Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To read my daughter's WhatsApp messages

416 replies

JoelyJoe · 06/11/2023 15:41

So. This is a genuine question, and I'm prepared for strong opinions either way, but I would really like to know what people think.
My daughter has just turned 13, she is in year 8 at school and has had a mobile phone since year 6. When she got the phone I told her the deal was that I would read her WhatsApps from time to time.
My reasons are to protect her / her friends, and to ensure that there is not bullying or situations / content that I think are inappropriate at her age. Social Media did not exist when I was young, and while I know that it can't be put back in the box, I think think there are inherent dangers... as many people do.
As I said, I have always been upfront with her that I will sometimes look at her messages, I don't do it very often, and obviously at some point in the near future (not sure exactly when though!!) I will stop doing it.
Any thoughts? Am I invading her privacy or is this a necessity to protect our young people... And for those of you who also do / did the same, at what age did you stop??

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
JazbayGrapes · 08/11/2023 10:25

you may soon discover that your kid has a second phone

Jellytot1234 · 08/11/2023 10:24

I surprised at some of the responses. At age 13, she is still a child and underage. I don’t think you’re unreasonable at all for occasionally having a skim through and wanting to do that. You are safeguarding your child against the ugly online world. If she was 16, then yes that’s crossing a line but at age 13, they are very much still a child.

CharlotteBog · 08/11/2023 09:57

I have helped/guided/taught my DS (14) a couple of times in the past year (there has also been some school involvement).
He knows I will only check his phone if I have concerns.
We have a very good relationship and I believe he would come to me if he found himself in a difficult situation (either by his own foolishness or by the actions of someone else). He knows that things can escalate quickly and that it's far better to have me involved than other parents/school/police/other authorities.

DarkwingDuk · 08/11/2023 09:52

my 13yo’s father and I have both worked in media in different ways…needless to say we have the same deal you do. We have been separated since 13yo was 1yo but have co patented very well and firmly agree on this

Too many people don’t understand how dangerous phones can be despite the restrictions you put on.
No apps can be downloaded without one of us signing off on it and there are time limits for each app…we both understand that doesn’t protect from everything we want to protect from.

We’ve also caught bullying and gaslighting messages from so called friends that we were able to nip in the bud by raising with other parents and the school. Not just to our child but from one child to another in group chats.
Within the friend group 3 “trends” were very clearly being misunderstood due to the ages of the people involved that had some rather dark undertones. All caught by different parents allowing a chat amongst adults before all talking to the children to explain why they needed to avoid certain things and how they were inadvertently sharing information.

Tbh those who don’t check in on what’s going on are being wilfully ignorant, boarding on neglectful.
Children do silly, thoughtless things and it’s our job to ensure those things cause as little harm as possible, in this day and age that includes checking their communications.

LimePi · 08/11/2023 08:50

I can see where you are coming from. It’s better to check messages than miss say online grooming and your DS running away with a seedy man and be never seen again (which clearly happens).

meanypegs · 08/11/2023 08:29

&They will delete what they don’t want you to see. They will use messaging facilities you don’t know they have. They will use Snapchat to communicate with one story view. Did you know huge chunks of kids have multiple social media accounts? Many go as far as a PAYG sim that connects to wifi so you don’t even know they have it*

@AnneValentine, sadly none of this is a newsflash either - especially not to those of us who have children in their 20s.

We know about the 'secret' social media accounts, and the PAYG sim cards and all that stuff. It was via a 'secret' social media account which I accessed that I discovered something that ended up with the police.

The best and most sensible comment thus far is @YetMoreNewBeginnings And here’s a news flash for you- you can have an open relationship with your children and talk to them and check phones

Don't think you are the expert and have the golden key to keeping your teenagers safe, because they can always surprise you however much you think you know, and however open you think your lines of communication are. Sometimes you find something out about somebody else's teenager whose parents are less vigilant, precisely because you check your own child's phone if you have a hunch that it's necessary.

Josell12345 · 08/11/2023 08:13

13 is probably more at risk as at secondary school.

Xsxjxmx · 08/11/2023 07:34

I check my 13 year olds phone occasionally, he's in huge class whatsapp groups and I want to make sure he's safe, he knows I check, he doesn't seem to care.

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 08/11/2023 06:16

AnneValentine · 08/11/2023 05:58

I do also have teenagers yes. One currently sitting they’re A levels, the other entering year 10. Both talk to me and we have an open relationship. But that is irrelevant because working in a school highlights to me daily how naive parents are. Including myself. You can read all the messages you want but here’s a newsflash. They will delete what they don’t want you to see. They will use messaging facilities you don’t know they have. They will use Snapchat to communicate with one story view. Did you know huge chunks of kids have multiple social media accounts? Many go as far as a PAYG sim that connects to wifi so you don’t even know they have it.

Must remind myself that something that was very helpful with the four teens I’ve already got to their twenties was utterly useless because someone not at that point yet says so…

Not a single person has said it’s the only thing they do. And here’s a news flash for you - you can have an open relationship with your children and talk to them and check phones.

AnneValentine · 08/11/2023 05:58

meanypegs · 07/11/2023 20:17

I’m well aware re phones. I work in a school. I know exactly how they work and how naive it is for parents to think monitoring messages is remotely useful

@AnneValentine You can work in a school all you like, but tell me that you have successfully parented several screen-bound children to a reasonably healthy adulthood and I will be more convinced by your views.

I do also have teenagers yes. One currently sitting they’re A levels, the other entering year 10. Both talk to me and we have an open relationship. But that is irrelevant because working in a school highlights to me daily how naive parents are. Including myself. You can read all the messages you want but here’s a newsflash. They will delete what they don’t want you to see. They will use messaging facilities you don’t know they have. They will use Snapchat to communicate with one story view. Did you know huge chunks of kids have multiple social media accounts? Many go as far as a PAYG sim that connects to wifi so you don’t even know they have it.

