Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To read my daughter's WhatsApp messages

416 replies

JoelyJoe · 06/11/2023 15:41

So. This is a genuine question, and I'm prepared for strong opinions either way, but I would really like to know what people think.
My daughter has just turned 13, she is in year 8 at school and has had a mobile phone since year 6. When she got the phone I told her the deal was that I would read her WhatsApps from time to time.
My reasons are to protect her / her friends, and to ensure that there is not bullying or situations / content that I think are inappropriate at her age. Social Media did not exist when I was young, and while I know that it can't be put back in the box, I think think there are inherent dangers... as many people do.
As I said, I have always been upfront with her that I will sometimes look at her messages, I don't do it very often, and obviously at some point in the near future (not sure exactly when though!!) I will stop doing it.
Any thoughts? Am I invading her privacy or is this a necessity to protect our young people... And for those of you who also do / did the same, at what age did you stop??

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
meanypegs · 07/11/2023 20:19

That was @AnneValentine

meanypegs · 07/11/2023 20:19

Schools will advise monitoring activity

So schools agree with the vast majority of parents posting here.

but they primary focus is on promoting a healthy relationship with your child

Funnily, most parents on here agree with this, too.

In the kindest possible way, you are talking utter bollocks.

meanypegs · 07/11/2023 20:17

I’m well aware re phones. I work in a school. I know exactly how they work and how naive it is for parents to think monitoring messages is remotely useful

@AnneValentine You can work in a school all you like, but tell me that you have successfully parented several screen-bound children to a reasonably healthy adulthood and I will be more convinced by your views.

Flyingsunflower · 07/11/2023 20:08

I think parents should check not only messages but throughly check the apps and websites their children are interacting with online. A phone is like an ocean to children. You will not trust a 13year old in an ocean even though they could swim without adult supervision. We can all see how people are getting counseled for things they said when they were young and did not know the consequences. Our dc are leaving behind digital footprint which could be used against them in the future if they are not being sensible and it is up to us as parents to guide them.

My ds school has a rule that teachers can check the kids phone anytime and kids have to open the phone for the teachers. All parents agree to this when you enroll your child there.

AnneValentine · 07/11/2023 20:03

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 07/11/2023 19:43

very bizarre thing for a member of school staff to say when every school I’ve ever worked in, and the schools my children have attended, all massively encourage parents (as did the chap from ceops that spoke to parents) to check phones.

Thinking that checking phones is a guarantee of no problems is naive. Thinking that it alone is enough is naive. Not naive at all to find it useful.

Schools will advise monitoring activity but they primary focus is on promoting a healthy relationship with your child.

They will delete the messages. It’s that simple.

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 07/11/2023 19:47

They are often secretly quite glad to have the problem taken away from them, even if they bluster about it being "not fair", and "nobody else's parents check their phone" etc.

My elder three, now all Uni age, have said exactly this. And they’ve all encouraged their younger siblings to make it known their phones are checked as it just takes them off the radar for some of the shit that goes on.

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 07/11/2023 19:43

AnneValentine · 07/11/2023 19:36

I’m well aware re phones. I work in a school. I know exactly how they work and how naive it is for parents to think monitoring messages is remotely useful.

very bizarre thing for a member of school staff to say when every school I’ve ever worked in, and the schools my children have attended, all massively encourage parents (as did the chap from ceops that spoke to parents) to check phones.

Thinking that checking phones is a guarantee of no problems is naive. Thinking that it alone is enough is naive. Not naive at all to find it useful.

Johnnybegood2 · 07/11/2023 19:39

Family members child was groomed over Snapchat recently and it moved onto WhatsApp. They are 11.

AnneValentine · 07/11/2023 19:36

meanypegs · 07/11/2023 19:23

You can teach all these things, and I have extremely good and close relationships with all of my children (who are no longer teenagers).

However, phones can be a complete menace, even in the hands of a child with whom you have a good and trusting relationship. 'Child' being the operative word here.

Children are children, and this includes young teenagers. Sometimes children need adults to step in and say "enough", and to keep them safe when they don't have the experience or tools to do it for themselves.

They are often secretly quite glad to have the problem taken away from them, even if they bluster about it being "not fair", and "nobody else's parents check their phone" etc. It's far easier for them to rail against parents than it is to deal alone with other children en masse telling them via Snapchat they ought to kill themselves for being fat/thin/thick/red-haired/ugly/babyish/insert whatever ridiculous reason children have to bully one another.

In my experience, if you have a good relationship with your children, it will survive you keeping them safe. They hide all kinds of stupid stuff, have 'secret' Instagram accounts etc - but any parent who knows their child properly also knows when it's time to intervene.

