Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To get involved with niece in uni

132 replies

Grealish · 06/11/2023 15:07

Was in my nieces uni town this weekend for work. Met up with her in the evening, took her out for dinner, and we went back to her flat afterwards. Her cupboards were EMPTY. She had a bag of pasta & a jar of pesto and no other food to her name. Asked her why and she eventually admitted she had no money to buy anything else. We had a big chat and she said she’s been struggling to find a job (she’s doing a really intense course, is in uni 9-7 each day) and shes scared to ask her mum for more money and has been eating a meal a day for the past couple of weeks. In Ireland so students don’t automatically get loans.

Oh my god when I say my heart broke seeing her crying over being hungry. I know all uni students are broke but the thought of my little niece hahahaha aw stop I was in bits on the way home. Went to Tesco to get her some food and left her a €50 note when I was leaving.

I rang her mum (my sister) when I got home and told her about it and she was very much of the attitude well she better get a job then because she pays her rent. I explained that she’s trying to and that her daughter is going hungry. I wouldn’t mind but my sis and her husband have good paying jobs (not rich but not stuck for cash by any means) and she’s their only daughter.

What would you do in this scenario. It’s really not my place to do anything but my hearts broke thinking about my little niece making her pesto pasta every day.

OP posts:
SisterMichaelsHabit · 06/11/2023 19:21

It's a real shame so many people have embarrassed themselves by posting when they've no idea of the Irish system. There was someone on the radio last year who was devastated that her son would have to leave his medical degree because she couldn't afford to keep paying towards him as COL had made it impossible.

There really isn't a system where the state pays for studies, FGS children in high school have to pay for their school books and I don't mean A-level texts, I mean you pay an annual fee for the books.

As for where to find temporary short term work, in most of Ireland that's not really an option unless you're in a tourist town and even then they will be overlooked in favour of people with years of experience if they apply too. There's little enough work for qualified and experienced people as it is.

People who grew up in England don't know they're born sometimes, honest to God.

OP you are being very kind helping your niece and I'm sure she'll appreciate it and hold you in her heart for doing this so she can get ahead in life. It's so lovely you've such a nice relationship with her.

Benandjerrysbonnoffeepie · 06/11/2023 19:17

Shame about your sisters attitude. I’d do as you’ve done already and send her a basic shopping (maybe with a small treat in it as I’m a soft touch) as often as you can afford.

I’ve just completed a very full on degree and survived by having two separate agency jobs so I could pick and choose my hours around my course/placements. Tell her to look at agency work!

Bartlebum · 06/11/2023 19:17

My uncle used to give me a little help when I was younger - I was a student but I worked full time hours and still struggled (wasn't in student accomodations)! It made my life so much easier and I will forever appreciate it..it wasn't loads £20 here and there, but if you can afford a little help, It could be the difference between her finishing the course and not.

Fionaville · 06/11/2023 19:13

I'd help her out with some shopping. You are her auntie, you're allowed.

OchonAgusOchonOh · 06/11/2023 19:12

Shinyandnew1 · 06/11/2023 18:47

Do you pay £9k each year in tuition fees as well in Ireland?

No. It's €3000.

You can get some form of maintenance grant plus fees on an income of approx €47k, full fees paid but not maintenance up to aprx €51, half fees paid on income up to €62k. The max maintenance element is approx €7k but that's only on an income of up to €25k and it drops progressively to €1051 for an income of €47k.

Chromium24 · 06/11/2023 19:00

TheresaCrowd · 06/11/2023 15:10

She's in Uni 9am to 7pm, seven days a week?

depending on the course, and if you want to put in the hours to achieve the grades and complete the assignments, then the hours are needed, more so if its also oxbridge etc

tortoiseshellcats · 06/11/2023 19:00

I would definitely help her out OP. I remember struggling to pay for food at uni and it was horrible. She might also need help with heating bills, my health suffered several times as a student when we couldn't afford to turn on the heating and that was before the huge price increases. If you can then I think a supermarket voucher every month or so would make a huge difference to her

Shinyandnew1 · 06/11/2023 18:47

Do you pay £9k each year in tuition fees as well in Ireland?

babytum · 06/11/2023 18:44

No they certainly do not. Under a certain threshold there are grants towards fees and living expenses but the threshold is exceptionally low. Parents here support their children. It’s normal for students to work part time to pay towards living expenses and parents to pay fees and rent.
I’ve have never heard of a student getting a bank loan to pay fees, I’ve known a few parents to take bank loans to pay college expenses though.
OP your sister may not have have the financial capacity to finance her daughters living expenses, after uni fees and rent especially in Dublin she has probably paid approx €12,000 per year and might just not have capacity to pay more.

Needmoresleep · 06/11/2023 18:34

Northern Ireland also gives very limited loans. DDs friend was supported by aunties. They clubbed together to ensure she had enough to live on. And all came to the graduation.

OP I would do what you can to support her. A regular trip to Lidl to stock up on basics. It is important she does well, which she won't if she is stressed or hungry. Don't worry about your sister, nor say anything to her. This is between you and your neice.

OhComeOnFFS · 06/11/2023 18:33

You haven't said whether you can afford to help her out, OP. If you can, then I really think you should.

Topseyt123 · 06/11/2023 18:31

This is such a tricky and sad situation. I feel very sorry for your niece. Well done you for helping her.

Her parents are paying her rent, which will be no small sum and that could probably mean that they are financially squeezed by that. So they may not have very much more money that they are able to give her.

Jobs for students that fit around studying can be very hard to find. My DD1 found that. She did have several jobs over her uni years but in her final year just couldn't keep it going. She'd been working nightshifts at the Students Union on her campus and studying all day. Not sustainable obviously because sleep is necessary at some point too. No other suitable jobs were forthcoming.

