Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To read my daughter's WhatsApp messages

416 replies

JoelyJoe · 06/11/2023 15:41

So. This is a genuine question, and I'm prepared for strong opinions either way, but I would really like to know what people think.
My daughter has just turned 13, she is in year 8 at school and has had a mobile phone since year 6. When she got the phone I told her the deal was that I would read her WhatsApps from time to time.
My reasons are to protect her / her friends, and to ensure that there is not bullying or situations / content that I think are inappropriate at her age. Social Media did not exist when I was young, and while I know that it can't be put back in the box, I think think there are inherent dangers... as many people do.
As I said, I have always been upfront with her that I will sometimes look at her messages, I don't do it very often, and obviously at some point in the near future (not sure exactly when though!!) I will stop doing it.
Any thoughts? Am I invading her privacy or is this a necessity to protect our young people... And for those of you who also do / did the same, at what age did you stop??

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
ToadOnTheHill · 06/11/2023 17:38

Personally I dont think 13 years olds whose parents are paying for their contract should expect privacy. If they know and expect parents to check their phone then they should be mindful if their behaviour. No different to work emails being accessible by the company IMO.

Informed by my personal experience of what I was up to on my phone at that age. Thank God i couldn't send pictures.

RandomButtons · 06/11/2023 17:38

Foxblue · 06/11/2023 16:03

I would argue that not checking what your child is doing on an Internet connected advice before the age of 16 is neglect!

I DID grow up with social media and the Internet, so speaking from experience - check their bloody phones.

Better to invade their privacy to keep them safe and them feel a little bit uncomfortable than them being groomed or bullied or seeing horrible content, surely?
(And yes, that stuff happens, it sadly happens all the time, even to innocent children who are young for their age, or kids who 'just use their phone for gaming' or kids that don't show any sign somethings wrong)
Also 'they will just delete what they don't want you to see' so... just don't bother at all then, what kind of logic is that?
Check their phones.
Check their phones.
Check their phones.

Same. I grew up with early social media and phones, and I got myself in a terrible terrible mess.

Sconehenge · 06/11/2023 17:38

When I was 13 myself and friends were absolutely obsessed with sex and had all sorts of amazing private jokes, but we all understood how to stay safe and made it through teenage years unscathed.

Maybe the internet is drastically changed from how it was 15 years ago but I really don’t see the added benefit of actually reading the content of your teenagers phone every night is apart from being extremely nosy.

If you have good lines of communication open and they are always reminded of the various dangers, then you shouldn’t have to read their phones.

If they’re potentially being bullied or you notice red flags then that’s a different story, but the idea that it’s a regular thing would just prevent them from having a private world/life - which they should be free to develop from age 13+

FFF3 · 06/11/2023 17:37

IceAndLemonPlease · 06/11/2023 16:22

An old college friends mum did this to her and it changed their relationship forever (for the worst obviously ). Is there a reason you need to look? I haven’t read through the whole thread, apologies

Perhaps read the full thread. And clearly that mum did it without her child’s consent - which is where the issue lies, not with the checking.

queenofthewild · 06/11/2023 17:37

Olly Stephen's parents have said that they regret not checking his phone. If they had, it might have saved his life.

An extreme circumstance, but children are groomed and manipulated online every day and as parents we have the responsibility of helping our children navigate their lives on and offline.

Pezdeoro41 · 06/11/2023 17:37

WillowCraft · 06/11/2023 16:59

I think it's fine if they know you are going to be checking, then they can delete or not send anything that they don't want you to see. It is not the same as reading a diary or eavesdropping on a conversation as those are both private things. Whereas WhatsApp groups are not private .

Totally. At 13 my parents were “monitoring” my phone use because it was plugged in the hallway next to the living room! There was not some private communication method that parents checking their children’s mobiles are taking away…

Userwithallthenumbers · 06/11/2023 17:36

I checked my DS phone to start with, gradually reduced and now at 13.5, I have completely stopped. Maybe it depends on the child, but everything on his phone was completely inane drivel between teens. I don't have time for checking that kind of rubbish!

Queucumber · 06/11/2023 17:35

I just don’t think checking a phone is necessary if you’ve done the work to ensure your child has good judgement and check in with them lots, really explain and constantly remind that everything said online these days is traceable, explain what bullying looks like and feels like and what to do etc.

Making errors of judgement is part of growing up. Teenagers brains are still developing and if anything they’re more likely to mess up than 10 or 11 year olds. They can get in over their heads so easily.

Queucumber · 06/11/2023 17:31

tellmewhenthespaceshiplandscoz · 06/11/2023 17:19

I think this is very different to a diary as phones give our kids access to all sorts of stuff and not all of it - or the people - is good

She does have a diary she writes in regularly and I wouldn't look at that

Exactly.

You assume they’re safe because they’re sitting on the sofa in your living room. Meanwhile they’re being bullied by ‘friends’, pressured to send nudes and exposed to all sorts of shit.

You don’t give your child the talk about crossing the road safely and not talking to strangers and then let them out unsupervised at all hours. You gradually allow them more freedom, give them rules about where they can go and when, keep an eye on the people they’re hanging around with and still expect them to let you know their general whereabouts when they’re older teens. You can’t just hand them a smartphone, dole out internet safety advice and feel your work is done.

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 06/11/2023 17:29

I think better just to instil good judgement and clear rules and ensure your kids know all the cautionary tales of exactly why you don’t send a nude with your face in it, and why you should never share porn etc.

