Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I got angry with nursery staff today

138 replies

angrym · 06/11/2023 20:09

My DD wasn't allowed to come into nursery today because she's on antibiotics and it hadn't been 48 hours since she started the course - although she has actually been on antibiotics since Wednesday..

In any case, they have a rule which states that even though she's been on antibiotics since Wednesday, because they she was put on a different one on Saturday- that's what counts and it's therefore counted as if she only started Saturday - hence Monday morning makes it less that 48 hours.

Official websites suggest you need to stay off work / school for 24 hours after starting antibiotics.

In any case, I lost my cool a bit. No shouting by any means but I showed that I was less than impressed. I said something like ' it's just not good enough and a ridiculous rule '.

I've never done anything like that before with nursery as I am usually very very nice/ complaint with them, as they look after my precious baby. I was feeling super stressed as I missed a lot of work last week due to the illness and I'm really falling behind and had a lot of important meetings today, so really needed DD in nursery.

Would you apologise or just ignore ?

OP posts:
Boymum2104 · 06/11/2023 22:37

Apologise. Likely the person you had a moan at does not make the rules & is simply doing their job.

AnneElliott · 06/11/2023 22:27

I think this rule is a bit odd - but it's probably a lesson in not giving out too much information. As you said she'd been on ABs since the Wednesday and they wouldn't have known they'd changed if you hadn't said.

I'd be minded to look at other providers. Some nurseries so have a reputation for trying to send kids home as they don't have enough staff- not saying yours is definitely do this but it's a possibility.

ThePeachIsSoUnusual · 06/11/2023 22:26

According to a medical website I have just taken a look at, allergic reactions to antibiotics can take minutes up to weeks to occur, so a cut-off of 48 hrs seems too long if you are just trying to catch early (the most severe?) reactions, and too short to cover all of them. Nonsense policy. And Early Years settings should NOT be being put in the position of being tasked with making up health-related policies with no formal training to do so, so the whole system needs challenging. There should be a nationwide policy, and with room in it to adapt for situations that don't quite fit. I am not suggesting the OP takes this on by the way! In the meantime, I'd adapt what I previously said to fit the exact situation i.e. it'll be the doctor who decides.

Rainallnight · 06/11/2023 22:23

verifyme · 06/11/2023 21:52

@Rainallnight "I’d have reacted very similarly to you, OP. You might want to consider a childminder. They’re usually a bit more relaxed about this kind of stuff"

Well that's OK then - let's just ignore official guidance (not necessarily in this case) so it doesn't inconvenience you - ridiculous response.

Hope you "are more relaxed" when your DC get ill through following this wisdom or others taking the same laissez-faire attitude to health protection.

Rules/guidance exist for a reason - not to inconvenience you.

Are you…ok?

viques · 06/11/2023 22:22

She is so unwell that a second batch of antibiotics is needed and yet you want to send her in to a cesspit of other snotty kids where she probably picked up the infection in the first place.

Delt · 06/11/2023 22:22

ThePeachIsSoUnusual · 06/11/2023 22:18

So in this case, the policy at the nursery may have had a point about allergic reaction, but then every staff member ought to be able to explain why that is or direct the parent to a person or a written explanation of the policy including those actual reasons. If the child has had the same antibiotic before, though, then it doesn't apply.

100% staff working at the nursery should be able to explain the policy and why it's there.

Parents should also be given the overall 'illness rules/policies' when signing up and the policy would normally be listed there - somewhere in the 'welcome pack'.

It's a fairly standard policy for nurseries in England, so yes you'd expect staff to be able to explain it.

Hankunamatata · 06/11/2023 22:21

Scarlet fever by any chance?

ThePeachIsSoUnusual · 06/11/2023 22:18

So in this case, the policy at the nursery may have had a point about allergic reaction, but then every staff member ought to be able to explain why that is or direct the parent to a person or a written explanation of the policy including those actual reasons. If the child has had the same antibiotic before, though, then it doesn't apply.

endofthelinefinally · 06/11/2023 22:18

I have been involved in writing policies and procedures in the NHS for years. The purpose is to keep staff and patients safe, amongst other things.
I once found myself being told to work with a medication policy written for carers in the community that was full of errors and misinformation and was actually dangerous. It took me weeks to find out who had written it and it turned out to have been literally cobbled together by a few people with no medical training or qualifications between them.
I am sure this is not applicable to this case, but, IMO, if everyone understands the reasons and the medical evidence behind particular rules in nurseries and other settings, they are going to be more willing to comply. Hopefully.