You sound like a lovely aunt here. If you can afford to, I would help your niece out during term time with either money for food shopping or with an online grocery order to be delivered to her.

Help her apply for any suitable looking holiday jobs if you see anything.

My DD3 is currently in her final year at Cambridge and also struggling financially although we give what we can too. She isn't allowed to work term time and that is in the terms and conditions issued by her college. Not sure how enforceable that one is, but they specify it anyway. She is bank staff for Costa Coffee, worked there in the summer and should be able to get some shifts over the Christmas and Easter holidays.

It's a difficult situation all around.

OchonAgusOchonOh · 06/11/2023 18:23

Shinyandnew1 · 06/11/2023 18:20

Surely most students in Ireland get bank loans then-why doesn’t she do that? Surely that’s more sensible than starving!

How did she pay for her living expenses for the first two years ?

No, they don't. It would be quite unusual. Most either get grants or are supported by parents and supplement by part-time term-time work and/or summer jobs.

TeaKitten · 06/11/2023 18:22

Shinyandnew1 · 06/11/2023 18:20

Surely most students in Ireland get bank loans then-why doesn’t she do that? Surely that’s more sensible than starving!

How did she pay for her living expenses for the first two years ?

The OP said she worked. Also she’s in her 3rd year so may have already used the bank loan I guess.

Shinyandnew1 · 06/11/2023 18:20

Grealish · 06/11/2023 17:56

@Shinyandnew1 There’s no minimum loan or anything like that in Ireland. We have grants for people whose parents earn under a certain threshold, but it’s quite a low threshold I believe. Any loans would be bank loans.

Surely most students in Ireland get bank loans then-why doesn’t she do that? Surely that’s more sensible than starving!

How did she pay for her living expenses for the first two years ?

OchonAgusOchonOh · 06/11/2023 18:12

Shinyandnew1 · 06/11/2023 17:55

Goodness, what courses are 9-7 every day? I lived with Med students which was pretty full on and they didn’t have such long days, plus for Wednesday afternoons off.

When you say they don’t get automatic loans in Ireland, well you don’t anywhere-you need to apply. Are you saying she hasn’t applied or doesn’t qualify? If her parents are paying her rent, what money is she getting via a loan? Is there no minimum loan in Ireland ?

All 3 of my dc had/have full on days like that. Dd is in final med and she is generally in from 8am to 6/7pm on hospital days and 9-6 on lecture days. Ds2 has one day a week when he finishes at 3, otherwise he is going 9-6 or 7 with an odd hour or two off in the middle of the day. He's doing engineering.

Odd hours off in the middle of the day are of no use for part-time jobs.

VenusClapTrap · 06/11/2023 17:58

I’d help her out. I remember struggling as a student and my dm took the line that your sister has done - ‘she’s got to learn to budget and get a job’ etc etc. My ddad would take pity on me and shove an envelope of cash my way every so often, with a gruff “Don’t tell your mother!”

I was ever so grateful. I still learnt to budget and got a job, but those handouts helped me navigate the tricky path to independence.

Motheranddaughter · 06/11/2023 17:57

In these circumstances I would support my niece
I was skint at Uni and it’s not nice

Grealish · 06/11/2023 17:56

@Shinyandnew1 There’s no minimum loan or anything like that in Ireland. We have grants for people whose parents earn under a certain threshold, but it’s quite a low threshold I believe. Any loans would be bank loans.

OP posts:
Shinyandnew1 · 06/11/2023 17:55

Goodness, what courses are 9-7 every day? I lived with Med students which was pretty full on and they didn’t have such long days, plus for Wednesday afternoons off.

When you say they don’t get automatic loans in Ireland, well you don’t anywhere-you need to apply. Are you saying she hasn’t applied or doesn’t qualify? If her parents are paying her rent, what money is she getting via a loan? Is there no minimum loan in Ireland ?

Grealish · 06/11/2023 17:53

Thanks for your help so far!
Just to add, she’s in her last year of study hence why it’s so intense. She has worked to support herself in past years and is actively looking for work this year, it’s not as if she’s just sitting around expecting a free ride!

Dublin is a very expensive place to live so I do really feel for her! I wouldn’t like to be a student there today!

OP posts:
Ohnoooooooo · 06/11/2023 17:46

Does she have inattentive ADHD? Common in girls ad they struggle to manage and plan their time and she could be studying at uni this amount of time.

DelightfullyDotty · 06/11/2023 16:49

Crikey! What sort of parent reacts like your neice’s mum when told her DD is eating one meal a day?! I’d be horrified!

Of course you should give her money for food. Any reasonable person would!

There’s a reason that the top universities advise their students not to get a job if at all possible.

jlpth · 06/11/2023 16:39

If she's in uni 9-7 each day, her mum is being very unreasonable to expect her to get a job on top. That's 50 hours per week, not counting any work she does at home. I bet your sister doesn't work a 50 hour week. And OK, sister pays the rent - but that's kind of the deal when you have a kid. You pay for them and you help them. Working on top of an intense degree like that is too much.

I'd send your niece little bits of money from time to time. Not a regular amount so she thinks oh, aunty will always buy my food, just from time to time send her varying amounts of money. Obviously don't send money that's going to cause you to be short.

ladymactíre · 06/11/2023 16:38

I would definitely help her with food. I couldn't live with myself knowing that my child goes without food.

We pay for our DDs accomodations, they work few hours Saturday and Sunday, I wouldn't give them money to go out, travel, clothes, but food?! Even if they work and buy their food most of the time, if they want to take food from home, they are welcome to do so.