AtTheStream · 07/11/2023 22:35

DS is 4 now and I don’t know how I’ll feel at age 13 really but I think it’s responsible to check. You don’t need to deep dive into conversations between trusted, known friends but a check for online grooming, bullying, numbers of people you don’t know, inappropriate photos and social media accounts just seems sensible given the level of risk involved. It also provides an opportunity to talk about issues and safety, so why not.

meanypegs · 07/11/2023 21:41

Tighginn · 07/11/2023 21:34

Bet you check your husbands too and snoop in people's bathroom cabinets.

Edited

You can surely do better than that if you want to argue that parents don't have a duty to ensure to the best of their ability that their children are safe.

Tighginn · 07/11/2023 21:34

Bet you check your husbands too and snoop in people's bathroom cabinets.

Trying2310 · 07/11/2023 21:31

I check my DS13 phone every two to three days. I control his phone from mine using Google family link. He has several apps blocked because of inappropriate and immature use of them in the past. He has time limits and the phone locks at 8.30pm. The language and inappropriate content on what's apps is shocking. In my opinion, 13 is far too young to be given complete freedom on a phone where bullying, exploitation and inappropriate content can happen. It is called responsible parenting and as a teacher I have witnessed and dealt with many fall outs / impacts of teenagers and mobile phone use.

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 07/11/2023 21:22

meanypegs · 07/11/2023 20:17

I’m well aware re phones. I work in a school. I know exactly how they work and how naive it is for parents to think monitoring messages is remotely useful

@AnneValentine You can work in a school all you like, but tell me that you have successfully parented several screen-bound children to a reasonably healthy adulthood and I will be more convinced by your views.

Exactly this.

I think it's very telling that the people telling my current teens to be very open with their friends that their phones are checked, and remind me (not that I need it) to do it are my uni age children.

I also don't know any school staff (and until covid I worked in schools for 20 years) who would say there was no point in checking a phone.

Often what you don't find is the biggest story teller.

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 07/11/2023 21:19

AnneValentine · 07/11/2023 20:03

Schools will advise monitoring activity but they primary focus is on promoting a healthy relationship with your child.

They will delete the messages. It’s that simple.

And where exactly did anyone on the thread that checks phones say that they didn't bother focussing on a healthy relationship?

That's just a lazy assumption on your part that parents will do one or the other. So checking phones is not "not remotely useful" at all.

Again you're assuming that people won't have thought that some teens will delete messages... another lazy assumption on your part.

TangointhePark · 07/11/2023 21:10

I’m well aware re phones. I work in a school. I know exactly how they work and how naive it is for parents to think monitoring messages is remotely useful

And yet many parents have given concrete examples of when it has been very useful. No one is saying checking will catch everything but it serves a useful purpose in many different ways.

indianwoman · 07/11/2023 21:08

EarringsandLipstick · 06/11/2023 16:05

DD15 was relieved I'd seen something on her phone as she didn't know how to tell me

Same with DS. A Snapchat group was getting way out of hand and he didn't know what to do.

With Snapchat they can see if someone is checking it (by the way we are looking but not snapping back) - so it frightened the bejasus out of the others too. They knew straightaway it was me checking and that softened their cough somewhat.

How do you do this?

Dunnoburt · 07/11/2023 20:51

If you genuinely made the deal then yanbu.....social media is fucking evil.

CasperGutman · 07/11/2023 20:48

The age limit for using WhatsApp is officially 16 anyway, so this shouldn't be an issue. WhatsApp helpfully provide information on how to help your underage child delete their account, in the very rare and unlikely event that they've somehow inadvertently created one! 😂
About minimum age to use WhatsApp | WhatsApp Help Center

Edit: sorry, my mistake. It's 13 in the UK. Although the NSPCC recommends 16+.
Is WhatsApp safe for my child? | NSPCC

GotNewHair · 07/11/2023 20:44

Mine know I have the right. Never bothered for one - only connects with his good friends and is a good mixture of savvy and solid.

Another used us as a don’t involve me in that as my mum will see…

one had his checked every night - while he slept. He didn’t know but it helped me manage the self harm, keep him safe and know when I needed a formal check to sort inappropriate image shit. I stopped as he became able to manage himself and don’t regret it at all.

Halllooo · 07/11/2023 20:44

It’s not a phone it’s the whole internet - with all the good and bad and dangerous that is the internet
Our 2 use our ‘strictness’ to say they can’t do things or join in a certain times or make videos for online etc and I know they find it a useful to get away from peer pressure

Halllooo · 07/11/2023 20:41

It’s also a good reminder for them that what they say on WA or in a text or email can be seen by parents, or other people, or shred, copied, pasted etc

we’ve just witnessed major upset on a group chat where 2 x 13 year old went at it other with language that would have made sailors blush… AND of course a parent spotted it, alerted other parents etc and the kids ( hopefully) learned a lesson as well as being punished.

Halllooo · 07/11/2023 20:38

It’s a condition of our kids having phones that we periodically check messages. Decide what apps they can and cannot have, have time limits each day AND have no social
media. They’re 11 and 13.
it’s a minefield out there. They need help to manage this new world.
so many issues with friends kids who’ve got unfettered access…

our kids seem happy, have plenty of friends, social lives despite these rules.

FallingFeathers · 07/11/2023 20:33

At 13 I would have a scan of Internet history but not read messages unless there is a significant reason you're concerned about DDs safety eg concerns about friends being an influence with drink/drugs or her messaging an older boy etc.

Swipe left for the next trending thread