ThePeachIsSoUnusual · 06/11/2023 22:16

Many 'policies' in education, care and healthcare settings are made-up nonsense which have no validity and wouldn't stand up to scrutiny. Quite a few of them are actively causing harm in some way.
Trotting out "it's our policy" as though that is the end of the conversation is common. Not long ago, a family member of mine challenged someone on a policy (which was causing harm or at least meaning something that obviously needing doing wasn't being done, in a not-joined-up kind of way) and when asked straight out "well whose policy is this, then?" the rather sheepish answer was "er... well... just mine really I suppose".

So, the policy is the policy, its no one's fault is clearly not true - it's the fault of whoever made up the policy - from the person standing opposite, through those with no expertise, and those with some, right up to an official body, it can still be a nonsense policy. If it's simply nonsense, or outdated, or not aligned with the current medical, educational, or legal best practice, it needs challenging.

Delt · 06/11/2023 22:11

CrispsandCheeseSandwich · 06/11/2023 22:03

What do you mean? It's different for different illnesses.

www.nhs.uk/live-well/is-my-child-too-ill-for-school/#:~:text=Otherwise%20they'll%20be%20infectious,24%20hours%20after%20starting%20antibiotics.

Impetigo - 48 hours
Scarlet fever - 24 hours

There's no single guidance that just covers all antibiotics.

There isn't via the NHS.

Nurseries have additional guidance for allergic reaction NOT just infection control.

They follow the NHS guidance for infection control too. But the general guidelines for nurseries takes into account allergic reaction as well as contagiousness. The NHS does not take allergic reaction into account as they are only looking at infection control.

daffodilandtulip · 06/11/2023 22:09

Early Years settings go above and beyond the minimum NHS guidelines, as there is an additional responsibility on them to prevent the spread of illness and to keep children well. They are required to create their own policies which show you are doing this.

I got angry with nursery staff today
ThePeachIsSoUnusual · 06/11/2023 22:08

I would write them a letter apologising for losing my cool, setting a poor example to the children, taking it out on whichever member of staff rather than taking it formally to management in a calm manner.

I would then go on to state in the letter that it is not acceptable that the nursery staff, none of whom are medically trained, are making up quasi-medical policies that have no scientific validity and are preventing your child from learning and you from working - for no good reason whatsoever, while you are still expected to pay the fee. And that you will henceforth be taking your GP's advice on when it is appropriate for your child to return to nursery. Put WITHOUT PREJUDICE at the top of the letter above everything including the addresses. Keep a copy and make sure you send it signed-for or hand it to management, noting who and what time and date you did.

IANAL. I did however have something similar and I was never their favourite parent from then on, but I also didn't get any nonsense again and my child continued to be properly cared for.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 06/11/2023 22:05

AlwaysPrettyOnTheInside · 06/11/2023 22:02

She sounds like she expects the service she is paying for, to me.

Nurseries are some of the cheekiest fuckers around imo.

I wouldn't apologise.

I seem to recall paying for a service to look after my kid when she was well, not the right to utilise her ability to act as a vector for infectious diseases to a bunch of other potentially more vulnerable children and babies.

CrispsandCheeseSandwich · 06/11/2023 22:03

angrym · 06/11/2023 20:46

NHS guidance is 24 hours after starting antibiotics.

What do you mean? It's different for different illnesses.

www.nhs.uk/live-well/is-my-child-too-ill-for-school/#:~:text=Otherwise%20they'll%20be%20infectious,24%20hours%20after%20starting%20antibiotics.

