your rights to leave that nursery and go to another one.

My impression is that this is a common problem because of the shortage of nursery workers, many nurseries are rejecting children for all sorts of made up reasons in order to maintain their ratios.

Rainallnight · 06/11/2023 21:05

I’d have reacted very similarly to you, OP.

You might want to consider a childminder. They’re usually a bit more relaxed about this kind of stuff

angrym · 06/11/2023 21:04

rockpoolingtogether · 06/11/2023 20:58

OP. I want to send you a DM about this. What letter does your nursery start with?

Haha why ? Which letter do you think it starts with ?

OP posts:
rockpoolingtogether · 06/11/2023 21:03

Itrymybestyesido · 06/11/2023 20:12

I think you have been fair in your annoyance. You pay a lot of money for nursery and it sounds like someone was being a jobsworth. I understand there are rules but there should also be an element of common sense involved also in cases like this.

Agree. Children attend school whilst taking anti biotics. I would actually escalate this beyond the room leader and book a meeting with the nursery manager to discuss. My nursery says at their discretion but seems their bias is no.