Do you think people who check phones just don't bother doing that as well?

Blabla81 · 06/11/2023 17:28

I check my 12 year old daughter’s phone every single night (if I have the energy). She knows. It’s a non negotiable I’m afraid.

Blaster22 · 06/11/2023 17:28

Ds11 received a child porn image from an unknown number ( i deleted it and reported to police). And a video of a kitten being killed. So i absolutely will keep on checking his messages for quite some time.
Its about protection. And i let all the other bits slide like swearing etc..so that he knows its ok to let me check.

Sconehenge · 06/11/2023 17:28

I was up to the weirdest stuff on the internet when I was 13-16 - back when those anon chat rooms were a thing. I would be horrified if my mother looked at any of that! I have turned out to be completely normal and just have hilarious memories of conversations with weird internet people (who could have been creepy men in their basements but just as likely other 13 year old girls).

I think better just to instil good judgement and clear rules and ensure your kids know all the cautionary tales of exactly why you don’t send a nude with your face in it, and why you should never share porn etc.

I just don’t think checking a phone is necessary if you’ve done the work to ensure your child has good judgement and check in with them lots, really explain and constantly remind that everything said online these days is traceable, explain what bullying looks like and feels like and what to do etc.

Actually looking on their phones is so icky and infantilising a teenager who will be an independent adult very soon.

I could never do it unless there were huge red flags and it was an emergency check for their safety or another teen’s.

Shoemadlady · 06/11/2023 17:27

She might be deleting messages anyway?

Createausername1970 · 06/11/2023 17:27

JustWhatWeDontNeed · 06/11/2023 15:55

Our 15 year old was sending and receiving extremely graphic home made porn. Illegal and disturbing. I am comfortable with our choice to invade that privacy. Wish it wasn't necessary, but there you go.

This.

My 13 year old was arranging with friends how much money to all chip in to buy weed and Xanax.

He said it was invading his privacy, I said it was damage limitation and avoiding trouble with the police. I pointed out that as the plan included selling it to other friends, basically it made them drug dealers.

Zanatdy · 06/11/2023 17:25

I’ve never checked messages; but I think if I had the time again (DD nearly 16 now and DS is 19) I would have checked until around 13-14. My mum massively invaded my privacy and I think that led me to decide not to, never been any issues but I think young kids need protection from the big bad world

OllieCollieWoo · 06/11/2023 17:25

I checked sporadically. It the deal in our household - I pay for their phones. My children are fine about it and the youngest in particular knows I do it to protect them.

But to be honest I hardly check now as was ok with how they used their phones and Apps. But would do if a change of mood/behaviour etc.
I work with young people and see some horrific stuff like sending nudes, bullying, grooming etc. If you are open with your young person on mobile phone responsibilities then it's not snooping.

tellmewhenthespaceshiplandscoz · 06/11/2023 17:25

VasHeal · 06/11/2023 17:18

How can it destroy trust @Blackalice? My dc know we check the messages sporadically. It fosters trust in our case. We never have a go at them, we discuss and guide, as parents that's our duty. But your children may be bullying others and you would never know. And yes, even the Naicest girls from the Naicest families with the most middle class parents bully on social media. All. The. Time.

Edited

Agree with this

WalKat · 06/11/2023 17:24

Nope you aren't being unreasonable at all. They're children, and it's a difficult thing to navigate.
After some of the things I come across in WhatsApp groups, I wish that more parents would check their kids phones every now and then!

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 06/11/2023 17:24

I checked dd's phone when she was younger - that was the agreement that we had in place when she first got it, and I think I probably continued to check until she was around 13/14, though the checks increasingly became less frequent as time went on. I stopped at the point I was confident that she was mature enough to manage the phone sensibly by herself.

I must confess, I'm a little bit surprised at the people who say that they are still checking (daily in some cases?!) phones at 16... that seems like a huge invasion of privacy to me. Equally, though, I'm shocked by the people who leave very young kids to use their phones without any supervision at all. I think a happy medium is required here!!

VasHeal · 06/11/2023 17:22

I really think in future this current generation will be very angry about the passivity with which their parents allowed them access to social media with so few safeguards.

Their parents are too busy tapping away on their own phones.

friendsfiend · 06/11/2023 17:21

Checking phones is absolutely fine and recommended for young people with phones.
If that's the condition to have a phone then they have a choice don't they.

I would always be open and check the phone with them. Also ask before the phone check if there's anything you might find that you need to discuss.

I don't agree at all it's an invasion of privacy and once you've worked with young teens downloading Tinder and sending explicit videos to random blokes on Snapchat pretending to be school kids you get wise to the risks out there.

Echobelly · 06/11/2023 17:21

At this age YANBU. I thought I would with oldest's phone when they got it but tbh they've only been in touch with close friends and, on my advice and that of other people, have stayed off class or, God forbid, year group chats which can get toxic as hell.

VasHeal · 06/11/2023 17:21

I would never read their diary, they all have diaries, I wouldn't touch them. Online communication on the other hand, of course we supervise this.

tellmewhenthespaceshiplandscoz · 06/11/2023 17:19

I think this is very different to a diary as phones give our kids access to all sorts of stuff and not all of it - or the people - is good

She does have a diary she writes in regularly and I wouldn't look at that

Swipe left for the next trending thread