Impetigo - 48 hours
Scarlet fever - 24 hours

There's no single guidance that just covers all antibiotics.

motherofawhirlwind · 06/11/2023 22:03

WalkingRunning · 06/11/2023 21:00

@motherofawhirlwind what were the antibiotics for? Mine have always been pretty poorly when they've needed them and even if nursery had allowed it, which they didn't, they wouldn't have been well enough to go straight to nursery with their antibiotics

Recurrent tonsillitis, every 28 days like clockwork. She'd be fine in herself once she'd had Calpol and the antibiotics, full of energy and raring to go. They were happy to have her and she never passed it on. Had them removed eventually. If she'd have been cuddly or not herself, I wouldn't have sent her.

CherryMyBrandy · 06/11/2023 22:03

I'm surprised that nurseries ever have any children to look after the amount of rules they have about children not attending. Literally none of these rules existed 20 years ago when my children were in nursery, and there certainly weren't huge issues as a result. Makes it seem like perhaps all these rules which have come in since free childcare places were available, are more to do with issues with staff ratios than anything else. I am surprised parents with children in nurseries are able to hold down their jobs, the amount of time they must have to take off work to look after perfectly well children who they are paying (assuming it's not a free place) good money for a nursery to look after.

AlwaysPrettyOnTheInside · 06/11/2023 22:02

Abbimae · 06/11/2023 20:10

You sound entitled

She sounds like she expects the service she is paying for, to me.

Nurseries are some of the cheekiest fuckers around imo.

I wouldn't apologise.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 06/11/2023 22:02

endofthelinefinally · 06/11/2023 20:32

What is the rationale for this rule? Have you asked them? What is the risk of contagion? Somebody must have written this policy and based it on scientific research and facts. Ask to see them.

Because the previous ones weren't working, hence having to change the type - so the infection wasn't being effectively treated?

Delt · 06/11/2023 22:01

The rule is: for a new antibiotic - 48hrs. For an antibiotic they've had before 24hrs.

The 48hr rule is incase of an allergic reaction.

It's nothing to do with being infectious. Whether it's a funky toenail or reoccurring ear infection (i.e not contagious issues) or scarlet fever (very contagious) - the rule is the same.

Thatsridiculous · 06/11/2023 21:57

I would leave it, take them in tomorrow and then look for a childminder. Far more reliable, your DC will be able to form a relationship with one caregiver as opposed to many (and a revolving door of staff) and they tend to be a bit more flexible.
Also handy for school age children too.

NumberTheory · 06/11/2023 21:57

It depends a bit on how exactly you spoke to them. You aren’t obliged to pretend all their rules are fantastic even if the workers you interact with aren’t the ones who set them. It’s okay to communicate negative opinions, they can pass it up the line to the management who do make the rules. It is probably more effective to also communicate directly with the manager, though. Sometimes management isn’t that great and doesn’t take much notice of messages passed on from front line staff.

But if you said it in a way that criticised the front line workers personally, or that was nasty rather than simply factual (and by saying you were angry, it sounds like this is the case) then an apology is definitely called for because it’s not their fault. You can maintain your disagreement with the policy while still genuinely apologising for the way you spoke.

warriorofhopelessness · 06/11/2023 21:56

TwiddlingMyToes · 06/11/2023 20:14

What's actually wrong with her that necessitates antibiotics? For me it would depend whether she was infectious.

But why did you tell them the antibiotic had changed? Surely you just tell them she's been taking them since last week?

Surely the antibiotic would have only been changed if the first one wasn’t working? You would have to start the 48 hour rule again as the child will still have an infection and not telling the nursery potentially puts other children and staff at risk. Whether the rules are stupid or not is another thing altogether.

Moonshine160 · 06/11/2023 21:55

You sound annoyed, not entitled. I’d be annoyed too in your shoes when you need to work and can’t send your well child into nursery. I would politely explain your frustrations to the nursery and ask to see their policy.

verifyme · 06/11/2023 21:52

@Rainallnight "I’d have reacted very similarly to you, OP. You might want to consider a childminder. They’re usually a bit more relaxed about this kind of stuff"

Well that's OK then - let's just ignore official guidance (not necessarily in this case) so it doesn't inconvenience you - ridiculous response.

Hope you "are more relaxed" when your DC get ill through following this wisdom or others taking the same laissez-faire attitude to health protection.

Rules/guidance exist for a reason - not to inconvenience you.

Swipe left for the next trending thread