I’m well aware re phones. I work in a school. I know exactly how they work and how naive it is for parents to think monitoring messages is remotely useful.

meanypegs · 07/11/2023 19:23

AnneValentine · 07/11/2023 16:10

You’re inciting trouble. All this will do is lead to her deleting messages and go out of her way to bury information. I work with teenagers, if they don’t want you seeing it you aren’t. You might think you are. But you aren’t. Anyone who thinks this is an effective safeguarding measure is deluded.

What you should be doing is teaching safe use, trust, open relationship etc.

You can teach all these things, and I have extremely good and close relationships with all of my children (who are no longer teenagers).

However, phones can be a complete menace, even in the hands of a child with whom you have a good and trusting relationship. 'Child' being the operative word here.

Children are children, and this includes young teenagers. Sometimes children need adults to step in and say "enough", and to keep them safe when they don't have the experience or tools to do it for themselves.

They are often secretly quite glad to have the problem taken away from them, even if they bluster about it being "not fair", and "nobody else's parents check their phone" etc. It's far easier for them to rail against parents than it is to deal alone with other children en masse telling them via Snapchat they ought to kill themselves for being fat/thin/thick/red-haired/ugly/babyish/insert whatever ridiculous reason children have to bully one another.

In my experience, if you have a good relationship with your children, it will survive you keeping them safe. They hide all kinds of stupid stuff, have 'secret' Instagram accounts etc - but any parent who knows their child properly also knows when it's time to intervene.

AnneValentine · 07/11/2023 19:06

Lavender14 · 07/11/2023 18:52

@Chanelbasketballandchain How so? Obviously if there is anything for concern op can address it appropriately but I wouldn't be jumping all over every conversation or digging where it's unnecessary. There's a line between safeguarding your child and allowing them to learn and figure some things out independently in an age appropriate way. Could you explain where that constitutes lazy parenting?

It’s not lazy parenting. Lazy parenting is sitting on your arse scrolling through your kids phones.

Lavender14 · 07/11/2023 18:52

Chanelbasketballandchain · 07/11/2023 17:51

that's such an excuse for lazy parenting.

@Chanelbasketballandchain How so? Obviously if there is anything for concern op can address it appropriately but I wouldn't be jumping all over every conversation or digging where it's unnecessary. There's a line between safeguarding your child and allowing them to learn and figure some things out independently in an age appropriate way. Could you explain where that constitutes lazy parenting?

sheflieswithherownwings · 07/11/2023 18:49

I check my nearly 12yo DS's phone and he knows that's part of the deal of having a mobile phone. And some of the messages I've seen on Whatsapp groups are really troubling - one recently from an 11 year old boy telling another child to kill themselves. So yeah, I'm going to check his phone and I really wish other parents would do the same - it might help to stop some of the awful bullying that happens online and the terrible consequences that follow.

Honestly sometimes I get very frustrated by other parent's lack of concern about what their children get up to on their mobile phones. And how these children subsequently have no boundaries around how much time they spend on the phone or what apps they can download - there are posts on here every week from parents wondering whether they should stop their child having their phone at night (yes, you really, really should), or having huge issues getting them off the bloody thing. Honestly, I think many parents in the UK are way too hands off when it comes to tech (and I've lived in another country for a while and many parents were far stricter, far more aware of the dangers of just giving their child a device and allowing them to get on with it with no boundaries what so ever).

As other PPs have said, it isn't a safe space and their behaviour on it could actually have huge consequences for them or others.

celticprincess · 07/11/2023 17:59

I have the same agreement with my 11&14 year olds. Eldest is autistic and I like to check to make sure people aren’t being horrible and her not noticing - it’s happened. I don’t check so much now. But in y6 there was a massive bullying issue around what’s app and something escalated on a group chat when a friend got hold of my daughters phone and was sending messages as my daughter. Since then she’s passcode locked her what’s app so no one can get on it except me as I know. She often shows me messages anyway and often asks me to decipher bad spelling when she can’t make out what her friends are saying. she’s stopped being part of what’s app groups as she can’t cope with them.

My youngest had an issue early days where a friend was messaging her and she was busy and my daughter’s reply was fairly rude and abrupt instead of simply telling the friend she was busy and not to keep bombarding. I even texted the friend’s mum so say is monitored messages and was aware my daughters were coming across nasty and we’d had words. She was really pleased I’d mentioned it (the other mother). I lapsed a bit but then was absolutely shocked over the summer at some of the language being used by the boys in a what’s app group after leaving y6. I told my daughter I’d checked the messages and I wasn’t happy with the language being used in them - too sexual and too bad mouthed for 11 year olds. She’s since distanced herself from the boys who were just being disgusting. A lot of it was probably harmless and hard to know if they even understood the words being used, but I suspect many did. I’ll keep checking to know nothing inappropriate is being sent. A girl committed suicide at my daughter’s school due to bullying on her phone and other devices never being dealt with and the other parents ignoring the seriousness of it.

Chanelbasketballandchain · 07/11/2023 17:51

Lavender14 · 07/11/2023 16:15

I do think op it'll be one where you need to pick your battles very carefully though.

that's such an excuse for lazy parenting.

AnneValentine · 07/11/2023 17:44

Koalalady · 07/11/2023 16:45

Are you for real? Why is everyone acting like she’s 18. She’s 13 fgs!!! Barely a teen. Ofcourse it’s ok to check her messages to make sure she is using her phone responsibly! Gosh you’re vile sounding anyway, no need for the f really!

What would you do if you had messaged you didn’t want read?

Koalalady · 07/11/2023 16:46

Yea that’s a little it. Borderline abuse if you ask me? Up til they finished their GCSEs! Jeez, they didn’t even have a life then? That isn’t normal at all

Koalalady · 07/11/2023 16:45

Are you for real? Why is everyone acting like she’s 18. She’s 13 fgs!!! Barely a teen. Ofcourse it’s ok to check her messages to make sure she is using her phone responsibly! Gosh you’re vile sounding anyway, no need for the f really!

Lavender14 · 07/11/2023 16:15

I do think op it'll be one where you need to pick your battles very carefully though.

Lavender14 · 07/11/2023 16:14

I think it would be a condition of having a phone for me. Its not about snooping or invading privacy, it's about safeguarding and i think as long as you're upfront and honest with her about what you're doing and why then I think that's acceptable. My dn is fairly responsible, her mum checks her phone at times and she found some worrying things on it that needed to be dealt with. Things she'd never have expected to find going on how mature my dn is for 13.

I think it's something that comes as part of an open and honest conversation with your dd and is as you say under review until you feel she can handle having a phone and the social pressures that can come with it safely.

AnneValentine · 07/11/2023 16:10

You’re inciting trouble. All this will do is lead to her deleting messages and go out of her way to bury information. I work with teenagers, if they don’t want you seeing it you aren’t. You might think you are. But you aren’t. Anyone who thinks this is an effective safeguarding measure is deluded.

What you should be doing is teaching safe use, trust, open relationship etc.

AnneValentine · 07/11/2023 16:10

You’re inciting trouble. All this will do is lead to her deleting messages and go out of her way to bury information. I work with teenagers, if they don’t want you seeing it you aren’t. You might think you are. But you aren’t. Anyone who thinks this is an effective safeguarding measure is deluded.

What you should be doing is teaching safe use, trust, open relationship etc.

sassyclassyandsmartassy · 07/11/2023 15:20

GwenGhost · 06/11/2023 15:50

What you are doing is entirely sensible. She knows you look through her messages sometimes. That’s not snooping, it’s monitoring. Don’t comment on anything that isn’t a massive issue though, especially if it’s her friends using language/talking in a way you find objectionable rather than her.
Consider that doing this gives her protection from other kids’ who might otherwise send/ask things like nudes.
Imagine your 13 year old gets her first 13 yr old boyfriend. If he asks her for a nude she can say No! My mum checks my phone! You can’t send me any either OMG majorly embarrassing.
I’d probably tell her I’ll stop when she turns 16. Age of consent seems a reasonable stopping point.

👆🏻this!!!! Your house, your rules OP, but the world is a very different place to the one we grew up in and by checking their phones it is not about snooping, it is about supporting, educating and protecting…. A friend of mine recently found out one of her children was being groomed online at 14, sensible girl that she was as teenagers their
cognitive abilities and risk assessment abilities are not fully developed and when parenting we are all responsible for ensuring their wellbeing.

CharlotteBog · 07/11/2023 15:17

Better off maintaining honestly from the start than to check on something that you’ll never actually see

Obviously that would be the ideal, but 1) people are not always honest, and 2) children are vulnerable and innocent/naive and can get in over their heads and scared and overwhelmed

ThisMama1 · 07/11/2023 15:11

Not really sure what checking her messages will achieve. She’ll just delete anything she doesn’t want you to see straight away so that when you do check there’s nothing out of the ordinary to see. Better off maintaining honestly from the start than to check on something that you’ll never actually see

Swipe left for the next trending thread